Michelle's Cake Shop

Introduction / Overview: Sellersburg's Go-To for Custom Cakes and Treats

For residents across Southern Indiana looking for that perfect centerpiece dessert, whether it's for a wedding, a birthday, or a grand celebration, Michelle's Cake Shop in Sellersburg has become a cherished local resource. This dedicated bakery focuses on creating not just beautiful, but also incredibly delicious custom-made baked goods. It is known as a specialty bakery where quality and customer service inspire genuine confidence from the very first consultation.

Michelle's Cake Shop specializes primarily in larger, custom-ordered items like multi-tiered cakes, sheet cakes, and dozens of cupcakes and cookies. This focus allows the bakery to concentrate its professional expertise on the details that truly matter for special events—from achieving custom flavor combinations to ensuring professional decoration and on-time delivery (based on customer testimonials). Unlike traditional bakeries with large retail storefronts, the emphasis here is on the art of the custom order, providing Indiana customers with a unique and personal experience for their most important events. The products speak for themselves, with patrons consistently raving about the quality and the surprisingly "low price" for such beautiful and amazing results. It’s a true local gem dedicated to the craft of exceptional baking.

Location and Accessibility in Southern Indiana

Michelle's Cake Shop is conveniently located in the heart of Sellersburg, Indiana, making it an accessible spot for customers across the Southern Indiana region, including the greater Clark County area. The specific address is:

231 Virginia St, Sellersburg, IN 47172, USA

The location offers a dedicated space for customers to pick up their custom orders. Given the specialty nature of the business, which relies on orders and scheduled pickups, the location emphasizes efficient service. For drivers planning a visit to pick up their beautiful, large-format cakes or dozens of treats, the bakery provides essential accessibility:

• Wheelchair accessible parking lot

This feature ensures that the process of safely loading your delicate custom cake into your vehicle is as smooth and stress-free as possible, a critical detail when handling specialty orders for a major event.

Services Offered

Michelle's Cake Shop operates as a specialty order bakery, concentrating on providing high-quality baked goods for special occasions. The service model is streamlined to focus entirely on the custom needs of the client.

• Takeout (Primary service option for order pickup)
• Custom Cake Design and Consultation (Inspiring confidence with professional and accommodating service)
• Specialty Cakes (2 Tier and 3 Tier cakes in Small, Medium, and Large sizes for major events)
• Sheet Cakes (Single Layer and Double Layer options, available in Quarter, Half, and Full Sheet sizes)
• Bulk Cupcakes and Mini Cupcakes (Sold by the dozen for events and parties)
• Sugar Cookies (Available to order by the dozen)
• Accommodation of Custom Flavors (Including requests for specialty needs like non-dairy toppings)

Features / Highlights

Michelle's Cake Shop stands out in the Indiana bakery scene due to its particular strengths in customization, pricing, and overall customer experience. These highlights reflect why local users choose this shop for their most important celebrations.

• Exceptional Customization: The bakery shines when it comes to personalized orders, with the ability to handle complex requests such as unique custom flavors—like Pistachio with a light Raspberry jam layer and Non-dairy topping—all finished with beautiful, fresh decorations.
• Unbeatable Value and Confidence: Customers are highly impressed with the combination of a BEAUTIFUL and AMAZING cake for a very low price, often citing that the initial pricing and the process (including receiving a quote without an immediate deposit request) instantly built trust and confidence in the service.
• Tiered and Sheet Cake Mastery: Specializing in larger formats, the shop offers an array of multi-tiered cakes, including 2 Tier (Small, Medium, Large) and 3 Tier (Small, Medium, Large) options, along with substantial Full Sheet Cakes for high-guest count events, establishing them as an expert for large gatherings.
• Professional and Accommodating Service: Repeat customers describe the owner as "so accommodating & professional," and the overall experience is noted for its warmth and guidance throughout the ordering process.
• Variety of Foundational Treats: Beyond large cakes, the bakery provides essential party staples such as Sugar Cookies (Dozen: $20.00) and both Normal and Mini Cupcakes (Dozen CupCakes - Normal: $20.00; 2 Dozen Mini Cupcakes: $20.00), perfect for supplementing a main dessert.

Contact Information

To begin your custom order consultation, inquire about specialty flavors, or arrange for an event, you can contact Michelle's Cake Shop using the following information:

Address: 231 Virginia St, Sellersburg, IN 47172, USA

Phone: (812) 202-7072

What is Worth Choosing at Michelle's Cake Shop

For Indiana residents seeking a bakery, especially for major events, choosing Michelle's Cake Shop means prioritizing personalized service, remarkable value, and a truly custom product. The main reason to choose this Sellersburg establishment is its reputation for delivering on promises: customers consistently receive cakes that are both BEAUTIFUL in design and AMAZING in taste, all while maintaining competitive and low pricing for specialty work. This combination of high quality and affordability is a significant draw for local customers planning expensive events like weddings or large family reunions.

The bakery’s expertise in custom flavors is a key differentiator. If you have a unique or challenging flavor combination in mind—like the customer who successfully ordered Pistachio cake with Raspberry jam and a non-dairy topping—Michelle's is the local professional to trust. They are not limited to basic flavors; they are masters of confectionery customization. The tier and sheet cake offerings, from the **$80.00 Full Sheet Cake Double Layer** to the impressive 3 Tier Specialty Cake ($150.00), indicate that they are well-equipped to handle high-volume, visually complex orders that serve a large number of guests.

In an area where finding a reliable, professional baker who is also "so accommodating" can be a challenge, Michelle's Cake Shop stands out. Customers report an initial experience that inspires confidence, from the friendly consultation to the fair and transparent pricing. This peace of mind is invaluable when planning a significant celebration. By choosing this local Sellersburg bakery, you are not just buying a cake; you are investing in a seamless, professional experience that guarantees a dessert that will be remembered and raved about by your guests, often with the sentiment, "I'll never go anywhere else for cakes." It is the ideal choice for any Indiana resident who believes their special event deserves a cake that is as high-quality and unique as the celebration itself.

Michelle's Cake Shop

231 Virginia St, Sellersburg, IN 47172, USA