GoodieBox Bakeshop Introduce
For those of us in New Jersey with a sweet tooth or a special occasion on the horizon, finding a bakery that truly delivers on both taste and artistry can be a game-changer. Look no further than **GoodieBox Bakeshop** in Rutherford, a local establishment that has quickly become a cherished name among dessert aficionados. This isn't just a place to grab a quick treat; it's where culinary passion meets creative design, resulting in baked goods that are as visually stunning as they are delicious. From intricate custom cakes for life's big moments to delightful everyday indulgences, GoodieBox Bakeshop, under the expert guidance of Carrie, offers an experience that goes beyond the ordinary. It's a place where every bite tells a story of dedication and love for baking, making it a true gem in our Garden State.
What truly sets GoodieBox Bakeshop apart is the personal touch and exceptional talent of its baker, Carrie. As loyal customers have raved, Carrie's creations are not merely desserts; they are edible works of art that taste as incredible as they look. Her ability to translate a vision into a beautiful, delectable cake, often with unique flavor combinations like lemon raspberry that strike the perfect balance of sweet and tart, has garnered her a dedicated following. Many have followed her journey since her early days, witnessing her growth and unwavering commitment to quality. This personal connection, combined with her unparalleled baking skills, fosters an atmosphere of warmth and trust. When you choose GoodieBox Bakeshop, you're not just buying a product; you're investing in a personalized, high-quality experience crafted with genuine care, making it a natural choice for anyone in New Jersey seeking something truly special.
GoodieBox Bakeshop is conveniently situated at **2 Franklin Pl, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA**. This address places it right in the heart of Rutherford, making it an incredibly accessible spot for local residents and those from surrounding New Jersey communities. Franklin Place is a well-known area within Rutherford, easy to locate and integrate into your daily errands or special trips.
For customers driving, finding parking in Rutherford's central areas is generally manageable, with street parking or nearby public lots often available within a short walk of the bakeshop. This ease of access ensures that picking up a custom cake or a last-minute treat is a smooth and stress-free process. If you rely on public transportation, Rutherford's local transit options likely have stops within reasonable proximity to Franklin Place, making it convenient for those who prefer not to drive. Being nestled in such an accessible location means that GoodieBox Bakeshop is not just a destination for planned orders, but also a convenient stop for a delightful spontaneous treat, truly serving the needs of the local New Jersey community. Its central position enhances its appeal as a go-to spot for all your bakery needs.
GoodieBox Bakeshop offers a delightful array of services tailored to bring sweetness to any occasion:
- **Custom Cakes:** Specializing in bespoke cakes for all events, including birthdays, weddings, anniversaries, and corporate functions, crafted with unique designs and exquisite flavors.
- **Specialty Baked Goods:** A rotating selection of unique and delicious pastries, cookies, and other baked treats, perfect for everyday indulgence or small gatherings.
- **Event Desserts:** Providing a variety of dessert options for larger events, beyond just cakes, to create a comprehensive sweet spread.
- **Flavor Innovation:** Known for creative and perfectly balanced flavor combinations, such as their highly praised lemon raspberry, ensuring a memorable taste experience.
- **Personalized Consultation:** Offering one-on-one consultations for custom orders to ensure every detail of your vision is brought to life.
GoodieBox Bakeshop stands out for several key features and highlights that make it a beloved local institution:
- **Exceptional Artistic Design:** Carrie's talent for creating visually stunning cakes and baked goods is consistently highlighted by customers, ensuring every item is a centerpiece.
- **Unforgettable Flavor Profiles:** Beyond their beauty, the baked goods are celebrated for their incredible taste, often described as perfectly balanced, not overly sweet, and with a homemade quality.
- **Responsive and Reliable Service:** Customers frequently praise the excellent communication, quick responses to inquiries, and dependable follow-through on orders, making the process smooth and stress-free.
- **Personal Touch and Care:** The bakeshop is known for its warm, welcoming atmosphere and the personal attention given to each order, making customers feel like family.
- **High-Quality Ingredients:** A commitment to using premium ingredients ensures both the superior taste and consistent quality of all their products.
- **Strong Community Connection:** GoodieBox Bakeshop has built a loyal following and a strong connection within the New Jersey community, with many customers returning for years due to their positive experiences.
For more information or to discuss your custom order, here's how you can get in touch with GoodieBox Bakeshop:
Address: **2 Franklin Pl, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA**
Phone: **(201) 256-3016**
Mobile Phone: **+1 201-256-3016**
For residents across New Jersey, especially those in and around Rutherford, **GoodieBox Bakeshop** represents everything you could want in a local bakery and more. It’s not just about the convenience of its central location; it's about the unparalleled quality, the exquisite flavors, and the genuine artistry that goes into every single creation. Carrie’s dedication ensures that whether you’re celebrating a major milestone with a custom-designed cake or simply indulging in a delicious pastry, you’re receiving a product crafted with immense care and passion.
The consistent praise from long-time customers who feel like family speaks volumes about the warmth and personal attention you receive. This level of service, combined with truly remarkable baked goods, makes GoodieBox Bakeshop a vital and cherished part of the Rutherford community. Supporting this local business means you’re not just getting a fantastic dessert; you’re contributing to the vibrant tapestry of local commerce and enjoying the kind of personalized service that big chains simply can't offer. For an unforgettable sweet experience that feels tailor-made just for you, GoodieBox Bakeshop is undoubtedly the place to go in New Jersey.
GoodieBox Bakeshop Vibe
Cupcakes
- Assorted Mini Cupcakes US$26.00
- Buzzworthy US$4.95
Devils food cupcake with mocha buttercream topped with chocolate covered espresso bean
- Choc Chip Mocha US$5.50
- Choc Raspberry US$5.75
Chocolate Devils food cake filled with raspberry compote, ganache and frosted with raspberry buttercream, dipped in chocolate, topped with a fresh raspberry
- Cookies & Cream US$5.75
Chocolate Devils Food cupcake w/Oreo cream frosting topped with Oreo
- Full Dozen US$50.00
1 dozen assorted cupcakes Includes 3 funfetti w/vanilla buttercream, 3 OG (chocolate w/chocolate buttercream, 3 Red velvet with cream cheese frosting, 3 rotating flavor
- Funfetti US$5.25
Vanilla cupcake w/rainbow sprinkles topped with vanilla buttercream
- GB Classic US$4.95
Vanilla Cupcakes w/vanilla buttercream frosting
- Gluten Free US$5.50
- Half Dozen US$28.00
6 pack of our most popular cupcakes 2 Funfetti w/vanilla buttercream, 2 chocolate w/ chocolate buttercream, 2 red velvet w/cream cheese frosting
- Marble US$4.75
Marble cake topped with a chocolate, vanilla swirl
- Old Fashioned Birthday US$5.25
Vanilla cake with chocolate buttercream
- PB & J US$5.50
Vanilla cake filled with strawberry preserves topped with peanut butter buttercream
- Peanut Butter-Cream Dream US$5.75
- Pink Champagne US$5.75
Pink champagne flavored cake w/strawberry cream frosting topped with a sliced strawberry
- Red Velvet US$5.25
Classic buttermilk based red velvet topped with cream cheese frosting
- The OG (Original Goodie) US$5.50
Chocolate Devils Food Cake topped with whipped chocolate buttercream
- Velvet Elvis US$5.95
- Strawberry Lemonade US$5.50
Cupcakes - Dozen
- Dozen GB Classic US$44.00
- Dozen Old Fashioned Birthday US$44.00
- Dozen The OG (Original Goodie) US$44.00
- Dozen Buzzworthy US$44.00
- Dozen Peanut Butter-Cream Dream US$40.00
- Dozen PB & J US$40.00
- Dozen Red Velvet US$40.00
- Dozen Cookies & Cream US$40.00
- Dozen Velvet Elvis US$40.00
- Dozen Chocolate Truffle US$40.00
- Dozen Mr. Goodstuffed US$40.00
- Dozen Snowball US$40.00
- Dozen Snowbunny US$40.00
- Mixed Dozen
Dozen
- Dozen GB Classic US$44.00
- Dozen Old Fashioned Birthday US$44.00
- Dozen The OG (Original Goodie) US$44.00
- Dozen Buzzworthy US$44.00
- Dozen Peanut Butter-Cream Dream US$40.00
- Dozen PB & J US$40.00
- Dozen Red Velvet US$40.00
- Dozen Cookies & Cream US$40.00
- Dozen Velvet Elvis US$40.00
- Dozen Chocolate Truffle US$40.00
- Dozen Mr. Goodstuffed US$40.00
- Dozen Snowball US$40.00
- Dozen Snowbunny US$40.00
- Mixed Dozen
Mini Treats
- Alfa Cookie US$2.50
- Almond Joy Cookie Bar US$5.95
- Apple Pie Bar US$7.95
- Banana Loaf US$4.00
- Banana Pudding US$9.95
- Bars US$3.25
- Blondie US$5.50
- Brookie US$6.50
- Brownie US$5.00
- Butterfinger US$3.75
- Cake Batter Cookie US$3.75
- Cake Crumblies US$5.00
- Cake Pop US$3.75
- Cakesicle US$4.95
- Caramel Brownie US$6.95
- Chocolate Chip US$3.25
- Coffee Cake US$5.50
- Cookie Box US$46.00
- Cookies + Cream Trifle US$7.25
- Cornflake Bar W/PB Ganache US$6.25
- Cowboy Cookie US$3.00
- Decorated Cookie US$5.00
- Decorated Krispy Treat US$5.50
- Dubai Brownie US$8.00
- Ginger Molasses US$3.50
- Goodie Box US$12.00
- Hand Pie US$6.00
- Ho!Iday Brownie US$6.50
- Kitchen Sink Cookie US$3.75
- Krispy Treat US$5.00
- Large Banana Pudding US$38.00
- Lemon Bar US$4.75
- Lemon Square US$5.50
- Medium Blind Box US$12.00
- Millionaire Bar US$5.75
- Mini Choc Raspberry US$10.50
- Mousse Cake US$7.25
- Oatmeal Creampie US$4.75
- PB Brownie US$6.95
- PB Krispy Treat US$5.75
- PB&J Cookie US$3.50
- Pecan Shortbread US$6.95
- Pie Bar Sampler US$42.00
- Pumpkin Crumb Loaf US$4.50
- Raspberry Crumble US$5.00
- Raspberry Tart US$5.25
- Red Velvet Cookie US$3.25
- Rocky Road US$20.00
- Small Blind Box US$8.00
- Small Krispy Treat US$3.50
- Smore's Tart US$7.25
- Smores Bar US$5.50
- Smores Bites US$2.50
- Snickerdoodle US$3.50
- Strawberry Cakesicle US$4.25
- Strawberry Crumb Bar US$5.95
- Strawberry Shortcake (Petite) US$9.50
- Sugar Cookie US$3.00
- Sugar Cookie Bar US$4.25
- Superbowl Pack US$40.00
- Sweet Potato Bar US$5.25
- Take And Bake US$11.00
- Trick Or Treat US$6.50
- Turtle Brownie US$6.50
- Vanilla Cookie Sandwich US$4.25
- Very Berry Jam Bar US$5.25
- Whoopie Pie US$4.25
Beverages
- 237ml Water US$1.00
- 500ml Water US$1.25
Party Supplies
- Banner US$10.00
- Candles US$7.00
- Mini Crowns US$12.00
- Dino Cake Topper US$8.00
- Party Hats US$12.00
- Party Horns US$10.00
- Space Cake Topper US$6.00
- Unicorn Cake Topper US$8.00
- Tassels US$10.00
- Cake Stand US$40.00
- Glitter Tiaras US$12.00
Holidays
- Sweet Potato US$26.00
- Apple Crumble US$45.00
- Pecan Chocolate Chunk US$38.00
- Assorted Box US$46.00
- Assorted Cupcakes US$52.00
- Holiday Platter US$45.00
- Brownie Box US$8.00
- Cookie Box US$10.00
- Sugar Cookie Box US$22.00
- Krispy Cakesicle Box US$30.00
- 6pack Cucpcakes US$30.00
- Cookie Platter US$30.00
- Cakesicle US$6.50
- Bite Box US$7.00
- Desert Goodiebox US$38.00
- Heart Cake US$23.00
- Easter Cupcakes US$56.00
- Treat Tray US$55.00
- 6" Carrot Cake US$65.00
- 7" Carrot Cake US$75.00
- S Strawberry Shortcake US$55.00
- Brookie US$24.00
- 6 Pack US$30.00
- Treat Box US$40.00
- Short Carrot US$35.00
- Teacher Box US$12.00
- Teacher Cookie Bag US$10.00
Cakes
- 5" Short Stack US$23.00
- 6" Short Stack US$28.00
- Basque Cheesecake US$6.95
- Birthday Cake Slice US$7.50
- Cake By The Slice US$10.50
- Funfetti Pound Cake Slice US$4.00
- Petite Slice US$6.95
- Pineapple Upside Down Slice US$5.25
- Strawberry Basque Cheesecake US$7.50
- Strawberry Shortcake US$7.95
- Pre Order US$0.00
- Coffee Cake US$5.50
- 8" Strawberry Shortcake US$55.00
- 7" Strawberry US$38.00
- Custom US$0.00
- Tiramisu US$12.95
- Lemon Curd Basque Cheesecake US$12.00
GoodieBox Bakeshop Details
Service options
- In-store pick-up
- Takeaway
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
GoodieBox Bakeshop Photos










GoodieBox Bakeshop Location
GoodieBox Bakeshop
2 Franklin Pl, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA
GoodieBox Bakeshop Reviews
cupcakesfrostingstrawberrycheesecakepartybanana puddingraspberrychampagnebaby shower cakeslices
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1It was amazing working with Carrie. She was quick to respond to emails, and really followed through on the design of the cake. The lemon raspberry tasted wonderful, not super sweet, and just the right amount of tart. Would absolutely work with them again.
May 13 · Vincent WuI truly can’t say enough amazing things about Carrie at GoodieBox Bake Shop. She is a powerhouse of a woman and hands down one of my all-time favorite bakers. I’ve been a fan since the early days back in Hudson County/Weehawken—hooked ever since her Valentine’s Day box (we’re talking way back, maybe 2012… but don’t quote me!).Her cakes and baked goods aren’t just beautiful to look at—they taste just as incredible. Whether it’s a specialty birthday cake for one of my parties or just a little treat to brighten my day, Carrie always delivers something special. She puts love into everything she bakes, and it shows.I’ve watched her grow over the years and I couldn’t be more proud. Her success is so well deserved, and if you haven’t tried her goodies yet—seriously, what are you waiting for?Even though I don’t live in the area anymore, I miss the bakery dearly… and I miss her. Carrie has that rare magic—she makes you feel like family from the moment you walk in. 💛
July 19 · Barbie VI had ordered smash cake for my daughter’s birthday. I really loved how the cake was. Carrie was amazing and accommodated all my requests. They go above and beyond to help their clients.
July 20 · kinjal patelMy family’s favorite bakeshop. Not only for their amazing cupcakes, brookies and GF cheesecakes. But also for their amazing custom cakes. I’ve ordered two cakes and will be ordering another soon.
April 14 · Barbara WhiteGoodiebox is the best in Rutherford, no question! I’ve had cupcakes, cake slices, a birthday cake, and most recently my baby shower cake from them and the quality is outstanding. My favorite flavor is the chocolate raspberry, which is a bakery staple and has its own distinctive design, but they were able to make the cake to match my shower theme. The cake was absolutely beautiful and so DELICIOUS! I’m so grateful to have such an amazing bakery in town and will be purchasing our cakes from Goodiebox for every celebration!
January 27 · Lori Hetzel
More Bakery Near Me
Erie Coffeeshop & Bakery4.0 (268 reviews)10 Franklin Pl, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA
Varrelmann's Bake Shop4.0 (77 reviews)60 Park Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA
Living Bread - artisan sourdough bakery5.0 (16 reviews)22 W Passaic Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA
Knead A Bagel4.0 (147 reviews)177 Park Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA
BJ's Bakery4.0 (8 reviews)300 NJ-17 North, East Rutherford, NJ 07073, USA
Food Baby5.0 (1 reviews)240 Paterson Ave, East Rutherford, NJ 07073, USA
Bagel Supreme | Rutherford4.0 (473 reviews)284 Park Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA
Aroma du2019 Cafe Bakery II4.0 (72 reviews)267 Paterson Ave, East Rutherford, NJ 07073, USA
Krispy Kreme4.0 (1105 reviews)Liberty Commons, 51 NJ-17, East Rutherford, NJ 07073, USA
FroDo Baking Company4.0 (7 reviews)94 E Union Ave, East Rutherford, NJ 07073, USA
Rutherford Bagels Inc4.0 (125 reviews)335 Union Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA
Veriella's Bakery & Cafe4.0 (151 reviews)309 Hackensack St, Carlstadt, NJ 07072, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
BF Bakery and Cafe4.0 (2 reviews)
Shipley Do-Nuts2.0 (127 reviews)
Alebrijes Bakery #24.0 (16 reviews)
Sunmerry Bakery4.0 (117 reviews)
Rebel Daughter Cookies4.0 (100 reviews)
Einstein Bros. Bagels3.0 (79 reviews)Top Bakery Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Make the Best Fruit and Nut Granola Bars
How to Make the Best Homemade Banana Pudding: A Simple, Delicious Recipe
How to Use Different Flours in Your Baking for Healthier Treats
How to Make the Best Homemade Honey Buns
How to Make Soft and Chewy Oatmeal Raisin Cookies: Easy & Delicious Recipe
The Ultimate Guide to Making Your Own Pie Fillings – Tips, Recipes, and Inspiration
