Polly's Pastries Introduce
For residents across Northwest Ohio, particularly those in the **Fremont** area and Sandusky County, **Polly's Pastries** is synonymous with authentic, comforting dessert. This local business operates as a cherished **Pastry shop** and **Bakery**, distinguishing itself through a steadfast commitment to traditional, high-quality baking. The key to their reputation is simple: everything is **Completely made from scratch**, a fact that customers enthusiastically attest to.
Polly's Pastries has long been a source of sweet nostalgia, offering treats that genuinely taste homemade. One satisfied customer perfectly captured this sentiment by noting that the **sugar cookies** are "just like my Grandma's," highlighting the bakery's success in preserving those classic, comforting flavors. This focus on using fresh, authentic ingredients and time-honored techniques ensures that every item, from a simple cookie to a decadent cream pie, delivers on its promise of being "Yummy!!!" and "The best."
While the full menu of a scratch bakery is typically extensive and changes seasonally, Polly's Pastries is particularly famous for its spectacular desserts. They are renowned for their wide variety of signature pies and other sweet creations, making it the perfect destination for anyone in the Ohio region seeking a superior treat for a celebration or simply a mid-week indulgence.
---**Polly's Pastries** is conveniently located on a key state route in **Fremont, Ohio**, making it an easy stop for both local residents and travelers passing through the area.
The specific address for the pastry shop is:
1015 OH-590, Fremont, OH 43420, USA
Situated directly on **OH-590**, the location is designed for maximum convenience and minimal hassle, fitting into the routine of a busy day.
In terms of customer convenience and accessibility, Polly's Pastries is accommodating:
- **Wheelchair accessible parking lot:** This feature ensures that the bakery is easily accessible for all customers, providing dedicated parking close to the entrance.
- **Quick visit planning:** The business model is structured to facilitate an efficient **Quick visit**, ideal for swiftly picking up pre-ordered pies or grabbing a spontaneous single-serving dessert.
- **Takeout Focused:** The primary service is **Takeout**, meaning orders are prepared to be easily transported and enjoyed at home, at a picnic, or on the road.
As a dedicated **Pastry shop** and **Bakery**, **Polly's Pastries** focuses on producing and selling a wide range of top-tier, scratch-made baked goods, specializing in sweet indulgences.
The core services and product categories available to customers include:
- **Scratch-Made Desserts:** The foundational promise of the business is that every item is **Completely made from scratch**, guaranteeing a noticeable difference in quality and flavor.
- **Signature Pies (The Highlight):** Offering a huge variety of both fruit and cream pies, such as:
- Cream Pies (e.g., Chocolate Cream, Coconut Cream, Banana Cream).
- Fruit Pies (e.g., Apple, Cherry, Boysenberry).
- Specialties like the famous **Banberry Pie**, known for its signature banana cream filling and fresh strawberries.
- **Cookies and Pastries:** Selling beloved items like their legendary **sugar cookies** that evoke nostalgic, "Grandma's recipe" flavor, alongside other pastries like Danishes, muffins, and cinnamon rolls.
- **Dessert Dining:** Products are available for **Dessert** consumption, whether purchased whole or by the slice, catering perfectly to an afternoon treat or the end of a family dinner.
- **Takeout Orders:** All items are available for **Takeout**, allowing customers to easily pick up and enjoy their delicious treats anywhere they choose.
The highlights of choosing **Polly's Pastries** stem from its unwavering dedication to quality, tradition, and customer satisfaction, making it a standout local favorite in the Ohio dessert scene.
The main features that define this Fremont gem include:
- **Commitment to Scratch Baking:** The philosophy that everything is **Completely made from scratch** is the single greatest feature, ensuring a superior, authentic taste profile in every product.
- **Nostalgic, Comforting Flavor:** The baked goods consistently deliver classic, old-fashioned taste, best exemplified by their **sugar cookies just like Grandma's**, providing an immediate sense of warmth and familiarity.
- **Renowned Dessert Quality:** The overall quality of the offerings is so high that the business is highlighted simply for having **Great dessert**, a testament to their mastery of sweet treats.
- **Local Business Support:** Choosing Polly's means supporting a genuine **local business** in the Fremont community, where the focus is on quality and personal service rather than mass production.
- **High-Quality Pie Selection:** The expansive menu of **pies**—ranging from deep-dish fruit pies to rich cream varieties—positions them as a top resource for celebratory desserts in Northwest Ohio.
For customers in the Ohio region wishing to place a large order, inquire about the daily selection, or confirm the availability of a specific signature pie, here is the direct contact information for **Polly's Pastries**:
Address: 1015 OH-590, Fremont, OH 43420, USA
Phone: (419) 307-3721
Mobile Phone: +1 419-307-3721
Calling ahead is highly recommended to reserve specialty items or large orders, ensuring you don't miss out on their freshly baked selections, which are incredibly popular for **Takeout**.
---For residents in Fremont and the wider Ohio area, **Polly's Pastries** is worth choosing because it offers an authentic, delicious escape from commercially-produced desserts. When you choose Polly’s, you are investing in **Completely made from scratch** quality—a labor of love that is increasingly rare today.
This is the ideal place to visit when you need a dessert that truly makes an occasion feel special, or when you simply crave that **Grandma's recipe** flavor that instantly brings back fond memories. The dedication to excellent, **Great dessert** quality, coupled with their specialization as a **Pastry shop**, guarantees a treat that satisfies every time.
The convenience of its location on **OH-590**, coupled with easy **Takeout** and **Wheelchair accessible parking**, makes it practical for a **Quick visit** whether you’re planning a family dinner or just need a comforting sugar cookie. For the best, most authentic, and most flavorful baked goods in Fremont, Ohio, Polly's Pastries is the unmistakable local favorite.
Polly's Pastries Details
Service options
- Takeout
- Delivery
Highlights
- Great dessert
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Dining options
- Dessert
Planning
- Quick visit
Polly's Pastries Photos







Polly's Pastries Location
Polly's Pastries Reviews
Polly's Pastries is a local business. Everything is Completely made from scratch. Yummy!!! The best
June 17 · Adele WagnerSugar cookies just like my Grandma's
January 19 · Kathy Stout- December 11 · Elizabeth Harlach
- May 23 · Scott W
- October 06 · Carol Slone
More Bakery Near Me
Cookie Lady4.0 (149 reviews)2480 W State St, Fremont, OH 43420, USA
Ideal Bakery West4.0 (193 reviews)1221 Oak Harbor Rd, Fremont, OH 43420, USA
El Aguila Bakery4.0 (328 reviews)1810 W State St, Fremont, OH 43420, USA
Kroger Bakery0.0 (0 reviews)1700 Cedar St, Fremont, OH 43420, USA
Ideal Bakery4.0 (205 reviews)101 W Madison St, Gibsonburg, OH 43431, USA
B Sweet0.0 (0 reviews)814 Linden Blvd, Fremont, OH 43420, USA
Jake's Bakery5.0 (2 reviews)169 Mill St, Oak Harbor, OH 43449, USA
The Curious Cookie Shop0.0 (0 reviews)12148 W State Rte 163, Oak Harbor, OH 43449, USA
Auntie Anne's2.0 (13 reviews)Erie Islands Service Plaza, Ohio Tpke, Vickery, OH 43464, USA
Buggy Whip Bakery4.0 (15 reviews)104 E Main St, Wayne, OH 43466, USA
Kroger Bakery3.0 (1 reviews)126 W High St, Fostoria, OH 44830, USA
Lake Donuts4.0 (54 reviews)70 Jefferson St, Port Clinton, OH 43452, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
PreciseLee Baked5.0 (4 reviews)
Ramallah Bakery مخبز رام الله4.0 (502 reviews)
Donut Palace4.0 (397 reviews)
Punto Rojo Bakery Freeport 34.0 (719 reviews)
Fosdal Home Bakery4.0 (569 reviews)
Doughnut Plant4.0 (2240 reviews)Top Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Create the Perfect Caramel Apple Pie: Expert Tips and Flavor Secrets
How to Create a Perfect Dessert Buffet with Your Favorite Pastries
How to Make the Best Pumpkin Churros from Scratch at Home
How to Make the Perfect Homemade Cinnamon Roll Cake
How to Bake the Best Homemade Apple Crisp with Real Flavor
How to Make Perfect Chocolate Lava Cakes from Scratch 
