Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen Louisville KY: Classic Pies, Cakes, and Fresh Ice Cream on Bardstown Road

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen Introduce

Introduction / Overview: A Louisville Tradition of Scratch-Made Sweets

For local Kentuckians seeking a taste of pure, old-fashioned comfort,

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen

is a name that evokes warmth and nostalgia. Since its founding in 1982 in Louisville, this establishment has grown into a true institution, celebrated for its unwavering commitment to making everything—from pie crusts and fillings to cake icings and ice cream—completely from scratch.

The Bardstown Road location at 5606 Bardstown Rd is a centerpiece of this local favorite, operating as a multi-faceted

Bakery

Pie shop

Ice cream shop

, and

Dessert restaurant

. This unique combination means that no matter your craving, whether it's a buttery slice of

Old Fashioned Shelf Stable Pies

or a cold, creamy

Double Scoop

of small-batch ice cream, this kitchen has you covered.

The essence of

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen

lies in its dedication to classic recipes. Their legendary pies, such as the

Chocolate Chess Pie

and

Caramel Dutch Apple Pie

, are often hailed as top sellers. Similarly, the cakes, including their rich

German Chocolate

and moist

Carrot Cake

, showcase a devotion to quality that keeps customers returning. As one happy customer noted, even those who aren't typically cake or pie people are impressed, calling the

chocolate chess pie and chocolate chip pecan pies... delicious

and the experience

Old time nostalgia at it's finest

. This is a place where every item is a celebration of Kentucky's heritage of generous, high-quality baking.

Location and Accessibility: Easily Found on Bardstown Road in Louisville

The

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen

is conveniently located for Louisville residents at 5606 Bardstown Rd, Louisville, KY 40291, USA. This accessible spot in the southeastern part of the city makes it an easy stop for residents across numerous neighborhoods.

Accessibility and convenience are central to the customer experience, ensuring a smooth visit for everyone:

Ample and Free Parking: The store offers a dedicated
Free parking lot
and additional
On-site parking
, providing hassle-free access, which is a major benefit in a busy area.
Accessible Facilities: The location includes a
Wheelchair accessible entrance
and
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
, ensuring that all members of the Kentucky community can visit comfortably.
Multiple Service Options: Whether you plan to stay and enjoy the atmosphere or grab a quick treat, the array of service options supports local user convenience. You can opt for
Dine-in
, a quick
Takeout
, or use
In-store pickup
.
Digital Amenities: Free
Wi-Fi
is available, allowing for a comfortable break while enjoying a slice of pie and
Coffee
.

The store's location and thoughtful amenities make it a perfect spot for a

Quick visit

or a leisurely afternoon treat.

Services Offered: A Complete Dessert Destination

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen

excels by offering a wide spectrum of sweet treats and services, cementing its role as a premier

Dessert shop

in the region. Their menu categories ensure there is a perfect item for any occasion or craving.

Artisan Pies by the Slice or Whole: Customers can purchase
Old Fashioned Shelf Stable Pies
and
Specialty Pies
(such as the popular meringue pies) individually or take home a whole pie for family gatherings. They even offer to
warm up the slice for you
, enhancing the experience.
Fresh Churned Ice Cream: The ice cream is made in small batches and served in various sizes, including a
Kid's Scoop
,
Big Scoop (Single)
, and
Double Scoop
, which can be enjoyed in a cup or a
Waffle Cone
. Pints and Quarts are also available for taking home.
Celebration Cakes: A large selection of layer cakes—
White
,
Chocolate
,
Strawberry
,
Yellow Cake
, and
German Chocolate
—are available by the slice ($6.50 - $7.00) or as full cakes for special events.
Specialty & Unique Baked Goods: Beyond the staples, the kitchen offers unique treats like the decadent
Banana 4 Layer
and
Chocolate 4 Layer
desserts, rich
Brownies
, fun
Upside Down Cupcakes
with caramel or chocolate icing, and classic Kentucky favorites like
Buckeyes
.
Convenient Ordering: Services are designed for maximum convenience, including
In-store shopping
,
Takeout
,
Delivery
, and
In-store pickup
, allowing locals to enjoy their favorite desserts however they prefer.
Payment Flexibility: All modern payment methods are accepted, including
Credit cards
,
Debit cards
, and
NFC mobile payments
.

Features / Highlights: Scratch-Made Quality and Nostalgic Flavors

The distinct features of

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen

are rooted in its commitment to traditional, from-scratch preparation, which provides a genuine, comforting experience for the Kentucky customer.

Authentic Scratch Baking: The key highlight is the commitment to the
Homemade
philosophy. Pies, cakes, and icings are made fresh daily, mirroring the quality of true home baking and catering to the local love for traditional Southern desserts like
Chocolate Chess Pie
and
Banana 4 Layer
.
Wide Variety of Dessert Categories: Few places in Louisville offer the trifecta of a high-quality
Bakery
,
Pie shop
, and
Ice cream shop
all under one roof. This makes it an ideal destination when hosting a party or simply satisfying multiple cravings in a single trip.
Iconic Specialty Items: Certain items are local must-tries, including the highly-rated
Chocolate Chip Pecan Pie
and the whimsical
Upside Down Cupcakes
(Yellow Cake with Caramel Icing being a standout). The rich
Monster Cookie
also proves popular for those seeking a substantial cookie fix.
Creamy, Fresh-Churned Ice Cream: The ice cream is not an afterthought; it is a core feature. The use of regionally sourced dairy and being
Fresh Churned by us!
ensures a level of quality and flavor that stands out from commercial brands. Flavors are available to complement the baked goods, such as the highly-praised
creme brulee ice cream
.
All-Day Indulgence: With items perfectly sized for individual enjoyment—from slices of
Sweetheart Cake
to single
Cake Balls
—you can easily stop by for a small treat at any time of day. The option to buy
Coffee
also makes it a perfect break spot.

Contact Information: Connect with Your Local Pie and Ice Cream Shop

To enjoy a taste of Louisville's sweet traditions, visit

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen

at their Bardstown Road location.

Address: 5606 Bardstown Rd, Louisville, KY 40291, USA.

For quick questions, to place an order, or to check on product availability, please call:

Phone: (502) 239-3880

Mobile Phone: +1 502-239-3880

What is Worth Choosing: The Unmatched Taste of True Homemade Quality

Choosing

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen

is choosing a genuine, high-quality dessert experience that respects the value of traditional baking. In a world of frozen, pre-made desserts, this Louisville institution commits to making its products

scratch made and baked

daily. This dedication ensures that the buttery crust of your pie, the moist crumb of your

Carrot Cake

, and the rich flavor of your ice cream are consistently superior.

For local Kentuckians, the value proposition is clear: you are getting a classic product that delivers on its

Homemade

promise. The sheer variety of high-quality items—ranging from the perfect celebratory

Cake

to a fun

Kid's Scoop

Ice Cream

—makes it the ultimate family-friendly dessert destination. Whether you need a full pie for a holiday, a small

Brownie

to satisfy a sudden craving, or a truly special

Specialty Cake

, this single location caters to every need. The warm, old-time atmosphere, coupled with the ability to enjoy both a slice of pie and a scoop of fresh ice cream, creates a nostalgic and delicious experience that keeps locals returning year after year. It remains the essential choice for anyone looking for the sweet taste of true Louisville tradition.

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen Vibe

All Day - Cakes
White $6.50
Strawberry $6.50
Chocolate $6.50
Sweetheart Cake $6.50
German Chocolate $7.00
Yellow Cake $6.50

All Day - Pies
Specialty Pies $7.00
Old Fashioned Shelf Stable Pies $6.50

All Day - Upside Down Cupcakes
Chocolate Cupcake Chocolate Icing $4.25
Yellow Cupcake Caramel Icing $4.25

All Day - Cookies
Sugar $3.50
Chocolate Chip $3.50
Monster Cookie $5.00

All Day - Specialty Cakes
Carrot Cake $7.00

All Day - Ice Cream
Double Scoop $6.75
Big Scoop (Single) $5.50
Waffle Cone $1.50
Kid's Scoop $4.25
Pint $7.50

All Day - Specialty Baked Goods
Cake Balls $2.50
Buckeyes $1.95
Banana 4 Layer $7.00
Chocolate 4 Layer $7.00
Brownies $3.75

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
In-store shopping
Takeout
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Amenities
Restroom
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
On-site parking

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen Photos

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen Picture 1

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen Picture 2

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen Picture 3

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen Picture 4

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen Picture 5

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen Picture 6

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen Picture 7

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen Picture 8

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen Picture 9

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen Location

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen

Kentucky Jefferson County Louisville Fern Creek Bardstown Road

5606 Bardstown Rd, Louisville, KY 40291, USA

Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen Reviews

An average rating of ★4.3 from 724 user reviews.

flavorscookiescaramelcupcakesbanana puddingicingpecansherbertcoconutvanilla ice cream

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

This place has really gone down hill. When did you start selling soft serve ice cream? And is it only certain flavors? I could’ve gotten this at McDonald’s drive thru for a dollar.
August 09 · Lyna Marshall
I'm not particularly a pie or cake person but wanted something sweet and decided to give them a try. I'm glad I did! The chocolate chess pie and chocolate chip pecan pies were delicious and did not disappoint! I got a kid scoop of creme brulee ice cream to cut the extra richness of the pie and it was just right-yummy... And they warn up the slice for you. Old time nostalgia at it's finest👌🏾⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
January 02 · Lisa Smith
Why does it always look closed from the outside and not much different on inside? Never seem to have same options at different stores.
May 05 · Kendra Zumhingst
Feels like this place has gone downhill. They’ve had a freezer out for a few weeks and little to no flavors of ice cream to offer (even tho they put a sign out saying they still have all products). The service is always extremely slow but wasn’t as big of a deal breaker until these last few times trying to go in - Such a shame but we won’t be going back.
May 11 · Lauren Korfhage
This place has gone down hill. The place is a dump. All tables are dirty, floors a mess. Everything you look at is filthy. The bathroom is a wreck and reeks of urine. Two out of 3 freezers have been down for at least a month so very little to choose from. The cake/pie area nearly bare and what is out looks like it's been sitting for a week. Out of cones.. at an ice cream shop. They need new management and a cleaning crew.
May 12 · Kayla Rose