Marilyn's Bakery: St John, IN’s Premier Destination for Custom Cakes, Fresh Pies, and Scratch-Made Breakfast

Marilyn's Bakery Introduce

Introduction / Overview

For residents across Northwest Indiana, Marilyn's Bakery in St John is far more than just a place to pick up baked goods; it is a celebrated local institution built on decades of scratch-made quality and exceptional customer care. This

Bakery

specializes in taking the ordinary and making it extraordinary, particularly when it comes to custom-designed creations. The commitment to meticulous detail and delicious flavor has made Marilyn's the go-to source for special occasion needs throughout the Indiana region.

Marilyn’s is particularly renowned for its custom cakes, which consistently receive high praise for both presentation and taste. Whether it is an intricately designed birthday cake, such as one reviewer's

Buzz Lightyear cake

that

looked absolutely incredible – every detail was spot on

, or a stunning wedding cake, their craftsmanship is second to none. The cakes are repeatedly described as

moist, rich, and perfectly balanced in flavor

, ensuring that there are

hardly any leftovers by the end of the day

What truly sets Marilyn's Bakery apart in the St John community is their dedication to customer satisfaction, even when a mistake happens. The story of the dedicated decorator who re-frosted an entire cake

at no charge

when the customer's picture didn't go through illustrates the high level of service. The decorator's willingness to make it

PERFECT!! Every detail exactly like the picture I had!

resulted in a daughter who was

so thrilled

, showcasing the bakery's family-first approach. This clearly demonstrates that Marilyn's Bakery

puts care and craftsmanship into their work

and truly goes

to infinity and beyond

for their patrons.

Beyond custom cakes, Marilyn's is a full-service bakery and cafe that bakes from scratch daily, offering a wide array of items from seasonal pies to

Breakfast

pastries and fresh coffee, making it a perfect destination for a

Quick visit

any day of the week. They use locally sourced, in-season ingredients, reflecting their Hoosier farm roots and commitment to the local Indiana community.

Location and Accessibility

Marilyn's Bakery is conveniently located in the heart of St John, making it an easy stop for residents across Lake County and Northwest Indiana. Its location is designed for a seamless, hassle-free customer experience.

Address: 9159 Wicker Ave, St John, IN 46373, USA

Major Road Access: The bakery is situated on Wicker Avenue (US 41), a main thoroughfare, providing excellent visibility and easy driving access from surrounding areas, including Dyer, Schererville, and points throughout the Calumet region.
Parking Convenience: Patrons benefit from a dedicated
Free parking lot
, ensuring that whether you are picking up a custom cake or grabbing a morning coffee and pastry, your stop will be quick and stress-free.
Universal Accessibility: Demonstrating a commitment to serving all members of the Indiana community, the location includes a
Wheelchair accessible entrance
and
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
.
Perfect for Quick Stops: The location and available services are perfectly set up for a
Quick visit
, whether you are commuting or running errands in St John.

Services Offered

Marilyn's Bakery offers a complete range of services to cater to both daily indulgences and grand celebrations, all with a focus on scratch-made quality.

Key Services:

Custom Cake Design: Specializing in
Amazing custom cakes
for all events—from birthdays (like the Buzz Lightyear theme) to weddings—with an emphasis on meeting specific style requests and a commitment to perfection.
Takeout and Pickup: Offering both standard
Takeout
and convenient
In-store pickup
options, ideal for those who have pre-ordered items or are making a spontaneous stop.
Daily Breakfast Options: Serving a variety of
Breakfast
options, including fresh-baked muffins, cinnamon rolls, scones, and their famous kolaches, paired with
Coffee
for a complete morning stop.
Specialty Baked Goods: Providing a wide selection of scratch-made items, including fresh pies (both fruit and cream varieties), cheesecakes, cookies, and seasonal tea breads.
Flexible Payment: Accepting all major payment types for customer convenience, including
Credit cards
,
Debit cards
, and modern
NFC mobile payments
.
Seasonal and Local Focus: Committing to baking with
local in-season ingredients
as a nod to their family’s farming history, ensuring the freshest flavor possible in their fruit pies and seasonal treats.

Features / Highlights

The unique features of Marilyn's Bakery are what have earned it a loyal following throughout Northwest Indiana.

Unrivaled Custom Cake Artistry: The bakery's ability to execute detailed designs, like the
Buzz Lightyear cake
where
every detail was spot on
, combined with an exceptional taste that made the cake
moist, rich, and perfectly balanced
, is a primary highlight. This artistic skill and flavor guarantee a memorable centerpiece for any celebration.
Commitment to Customer Delight: The willingness of the decorator to re-frost an entire cake
at no charge
to ensure the customer’s daughter was
so thrilled
is an outstanding example of the personal, family-focused service that defines this business. This is where
care and craftsmanship
truly shine.
Scratch-Made Daily Baking: The promise to
bake from scratch daily
and use
local in-season ingredients
ensures a superior flavor and freshness across all their products, from their popular kolaches to their famous pies.
A True Local Hub: As an established, family-owned institution in Northwest Indiana, Marilyn's provides a classic, friendly neighborhood atmosphere that big box stores simply cannot replicate, making every visit a pleasant experience.
Convenience and Accessibility: Offering
In-store pickup
and
Takeout
, along with easy-to-use
NFC mobile payments
and a
Free parking lot
, the bakery makes grabbing a quick breakfast or a large custom order completely effortless.

Contact Information

To place a custom cake order, inquire about a specialty pie, or simply stop in for fresh breakfast and coffee, use the contact information below.

Address: 9159 Wicker Ave, St John, IN 46373, USA

Phone: (219) 627-1104

What is worth choosing

Choosing Marilyn's Bakery is an easy decision for anyone in the Indiana region looking for exceptional quality, service, and a truly local touch. It is worth choosing for several definitive reasons.

Foremost, the bakery’s reputation for

Amazing custom cakes

is unparalleled. When you need a celebratory cake, you need a guarantee of perfection, both in looks and taste. Marilyn’s delivers this consistently, proving that they are the experts in custom design—even rectifying a customer error

at no charge

just to ensure the cake was

PERFECT!!

This level of dedication is a rare and precious find. When a cake can make a special occasion

everything she had wanted

, that is an invaluable service.

Second, beyond the custom orders, Marilyn's is an outstanding choice for daily needs. They offer authentic

Breakfast

and coffee options, from scratch-made cinnamon rolls to their highly-rated pies and famous kolaches, all baked using the freshest ingredients. The commitment to using

local in-season ingredients

reflects a genuine pride in Hoosier produce and flavor.

Finally, the combination of convenient services—including fast

In-store pickup

, high accessibility, and a

Free parking lot

—with a family-first philosophy means every interaction is pleasant and efficient. Marilyn's Bakery truly embodies the spirit of a professional, high-quality, neighborhood business, making it the premier choice for any baking need in St John and Northwest Indiana.

Marilyn's Bakery Details

Service options
In-store pickup
Takeout

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free parking lot

Marilyn's Bakery Photos

Marilyn's Bakery Location

Marilyn's Bakery

Indiana Lake County Saint John Wicker Avenue

9159 Wicker Ave, St John, IN 46373, USA

Marilyn's Bakery Reviews

An average rating of ★4.5 from 134 user reviews.

pielunchbirthdaycupcakespricecoffeedonutskolacheschicken saladcherry

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

I recently ordered a custom Buzz Lightyear cake from Marilyn’s Bakery, and I couldn't be happier with the result! The cake looked absolutely incredible – every detail was spot on, from the colors to the character design. It truly captured the spirit of Buzz Lightyear and made the celebration extra special.But this cake wasn't just about looks – it tasted amazing too! The cake was moist, rich, and perfectly balanced in flavor. Everyone at the party raved about it, and there were hardly any leftovers by the end of the day.Marilyn’s Bakery clearly puts care and craftsmanship into their work, and it shows in both presentation and taste. Highly recommend them for any custom cake needs – they definitely go to infinity and beyond!
June 28 · Kelly Carlson
Amazing custom cakes!! My daughter had a specific style cake she was hoping for. I thought I had emailed the picture when I ordered the cake but it did not go through. When I arrived to pick up the cake it was pretty but not as my daughter had wanted. And even though it was my fault that I didn’t check to make sure they had my picture, the decorator offered to fix it at no charge! And it pretty much meant she had to re-frost the whole cake. When I came back to pick it up it was PERFECT!! Every detail exactly like the picture I had! On top of everything else the cake tasted as good as it looked! My daughter was so thrilled!!! It was everything she had wanted for her special occasion! Thank you Marilyn’s!!!
February 27 · Jennifer Isom
I recently ordered two large cakes for my 55th St. Francis de Sales High School reunion. They were professionally decorated and they tasted WONDERFUL! All my former classmates raved about them.
September 22 · Kathy Doherty
They forgot half our bridal shower order the afternoon of our bridal shower. They still charged full price for the entire order. When we called for a manager the next day, we were told they'd call back if it was a manager related issue. Do not use them for events!!!
August 25 · Zack Pauser
I ordered my first cake here for a going away party. It was a big hit! Marble cake with salted caramel buttercream frosting with French silk filling. I will be ordering again!
August 01 · JoEllen Nikolich