Just Like Magic Bakery Introduce
Hello, Pennsylvania residents! Are you on the hunt for a bakery that truly brings your dessert dreams to life without breaking the bank? Look no further than Just Like Magic Bakery in Stroudsburg, PA. This local establishment is earning rave reviews for its ability to create custom cakes that are as delightful to look at as they are to eat, all while providing an exceptional customer experience. If you’re in Stroudsburg or the surrounding areas and seeking a go-to spot for all your sweet needs, this article will show you why Just Like Magic Bakery is living up to its enchanting name.
Just Like Magic Bakery is quickly becoming a beloved staple in the community, renowned for its commitment to both artistry and flavor. It’s a place where personal touches and genuine care transform your ideas into edible masterpieces. From elaborate custom birthday cakes to charming daily treats, this bakery aims to impress with every creation. For those of us in Pennsylvania who appreciate quality, creativity, and a friendly smile, understanding what this bakery offers is truly worth your time.
---
Just Like Magic Bakery is conveniently located at 727 Main St, Stroudsburg, PA 18360, USA. This prime Main Street address places it right in the heart of Stroudsburg, making it incredibly accessible for local residents and visitors alike. Being on a main thoroughfare means it's easy to find, whether you're making a dedicated trip for a custom cake pickup or simply stopping by for a delightful treat while exploring the town.
The central location in Stroudsburg ensures that Just Like Magic Bakery is a practical choice for anyone in the Monroe County area and beyond looking for a reliable and creative bakery. Its accessibility contributes significantly to its appeal, allowing customers to easily drop by, discuss their custom orders, or pick up their sweet creations without hassle. Parking availability on or around Main Street should be considered when planning your visit, but the convenience of its location generally outweighs any minor considerations.
---
Just Like Magic Bakery specializes in bringing imaginative dessert ideas to life, with a strong emphasis on custom creations. Based on enthusiastic customer feedback, their primary services and offerings include:
- Custom Cakes: This is a major highlight, with the bakery excelling at creating personalized cakes for various occasions (birthdays, anniversaries, special events) that closely match desired designs and themes. They are particularly praised for delivering on unique and intricate requests.
- Delicious Flavors: Beyond the visual appeal, the cakes are celebrated for their taste, with flavors like chocolate noted for being "delicious" and "not overly sweet," striking a perfect balance.
- Affordable Custom Options: A key differentiator is their ability to create custom cakes "without causing me to sell my kidneys," indicating that they offer high-quality, personalized designs at reasonable prices.
- Whimsical Desserts and Pastries: The bakery also offers other "delicious products in whimsical designs," suggesting a range of cupcakes, pastries, and other treats available for everyday enjoyment.
- Consultation and Design Services: The manager, Paula, is noted for being "attentive and easy to talk to," listening to customer desires, offering insights, and setting "reasonable expectations" for custom orders.
- Exceptional Customer Service: The staff, including sales associate Troi, are praised for being "very sunny," having a "pleasing personality," and making customers feel welcome and comfortable in the store.
These services highlight a bakery that not only delivers on product quality but also prioritizes a positive and seamless customer journey from initial inquiry to final pickup.
---
Just Like Magic Bakery truly lives up to its name through several outstanding features and highlights that make it a local favorite:
- True to its Name - "Just Like Magic": The most recurring sentiment is that the bakery genuinely delivers on its promise, turning ideas into reality in a way that feels almost magical. This speaks volumes about their execution and customer satisfaction.
- Stunning and Accurate Custom Designs: Customers rave about how well the "actual cake closely matched the original design," emphasizing their skill in bringing complex ideas to fruition with precision and artistry. They can even create designs to perfectly match invitations.
- Exceptional Taste Profile: Beyond looks, the cakes and desserts are consistently praised for their deliciousness, with a particular note on flavors like chocolate being perfectly balanced and "not overly sweet."
- Personalized and Attentive Service: The managerial and sales staff, specifically Paula and Troi, receive high commendation for their attentiveness, friendly demeanor, and ability to make customers feel valued and understood. This high level of personal interaction sets a welcoming tone.
- Clean, Quaint, and Presentable Store: The physical space is described as "very quaint, clean, and presentable," contributing to a pleasant and comfortable shopping experience. This indicates a high standard of care extending beyond just the products.
- Value for Custom Creations: The ability to get "custom cakes without causing me to sell my kidneys" is a significant highlight, positioning them as an accessible option for personalized, high-quality baked goods.
- Whimsical and Quality Products: The general assortment of products, beyond custom cakes, are noted for their "whimsical designs" and clear indication of being "made with quality and care," promising delightful surprises for casual visitors.
These highlights demonstrate that Just Like Magic Bakery is dedicated to providing not just baked goods, but a complete, enchanting experience for its customers.
---
To experience the magic for yourself, or to discuss your custom cake needs, you can contact Just Like Magic Bakery using the following details:
- Address: 727 Main St, Stroudsburg, PA 18360, USA
- Phone: (570) 872-0132
- Mobile Phone: +1 570-872-0132
It is highly recommended to call ahead, especially for custom cake inquiries or large orders, to schedule consultations and ensure they can perfectly accommodate your request. Their friendly team will guide you through the process.
---
For residents of Stroudsburg, PA, and indeed anyone in the surrounding Pennsylvania areas, Just Like Magic Bakery is an ideal local choice for all things sweet and celebratory. Its suitability for locals is evident through several key factors:
- Community-Oriented Customization: The bakery's strength in creating personalized cakes that are both beautiful and delicious means locals have a trusted partner for all their special occasions, from birthdays to significant milestones. This eliminates the need to travel far for high-quality custom work.
- Affordable Quality: The emphasis on delivering custom designs at reasonable prices makes premium, personalized desserts accessible to a wider local audience, ensuring that celebrations don't have to break the bank.
- Exceptional Local Service: The warm, attentive, and welcoming staff foster a positive and comfortable environment, making customers feel valued and understood. This personal touch is a hallmark of truly great local businesses.
- Consistent Delight: The consistent positive feedback on both taste and visual appeal ensures that locals can rely on Just Like Magic Bakery for a consistently delightful experience, whether it’s for a planned event or an impromptu treat.
- Enhancing Local Celebrations: By bringing unique and delicious edible art to the community, Just Like Magic Bakery contributes to making local celebrations truly memorable and special, fostering a sense of pride in local businesses.
In short, Just Like Magic Bakery stands as a testament to local craftsmanship, delightful flavors, and outstanding customer care. For anyone in Pennsylvania seeking a bakery that combines artistry with affordability and a genuinely warm experience, your search truly ends here. They don't just bake cakes; they craft happiness, one "magical" creation at a time.
Just Like Magic Bakery Menu
Menu
- Cookies US$5.25
We have our famous Oreo Blast cookies, chocolate chip, white-chocolate macadamia nut (with cranberries), and oatmeal raisin cookies!
- Cupcakes - 4 Pack US$16.00
Order a cupcake variety pack. Cupcakes are always buy 11 get 1 free! Please let us know of any allergies when placing your order. The flavors we have available are as follows: Our signature GALAXY cupcake (ultimate chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream), Red Velvet, Funfetti, Butterscotch, Vanilla Salted Caramel, Salted Caramel Pretzel (chocolate cake), Peanut Butter Lovers, Chocolate Lovers, Smores, Oreo, Samoa, Love That Nilla, and a weekly surprise cupcake flavor!
- Cupcakes - 12 Pack US$44.00
Order a cupcake variety pack. Cupcakes are always buy 11 get 1 free! Please let us know of any allergies when placing your order. The flavors we have available are as follows: Our signature GALAXY cupcake (ultimate chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream), Red Velvet, Funfetti, Butterscotch, Vanilla Salted Caramel, Salted Caramel Pretzel (chocolate cake), Peanut Butter Lovers, Chocolate Lovers, Smores, Oreo, Samoa, Love That Nilla, and a weekly surprise cupcake flavor!
- Cupcakes - 6 Pack US$24.00
Order a cupcake variety pack. Cupcakes are always buy 11 get 1 free! Please let us know of any allergies when placing your order. The flavors we have available are as follows: Our signature GALAXY cupcake (ultimate chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream), Red Velvet, Funfetti, Butterscotch, Vanilla Salted Caramel, Salted Caramel Pretzel (chocolate cake), Peanut Butter Lovers, Chocolate Lovers, Smores, Oreo, Samoa, Love That Nilla, and a weekly surprise cupcake flavor!
- Brownies US$5.25
A rich, fudge brownie to make your mouth water.
- Muffins US$5.25
Our blueberry muffins are a staple of Just Like Magic Bakery! In addition to blueberry, we also offer a "flavor of the day."
- Pecan Roll (Sticky Bun) US$7.00
Our ooey gooey cinnamon roll with brown sugar sauce and chopped pecans. Delicious when warmed up!
- Cookie Brownies US$6.00
Our delicious, rich chocolate brownies, topped with our very own chocolate chip cookie dough and Oreo cookie pieces!
- Cinnamon Rolls US$6.50
A favorite of our customers! Our cinnamon rolls are loaded with cinnamon and topped with a decadent cream cheese icing.
Just Like Magic Bakery Details
From the business
- Identifies as women-owned
- Small Business
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pick-up
- Takeaway
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible seating
- Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Offerings
- Coffee
Amenities
- Gender-neutral toilets
- Toilet
Crowd
- LGBTQ+ friendly
- Transgender safe space
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Parking
- Paid parking lot
- Paid street parking
Just Like Magic Bakery Photos










Just Like Magic Bakery Location
Just Like Magic Bakery
727 Main St, Stroudsburg, PA 18360, USA
Just Like Magic Bakery Reviews
cupcakesicingbirthdayflavorcoffeepricewedding cakemacaronsblueberry muffinsalmond joy cupcake
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Just Like Magic Bakery is true to their name.I had been looking for a bakery that can create custom cakes without causing me to sell my kidneys, and this store did just that.The manager, Paula, was very attentive and easy to talk to. She listened to what I wanted, offered insights, and set reasonable expectations.On the day of the pickup, the sales associate, Troi, welcomed me with a very sunny smile. She did not make me feel awkward nor alienated inside the store. She had a pleasing personality.The store itself is very quaint, clean, and presentable. They had other delicious products in whimsical designs that are clearly made with quality abd care.As for my actual cake, i was very happy with the output. The actual cake closely matched the original design. The chocolate flavor was delicious - it wasn't overly sweet. Just Like Magic Bakery brought the idea to life.The whole experience was just surreal and wonderedJust. Like. Magic.
June 02 · Therese SeptimoWe love this bakery. Not only are the cakes beautiful but they taste good too! (I messed up the "happy birthday" writing when I brought it home, just my luck!) I was extremely happy with how the cake for my son's first birthday came out and how good it tasted, we ordered another for my other son's 3rd birthday and I added on cupcakes because the first cake came out so good! If you're looking for a custom cake that's going to taste as good as it looks then you have found your bakery right here!EDITI picked up my son's 3rd birthday cake and wow! He loved it and so did everyone else! All I did was show them the birthday invitation and they made a cake and cupcakes to match perfectly! I'll definitely be ordering all my cakes from here from now on, I'm very happy to have found this place.
February 02 · S BI absolutely love the Halloween decor and Willow was so helpful and friendly. She took the time to chat with us when she wasn’t busy. This was the best stop of the day and the Oreo Cookie was delicious.
April 05 · Carol HarrisKaitlyn did an AMAZING job! My husband and I had a trip to Paradise Stream Resort for our honeymoon and surprised me with the beautiful cake! The shop was absolutely stunning and I had to get some extras while we were there as well (: THANK YOU KAITLYN! OUTSTANDING JOB!
April 21 · Ashlynn ClineOrdered an Italian Rum Cake for a birthday and requested sunflowers on it. What we got was the picture posted. That was it. 3 little smushy yellow flowers. We took the cake out of the box and it was leaning. The cake itself was dry, tough, and over cooked. The bottom was entirely too dark. The almonds weren’t toasted and there was barely enough frosting for the almonds to stick to the sides. The sides were also missing the almond coating in spots. I’m not sure what the filling was but it tasted nothing like pastry cream. Very disappointing and a very expensive learning experience. What a shame.
February 17 · shana Earling
More Bakery Near Me
Stroudsmoor Bakery & Cafu00e94.0 (353 reviews)125 Broad St, Stroudsburg, PA 18360, USA
Walmart Bakery5.0 (1 reviews)355 Lincoln Ave, East Stroudsburg, PA 18301, USA
Sonia's Sweet Inspirations4.0 (172 reviews)Soniau2019s Sweet Inspirations Award Winning Custom Cakes & Specialty Desserts, 927 N 9th St, Stroudsburg, PA 18360, USA
Auntie Anne's3.0 (25 reviews)341 Stroud Mall Rd, Stroudsburg, PA 18360, USA
Hot Bagels & Deli4.0 (457 reviews)704 Milford Rd, East Stroudsburg, PA 18301, USA
Apple Pie Bakery4.0 (491 reviews)25-99 Broad St, Stroudsburg, PA 18360, USA
Village Farmer and Bakery4.0 (1446 reviews)13 Broad St, Delaware Water Gap, PA 18327, USA
Bella Artisan Bakery4.0 (215 reviews)809 Seven Bridge Rd, East Stroudsburg, PA 18301, USA
Carson' Custom Creative Cakes0.0 (0 reviews)233 Aspen Rd, Stroudsburg, PA 18360, USA
Philly Pretzel Factory4.0 (202 reviews)1619 N 9th St, Stroudsburg, PA 18360, USA
Bagels & moore4.0 (218 reviews)1672 N 9th St, Stroudsburg, PA 18360, USA
EURO BAGEL4.0 (348 reviews)2199 Milford Rd, East Stroudsburg, PA 18301, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Auntie Anne's3.0 (112 reviews)
Parlor Doughnuts4.0 (687 reviews)
Dough & Joe4.0 (124 reviews)
Sugar Rush by MB4.0 (22 reviews)
El Tikal Bakery4.0 (21 reviews)
Einstein Bros. Bagels3.0 (34 reviews)Top Bakery Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Bake Your Own Homemade Baked Alaska: A Step-by-Step Guide
The Secret to Making Flaky Puff Pastry: Expert Tips for Perfect Results
How to Make the Best Fresh Lemon Curd for Tarts – Heavenly Delights Bakery
How to Make Bakery-Style Croissants with Puff Pastry
Discover the Best Bakeries for Cupcakes and Frosting Lovers Across the U.S.
The Ultimate Guide to Making Your Own Pie Fillings – Tips, Recipes, and Inspiration
