Manhattan Bagel Sayreville: Authentic NJ Bagels, Full Cafe Menu, and Exceptional Local Service

Manhattan Bagel Introduce

For New Jersey residents, a great bagel shop is a daily necessity, and

Manhattan Bagel

in Sayreville stands as a premier example of the authentic, high-quality experience that defines the Garden State's bagel culture. More than just a dedicated bagel shop, this establishment functions as a full-service

Bakery

Breakfast Restaurant

, and

Cafe

, providing a comprehensive menu for any time of day. While the name evokes the neighboring city, the service, commitment to quality, and community spirit are purely New Jersey through and through.

The foundation of their reputation lies in the quality of the bagels themselves—handcrafted to achieve that signature New Jersey density, chewiness, and perfectly golden crust. From a simple

Single Bagel

to a

Dozen Bagels

for the office or family, they provide the essential start to any morning. However,

Manhattan Bagel

's appeal extends dramatically with a menu that transitions smoothly from robust breakfast options to extensive lunch offerings, ensuring a diverse clientele always finds exactly what they are craving.

Customer experiences consistently highlight the shop's strengths: delicious food, fast service, and a welcoming, professional staff that demonstrates genuine local hospitality. One patron noted the service was "truly above and beyond," illustrating that while the food is fantastic, the customer care is what truly makes this location a beloved neighborhood spot. Whether grabbing a quick

Original Classic Breakfast Sandwich

on a favorite bagel or settling in for a deli-style lunch, this Sayreville institution promises quality and convenience, a winning combination for the discerning New Jersey user.

The menu selection is tailored to regional preferences, offering everything from the hearty

Philly Steak Egg & Cheese

to health-conscious options like the

Avocado Egg White Sandwich

and

Yogurt Parfait

. This commitment to variety and quality cements

Manhattan Bagel

’s status not just as a quick-stop bagel place, but as a reliable, full-spectrum local cafe in Middlesex County.

Location and Accessibility

Manhattan Bagel

is strategically located at 881 Main St, Sayreville, NJ 08872, USA. This Main Street address places it in a highly visible and convenient area of Sayreville, easily accessible to commuters on their way to work or residents running daily errands in the community. Its positioning is key to its success as a grab-and-go morning staple.

The business prioritizes accessibility, ensuring all members of the New Jersey community can visit comfortably and safely. This commitment is evidenced by its comprehensive physical features:

Wheelchair accessible entrance: Provides smooth, unimpeded access for all patrons.
Wheelchair accessible parking lot: Dedicated spaces are available for convenient access directly from the vehicle.
Wheelchair accessible restroom: Ensures that all guests have access to necessary, well-maintained facilities.

In addition to these essential physical accessibility features, the location offers excellent parking options, a crucial factor in the busy New Jersey environment. Patrons can take advantage of both a

Free parking lot

and

Free street parking

, eliminating the stress of finding a spot. The seamless transaction process is also assured, as the establishment accepts

Credit cards

Debit cards

, and modern

NFC mobile payments

, streamlining the checkout process for the busy New Jersey customer.

Services Offered

Manhattan Bagel

provides a flexible and diverse range of services designed for maximum customer convenience, supporting the full spectrum of dining needs from a quick bite to a catered office breakfast.

Dine-in: Allows patrons to sit, relax, and enjoy their meal in the cafe setting, often encouraged by the accommodating staff.
Takeout: The traditional service for grabbing individual items or larger orders to be consumed off-site.
In-store pickup: Customers can place their orders ahead of time for fast, efficient retrieval inside the shop.
Delivery: For those unable to visit, delivery service brings the full menu of bagels, sandwiches, and coffee right to their home or workplace.
In-store shopping: The standard option for browsing the baked goods, selecting spreads, and customizing orders on the spot.

The culinary services are equally broad, covering all major meal categories:

Breakfast: The primary dining option, featuring a vast selection of sandwiches, wraps, and lighter fare.
Coffee Service: Offering a full range of hot and iced coffee, as well as specialty beverages like
Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice
and
Iced Tea
.
Bulk Orders: Special
Half Dozen
and
Dozen Bagels Value Packs
are available, perfect for family breakfasts or office meetings.

Features / Highlights

The key features of

Manhattan Bagel

in Sayreville revolve around its menu depth, quality ingredients, and an outstanding dedication to the customer experience—all vital elements for success in New Jersey.

Full Spectrum of Breakfast Sandwiches: Ranging from the classic
Original Classic (Breakfast Meat, Egg & Cheese)
and the local favorite
Hash Brown
add-on, to unique offerings like the massive
Big Breakfast Burrito Wrap
and the hearty
Farmhouse
sandwich.
Lox and Deli Excellence: The shop offers high-quality
Sliced Nova Lox & Cream Cheese
and an array of
Deli Style Lunch Sandwiches
, ensuring authentic New York-style deli options are readily available in Sayreville.
Convenience and Efficiency: The business is designated for a
Quick visit
, and its extensive service options (Delivery, In-store pickup, Takeout) are designed to minimize waiting, catering directly to the busy New Jersey consumer.
Exceptional Hospitality: Customer reviews highlight service that goes "truly above and beyond," with staff welcoming patrons even close to closing time and offering friendly, fast service, which is a major highlight in any highly trafficked food service environment.
Inclusivity and Comfort: Featuring fully accessible physical amenities, including a wheelchair accessible entrance, parking, and restroom, alongside a clean environment praised by local users.

Contact Information

To visit or place an order, customers can utilize the following contact details for the Sayreville location.

Address: 881 Main St, Sayreville, NJ 08872, USA

Phone: (732) 525-0696

Mobile Phone: +1 732-525-0696

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing

Manhattan Bagel

in Sayreville is choosing the ideal blend of authentic New Jersey bagel tradition and modern, full-service convenience. This location is particularly worth choosing for the local user who expects variety, speed, and premium ingredients from their neighborhood bagel spot.

The fact that they function as a bagel shop, bakery, and cafe is a significant advantage. This means you can satisfy a basic bagel craving, order a complete lunch like the

Ellis Island Hot Pastrami

, or grab a refreshing

Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice

—all in one highly accessible, centrally located establishment. The inclusion of

Lighter Side Breakfast

options like the

Santa Fe Egg White Sandwich

and the

Avocado Egg White Sandwich

ensures that patrons with dietary goals are also thoughtfully accommodated.

Ultimately, the commitment to superior hospitality, as demonstrated by the staff's welcoming nature and willingness to go the extra mile, is the intangible highlight that makes

Manhattan Bagel

a true community asset. When looking for a guaranteed fresh, authentic NJ bagel experience supported by a full grill menu, excellent accessibility, and reliably warm service, this Sayreville location is the clear, professional choice for New Jersey residents. It stands as a reliable pillar of morning routine and mid-day nourishment.

Manhattan Bagel Food & drink

Yoohoo
Yoohoo $4.49
Chocolate Drink

Breakfast Sandwich
Sweet Meets Savory $12.49
French Toast Maple Roll, served with Sausage, Bacon, Egg, Cheddar cheese, with Honey Almond Spread topped with a drizzle of Maple Syrup.
Original Classic (Breakfast Meat, Egg & Cheese) $10.48
Grilled egg, American cheese & choice of meat
Hash Brown $2.39
Served on the side.
Breakfast Cheesestak $10.69
Steak Roll Scrambled Egg, Roasted Peppers Grilled Onions & American Cheese
Philly Steak Egg & Cheese $11.68
Bagel with American cheese & grilled onion
Farmhouse $11.99
Cheesy Hash Brown Gourmet Roll , Grilled Egg, Bacon, Ham, Cheddar Cheese & Country Pepper Cream Cheese
Egg & Cheese $7.58

On a Wrap
Big Breakfast Burrito Wrap $11.99
3 Scramble eggs American cheese, Bacon, Sausage, Chipotle Salsa and Jalapeno Cream Cheese with Hash Brown on it
Ranchero Wrap $10.29
Three scrambled eggs, pepper jack cheese, salsa and choice of meat.
Omelet Wrap $14.38
Three scrambled eggs, choice of breakfast meat and cheese.

Bagel & Sweets
Bagel With Butter $4.88
Whipped Butter (Tub) $6.49
Eight ounces tub.
Single Bagel $3.08
Cookies $2.89
With six pieces. All varieties.
Sliced Nova Lox & Cream Cheese $14.38
Yogurt Parfait With Granola & Berries $5.99
Muffin $4.99
All varieties.
Fresh Fruit Cup $6.49
Plain Cream Cheese (Tub) $6.29
Six ounces tub.
Fruit Cereal Treat $2.69
Egg Sugar Cookie $4.99
Flavored Cream Cheese (Tub) $5.89
Six ounces tub.
Strawberry Pastry Strudle $5.29
Nova Lox (Package) $12.99
Four ounces.
Bagel With Flavored Cream Cheese $5.78
Bagel With Cream Cheese $5.88
Half Dozen Bagels $13.88
Dozen Bagels $20.38

Deli Style Lunch Sandwiches
Big City BLT Sandwich $12.98
Served with a pickle. Comes with multigrain toast.
Ham And Swiss $12.98
On a bagel with ham, swiss, onion, mustard, lettuce and tomato.
Turkey & Cheddar $12.98
Boars head turkey, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo on multigrain bread. with pickle
Empire State Turkey $12.98
With bacon, onion, mayo, lettuce and tomato. Come with pickle
Great White Tuna $12.98
Served with a pickle . Comes with wrap.
Chicken Salad $12.98
Served with a pickle , Comes with a bagel.
NYC Chicken Salad Sandwich $12.98
House-made chicken salad.

Grilled Lunch Sandwiches
Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap $12.49
In a whole wheat wrap with caesar dressing, lettuce, and tomato.
Chelsea Grilled Chicken $12.49
With roasted red peppers, Monterey jack cheese, and garlic tomato sauce.
Ellis Island Hot Pastrami $13.48
On a rye bagel with swiss, grilled onions and mustard.
Manhattan Cheesesteak $13.48
On a hero with grilled steak, roasted peppers, grilled onions, and cheese.

Beverages
Gatorade $3.99
A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine
Iced Coffee (Large) $4.99
Coffee (XL) $4.59
Milk Pint $3.29
Fountain Soda $4.39
Coffee (Large) $4.29
Nesquick $4.29
Coffee (Medium) $4.19
Water (Poland Spring) $3.74
OJ (Tropicana) $3.99
Snapple $3.59
Iced Tea (Medium) $4.29
Iced Tea (Large) $4.99
Iced Coffee (Medium) $4.89

Value Packs
Dozen Bagels Value Pack $24.88
13 bagels and two tubs cream cheese.
Half Dozen Bagels Value Pack $16.88
Six bagels and one tub cream cheese.

Lighter Side Breakfast
Spinach Bacon Croissant $11.39
Bacon, Scrambled Eggs with Spinach, and Swiss Cheese with Zesty Tomato Spread on a Croissant
Santa Fe Egg White Sandwich $9.99
Asiago Thin-tastic Bagel, Grilled Egg White, Turket-Sausage, Cheddar, Roasted Tomato Salsa and Jalapeño Salsa Cream Cheese
Lighter Side Breakfast Sandwich $11.58
Choice of turkey bacon or turkey sausage. Served with two egg whites and cheese.
Avocado Egg White Sandwich $11.58
Yogurt Parfait With GRANOLA And Berry $6.39

Fresh Juice - OJ & Lemonade ( Blackberry, Strawberry)
Fresh Lemonade(Strawberry) $4.49
Fresh Lemonade(Blackberry) $4.49
Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice $5.99
Fresh Lemonade $4.49
Fresh Lemonade

Bagel Thin Sandwiches
Avocado BLT Thin Sandwich $11.39
Avocado with turkey-bacon and roasted tomato spread.
Tuna Thin Sandwich $10.89
Tuna with white albacore tuna salad, lettuce, tomato, and red onion.
Turkey Thin Sandwich $10.49
Turkey with veggie cream cheese, lettuce, tomato, and red onion.

Manhattan Bagel Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
In-store shopping
Takeout
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Amenities
Restroom

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking

Manhattan Bagel Photos

Manhattan Bagel Location

Manhattan Bagel

New Jersey Middlesex County Sayreville Main Street

881 Main St, Sayreville, NJ 08872, USA

Manhattan Bagel Reviews

An average rating of ★3.9 from 251 user reviews.

sandwichbaconmorningpork rollhash brownscroissantsdeliverylemonadezeropepper

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

I went to this Manhattan Bagel location on Thursday! I got a Bacon, Egg, and Cheese bagel (Hash Brown inside). With a side of Tropicana Raspberry Lemonade. It was delicious, good service, and really clean. The Tropicana was a bit pricey (almost $4 for 11oz drink). However, if I visit again. I’ll be going to this location!
July 19 · Julian Steve
I walked in just 5 minutes before closing, but they welcomed me without hesitation and even encouraged me to sit and enjoy my meal. The bagels were fantastic, but the hospitality was even better. They even threw in a few bagels on the house—truly above and beyond.
July 31 · Syed Ahmed
Wished I could do zero star...the sign states "free coffee with hot breakfast sandwich". The owner decided to let us know as we are cashing out that the free coffee is not available on weekends. See the photo with nothing mentioned that free coffee with hot sandwich purchase is not available on weekends. FALSE ADVERTISING
August 03 · Carmeleta Pestano
I ordered delivery a few times. In the past, I felt a bit unwell after drinking their lemonade, but did not make the connection. This time, I noticed the lemonade I ordered was covered in mold. A restaurant should never have moldy food, let alone serve it to customers. Do they not keep track of when things expire?
April 25 · Karel Jaros
Not sure what happened to this place. It used to be very good at one point but it seems that as the franchise expanded, they got greedier just like every other fast food corporation. I haven’t complained publicly before but this is the third time in a row where I’ve received terrible quality of food. Our bagels literally had no cream cheese in it and they forgot my hashbrown. Who wants to pay $5+ for basically just a bagel? Prices are ridiculously high and I feel like they keep increasing them every few months too. You’ll see other reviews talking about the same thing, but it seems that they don’t care anyway. Avoid this location and/or franchise and get your bagels from a local shop instead. I won’t be going back.
May 10 · Harsh Kadakia