Great American Cookies and Marble Slab Creamery

Introduction / Overview

For residents of Athens, Georgia, the combination of Great American Cookies and Marble Slab Creamery offers a powerful, one-stop destination for all things celebratory and sweet. Located conveniently at 5405 Jefferson Rd, Suite 320, this co-branded concept brings together two iconic dessert experiences under one roof. Since its founding in Georgia in 1977, Great American Cookies has earned renown as the creator of the Original Cookie Cake, delivering fresh-baked, customized treats that are essential for birthdays, graduations, and everyday occasions across the state.

Complementing the cookie expertise is Marble Slab Creamery, which has been an innovator in the ice cream industry for over 40 years, celebrated for its small-batch, homemade ice cream and the famous frozen slab technique, which allows for free, unlimited mix-ins. The synergy of these two brands is perfectly suited for the vibrant Athens community, offering an expansive menu that covers everything from quick, fresh-baked cookies to fully customized, elaborate ice cream cakes.

The Athens location caters exceptionally well to customer convenience and service quality. Local patrons have praised the staff for being "SO kind," with one review noting their willingness to assist customers by taking large orders out to the car—a small but significant detail that reflects their high standard of service. Whether you're planning a massive party, craving a single slice of cookie cake, or looking to indulge in a custom-mixed scoop of ice cream, this combined establishment provides a professional, engaging, and utterly sweet experience for all of Georgia.

Location and Accessibility

The bakery and creamery are easily accessible to the Athens community, located at 5405 Jefferson Rd, Suite 320, Athens, GA 30607, USA. This central location ensures it is a simple stop for residents and visitors alike.

The operating hours are tailored to accommodate dessert cravings from noon until late evening, providing flexible options for both post-lunch treats and late-night indulgences:

• Monday - Thursday & Sunday: 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM
• Friday - Saturday: 12:00 PM – 10:00 PM

Accessibility is a top priority at this location, making it a welcoming environment for all Athens citizens. The facility offers comprehensive features, including a Wheelchair accessible entrance, a Wheelchair accessible parking lot, a Wheelchair accessible restroom, and Wheelchair accessible seating. Parking is hassle-free, with a Free parking lot available for patrons. For a quick treat, the store is designated for a Quick visit and accepts multiple payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Services Offered

The combined operation provides an extensive range of services and product formats, solidifying its role as the ultimate dessert hub in Athens:

• Custom Cookie Cakes: Order the iconic, customizable Cookie Cakes in various shapes, sizes (e.g., 16-inch Round, 1/4 Sheet), and batters (Original Chocolate Chip, Sugar, Double Fudge, Birthday Cake).
• Ice Cream Cake Orders: Full ice cream cakes like the Classic Cookies & Cream (starting at $34.99) and Strawberry Shortcake are available in multiple sizes (6-inch, 8-inch, 1/4 Sheet).
• Fresh-Baked Goods: Daily selection of gourmet cookies in flavors such as Original Chocolate Chip, Double Fudge, Peanut Butter Supreme, and decadent brownies.
• Double Doozies®: Specialized treats made with creamy icing sandwiched between two cookies, customizable with a variety of flavors.
• Unlimited Mix-in Ice Cream: Enjoy small-batch, homemade ice cream with a free, unlimited selection of Mix-ins blended on the signature frozen slab (including Cookie Dough, Oreo® Pieces, M&M’s®, and various nuts/toppings).
• Multiple Service Options: Flexibility for customers with Delivery, In-store pickup, Takeout, and Dine-in options for enjoying desserts on-site.

Features / Highlights

This Athens dessert destination is celebrated across Georgia for several standout features:

• The Original Cookie Cake Creator: Great American Cookies is the nationally recognized creator of the first Cookie Cake, making it the definitive choice for customized cookie celebrations.
• Iconic Ice Cream Cakes: The combination allows for unique Ice Cream Cake creations, such as the Cookie Jar Chaos (Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Oreo® and cookie dough pieces) and the Classic Cookies n' Cream.
• Free Unlimited Mix-ins: Marble Slab Creamery's innovative approach allows Athens customers to fully customize their scoop or pint of ice cream with as many mix-ins as they desire at no extra charge.
• Exceptional Customer Service: As noted by local reviews, the staff is highly praised for being "SO kind" and willing to provide extra assistance, such as helping customers with large items out to their car, enhancing the overall purchasing experience.
• Convenient Digital Ordering: The online ordering system for custom Cookie Cakes and Ice Cream Cakes is simple and highly efficient, ensuring orders are ready on time for pickup or delivery.

What is Worth Choosing

For residents in the Athens, Georgia area, choosing Great American Cookies and Marble Slab Creamery is highly recommended for anyone needing a party dessert or simply wanting a superior sweet treat.

The most noteworthy item to choose is an Ice Cream Cake, such as the Classic Cookies & Cream or the unique Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream Cake. This choice leverages the strength of both brands—a perfect blend of Great American Cookies' baking and Marble Slab Creamery's small-batch ice cream expertise—for a show-stopping dessert that is unparalleled in the local market. For those who need a quick treat, grabbing a Double Doozie® or a slice of Cookie Cake ($5.38 - $5.74) is the perfect size for an immediate, satisfying indulgence.

A Note for Custom Orders: While the staff is known for exceptional service, a small number of customer reports indicate occasional miscommunication regarding highly specific customizations, such as the "M&Ms baked in" feature, which may result in toppings being placed on top instead of blended throughout the dough. To ensure absolute satisfaction, it is advisable for Athens customers placing detailed or custom orders online to call the store directly after ordering to confirm the specifics of their request, thereby guaranteeing the product is exactly as desired.

Overall, the combination of convenient service, full accessibility, and a massive menu of fresh cookies, brownies, custom cookie cakes, and endless ice cream possibilities makes this Athens location the premier spot for celebrations and everyday sweet cravings in Georgia.

Contact Information

To place a custom order, confirm product availability, or inquire about their menu, please contact the Athens location:

Address: 5405 Jefferson Rd Suite 320, Athens, GA 30607, USA

Phone: (706) 850-1016

Great American Cookies and Marble Slab Creamery

5405 Jefferson Rd Suite 320, Athens, GA 30607, USA