Oh what a bagel

Introduction / Overview

In New Jersey, the quest for the perfect bagel is a serious affair, and for residents of Ocean County, one name consistently rises to the top: Oh What A Bagel. More than just a simple shop, this Bayville institution is a cornerstone of the local breakfast and lunch scene, embodying the authentic 'Jersey' bagel shop feel that locals know and love. It’s a place where traditional craftsmanship meets prompt, friendly service, making it a reliable favorite for your morning routine or a quick midday bite.

Located conveniently in Bayville, Oh What A Bagel specializes in the art of the fresh-baked bagel. They are celebrated for their traditional boiling and baking methods, which result in a bagel that achieves the perfect textural balance: a slightly crisp, flavorful crust enveloping a soft, chewy, and pillowy interior. This dedication to quality ensures that whether you're grabbing a single, warm bagel or a dozen for the office, you're getting the genuine article.

The shop's menu extends far beyond the basics. While their classic bagels and homemade cream cheese spreads are a major draw—with popular, highly-praised options like olive pimento cream cheese—they also serve up a full range of breakfast favorites and lunch options. You’ll find everything from perfectly cooked egg sandwiches to unique and delicious items like their noted crunchy avocado egg sandwich, ensuring there’s something fresh and satisfying for every craving. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick cup of coffee and a plain bagel or settling in to enjoy a hearty breakfast sandwich, Oh What A Bagel maintains a commitment to using fresh ingredients and providing a welcoming community atmosphere.

Location and Accessibility

Accessibility is key for any successful local spot, and Oh What A Bagel is strategically situated to serve the Bayville and wider Ocean County communities. You’ll find this local gem at:

657 Atlantic City Blvd, Bayville, NJ 08721, USA.

The location on Atlantic City Boulevard (Route 9) makes it highly convenient for commuters traveling through the area or for local residents planning a quick stop. Its position helps solidify its status as a reliable daily destination.

For patrons with mobility concerns, the shop ensures a hassle-free visit with thoughtful accommodations. The location is equipped with a Wheelchair accessible entrance, providing easy access for everyone. Furthermore, parking is simple and convenient, featuring a dedicated Free parking lot right on the premises, along with options for Free street parking nearby. This makes for a quick visit possible whether you're rushing to work or enjoying a leisurely morning.

Services Offered

Oh What A Bagel is committed to providing service options that fit the fast-paced lifestyle of New Jersey locals while also offering a comfortable spot for dining in. Their service structure is designed for maximum convenience and speed.

Primary Service Options:

• Takeout: The classic New Jersey bagel run—quick and efficient service to get your breakfast on the road. Patrons consistently praise the staff for being "super fast."
• Dine-in: For those who prefer to enjoy their hot and crunchy bagel sandwich right away, comfortable seating is available. Customers note that dining in is an excellent choice for a hot and fresh experience.
• In-store pickup: Convenient for placing an order ahead of time to minimize wait, especially during busy morning hours.

Convenience and Payment:

• Payment Methods: The shop accepts a variety of modern payment options, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, streamlining the checkout process.

Features / Highlights

What truly sets Oh What A Bagel apart and maintains its strong reputation within the competitive New Jersey bagel market are its distinct features and culinary highlights.

Standout Features:

• Authentic Bagel Preparation: The shop is locally renowned for using traditional methods, including boiling the dough before baking. This commitment is what creates the superior texture—the desired chewy inside and crisp exterior—that defines a true Jersey bagel.
• Fresh-Made Breakfast Items: Beyond the bagel itself, the quality of their made-to-order sandwiches is a major draw. Reviewers highlight the use of fresh eggs and fresh toppings, making the experience consistently excellent.
• Specialty Cream Cheeses: The variety of cream cheese is a key component of their success. They offer classic flavors but are particularly celebrated for their unique and flavorful gourmet spreads. A customer favorite often mentioned is the distinct olive pimento cream cheese.
• Signature Sandwiches: A must-try item that receives high praise is the crunchy avocado egg sandwich, showcasing their willingness to offer modern, appealing options alongside traditional staples.
• Community Staple and Friendly Service: Operating for many years, the shop has cultivated a loyal following. The staff is consistently described as friendly, kind, and thoughtful, enhancing the overall welcoming experience.
• Full Breakfast and Lunch Menu: While bagels are the core offering, the menu includes a wide variety of deli meats, egg and cheese combinations (including the New Jersey staple Taylor Ham), and a selection of pastries, ensuring options for any time of the morning.

Contact Information

Whether you're calling ahead to place a large order, checking the daily bagel selection, or simply confirming hours, here is the essential contact information for Oh What A Bagel in Bayville, NJ:

Address: 657 Atlantic City Blvd, Bayville, NJ 08721, USA

Phone Number: (732) 269-8828

What is Worth Choosing

For any first-time visitor or long-time local looking for a reminder of the best to order, certain items at Oh What A Bagel stand out as true testaments to their quality and flavor.

The Fresh Bagel Itself: You can’t go wrong with a simple bagel. Since the process of boiling and baking is what makes the base product so exceptional, try any classic flavor—such as Everything or Plain—to appreciate the perfect chewy texture and thin, slightly crispy crust.

Specialty Cream Cheese: The cream cheeses are a signature offering. The olive pimento cream cheese is a fan-favorite, providing a savory and unique counterpoint to the warm bagel. They also offer a variety of other flavored cream cheeses to cater to all preferences, including sweeter options and vegetable blends.

Breakfast Sandwiches: For a substantial start to your day, one of their fresh, hot breakfast sandwiches is a top choice. The combination of fresh-cooked eggs, melted cheese, and your choice of meat on a toasted bagel is a benchmark for quality in the region. And for the health-conscious or those seeking a modern flavor, the crunchy avocado egg sandwich is a highly recommended and innovative menu highlight that local customers love.

Quick and Friendly Service: Finally, what makes Oh What A Bagel a destination is the overall experience. The staff is consistently praised for being super friendly and providing fast service. In the rush of a New Jersey morning, this commitment to a pleasant and efficient transaction is a value that keeps customers—from casual visitors to nearby business owners—coming back for their daily fix.

Oh what a bagel

657 Atlantic City Blvd, Bayville, NJ 08721, USA