Lakeside Cookie Co.

Introduction / Overview: Lakeside Cookie Co. – Wisconsin's Cookie Destination

For residents of Wisconsin with a serious sweet tooth, Lakeside Cookie Co. in Cedarburg has become synonymous with gourmet, over-the-top cookie indulgence. More than just a simple bakery, this establishment is a dedicated cookie haven that combines imaginative flavors with high-quality ingredients, resulting in products so good that customers often confess they "couldn't stop eating" them. Lakeside Cookie Co. specializes in decadent, jumbo drop cookies and meticulously crafted custom-decorated sugar cookies, catering to both the casual visitor and those needing a show-stopping dessert centerpiece.

Located in the charming, historic environment of Cedarburg, the bakery has carved out a unique niche by offering memorable and creatively named treats. Their product line is a testament to flavor adventure and quality, offering something truly for "every palate." Customers frequently highlight the friendly staff and the inviting atmosphere, noting that a stop here is an essential part of any visit to the area—even more so than local traditions like apple picking, for some dedicated fans. The shop embodies a commitment to exceptional baking, friendly service, and a delightful consumer experience, solidifying its place as a regional favorite in the greater Milwaukee and Ozaukee County areas.

This focus on an artisanal, specific product—the cookie—allows them to excel, providing a level of quality and flavor creativity that keeps Wisconsin residents coming back again and again. It is the ideal place for a Quick visit to pick up a treat that is guaranteed to impress.

Location and Accessibility: Easily Accessible on Washington Avenue

Lakeside Cookie Co. is conveniently situated at W63N706 Washington Ave, placing it right in the central, highly-visited downtown area of Cedarburg, Wisconsin. This prime location is easily reachable for locals and those making a special trip from other parts of the state, such as Milwaukee, Mequon, and Grafton. Being on Washington Avenue means the bakery is a perfect stop while enjoying the shops, restaurants, and historical sights of this picturesque town.

A significant highlight for all Wisconsin users is the bakery's commitment to accessibility. Lakeside Cookie Co. offers critical features to ensure everyone can enjoy their delicious offerings:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance: Making the bakery welcoming and easy to enter for all patrons.
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot: Providing convenient parking immediately close to the building for those with mobility needs.

This dedication to accessibility, combined with the acceptance of Credit cards for hassle-free payment, underscores the bakery's focus on customer convenience and providing a stress-free experience for everyone in the community.

Services Offered

Lakeside Cookie Co. provides a robust range of services tailored to meet various customer needs, from a casual treat to a major event:

• Delivery: Convenient option for residents in the service area to have fresh cookies and treats brought directly to their home or office.
• Takeout: Quick and easy carryout service for picking up individual cookies or small boxes of sweets.
• In-store pickup: Efficient collection of pre-ordered custom cookie sets, large orders, or corporate gifts.
• Onsite services: Enjoying the atmosphere and making selections from the daily rotation of decadent cookies and accompanying beverages.
• Coffee Service: Offering freshly brewed Coffee and espresso drinks, such as Iced Matcha and Caramel Macchiato, perfect for pairing with a freshly baked cookie.

Features / Highlights

The reputation of Lakeside Cookie Co. is built on its unique menu and the sheer quality of its products:

• Legendary, Creative Cookie Flavors: The bakery is famous for its inventive names and complex flavor profiles, including the highly-rated "Dumpster Fire" (a sweet, salty, and chewy concoction), "Salted Caramel" (a customer favorite), "Oreo Explosion," and "The Brookie" (a half-brownie, half-cookie hybrid).
• Jumbo, Decadent Drop Cookies: The core offering features large, substantial drop cookies made with quality ingredients and often filled with candies, nuts, and chocolate, ensuring a satisfyingly rich treat.
• Artistic Custom Decorated Sugar Cookies: They specialize in royal icing cookies for special occasions, offering intricate, beautiful designs for custom sets, logo cookies for corporate events, and mini decorated cookies.
• Additional Sweet Treats: Beyond cookies, the menu includes other delicious items like macaron 6-packs made fresh in-house, various brownies (such as Salted Caramel Brownie and Snickers Brownie), and unique bars.
• Exceptional Customer Experience: Reviewers consistently praise the staff, including the "lovely" owner, highlighting the friendly, welcoming, and knowledgeable service that enhances the visit.

Contact Information

To place an order or plan your visit to this Cedarburg favorite:

Address: W63N706 Washington Ave, Cedarburg, WI 53012, USA

Phone: (262) 343-3862

What is Worth Choosing: The Unrivaled Flavor Creativity and Custom Options

For Wisconsin residents, Lakeside Cookie Co. is worth choosing because it is not just a bakery—it is a specialty dessert destination that focuses intensely on one product and perfects it. If you are a cookie enthusiast, you will find a flavor experience here that is genuinely unmatched in the region. The bakery’s courage to experiment, creating legendary and unforgettable flavor profiles like the "Dumpster Fire," ensures that every visit is an adventure. Whether your preference is for something rich, salty, sweet, or decadent, there is an option designed to be your next favorite.

Beyond the daily drop cookies, the mastery of custom-decorated sugar cookies is a significant reason to choose Lakeside Cookie Co. for professional or celebratory needs. Their custom work turns cookies into miniature edible art, perfect for corporate branding, wedding favors, or highly personalized birthday gifts. The combination of convenient services—including delivery and excellent accessibility features like wheelchair-accessible parking and entrance—removes any logistical barriers. When you choose Lakeside Cookie Co., you are choosing gourmet quality, playful creativity, and a reliably delightful experience right here in Cedarburg, making it a true Wisconsin gem for all things sweet and cookie-related.

Lakeside Cookie Co.

W63N706 Washington Ave, Cedarburg, WI 53012, USA