Pennington Bagel: Authentic New Jersey Bagels and Deli in Mercer County

Pennington Bagel Introduce

If you live in Central New Jersey, the quest for the perfect, authentic bagel often feels like a serious mission. Fortunately, the residents of Mercer County and beyond consistently point to one establishment as a local champion: Pennington Bagel. Operating as both a quintessential bagel shop and a fantastic all-day breakfast and lunch restaurant, this local gem has carved out a reputation built on traditional preparation, high-quality ingredients, and an incredibly diverse menu.

For New Jersey locals, a true bagel is more than just a ring of bread; it's a testament to tradition, featuring a crispy, slightly chewy crust and a soft, dense interior. Pennington Bagel has prided itself on upholding this standard, boiling their dough and baking on stone to ensure that authentic texture and flavor. This commitment to the "old-fashion way" of baking is what sets them apart in a state known for its high bagel standards.

Whether you are stopping by for a quick breakfast sandwich to fuel your morning commute down Route 31, planning a large office catering order, or simply craving a freshly baked bagel with a specialty spread for a midday treat, Pennington Bagel offers a welcoming, quick-visit amenity that delivers on its promise of quality.

The menu selection extends far beyond the basic plain and everything bagels, offering dozens of fresh-made options and a full-service deli, making it a reliable destination for any meal of the day. The dedication to making core ingredients fresh from scratch daily—including all of their homemade salads like chicken, tuna, and egg salad—ensures that every item served maintains a consistently high level of freshness and flavor.

Location and Accessibility

Pennington Bagel is conveniently situated at a prime location for residents and commuters in the greater Hopewell Township and Pennington area. The address is 25 NJ-31, Pennington, NJ 08534, USA. This placement directly on Route 31 ensures easy access for anyone traveling through Mercer County.

As a local business, the shop has made significant efforts to ensure accessibility for all patrons. The facility offers practical amenities, including a wheelchair-accessible entrance, a wheelchair-accessible parking lot, and a wheelchair-accessible restroom. This focus on ease of access, combined with a free parking lot and free street parking options, makes stopping in for a quick bite or picking up a full dozen of bagels simple and stress-free. The quick-visit planning amenity also highlights its efficiency, catering perfectly to busy New Jersey schedules.

Services Offered

Pennington Bagel operates as a full-service breakfast and lunch establishment, providing a variety of convenient services to the local community.

In-store dining and quick visits for a fresh meal.
Takeout for easy ordering and pickup.
Delivery and in-store pickup options for maximum convenience.
Catering services, including popular options like Party Bagels or Two-Foot Bagel Hoagies, ideal for local business meetings or family gatherings.
A full coffee menu featuring Hot Regular Coffee, Dark Roast, Decaf, Organic Coffee, and Iced Coffee.
An extensive all-day menu of breakfast sandwiches, custom deli sandwiches, hoagies, and full-size salads.
Specialty menus including Vegetarian Combos and Low-Fat Sandwich Combos to meet diverse dietary needs.
Prepared salads and deli meats available by the pound or half-pound, such as Homemade Tuna Salad, Chicken Salad, Egg Salad, Potato Salad, Macaroni Salad, and Coleslaw.

Features / Highlights

The reputation of Pennington Bagel is built on several key features that resonate strongly with the local New Jersey market:

Authentic Bagel Quality: The bagels are made fresh daily on the premises. The traditional method of boiling the dough and baking them on stone ensures the classic New Jersey bagel texture—chewy on the inside and crisp on the outside.
Creative and Unique Bagel Flavors: Beyond the classics like Plain, Everything, Sesame, and Poppy, the shop offers distinctive flavors such as Asiago, Asiago Everything, Swiss Cheese, Swiss Onion, Blueberry Crunch, and a variety of French Toast bagels (Plain, Egg, and Cinnamon Raisin).
Gourmet and Specialty Spreads: An impressive selection of spreads goes beyond basic cream cheese. Highlights include Lox Spread, Veggie Specialty Spread, Scallion Specialty Spread, Olive Specialty Spread, Strawberry Specialty Spread, Cinnamon-Sugar Butter Spread, and the decadent Cinnamon-Raisin Walnut Specialty Spread.
Comprehensive Deli and Lunch Menu: The commitment to quality extends to their deli, which offers a full range of sandwiches (Pastrami, Roast Beef, Homemade Chicken Salad, etc.), Hoagies, and Tossed Salad Combos (Chef's Salad, Cobb Salad, Chicken Caesar Salad).
All-Day Breakfast: Serving classic breakfast sandwiches—including Egg & Cheese, Meat & Egg, and Meat, Egg & Cheese—made to order on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread.
Homemade Salads: Chicken salad, tuna salad, egg salad, potato salad, macaroni salad, and coleslaw are made fresh from scratch every day.
Payment Flexibility: The shop accepts Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC mobile payments for a quick and modern transaction experience.

Contact Information

To place an order, inquire about catering, or find directions, please use the following contact information.

Address: 25 NJ-31, Pennington, NJ 08534, USA

Phone: (609) 737-8990

Mobile Phone: +1 609-737-8990

What is Worth Choosing at Pennington Bagel

For anyone in New Jersey, Pennington Bagel is worth choosing first and foremost for the unparalleled quality of its core product: the bagel itself. Customer testimonials frequently praise the shop for having "THE BEST bagels in Mercer County," and for their "incredible texture and flavor." For those who grew up near New York City and understand the standard for a great bagel, Pennington Bagel consistently meets and exceeds expectations.

The variety of offerings, from the extensive list of specialty spreads to the hearty lunch options, ensures there is something for every taste and craving. If you are looking for a unique breakfast experience, try one of the French Toast-style bagels or the Asiago Everything bagel, paired with a Cinnamon-Raisin Walnut Specialty Spread. For lunch, a classic deli sandwich made with homemade chicken or tuna salad, served on one of their freshly baked bagels, is a local favorite. The dedication to homemade ingredients across the menu—from their salads to their specialty spreads—provides a fresh, high-quality meal every time you visit. It's a true local institution that maintains its high standards, making it a reliable and beloved choice in the New Jersey food scene.

Pennington Bagel Vibe

All Day Menu - Spreads
Cream Cheese Spread $4.50
Choose between regular cream cheese and low fat cream cheese.
Lox Spread $6.75
Veggie Specialty Spread $5.25
Peanut Butter $5.00
On your choice of a Bagel
Scallion Specialty Spread $5.25
Strawberry Specialty Spread $5.25
Cinnamon-Sugar Butter Spread $4.25
Cinnamon-Raisin Walnut Specialty Spread $5.25
Olive Specialty Spread $5.25
Jelly Spread $4.00
PB & Jelly Spread $5.50
Choice of strawberry or grape spread.
Buttered Bagel $4.00

All Day Menu - Coffee
Hot Regular Coffee
Dark Roast Hot Coffee
Decaf Hot Coffee
Iced Coffee
Organic Hot Coffee
Flavor Of The Day Hot Coffee

All Day Menu - Create Your Own Sandwich
Pastrami Sandwich $11.50
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
Cheese Sandwich $8.00
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
Homemade Egg Salad Sandwich $12.50
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
Ham Sandwich $10.50
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
BLT Sandwich $10.50
Bacon, lettuce & tomato. Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
Cappicola Sandwich $10.00
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
Roast Beef Sandwich $11.50
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
Turkey Sandwich $10.50
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
Salami Sandwich $9.00
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
Chicken Sandwich $10.50
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
Homemade Tuna Salad Sandwich $12.50
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
Homemade Chicken Salad Sandwich $12.50
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
Corned Beef Sandwich $11.50
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.

All Day Menu - Vegetarian Combos
15 | Vegetarian Combo $13.00
Fresh Mozzarella cheese, lettuce, tomato & roasted red peppers with balsamic vinaigrette dressing.
16 | Vegetarian Combo $13.00
Roasted red pepper hummus, sprouts, carrots, cucumber & tomato.
18 | Vegetarian Combo $13.00
Sprouts, lettuce, tomato, carrots, cucumber, & onions with Lite Ranch dressing.
17 | Vegetarian Combo $13.00
Your choice of low fat veggie cream cheese, low fat scallion cream cheese, or melted Colby Jack cheese with lettuce, tomato, cucumber, carrots & honey mustard.

All Day Menu - Tossed Salad Combos
Create Your Own Salad $14.50
Choose from any one meat, one cheese, and any of our salad toppings. Served with your choice of mini bagel.
Chef's Salad $14.50
Boar's Head turkey, ham, and roast beef with cheese and half boiled egg. Served on a bed of mixed greens with carrots, cucumbers, tomato, with your choice of dressing and a mini bagel.
Just Veggies & Cheese Salad $13.50
Choose two cheeses with roasted red peppers and hard boiled egg. Option to add hot peppers. Served on a bed of mixed greens with carrots, cucumbers, tomato, with your choice of dressing and a mini bagel.
Chicken B.L.T. Salad $14.50
Oven roasted chicken breast with Muenster cheese and bacon. Served on a bed of mixed greens with carrots, cucumbers, tomato, with your choice of dressing and a mini bagel.
Single Scoop Salad $13.50
Choose one scoop of homemade chicken, tuna, or egg salad. Served on a bed of mixed greens with carrots, cucumbers, tomato, with your choice of dressing and a mini bagel.
Three Scoop Sampler Salad $14.50
Choose three scoops of our homemade chicken, tuna, or egg salad. Served on a bed of mixed greens with carrots, cucumbers, tomato, with your choice of dressing and a mini bagel.
Cobb Salad $14.50
Chicken breast, bacon, crumbled Blue cheese and hard boiled egg. Served on a bed of mixed greens with carrots, cucumbers, tomato, with your choice of dressing and a mini bagel.
Chicken Caesar Salad $14.50
Mixed greens, chicken breast and Asiago cheese with bagel croutons and Caesar dressing. Served with your choice of mini bagel.
Roasted Red Pepper & Chicken Breast Salad $14.50
Chicken breast with roasted red peppers and Provolone cheese. Served on a bed of mixed greens with carrots, cucumbers, tomato, with your choice of dressing and a mini bagel.

All Day Menu - Low Fat Sandwich Combos
9 | Low Fat Sandwich Combo $12.00
Maple honey ham, Lite scallion cream cheese, cucumbers and tomato. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
10 | Low Fat Sandwich Combo $12.00
Cracked Pepper Mill Turkey, tomato, onions and spicy mustard. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.

All Day Menu - Soups
Soup
Call for the flavors at 609-737-8990 Small 12oz Large 16oz

All Day Menu - Mini Bagels
Dozen Mini Bagels $14.50
Everything Mini Bagels
Sesame Mini Bagels
Plain Mini Bagels
Mini Bagel With TOPPING
In notes write what kind if mini ( Plain, Ev, Poppy, Ses) and if you pick Specialty Cream cheese what kind!
Poppy Mini Bagels

All Day Menu - Bagel Twists
Plain Bagel Twist $5.00
Everything Bagel Twist $5.00
Sesame Bagel Twist $5.00

All Day Menu - Drinks
Diet Coke $3.75
Snapple Lemon $3.50
Diet Peach Snapple $3.50
Diet Lemon Snapple $3.50
Diet Pepsi $3.75
Chocolate Milk $3.75
Poland Spring Water $2.50
Orange Juice $3.75
Coke $3.75
Pepsi $3.75
Prime $4.50
Snapple Peach $3.50

All Day Menu - Smoked Fish on a Bagel
Nova Bagel $13.00
Nova & Cream Cheese Bagel $14.00
Whitefish Bagel $11.50

All Day Menu - Bagels
Blueberry Crunch Bagel $1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Cinnamon Raisin French Toast Bagel $1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Gluten Free Bagel $2.00
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Blueberry Bagel $1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Swiss Cheese Bagel
Egg Bagel $1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Poppy Bagel $1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Cinnamon Sugar Bagel $1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Plain French Toast Bagel $1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Asiago Everything $2.00
Sesame Bagel $1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Egg Everything Bagel $1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Plain Bagel $1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Salt Bagel $1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Onion Bagel $1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Asiago $2.00
Dozen Bagels $18.00
Bagels by the dozen. Don't forget to click 3 bagels at the end you get 14 in our Dozen :)
Half Dozen Bagels $9.00
6 bagels of your choice.
Cinnamon Raisin Bagel $1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Egg French Toast Bagel $1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Whole Wheat Everything Bagel $1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.

All Day Menu - Sandwich Combos
7 | Sandwich Combo $14.00
Cracked Peppermill turkey, Swiss cheese, coleslaw, and Russian dressing. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
13 | Sandwich Combo $13.25
Chicken breast, roasted red peppers, melted Provolone cheese and mayo. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
5 | Sandwich Combo $14.00
Ham and turkey, Monterey Jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, honey mustard and mayo. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
Spicy Hot Sandwich $14.00
Buffalo chicken breast, melted Colby Jack cheese, cream cheese, shredded lettuce, tomatoes, and Tostitos. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
12 | Sandwich Combo $14.00
Buffalo chicken breast, Cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo or Blue cheese dressing. Can be served hot or cold. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
8 | Sandwich Combo $14.00
Homemade famous chicken salad, Provolone cheese, bacon and honey mustard. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
Olympic Sandwich $14.00
Chicken breast, melted Gouda cheese, avocado, cranberries, lettuce, tomato and honey mustard. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
Apple/Brie & Chicken Sandwich $14.00
Chicken breast, melted Brie cheese, spinach and pesto. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
19 | Sandwich Combo $14.00
One of our most popular sandwiches! BBQ chicken breast, melted Colby Jack cheese, minced onions, BBQ sauce, bacon and mayo. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
11 | Sandwich Combo $14.00
Hot corned beef with sauerkraut, melted Swiss cheese, and Russian Dressing. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
14 | Sandwich Combo $14.00
Maple honey turkey breast, melted Monterey Jack cheese, lettuce, tomato and honey mustard. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
WeMakeWich $14.00
Bacon, melted Pepper jack Cheese, Red Onion, Avocado and Cajun Mayo
4 | Sandwich Combo $14.00
Salsalito turkey breast, melted Cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
3 | Sandwich Combo $14.00
Roast beef, melted Cheddar cheese, minced onions and horseradish sauce. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
Blazing Chicken Sandwich $14.00
Buffalo chicken breast, Blue cheese, melted Cheddar cheese, shredded lettuce, avocado, bacon and hot sauce. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
1 | Sandwich Combo $14.00
Maple honey ham with scallion cream cheese, cucumbers, lettuce, tomato and honey mustard. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
6 | Sandwich Combo $14.00
Chicken breast, melted Muenster cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
2 | Sandwich Combo $14.00
Hot pastrami with melted Swiss cheese, homemade coleslaw and cajun mayo. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
Stoked Combo $14.00
Chicken breast with melted cheddar, spinach, bacon , avocado and topped with ranch

All Day Menu - Hoagies
Homemade Tuna Hoagie $12.50
Served on a base of your choice with a pickle.
Chicken Breast & Cheese Hoagie $11.00
Served on a base of your choice with a pickle.
Pastrami Hoagie $12.50
Served on a base of your choice with a pickle.
Turkey & Cheese Hoagie $11.50
Served on a base of your choice with a pickle.
Egg Salad Hoagie $12.50
Served on a base of your choice with a pickle.
Corned Beef & Cheese Hoagie $11.50
Served on a base of your choice with a pickle.
Chicken Salad Hoagie $12.50
Served on a base of your choice with a pickle.
Italian Hoagie $10.50
Ham, salami, cappicola, and Provolone cheese served on a base of your choice with a pickle.
Roast Beef Hoagie $12.50
Served on a base of your choice with a pickle.

All Day Menu - Extra Sides
Bag Of Chips $2.50
Choose between regular or sour cream.
Side Macaroni Salad $2.50
Side Potato Salad $2.50
Deep River Chips $3.19
Choose between plain, BBQ, salt & vinegar, sour cream & onion, and jalapeno.
Side Coleslaw $2.50

All Day Menu - Breakfast Sandwiches
Egg Breakfast Sandwich $7.00
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread.
Meat & Cheese Breakfast Sandwich $8.75
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread.
Egg & Cheese Breakfast Sandwich $8.00
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, twist or bread.
Meat Breakfast Sandwich $8.25
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread.
Meat, Egg & Cheese Breakfast Sandwich $8.75
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread.
Meat & Egg Breakfast Sandwich $8.25
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread.

All Day Menu - By the Pound or Half Pound
Potato Salad
Chicken Salad
Macaroni Salad
Egg Salad
Fresh Sliced Nova
Coleslaw
Tuna Salad

Pennington Bagel Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
Takeout
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Amenities
Restroom

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking

Pennington Bagel Photos

Pennington Bagel Location

Pennington Bagel

New Jersey Mercer County Pennington New Jersey 31

25 NJ-31, Pennington, NJ 08534, USA

Pennington Bagel Reviews

An average rating of ★4.2 from 296 user reviews.

areabreakfast sandwichesmicrowavefrench toasteverything bagelgrillpork rolltomatoplain bagellunch

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

A wide variety of very good bagels and spreads. Actually, I have to say it more directly --- PB has THE BEST bagels in Mercer County! And very good coffee.I grew up in New York City. I know a good bagel when I see it (or better yet eat it). I have tried all of the bagel shops in Mercer and Somerset counties and Pennington is The Best!I don't live near the place, but I will go out of my way to have a bagel here. Give 'em a try. You won't be disappointed.
April 05 · Jersey Guy
A great local bagel shop with a wide array of classic, out-of-the-box, and seasonal flavors. Above all, however, is their delicious bagel quality. We assessed the quality of their Plain Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese to other local bagel shops, and they came out on top due to their incredible texture and flavor. Service is timely and welcoming, while the food is inexpensive. Would highly recommend.
November 18 · Gabriella
I ordered a turkey sandwich on a plain bagel, lettuce, tomato, mayo, and bacon.It came with coleslaw and pickles. I also got kettle cooked sea salt chips and got a raspberry Snapple iced tea. I must say the sandwich was incredibly delicious. I’m pretty sure they make their own coleslaw and it was perfect. Not sure what kind of pickles they use, but they were better than your average pickle. And not spears. All the ingredients tasted very fresh, Including the turkey. And for some reason everything didn’t slide out when I took a bite into the sandwich. Although it was Sunday at 1:30 PM, I barely waited 2 minutes. I think they do a great job over there and I will definitely be back.
October 22 · Adam Jankos
Decent experience. The bagel shop has a family feel. And the bagels are fresh and well-seasoned.Not thrilled about the microwaved eggs though. I prefer a flat-top grill any day.Would return.
September 04 · Nicole
Fantastic Bagel Sandwiches. Fast and friendly service, we'll priced. Can't ask for more. Everytime i go they've got some kind of new coffee creamer to try which makes things fun and interesting.
April 24 · A McCollum (aMcCollum153)