Pie Chicks: A Martha's Vineyard Bakery Tour Staple in Vineyard Haven, MA

Pie Chicks Introduce

For anyone in Massachusetts, especially those on or visiting Martha's Vineyard, the name Pie Chicks has become synonymous with fresh, high-quality baked goods. This charming bakery, located in Vineyard Haven, has carved out a special niche for itself by focusing on what it does best: crafting exceptional pies and other delicious treats. As one customer review perfectly encapsulates, Pie Chicks is a mandatory "stop on our State Rd morning bakery tour!" This is a place where you can find goods that are truly "fresh baked," with warm scones coming "right out of the oven." This dedication to freshness and quality is what makes the experience so memorable. While a first-time visitor might wish for more single-serving baked fruit desserts, the overall impression is overwhelmingly positive. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, and the staff, who are a part of the bakery's identity, are known for their "great service." Pie Chicks has mastered the art of creating a simple yet powerful experience centered around delicious food, from their celebrated pies to their delightful cookies. It’s a perfect spot for both locals grabbing a treat and tourists looking for an authentic taste of the island's culinary scene.

The location and accessibility of Pie Chicks are integral to its status as a local favorite. The bakery is conveniently located at 395 State Rd in Vineyard Haven, MA 02568, USA. This places it on a well-traveled road, making it a visible and easily accessible stop for those exploring Martha's Vineyard. For island residents, State Road is a major artery, so a visit to Pie Chicks can easily be part of a daily commute or errand run. While Vineyard Haven is a popular destination, the shop is a bit removed from the most congested parts of the town center, which can sometimes make for an easier visit. A key feature mentioned in a customer review is the "good patio seating area," which allows patrons to relax and enjoy their treats on-site. This adds to the appeal of the location, turning a quick stop into a pleasant moment of respite. For those arriving on the island via the ferry, the shop is a relatively short drive away, making it a great first or last stop on a trip. The accessibility, combined with the welcoming environment, makes Pie Chicks a convenient and appealing destination for a wide range of customers.

Pie Chicks offers a delicious and focused menu of services and products, centered around their passion for pies but extending to other baked goods as well. Their offerings are designed to satisfy both an individual craving and the needs of a larger gathering.

Pies: This is the star of the show. Pie Chicks offers a rotating selection of large and small pies in a variety of seasonal and classic flavors. Customer reviews specifically praise the delicious Key Lime and Lemon Meringue Pies. The menu often includes fruit pies like Raspberry Apple, Blueberry Peach, and Strawberry Rhubarb, as well as gluten-free options. The pies are available in various sizes, including 6-inch, 9-inch, and by the slice, catering to different needs and group sizes.
Scones: A customer review highlighted the "warm right out of the oven scones," which are a popular choice. The scones come in a variety of flavors, which change daily, and they are perfect for a morning treat with coffee.
Cookies: The bakery also offers a selection of cookies, available in bags of six. These are described as "delicious" and are another great option for a quick treat or to take home.
Pot Pies and Quiches: Pie Chicks isn't just about sweet treats. They also offer savory items like chicken, beef, and vegetarian pot pies and quiches, which are perfect for a hearty meal. These are often offered seasonally and are a great option for a comforting dinner.
Online Ordering: For maximum convenience, the bakery offers an online ordering system through their website. This service allows customers to place their orders ahead of time, ensuring their desired items are ready for pickup. This is especially helpful for large orders or for tourists on a tight schedule.
On-Site Seating: The availability of patio seating is a key service, providing a pleasant space for customers to sit and enjoy their purchases in a relaxed setting.

This diverse range of services, all rooted in high-quality baked goods, makes Pie Chicks a versatile and appealing choice for the local community.

Several key features and highlights make Pie Chicks a standout bakery and a favorite among locals and visitors to Martha's Vineyard.

Freshness and Quality: The commitment to making "fresh baked goods" is a primary highlight. As one review noted, the scones are served "warm right out of the oven," which is a testament to their dedication to providing a high-quality, freshly made product.
Friendly and Helpful Staff: The staff, described as "the Pie Chicks" and providing "great service," contribute significantly to the positive atmosphere of the bakery. Their helpful and friendly demeanor enhances the overall customer experience.
Exceptional Pies: The pies are a major feature and the namesake of the business. With flavors like Key Lime and Lemon Meringue receiving specific praise, their reputation for excellent pies is well-established. The option for gluten-free pies also shows a commitment to catering to a wider audience.
Outdoor Patio Seating: The presence of a "good patio seating area" is a great highlight. It offers a relaxing space for customers to enjoy their food and soak in the Vineyard atmosphere, which is a valuable feature for both locals and tourists.
Variety of Sizes: Offering pies in different sizes, from a 6-inch pie for a couple to a full 12-inch pie for a group, shows a thoughtful approach to customer needs. This flexibility makes them a suitable choice for various occasions.

These highlights collectively create a bakery that is not only known for its delicious food but also for its welcoming environment and customer-focused approach.

For those in the Massachusetts area who want to get in touch with or visit Pie Chicks in Vineyard Haven, here is the essential contact information.

Address: 395 State Rd, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568, USA

Phone: (508) 693-0228

In conclusion, Pie Chicks is an outstanding bakery and a perfect fit for the Massachusetts community, especially on Martha's Vineyard. Its location on State Road in Vineyard Haven makes it a convenient and essential stop for both locals and tourists. The bakery’s dedication to producing "fresh baked goods," particularly their "incredible" pies and warm scones, has earned them a loyal following and a sterling reputation. The friendly and helpful staff contribute to a welcoming atmosphere, making every visit a pleasant experience. With a versatile menu that includes sweet and savory items, as well as various sizes for individual and group needs, Pie Chicks is an adaptable and reliable choice for any occasion. The availability of outdoor seating and the convenience of online ordering further enhance its appeal. For anyone seeking a genuinely delicious, high-quality pie or baked good on Martha's Vineyard, Pie Chicks is the clear and cherished choice. It is a business that truly embodies the spirit of a beloved local bakery.

Pie Chicks Services

BAKERY - Bread
Sourdough US$12.00
Rustic Baguette US$8.00
Cornbread US$5.00
Sourdough English Muffins 4pk US$8.00

BAKERY - Cookies
Is there anything better than a homemade cookie? Nah, we didn't think so either. Enjoy one at a time or go ahead and buy the bag. You're worth it!
Single Cookie US$3.00
Our generously sized 4 oz. cookie is big enough to share, but if you don’t…we won’t tell! Some varieties also available in gluten-free (GF).
Bag Of Cookies (6) US$13.00
Is there anything better than a homemade cookie? How about 6 of them? Our signature cookies packed and ready for any occasion! Some varieties also available in gluten-free (GF).
GF Bag Of Cookies US$15.00
As good as our original cookies, we use Cup 4 Cup flour to make our GF version. Just as delicious, only no gluten!

BAKERY - Granola
Twice-baked and super loved it really is GREAT Granola! Regular and Gluten-Free. (Oats are a naturally GF product, but our GF oats are manufactured in a certified GF facility.)
Granola US$16.00
Expertly baked for that singular crunch! Balanced, whole, crunchy, yummy. We call it “Great Granola” for a reason. Also available in gluten-free.
GF Granola US$18.00
Oats are naturally gluten-free, but the shared equipment in gluten-full processing facilities can contaminate them. These oats are 100% certified GF! Same exact recipe as our regular granola, but safe for celiacs!

BAKERY - Pastry
A dazzling array of made-from-scratch pastries to tempt you!
Day Old US$2.00
Pecan Coffee Cake US$5.00
We pour melted sugary butter over this deceptively decadent pound cake while it's still warm...part crueler part poundcake...100% amazing.
Scone US$5.00
This buttery flaky piece of heaven is Chrissy’s all-time favorite thing to bake. Scones are an art form at Pie Chicks kitchen. Pairs beautifully with coffee, tea and conversation at any time of day. Apricot Ginger, Cranberry Walnut, Fig Almond, Cinnamon Date Walnut, Cherry Vanilla, Currant, Blueberry. Flavors change daily.
Almond Roll US$6.25
Blueberry Corn US$5.00
Kentucky Butter Cake US$5.00
GF Scone US$6.00
Everything Croissant US$6.00
Cinnamon Roll US$6.00

BAKERY - 9" Pies
Our signature item. From Apple to Blueberry to Key Lime and Strawberry Rhubarb--the original Pie Chicks pie will not disappoint! Flavors change daily. 6", 9" and by the slice.
9" Pies
Deliciously tender and flaky crust generously filled with an abundance of tart fruit. Our signature product is just like Grandma’s, only better. Like everything we make—it tastes better when it’s shared! Approximately 8 servings. Flavors change daily.
9" GF Pie
Our motto? If you can tell it’s gluten-free we won’t sell it. Just as great as our original pie, but zero gluten with a sweet and crunchy oat crumble topping. We dare you to taste test it yourself! As flavors change daily please call the shop for more information.
6" Pie US$15.00
Just the two of you? Just the one of you? Perfectly sized for the perfect treat. Flavors change daily.
1/2 Pie
Just a few of you? No problem! 4 beautiful slices. Based on availability. Flavors change daily!
Pie Bites US$6.00
Love our crust? Yeah, so do we. These are the beautiful trimmings left when we make our pies…why waste them when they’re just as delicious? Rolled in cinnamon sugar and bagged for a perfect little treat any time of the day! Warning—highly addictive.
1/4 Pie US$11.00

BAKERY - Quiche
Our original pie crust filled with eggs, cream and a myriad of savory flavors. Try our original Spinach Ricotta, the Mushroom Onion Cheddar, or take a chance on the Farmer's Market Quiche--an ever-changing flavor extravaganza based on what's fresh at the market!
1/4 Quiche US$10.00
9" Farmers Market US$44.00
9" GF Mushroom Onion Cheddar US$40.00
9" Spinach Ricotta US$44.00
9" Bell Pepper, Onion, Cheddar US$40.00
9" Brocoli, Onion, Cheddar US$40.00
1/2 Quiche US$20.00
9" GF Quiche US$40.00

Bread
Sourdough US$12.00
Rustic Baguette US$8.00
Cornbread US$5.00
Sourdough English Muffins 4pk US$8.00

Cookies
Is there anything better than a homemade cookie? Nah, we didn't think so either. Enjoy one at a time or go ahead and buy the bag. You're worth it!
Single Cookie US$3.00
Our generously sized 4 oz. cookie is big enough to share, but if you don’t…we won’t tell! Some varieties also available in gluten-free (GF).
Bag Of Cookies (6) US$13.00
Is there anything better than a homemade cookie? How about 6 of them? Our signature cookies packed and ready for any occasion! Some varieties also available in gluten-free (GF).
GF Bag Of Cookies US$15.00
As good as our original cookies, we use Cup 4 Cup flour to make our GF version. Just as delicious, only no gluten!

Granola
Twice-baked and super loved it really is GREAT Granola! Regular and Gluten-Free. (Oats are a naturally GF product, but our GF oats are manufactured in a certified GF facility.)
Granola US$16.00
Expertly baked for that singular crunch! Balanced, whole, crunchy, yummy. We call it “Great Granola” for a reason. Also available in gluten-free.
GF Granola US$18.00
Oats are naturally gluten-free, but the shared equipment in gluten-full processing facilities can contaminate them. These oats are 100% certified GF! Same exact recipe as our regular granola, but safe for celiacs!

Pastry
A dazzling array of made-from-scratch pastries to tempt you!
Day Old US$2.00
Pecan Coffee Cake US$5.00
We pour melted sugary butter over this deceptively decadent pound cake while it's still warm...part crueler part poundcake...100% amazing.
Scone US$5.00
This buttery flaky piece of heaven is Chrissy’s all-time favorite thing to bake. Scones are an art form at Pie Chicks kitchen. Pairs beautifully with coffee, tea and conversation at any time of day. Apricot Ginger, Cranberry Walnut, Fig Almond, Cinnamon Date Walnut, Cherry Vanilla, Currant, Blueberry. Flavors change daily.
Almond Roll US$6.25
Blueberry Corn US$5.00
Kentucky Butter Cake US$5.00
GF Scone US$6.00
Everything Croissant US$6.00
Cinnamon Roll US$6.00

9" Pies
Our signature item. From Apple to Blueberry to Key Lime and Strawberry Rhubarb--the original Pie Chicks pie will not disappoint! Flavors change daily. 6", 9" and by the slice.
9" Pies
Deliciously tender and flaky crust generously filled with an abundance of tart fruit. Our signature product is just like Grandma’s, only better. Like everything we make—it tastes better when it’s shared! Approximately 8 servings. Flavors change daily.
9" GF Pie
Our motto? If you can tell it’s gluten-free we won’t sell it. Just as great as our original pie, but zero gluten with a sweet and crunchy oat crumble topping. We dare you to taste test it yourself! As flavors change daily please call the shop for more information.
6" Pie US$15.00
Just the two of you? Just the one of you? Perfectly sized for the perfect treat. Flavors change daily.
1/2 Pie
Just a few of you? No problem! 4 beautiful slices. Based on availability. Flavors change daily!
Pie Bites US$6.00
Love our crust? Yeah, so do we. These are the beautiful trimmings left when we make our pies…why waste them when they’re just as delicious? Rolled in cinnamon sugar and bagged for a perfect little treat any time of the day! Warning—highly addictive.
1/4 Pie US$11.00

Quiche
Our original pie crust filled with eggs, cream and a myriad of savory flavors. Try our original Spinach Ricotta, the Mushroom Onion Cheddar, or take a chance on the Farmer's Market Quiche--an ever-changing flavor extravaganza based on what's fresh at the market!
1/4 Quiche US$10.00
9" Farmers Market US$44.00
9" GF Mushroom Onion Cheddar US$40.00
9" Spinach Ricotta US$44.00
9" Bell Pepper, Onion, Cheddar US$40.00
9" Brocoli, Onion, Cheddar US$40.00
1/2 Quiche US$20.00
9" GF Quiche US$40.00

LUNCH - Soup
Tomato Basil
Soup Is Served With Fresh Sliced Baguette For Dipping!

LUNCH - Sides
Cabbage & Noidles US$12.00

Soup
Tomato Basil
Soup Is Served With Fresh Sliced Baguette For Dipping!

Sides
Cabbage & Noidles US$12.00

DRINKS - Coffee
Americano US$4.00
Café Latte US$4.00
Cappucinno US$4.00
Cortado US$4.00
Double Espresso US$3.00
Extra Shot Espresso US$1.50
Hot Coffee
Iced Coffee US$3.50
A refreshing and delicious pick me up!
Macchiato US$4.00
Refill US$1.00

DRINKS - Tea
Iced Tea US$4.00
My mother Dorie's famous Ohio iced tea. A little sweet, a little lemon, a whole lotta refreshing awesomeness!

DRINKS - Nantucket Nectar
Pomegranate US$3.00
Apple US$3.00

DRINKS - Water
Poland Springs US$3.00

Coffee
Americano US$4.00
Café Latte US$4.00
Cappucinno US$4.00
Cortado US$4.00
Double Espresso US$3.00
Extra Shot Espresso US$1.50
Hot Coffee
Iced Coffee US$3.50
A refreshing and delicious pick me up!
Macchiato US$4.00
Refill US$1.00

Tea
Iced Tea US$4.00
My mother Dorie's famous Ohio iced tea. A little sweet, a little lemon, a whole lotta refreshing awesomeness!

Nantucket Nectar
Pomegranate US$3.00
Apple US$3.00

Water
Poland Springs US$3.00

FROZEN - Frozen Fruit Pies
Stock your freezer with all your favorites! Easy to bake at home Pie Chick's pies! Keep one handy for when the pie mood strikes you!
9" Apple Pie--Frozen US$28.00
An absolute classic. Warming cinnamon & nutmeg meet deliciously tart Granny Smith apples.
9"Apple Blackberry-Frozen US$28.00
9" Blueberry Pie--Frozen US$28.00
No matter what the season this is our best seller. Wild Maine blueberries with a hint of lemon. Perfectly tart.
9" Blueberry Peach Pie--Frozen US$28.00
Is it a peach-y Blueberry pie or a berry-ish Peach pie? You decide.
9" Key Lime Frozen US$28.00
9" Peach Pie--Frozen US$28.00
Ooooh....Peach pie...one of Chrissy's all-time favorites and for good reason! Try it and find out what all the fuss is about.
9" Strawberry Rhubarb Pie--Frozen US$28.00
Rivals our Blueberry pie for best seller! Tart crisp rhubarb and sweet, juicy strawberries are mouth-wateringly amazing!
9" Triple Berry Pie--Frozen US$28.00
Blueberry, blackberry, raspberry. Deliciously tart--this one will keep you coming back!

FROZEN - Frozen Pot Pies
9" Beef Pot Pie US$48.00
Beautifully braised shredded chuck roast amidst onions, carrots, peas with a beef stock tomato base. The perfect treat for a cold evening!
9" Chicken Pot Pies US$48.00
Chicken, onion, carrots and peas in a rich chicken gravy served in our famous buttery crust. Our signature pot pie serves 3-4 people. Get it while you can! Offered seasonally Sept-May.
9" Mushroom Pot Pie US$44.00
Our vegetarian mushroom pot pie will please even the staunchest of meat eaters! Made with local MVM shiitake mushrooms (when in season), this 9" pie is packed with mushrooms, carrots, and peas in an herby mushroom gravy. Mmmm...serves 3-4. Offered seasonally Sept-May.

FROZEN - Frozen Soup
Butternut Squash & Cashew Cream US$16.00
Carrot Ginger US$16.00
Kale & Linguica US$16.00
Chicken Corn Chowder US$16.00
Veggie Chili US$16.00

Frozen Fruit Pies
Stock your freezer with all your favorites! Easy to bake at home Pie Chick's pies! Keep one handy for when the pie mood strikes you!
9" Apple Pie--Frozen US$28.00
An absolute classic. Warming cinnamon & nutmeg meet deliciously tart Granny Smith apples.
9"Apple Blackberry-Frozen US$28.00
9" Blueberry Pie--Frozen US$28.00
No matter what the season this is our best seller. Wild Maine blueberries with a hint of lemon. Perfectly tart.
9" Blueberry Peach Pie--Frozen US$28.00
Is it a peach-y Blueberry pie or a berry-ish Peach pie? You decide.
9" Key Lime Frozen US$28.00
9" Peach Pie--Frozen US$28.00
Ooooh....Peach pie...one of Chrissy's all-time favorites and for good reason! Try it and find out what all the fuss is about.
9" Strawberry Rhubarb Pie--Frozen US$28.00
Rivals our Blueberry pie for best seller! Tart crisp rhubarb and sweet, juicy strawberries are mouth-wateringly amazing!
9" Triple Berry Pie--Frozen US$28.00
Blueberry, blackberry, raspberry. Deliciously tart--this one will keep you coming back!

Frozen Pot Pies
9" Beef Pot Pie US$48.00
Beautifully braised shredded chuck roast amidst onions, carrots, peas with a beef stock tomato base. The perfect treat for a cold evening!
9" Chicken Pot Pies US$48.00
Chicken, onion, carrots and peas in a rich chicken gravy served in our famous buttery crust. Our signature pot pie serves 3-4 people. Get it while you can! Offered seasonally Sept-May.
9" Mushroom Pot Pie US$44.00
Our vegetarian mushroom pot pie will please even the staunchest of meat eaters! Made with local MVM shiitake mushrooms (when in season), this 9" pie is packed with mushrooms, carrots, and peas in an herby mushroom gravy. Mmmm...serves 3-4. Offered seasonally Sept-May.

Frozen Soup
Butternut Squash & Cashew Cream US$16.00
Carrot Ginger US$16.00
Kale & Linguica US$16.00
Chicken Corn Chowder US$16.00
Veggie Chili US$16.00

MERCHANDISE - Tee Shirt
Tee Shirt US$25.00
Sticker US$1.00
Pie Chicks stickers! to grace your car, your laptop, your travel mug, your life!

Tee Shirt
Tee Shirt US$25.00
Sticker US$1.00
Pie Chicks stickers! to grace your car, your laptop, your travel mug, your life!

Pie Chicks Details

Service options
In-store pick-up
In-store shopping
Takeaway
Delivery

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park

Offerings
Coffee

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Cheques
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Pie Chicks Photos

Pie Chicks Location

Pie Chicks

Massachusetts Dukes County Tisbury Vineyard Haven State Road

395 State Rd, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568, USA

Pie Chicks Reviews

An average rating of ★4.5 from 23 user reviews.

cookiespeachislandgluten freeprice

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Stop 3 on our State Rd morning bakery tour! When I say fresh baked goods, I mean warm right out of the oven scones. Great service from who I would assume are the Pie Chicks. Good patio seating area to enjoy their wares. Only complaint was that there wasn’t more to try - was really counting on this place to have an abundance of baked fruit desserts, like small tarts, jam cookies, mini pies for a single serving - the large pies looked excellent but were more than a baked good tourist could manage at this stage in the game.
October 05 · Ryan Menrath
Delicious selection of pies and cookies. $10 for 6" pie and $20 for the 12". Definitely got to try the Lemon Meringue and the Key lime Pies.
May 14 · A. M.
I recently tried the pie from Pie Chicks, and I have to say, it was a bit of a letdown, especially considering the $38 price tag. While the pie was decent, it didn't stand out compared to other pies I've had. In fact, Corning's and Stop and Shop pies, which cost only $15, taste just as good, if not better. For nearly three times the price, I expected something exceptional, but unfortunately, Pie Chicks didn't deliver. Save your money and get the same quality for a fraction of the cost elsewhere.
August 15 · Len
I am in my 3rd decade of eating gluten free (NOT by choice) and I have to say your gluten free pies and cookies are by far the most DEE-LISH-US I have ever encountered. For me the treat is definitely worth the price! Keep up the good work!
September 07 · S. B.
Omg yum!!! I’m eating the key lime pie as I write this and I’m absolutely blown away. How do I stop after 1 piece??! It’s beyond tasty. I’ve had just about every pie they sell and they are all extremely good. If you are a pie lover you will appreciate their pies. Not fake nasty glunky stuff… it’s all super high quality ingredients.
July 17 · AMH