Pick a Bagel: A Reliable Upper East Side Staple for Authentic Bagels

Pick a Bagel Introduce

For many New Yorkers, a great day starts with a great bagel, and for those on the Upper East Side, Pick a Bagel is a name that comes to mind. This local establishment on 2nd Avenue has been serving the community for years, building a reputation as a consistently reliable and friendly spot for breakfast, lunch, and everything in between. In a city saturated with bagel shops, Pick a Bagel distinguishes itself with its commitment to fresh, hand-rolled bagels and a broad menu that goes far beyond the basics. It's the kind of place that becomes a neighborhood fixture, where regulars are known and service is a point of pride.

The true mark of a quintessential New York bagel shop is not just the quality of the bagel itself, but the entire experience surrounding it. Pick a Bagel understands this, offering a welcoming atmosphere and a newly renovated space that enhances the customer journey. Patrons appreciate the courteous service and the attention to detail that ensures every order is made to perfection. This focus on customer satisfaction, from double-checking order details to offering thoughtful gestures like rewarming coffee, is a testament to the bakery’s dedication to its clientele. It's this combination of delicious food and a positive, personalized experience that makes Pick a Bagel a staple for many in the neighborhood.

This article will provide a comprehensive and factual overview of Pick a Bagel, focusing on its prime Manhattan location, the extensive range of services and food items available, and the key features that make it a favorite among locals. We'll explore why this shop is more than just a place to grab a quick bite—it's an essential part of the community's daily rhythm. By highlighting its strengths and acknowledging the full customer experience, we aim to give a complete picture of why this bagel shop is a recommended choice for anyone in the New York region.

Location and Accessibility

Pick a Bagel is located at 1475 2nd Avenue in New York, NY 10075. This is a highly desirable and easily accessible location in the heart of the Upper East Side. 2nd Avenue is a major thoroughfare, making the shop a convenient stop for a wide range of customers. Whether you are a local resident walking from a nearby apartment building, a commuter passing through the area, or someone visiting the neighborhood, the location is simple to find.

The accessibility is further enhanced by the area's excellent public transportation options. The shop is within walking distance of multiple subway stations, including the Q train and other major lines, as well as several bus routes. For those who walk, the shop is a quick and easy stop during a morning routine. While parking in Manhattan can be a challenge, the convenience of the public transit system and the general walkability of the neighborhood mean that getting to Pick a Bagel is straightforward for most New Yorkers.

Services Offered

Pick a Bagel offers a vast and impressive menu that extends far beyond just bagels. This diverse selection of food and beverages makes it a one-stop shop for breakfast, lunch, and a snack at any time of day.

Freshly Baked Bagels and More: The core of their business is a wide variety of freshly made, hand-rolled bagels in classic flavors like plain, everything, sesame, and poppy. They also offer other baked goods like mini bagels, flagels, bialys, and challah rolls.
Cream Cheese and Spreads: To go with the bagels, there is an extensive selection of cream cheeses and spreads. This includes classic plain and scallion cream cheese, as well as a variety of flavored options like vegetable, olive, walnut and raisin, strawberry, and even jalapeño. They also offer low-fat and tofu-based spreads.
Breakfast and Lunch Menu: The menu is robust, featuring a full range of hot breakfast items like scrambled egg sandwiches, omelettes, pancakes, and French toast. For lunch, they offer a huge selection of deli sandwiches, paninis, salads, and wraps with options like roast beef, pastrami, smoked fish, and various salad spreads.
Smoked Fish Platters: For a true New York deli experience, they offer beautifully arranged smoked fish platters with Nova Scotia salmon, smoked sable, and whitefish, served with bagels and all the trimmings.
Catering and Delivery: Pick a Bagel offers catering services, making it a great option for office meetings or parties. They also have delivery and pickup services through their own website and third-party platforms, which is a key convenience for many New Yorkers.
Beverages: A full range of beverages is available, including coffee, tea, fresh-squeezed juices, and more to complement any meal.

Features and Highlights

Pick a Bagel is known for several key features that make it a standout choice in a competitive market.

Exceptional Customer Service: As noted by a satisfied customer, the service is "friendly" and "courteous." The staff goes above and beyond to ensure order accuracy by asking important, detailed questions. This level of attentiveness, such as offering to rewarm a coffee, is a rare and highly appreciated gesture in a busy shop.
Post-Renovation Improvements: The shop recently underwent a renovation that improved the customer experience, including a lower counter that makes ordering easier. This demonstrates the business's commitment to creating a comfortable and accessible environment for all patrons.
Freshness and Variety: Customers consistently praise the bagels for being "very fresh" and "high quality." The wide variety of bagels, spreads, and full-service deli and breakfast menus ensures there is always something new and delicious to try.
Convenient and Reliable: The shop is described as a "neighborhood go-to staple" and a "consistently reliable" option. This reputation for dependability is crucial for a local business in a major city.
Outdoor Seating: The availability of a few outdoor tables is a great feature for those who want to enjoy their meal outside, especially on a nice day.

Contact Information

To connect with Pick a Bagel's Upper East Side location, you can use the following information:

Address: 1475 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10075, USA

Phone: (212) 717-4668

Conclusion: Why this place is suitable for locals

Pick a Bagel on 2nd Avenue is perfectly suited for locals in New York, and especially the Upper East Side, because it offers an ideal blend of classic quality and modern convenience. For many, a good bagel is a cornerstone of daily life, and this shop delivers on that front consistently. The fresh, hand-rolled bagels are a highlight, but it's the entire ecosystem of services—from a huge variety of spreads and a full-service deli menu to quick, friendly service—that makes it a standout. The recent renovations show a commitment to improving the customer experience, which is always a welcome sign for a neighborhood business.

While a small number of customers have noted issues with pricing or order accuracy, the overwhelmingly positive feedback points to a business that strives to get things right. The personalized, courteous service is a key differentiator in a city where fast-paced interactions are common. The convenience of its location and its various ordering options, including pickup and delivery, make it an easy and reliable choice for a quick breakfast, a satisfying lunch, or a catering order for a special event. For anyone in the area seeking a genuine New York bagel experience from a trusted local spot, Pick a Bagel is a highly recommended and essential part of the community.

Pick a Bagel Food & drink

All Day - Hot Breakfast
Eggs On A Bagel US$6.25
2 Eggs any Style.
Eggs Platter US$6.25
2 Eggs Any Style On A Platter (Does Not Come With A Bagel Or Bread. Doesn't Include Home Fries)
2 Cinnamon Pancakes, 2 Eggs, 2 Sausage And 2 Bacon US$21.25
Cinnamon pancakes paired with your choice of egg preparation, served alongside sausage and bacon.
1 Cinnamon Pancake, 1 Egg, 1 Sausage And 1 Bacon US$13.95
Cinnamon pancake, choice of egg preparation, served with sausage and bacon.
2 Cinnamon Pancakes With 2 Eggs US$11.95
Cinnamon pancakes, served with choice of eggs: scrambled (soft, well-done), egg whites, fried, sunny side up, over easy/medium/hard.
2 Cinnamon Pancakes US$7.95
Eggs not included.
Side Home Fries US$7.25
Seasoned potato cubes, crispy on the outside and tender inside.
Side Turkey Bacon US$8.25
Side Crispy Bacon US$7.25
Side Sausage Patties (2 Pcs) US$8.25

All Day - Omelettes
Western Omelet US$16.95
With ham, peppers, onions and tomatoes. Served with a bagel and home fries.
Greek Omelet US$16.95
With feta cheese, olives and tomatoes. Served with a bagel and home fries.
Cheese Omelet US$16.95
With your choice of cheese. Served with a bagel and home fries.
Vegetable Omelet US$16.95
With mushrooms, peppers, tomatoes and broccoli. Served with a bagel and home fries.
Leo Omelet US$22.95
With lox, eggs and onions. Served with a bagel and home fries.
Customer Specialty Omelet US$16.95
Any 4 Vegetables of Your Choice. Served with a Bagel and Home Fries.

All Day - Cream Cheese Sandwiches
Buttered Bagel US$3.75
Buttered bagel with cream cheese. Choice of bagel includes plain, sesame, varieties of whole wheat, cinnamon raisin, salt, and more. Flat bagel options available.
Cream Cheese Bagel US$5.95
Choose your base from a wide array of bagels or breads, ranging from plain, sesame, to whole wheat, and more. Pick a cream cheese flavor from plain, vegetable to unique blends like jalapeño or walnut-raisin.
Peanut Butter Bagel US$5.95
Peanut butter spread on your choice of bagel or bread, including options like sesame, whole wheat, cinnamon raisin, and more.

All Day - Sandwiches
Salad Sandwich US$9.75
Salad sandwich with choice of egg, tuna, chicken, or salmon salad. Various bagels, breads, wraps including whole wheat, 7 grain, croissant. Options for low fat and different flavors available.
Smoked Fish Sandwich US$15.75
Smoked fish sandwich with choice of Nova Scotia salmon, smoked sable, or whitefish. Various bagels like plain, sesame, or whole wheat. Cream cheese options include vegetable, scallion, jalapeno.
Meat Sandwich US$10.95
Meat sandwich with choice of protein like turkey or roast beef. Variety of bagels and breads including whole wheat, rye, and croissant.
BLT Sandwich US$10.50
BLT with choice of bagel or bread including plain, sesame, whole wheat options, and more. Croissant and bialy available.
Gourmet Food Sandwich US$11.25
Gourmet food sandwich on a choice of bagels or breads, including sesame, whole wheat, and croissant options. Protein selections like grilled chicken and turkey burger.
Cheese Sandwich US$5.75
Hard cheese sandwich.
Egg Sandwich US$5.75
Egg sandwich with choice of egg prep and a variety of bagels, flatbreads, wraps, or traditional breads, including grains and flavored options.

All Day - Combination Sandwiches
No.1. Combination Sandwich US$18.95
With corned beef, pastrami, swiss cheese and coleslaw.
No.2. Combination Sandwich US$18.95
Grilled chicken, onions, oven roasted peppers, mozzarella cheese and mustard.
No.3. Combination Sandwich US$18.95
Roast beef, Turkey, lettuce, tomato and Russian dressing.
No.4. Combination Sandwich US$18.95
Turkey, corned beef, swiss cheese, Russian dressing and coleslaw.
No.5. Combination Sandwich US$18.95
Reuben sandwich with corned beef, melted swiss cheese, sauerkraut and mustard.
No.6. Combination Sandwich US$18.95
Turkey, ham, swiss cheese, Russian dressing and coleslaw.
No.7. Combination Sandwich US$18.95
Italian hero with ham, provolone cheese, salami, lettuce and tomato.
No.8. Combination Sandwich US$18.95
Turkey club with Turkey, bacon, lettuce and tomato.

All Day - Breakfast Healthy Start
Homemade Granola US$6.95
With low-fat yogurt and fresh berries.
Freshly Sliced Seasonal Fruit US$8.50
A medley of freshly sliced strawberries, kiwi, pineapple, and orange.
Fruit US$1.50
Healthy morning selection: Choose from banana, red apple, or orange.
Oatmeal US$5.50
Creamy oatmeal topped with rolled oats, served with fresh banana, blueberries, strawberries, and a side of raisins.

All Day - Bagels, Muffins, Pastries and Desserts
Bagel US$1.99
Assorted bagels including plain, sesame, pumpernickel, whole wheat everything, cinnamon raisin, salt, poppy seed, onion, everything, whole wheat, 7 grain, and bialy.
Flat Bagel US$3.00
Flat bagel in assorted varieties: everything, whole wheat everything, sesame, cinnamon raisin, plain, whole wheat, 7 grain, sunflower seed, and poppy seed.
Mini Bagel US$1.25
Mini Bagel selection: plain, sesame, poppy seed, or everything.
Baker's Dozen Bagels US$23.88
14 bagels. Please specify the breakdown in the special instructions box.
Plain Croissant US$4.50
Flaky, buttery layers with a golden-brown crust.
Chocolate Croissant US$5.50
Flaky, buttery croissant filled with rich chocolate, offering a delightful blend of crisp layers and sweet cocoa.
Muffin US$5.50
Assorted muffins, options include corn, blueberry, chocolate chip, cranberry, bran, raisin bran, banana nut, apple cinnamon, lemon poppy, carrot, double chocolate.
Pound Cake US$5.50
Available in plain, lemon, or marble flavors.
1 Lb. Assorted Small Cookies US$19.95
Jumbo Cookie US$4.50
Jumbo cookie options include black and white, all black, or all white varieties.
Crumb Cake US$5.50
Soft, moist cake topped with a thick layer of streusel. Available in original or chocolate flavors.
Box Of Mini Black & White Cookies US$11.50
Half-moon cookies with one side coated in dark chocolate and the other in vanilla icing.

All Day - Beverages
Tropicana Orange Juice US$4.95
A juice drink made with a blend of summer’s most delicious fruit juices, with no artificial sweeteners or flavors.
Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice US$6.25
Fresh squeezed orange juice, available in small or large sizes.
Freshly Brewed Coffee US$3.50
Freshly brewed coffee available in small or large. Choose from regular, decaf, or hazelnut. Milk options include skim, whole, almond, oat, or black. Sweeten with sugar or artificial alternatives.
Iced Coffee US$5.00
Chilled coffee with customizable options: milk selections include dairy and plant-based; sweeteners vary from traditional to artificial. Size available in small or large.
Fresh Iced Tea US$5.00
With lemon.
Lipton Tea US$3.50
A sunny, refreshing taste with a delicious blend of tea and tasty citrus flavor.
Herbal Tea US$4.00
Herbal tea with choice of milk including plant-based options. Flavors from green to apple cinnamon. Sweeteners available. Small or large.
Hot Chocolate US$4.00
Rich hot chocolate, available in small or large.
Cappuccino US$5.25
Espresso and steamed milk, customizable with black, skim, whole, half & half, almond, or oat milk. Sweetener options include sugar, Sweet N Low, Equal, Splenda, or none. Available in small or large.
Iced Cappuccino US$6.75
Iced cappuccino with milk options including dairy and plant-based. Sweetener varies from classic to artificial. Available in small or large.
Bottled Water US$2.50
Bottled water in various sizes: 0.5L to 1.5L, sports cap, essential, and Fiji options.
Snapple US$4.25
Snapple tea available in a variety of flavors including lemon, peach, raspberry, and their diet counterparts; also offers a unique 1/2 & 1/2 blend.
Vitamin Water US$4.75
Vitamin and nutrient-enhanced water beverage with electrolytes and other good stuff.
Bottled Soda US$3.95
20 oz.
Gatorade US$4.75
A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine
Milk US$3.25
Choice of Nesquik chocolate, whole, skim milk, or half & half.
Can Soda US$2.75
Selection of canned sodas: classic and diet options including Coke, Sprite, and Dr. Pepper, plus unique flavors like Black Cherry and Cream Soda.

All Day - Homemade Soups
Chicken Noodle Soup US$6.95
Chicken broth with tender noodles and pieces of chicken.

All Day - Salads
Chef's Salad US$16.25
Roasted turkey, roast beef, hard-boiled egg, swiss cheese, American cheese all wrapped and sliced on a bed of lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, and onions.
Tuna Salad Platter US$16.25
With lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, olive and your choice of potato, macaroni or coleslaw.
Chicken Salad Platter US$16.25
With lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, olives and a choice of side salad.
Whitefish Salad Platter US$16.25
With lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, olives and a choice of side salad.

All Day - Side Orders
Potato Chips US$2.25
Potato chips selection: Lays Classic, Kettle Cooked, Doritos, Jalapeno, Salt & Vinegar, B.B.Q.
Side Crispy Bacon US$7.25
Side Turkey Bacon US$8.25
Side Avocado US$3.00
Creamy mashed avocado, perfect for adding a rich, buttery texture to any meal.
Side Macaroni Salad - 1/2 Lb US$6.00
Side Potato Salad - 1/2 Lb US$6.00
Side Coleslaw - 1/2 Lb US$6.00
1/2 lb.
Side Tomato US$3.00
Side Cucumber US$3.00
Side Shredded Lettuce US$2.00
Side Red Onion US$1.50
Side Home Fries US$7.25
Seasoned potato cubes, lightly browned and crispy.
Side Sausage Patties (2 Pcs.) US$8.25

All Day - Smoked Fish Platters
Nova Scotia Salmon Platter US$27.95
Served with lettuce, tomato, Bermuda onion, bagel and a side of plain or scallion cream cheese.
Smoked Sable Platter US$27.95
Served with lettuce, tomato, Bermuda onion, bagel and a side of plain or scallion cream cheese.
Sable And Nova Platter US$32.95
Served with lettuce, tomato, Bermuda onion, bagel and a side of plain or scallion cream cheese.
Smoked Whitefish Platter US$19.95
Served with lettuce, tomato, Bermuda onion, bagel and a side of plain or scallion cream cheese.
Smoked Fish Supreme Platter US$37.95
With sable, nova Scotia lox and whitefish. Served with lettuce, tomato, Bermuda onion, bagel and a side of plain or scallion cream cheese.

All Day - Knishes
Potato Knish US$7.50
Potato filling wrapped in dough, choice of hot or cold.
Spinach Knish US$7.50
Spinach knish, choice of served hot or cold.
Mushroom Knish US$7.50
Mushroom knish, offered hot or cold.
Kasha Knish US$7.50
Buckwheat-filled pastry, available hot or cold.

All Day - Salad Spreads by the Pound
Egg Salad - By The Lb US$4.50
Egg salad, available in 1/4, 1/2, 3/4, or 1 lb increments.
Low Fat Egg White Salad - By The Lb US$5.00
Egg white salad, low fat, available in various sizes ranging from 1/4 lb to 1 lb.
Tuna Salad - By The Lb US$6.00
Tuna salad available in increments of 1/4 lb up to 1 lb.
Low Fat Tuna Salad - By The Lb US$6.00
Low fat tuna salad available in various sizes. Options include 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, 3/4 lb, or 1 lb servings.
Vegetable Tuna Salad - By The Lb US$6.00
Diet mayo.
Whitefish Salad - By The Lb US$9.25
Whitefish bound salad available in various sizes ranging from 1/4 lb to 1 lb.
Low Fat Whitefish Salad - By The Lb US$9.25
Low fat whitefish in a creamy dressing. Sizes: 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, 3/4 lb, 1 lb. Ideal for spreads.
Baked Salmon Salad - By The Lb US$9.25
Baked salmon mixed into a creamy salad, available in sizes ranging from 1/4 lb to 1 lb.
Chicken Salad - By The Lb US$6.00
Chicken salad, available in sizes from 1/4 lb to 1 lb.
Low Fat Chicken Salad - By The Lb US$6.00
Low fat chicken salad, available in various sizes ranging from 1/4 lb to 1 lb.
Chopped Herring - By The Lb US$4.50
Chopped herring salad available in various sizes: 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, 3/4 lb, and 1 lb.

All Day - Cream Cheese Spread by the Pound
Butter - By The Lb US$3.25
Cream cheese spread available in various sizes from 1/4 lb to 1 lb.
Plain Cream Cheese - By The Lb US$3.50
Smooth, rich cream cheese available in multiple sizes: 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, 3/4 lb, 1 lb.
Vegetable Cream Cheese - By The Lb US$5.25
Cream cheese blended with fresh vegetables. Available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, 3/4 lb, or 1 lb options.
Scallion Cream Cheese - By The Lb US$5.25
Scallion cream cheese, available in four sizes: 1/4 lb to 1 lb.
Olive Cream Cheese - By The Lb US$5.25
Olive cream cheese available in multiple sizes: 1/4, 1/2, 3/4, or 1 lb. Ideal for spreads and dips.
Walnuts And Raisins Cream Cheese - By The Lb US$5.25
Walnuts and raisins mixed with cream cheese. Available in 1/4, 1/2, 3/4, or 1 lb sizes.
Strawberry Cream Cheese - By The Lb US$5.25
Strawberry cream cheese. Options include various sizes from 1/4 lb to 1 lb.
Jalapeño Cream Cheese - By The Lb US$5.25
Jalapeño cream cheese, available in various sizes from 1/4 lb to 1 lb.
Low Fat Plain Cream Cheese - By The Lb US$4.00
Low fat plain cream cheese available in 1/4, 1/2, 3/4, or 1 lb options.
Low Fat Vegetable Cream Cheese - By The Lb US$5.50
Low Fat Vegetable Cream Cheese available in quantities of 1/4, 1/2, 3/4, or 1 lb.
Low Fat Scallion Cream Cheese - By The Lb US$5.50
Low fat cream cheese blended with fresh scallions. Available in various sizes: 1/4 lb to 1 lb.
Low Fat Sun-Dried Tomato Cream Cheese - By The Lb US$5.50
Sun-dried tomato cream cheese, low fat. Available in various sizes ranging from 1/4 lb to 1 lb.
Plain Tofu (Cream Cheese) - By The Lb US$4.00
Cream cheese spread made from plain tofu. Available in sizes: 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, 3/4 lb, 1 lb.
Vegetable Tofu (Cream Cheese) - By The Lb US$5.50
Vegetable tofu cream cheese available in various sizes: 1/4, 1/2, 3/4, or 1 lb options.
Scallion Tofu (Cream Cheese) - By The Lb US$5.50
Scallion tofu cream cheese spread, options for 1/4, 1/2, 3/4, or 1 lb sizes.
Lox Spread - By The Lb US$7.00
Lox spread available in various sizes: 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, 3/4 lb, and 1 lb.
Low Fat Lox - Spread By The Lb US$7.00
Low fat lox cream cheese spread, available in multiple sizes: 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, 3/4 lb, or 1 lb options.

All Day - Smoked Fish by the Pound
Smoked Sable - By The Lb US$17.25
Smoked sable available in weights of 1/4, 1/2, 3/4, or a full pound.
Nova Scotia Salmon - By The Lb US$15.25
Nova Scotia salmon. Available in various sizes: 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, 3/4 lb, 1 lb.
Smoked Whitefish - By The Lb US$11.95
Smoked whitefish available in various sizes: 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, 3/4 lb, 1 lb.
Herring In Cream Sauce - By The Lb US$6.00
Herring, creamy sauce, available in four sizes: 1/4 to 1 lb.
Side Tomato US$3.00
Side Cucumber US$3.00
Side Capers US$2.00
Side Kalamata Olives US$2.00
Side Red Onion US$1.50

All Day - Meat by the Pound
Bologna - By The Lb US$5.75
Sliced bologna available in increments from 1/4 lb to 1 lb. Ideal for sandwiches.
Kosher Salami - By The Lb US$5.75
Kosher salami, available in sizes ranging from 1/4 lb to 1 lb.
Genoa Salami - By The Lb US$5.75
Genoa salami, available in sizes from 1/4 lb to 1 lb.
Hard Salami - By The Lb US$5.75
Hard Salami: Available in various portions from 1/4 lb to 1 lb. Ideal for customized servings.
Boiled Ham - By The Lb US$5.00
Boiled ham offered in portions of 1/4, 1/2, 3/4, or 1 lb.
Turkey Breast - By The Lb US$6.75
Turkey breast, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, 3/4 lb, or 1 lb options.
Honey Glazed Turkey - By The Lb US$6.75
Honey glazed turkey, available in various sizes ranging from 1/4 lb to 1 lb.
Smoked Turkey - By The Lb US$6.75
Smoked turkey, available in various sizes: 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, 3/4 lb, or 1 lb.
Roast Beef - By The Lb US$8.25
Roast beef, available in sizes: 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, 3/4 lb, 1 lb.
Pastrami - By The Lb US$9.75
Pastrami available in four sizes: 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, 3/4 lb, and 1 lb.
Corned Beef - By The Lb US$9.75
Corned beef available in increments of 1/4 lb up to 1 lb.
Side Tomato US$3.00
Side Cucumber US$3.00
Side Red Onion US$1.25
Side Shredded Lettuce US$2.00

All Day - Cheeses by the Pound
American Cheese - By The Lb US$2.95
American cheese available in increments of quarter, half, three-quarters, or a full pound.
Muenster Cheese - By The Lb US$3.25
Muenster cheese, available in various sizes: 1/4 lb to 1 lb.
Swiss Cheese - By The LB US$3.25
Swiss cheese available in various sizes: 1/4, 1/2, 3/4, or a full pound.
Provolone Cheese - By The Lb US$3.25
Provolone cheese available in varying weights: 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, 3/4 lb, 1 lb.
Cheddar Cheese - By The Lb US$3.75
Cheddar Cheese: Available by the pound. Choose from 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, 3/4 lb, or 1 lb options.
Mozzarella Cheese - By The Lb US$3.75
Mozzarella cheese available in increments from 1/4 lb to 1 lb. Choose your size.

All Day - Gourmet Food by the Pound
Grilled Chicken - By The Lb US$6.00
Grilled chicken, available in sizes ranging from 1/4 lb to 1 lb.
Breaded Chicken - By The Lb US$6.00
Breaded, crispy chicken available in various weights: 1/4 lb to 1 lb.
1 Pc. Veggie Burger US$6.00
1 Pc. Turkey Burger US$6.00
Side Pickle US$1.50
Side Of Bacon US$7.25
Crispy, savory strips of cured pork.
Side Of Turkey Bacon US$8.25
Side Of Sausage Patties (2 Pcs) US$8.25

Pick a Bagel Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pick-up
Takeaway

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Amenities
Toilet

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Pick a Bagel Photos

Pick a Bagel Location

Pick a Bagel

New York New York County New York 2nd Avenue

1475 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10075, USA

Pick a Bagel Reviews

An average rating of ★3.9 from 421 user reviews.

pricebagel with cream cheesemorningspreadsareasaladdeliverymuffinsordertake out

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Consistently reliable bagel shop, with friendly, courteous service and clean premises. Post Reno, this place is awesome, I don't have to get on my tiptoes to order over a tall counter. These guys will ask important detailed Qs on your order to get your order right! Even asked if he wanted us to rewarm our coffee to hit since we asked for extra cream, never heard of this anywhere I've been at a busy shop. Great variety of a bagel shop, and very fresh. My neighborhood go to staple!
September 01 · Connie Kwok
An absolute scam. The man behind the counter told me he would not put the cream cheese on my bagel. Instead they charge you for cream cheese on the side…$4.94!!!!! Wake up people and go somewhere else.
June 05 · Yauheni Yakauleu
The bagels were not fresh, the toaster barely works, the lox spread was borderline spoiled and the coffee is nasty. I don’t mind paying top dollar when food is good or at least decent. This place is horrific.
July 22 · steve weinberg
I liked this place. Lot of sitting; you could sit out. Coffee is good. Bagels are good. Tried different combinations- different bagels- different spreads. They check out. My favorite Multi Grain whole wheat with Butter.
May 07 · Narayan Ram
This place is amazing. They have all what you want in a bagel. They have different kind of bagels, spreads, proteins, coffee is really good. The price is reaaally good and service is quick and gentle.
July 08 · maribell gonzalez