My Sugar Slice

When New Jersey residents are searching for a true indulgence, they often seek out local spots that deliver on freshness, creativity, and incredible flavor. In Trenton, that destination for all things sweet is My Sugar Slice. Situated on Spring Street, this pastry shop has quickly built a reputation for crafting exceptional desserts that are far from ordinary. It’s a dedicated dessert haven, where cookies are hailed as the “best,” and the menu is an imaginative blend of comforting classics and gourmet flavor innovations.

My Sugar Slice specializes in elevating everyday treats into high-quality, unforgettable experiences. They are particularly famous for their diverse and high-quality cookies, with customers specifically singling out the sugar cookies for their superior taste and presentation. But the offerings go far beyond a simple cookie jar. The shop is a hub for a broad spectrum of baked goods, including delicate macarons, rich cheesecakes, and celebration-worthy cakes.

What truly distinguishes My Sugar Slice is the sheer variety and creativity evident in their flavor lists. From bold choices like Berry Champagne and Wildberry Lavender to comforting favorites like Cookie Dough and Red Velvet Cream Cheese, there is an exciting flavor profile to satisfy any craving. This commitment to fresh, unique, and beautifully executed desserts makes My Sugar Slice a standout establishment in Mercer County and a highly recommended spot for anyone seeking to add a little sweetness to their day.

***

Location and Accessibility

My Sugar Slice is a local gem located in Trenton, the heart of Mercer County. Its location offers convenience for local residents and those visiting the city, providing a quick stop for high-quality dessert cravings.

The precise address is:

88 Spring St 1st fl, Trenton, NJ 08618, USA

Located on the first floor of an easily identifiable property on Spring Street, the shop focuses on a focused, dessert-oriented quick visit dining option. As a local pastry shop, the primary service model is tailored for immediate enjoyment or easy takeout. It is important for visitors to note that My Sugar Slice operates as a Cash-only business, so patrons should plan their visit accordingly.

***

Services Offered

My Sugar Slice provides an impressive variety of services focused entirely on delivering a premium dessert experience. The shop is a go-to for daily treats as well as special occasion planning in New Jersey.

• Gourmet Cookie Selection: Offering a wide array of cookies, including highly praised sugar cookies, Snickerdoodle, Peanut Butter, Cookies n’ Cream, and Triple Chocolate.
• Specialty Flavor Cakes and Cupcakes: Featuring imaginative flavors that extend beyond the usual, such as Wildberry Lavender, Caramel Mocha, Lemon Raspberry, German Chocolate, and Nutella Marshmallow.
• Artisan Macarons: Providing a selection of delicate French macarons in sophisticated flavors, which may include Lemon, Creamsicle, Nutella, and White Chocolate Raspberry.
• Unique Dessert Concepts: Known for specialized and creative desserts, notably a unique cheesecake-on-a-stick, which is dipped in chocolate and finished with various toppings like cookie crumbs and sprinkles.
• Custom and Pre-Designed Cakes: Offering services for ordering both pre-designed cakes and receiving quotes for custom cakes, making it a versatile choice for birthdays, holidays, and other celebrations.
• Wide Range of Cheesecake Flavors: Providing a deep selection of cheesecake fillings, including Plain, Chocolate Chip, Strawberry, Raspberry, Key Lime, Apple Pie, and a unique Chocolate Cookie Dough Pecan.
• Pastry and Pie Selection: Including various pastries and pies, with featured options like Blueberry Pie, Key Lime Pie, and seasonal choices available in-store.
• Dessert Catering and Packaging: Offering great packages (as noted by customer reviews), making it ideal for large orders, parties, and gifts.

***

Features / Highlights

My Sugar Slice’s reputation is built on several key features that make it a favorite among local New Jersey dessert enthusiasts.

• Exceptional Cookie Quality: Customer reviews emphatically rate the cookies as 10/10 and the "best," highlighting the high quality and delicious taste, particularly the sugar cookies.
• Creative and Extensive Flavor Menu: The shop goes above and beyond standard offerings with a rotating and diverse flavor list that includes gourmet options like Wildberry Lavender, Berry Champagne, and Peanut Butter Party, which keeps customers eagerly anticipating new seasonal additions.
• Signature Dessert: The Cheesecake-on-a-Stick is a standout feature, providing a fun, unique, and portable dessert experience dipped in chocolate and customizable with various toppings.
• Macarons and Mini Sweets: The availability of beautifully crafted macarons and various mini sweets caters to customers looking for light, delicate, or visually appealing dessert options.
• Focus on Dessert: Specializing purely in desserts ensures all efforts are concentrated on the art of baking and pastry, resulting in a higher quality finished product across the board.
• Great Packaging for Gifting: The shop's attention to professional and attractive packaging makes its products ideal for gifts, party favors, or professional presentation.

***

Contact Information

For Trenton-area residents looking to satisfy a sweet craving or place a custom order, the contact information for My Sugar Slice is provided below. Please remember that the shop is Cash-only for payments.

Address:

88 Spring St 1st fl

Trenton, NJ 08618, USA

Phone:

(646) 764-3193

Mobile Phone (for calls or text inquiries):

+1 646-764-3193

***

What is Worth Choosing

For anyone in New Jersey, particularly those in the Trenton and Mercer County area, choosing My Sugar Slice is choosing a guaranteed high-quality, memorable sweet treat. What makes this pastry shop truly worth choosing is the unparalleled combination of gourmet creativity and comfort-food execution.

If you are looking for a reliable, exceptional cookie, the local recommendation is clear: the sugar cookies here are a must-try. For events and celebrations, the shop's willingness to work on pre-designed and custom cakes, backed by an imaginative flavor repertoire, simplifies party planning with a delicious centerpiece.

Finally, the unique specialty items like the cheesecake-on-a-stick offer a fun, distinctive choice you won't easily find elsewhere. My Sugar Slice is the perfect local spot for anyone seeking an instant indulgence, a special gift (thanks to their great packaging), or a show-stopping dessert for any occasion. Just remember to bring cash to enjoy this Trenton dessert gem!

My Sugar Slice

88 Spring St 1st fl, Trenton, NJ 08618, USA