Mike's Pies Inc

Introduction / Overview

For residents and businesses across Florida, the name Mike's Pies Inc is synonymous with exceptional, high-quality, and award-winning desserts. Originating in a modest 700-square-foot retail store in Tampa in 1992, this local business has blossomed into one of the country's most respected gourmet bakeries, all while remaining deeply rooted in its Tampa heritage. Mike's Pies is not just a place to buy a dessert; it’s the culmination of three generations of family tradition, with all recipes traced back to Mike Martin’s Grandma Smith and passed down by his mother, Jean.

The bakery’s success is a testament to its unwavering commitment to quality. Mike's Pies proudly operates on the motto: “We cut no corners at Mike's Pies because pies have no corners.” This philosophy translates into using only high-quality ingredients you would find in your own kitchen, explicitly forbidding fillers, preservatives, and artificial additives. This dedication has paid off handsomely, securing Mike's Pies an incredible record of 15 National Championships at the annual Great American Pie Festival, solidifying its place as a dessert powerhouse in Florida and nationwide.

While the company's primary focus is on wholesale distribution to restaurants, grocery stores, and food service partners across the lower 48 states, the Tampa headquarters welcomes local Florida customers for in-store purchases and takeout. This unique setup means that locals can access the very same gourmet, award-winning desserts served in nationally recognized restaurants, including locations at Walt Disney World, right from the source in Tampa. The company produces about 65 different varieties of frozen pies and cakes, ensuring the flavor and consistency remain locked in from their kitchen to your table.

Location and Accessibility

Mike's Pies Inc is headquartered at 10350 Windhorst Rd #100, Tampa, FL 33619, USA. Located in the Windhorst Road area near Falkenburg Road and the state fairgrounds, the physical location is less of a traditional storefront and more of a bustling production and office facility. This distinct location means a quick visit is often the preferred method for local patrons picking up their orders.

A common note from local Florida customers is the importance of calling ahead or paying close attention to directions, as the bakery is situated within a cluster of businesses and warehouses. However, once you arrive, accessibility is well-provided for:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance ensures ease of access for all guests.
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot is available directly on site.

The bakery focuses on efficiency for its local retail patrons, primarily offering Takeout and In-store shopping for pre-ordered or limited selection items. The hours of operation cater to typical business days, running Monday through Friday, but they are closed on weekends, so weekend celebration planners should arrange their pickup accordingly. Payment is convenient, with options for Credit cards and Debit cards.

Services Offered

Mike's Pies Inc offers a focused but vast array of gourmet desserts, with service delivery structured to accommodate both individual retail customers and major wholesale accounts across the country.

• Gourmet Pie Production: Specializing in over 60 varieties of pies, including their signature Key Lime Pie (a multiple National Champion), Mississippi Mud Pie, Southern Pecan, and unique Florida flavors like Orange Blossom and Mango-Lime.
• Cheesecakes and Layer Cakes: A full line of creamy cheesecakes, featuring flavors like Sea Salt Caramel, Irish Cream, and Red Velvet, along with layered cakes such as the Btym Chocolate and Carrot cakes in two or three-layer options.
• Specialty and Seasonal Desserts: Providing holiday favorites like Pumpkin Pie, Sweet Potato Pie, and Pumpkin Cheesecake to meet seasonal demand from Florida families and restaurants.
• Gluten-Free Selections: Catering to dietary needs with popular gluten-free options, including their Reese's Peanut Butter Pie, Key Lime Pie, and New York Cheesecake.
• Local Tampa Retail Sales: Offering direct retail sales for individuals at their Tampa facility, allowing the public to purchase the same fresh-frozen, quality products distributed nationally. Specific items can often be ordered with a 2-day notice.
• National Wholesale Distribution: Serving as a major supplier of frozen desserts to a vast network of restaurants, grocery chains, and food service providers (including Sysco, US Foods, and DOT Foods) across the nation.

Features / Highlights

Mike's Pies Inc stands out in the competitive Florida dessert market due to several key features that underscore their reputation for excellence and reliability.

• Multiple National Championship Winner: The company boasts an impressive 15 National Championships from the Great American Pie Festival, with particular recognition for their Key Lime Pie and Reese's Peanut Butter Pie. Their famous Key Lime Pie is a four-time winner, made authentically with egg yolks, condensed milk, and genuine Nellie & Joe’s Key Lime Juice—no fillers.
• Family Recipe Quality: The entire product line is built upon time-honored family recipes, ensuring a traditional, homemade taste. This heritage translates to a strict "no preservatives or fillers" policy, making their desserts a clean and honest choice.
• The Florida Dessert Authority: Beyond awards, Mike's Pies has been recognized by local publications like the Tampa Bay Times and Creative Loafing Tampa Bay as the Best Key Lime Pie, cementing their status as the local authority on this iconic Florida dessert. Their Key Lime Pie is often described as the "epitome of Florida in every bite."
• Frozen-Fresh Advantage: The company utilizes a successful method of freezing pies immediately after creation. This process locks in the flavor and allows for efficient, consistent quality, ensuring that customers receive a product that is perfectly preserved until it is thawed for consumption. This method is the key to their ability to serve high-quality desserts nationwide without compromising taste.
• Diverse Menu Catering to All Tastes: With an extensive menu including specialty items like Blackberry Pie, Buttermilk Pie, and Banana Foster Cheesecake, the bakery caters to virtually every dessert craving, offering a much wider selection than most traditional retail bakeries.

Contact Information

For Florida customers, whether you are picking up a pre-ordered specialty cake or dropping by for a few pies, here is the essential contact and location information for Mike's Pies Inc.

Address: 10350 Windhorst Rd #100, Tampa, FL 33619, USA

Primary Phone: (813) 249-7437

Mobile Phone: +1 813-249-7437

Given the location within a commercial area, local customers are encouraged to use the provided phone number to confirm current hours, check stock availability, or receive helpful, detailed directions upon arrival to ensure a smooth and quick visit.

What is Worth Choosing

For local Florida residents, choosing Mike's Pies Inc is an excellent decision driven by quality, tradition, and an unmatched reputation. What makes this Tampa bakery truly worth choosing is the opportunity to purchase national-caliber, award-winning desserts directly from the source.

If you value authenticity, there is no better choice for the iconic Florida dessert: the Key Lime Pie. Mike's version is consistently acclaimed for its perfect balance—a tart, zesty filling complemented by a perfectly crunchy, non-sweet Graham cracker crust—a flavor profile that has been recognized with multiple national titles. You are getting the 'Best of Tampa Bay' in every slice.

Beyond the signature pie, the sheer breadth of the menu ensures a perfect dessert for any occasion. Whether you need a full Southern Pecan Pie for a holiday gathering, a decadent Red Velvet Cheesecake for a dinner party, or a satisfying slice of Heath Bar Crunch for yourself, the quality is guaranteed. Customers frequently commend the convenience of the frozen-fresh format, which allows them to purchase in advance and thaw only what they need, maintaining optimal flavor and texture.

In essence, Mike's Pies Inc offers a chance to bypass the often lower-quality, mass-produced supermarket options and bring home a dessert that has been tried, tested, and awarded on a national stage. This Tampa gem represents the highest standard in Florida baking, making it the premier choice for anyone who believes that life is short, and you should always eat dessert first.

Mike's Pies Inc

10350 Windhorst Rd #100, Tampa, FL 33619, USA