Sal & Dom's Pastry Shop Introduce
For many New Yorkers, especially those of us in the Bronx, a local bakery is more than just a place to buy sweets; it's an integral part of our community's celebrations and daily joys. Sal & Dom's Pastry Shop, located on Allerton Avenue, has been a long-standing fixture in this culinary landscape, known for its extensive selection of Italian pastries and its specialization in custom-designed cakes for all occasions. This isn't just a shop; it's a place where many turn to transform their special moments into edible works of art. While customer experiences, particularly with custom orders, can sometimes be varied, Sal & Dom's has a history of creating visually stunning and delicious cakes that become the centerpiece of important events. From intricate bridal shower cakes to everyday Italian treats, they aim to cater to the diverse needs of their clientele. This article will provide you with a comprehensive overview of Sal & Dom's Pastry Shop, detailing its location, services, and why it remains a prominent name in the Bronx.
In the vibrant and demanding culinary scene of New York City, a bakery's reputation is often built on its ability to deliver on both aesthetics and taste, especially for custom orders. Sal & Dom's Pastry Shop clearly demonstrates a capability for creating truly remarkable custom cakes. As one delighted customer enthusiastically recounted for a bridal shower cake, "Sal and Dom’s went above and beyond in creating the perfect cake… turning my vision into a stunning reality. The book-themed design was breathtaking, with intricate details, delicate florals, and elegant gold accents. It was truly a work of art!" This glowing review highlights the bakery's artistic talent and commitment to fulfilling complex design requests, resulting in a cake that was not only beautiful but also "fresh, moist, and absolutely delicious." Such feedback underscores their mastery in crafting memorable celebration cakes that exceed expectations.
However, it's also important to acknowledge that customer experiences can sometimes diverge. While some patrons rave about their custom creations, others have reported significant issues with product quality and, more critically, with customer service responses. These varied perspectives are part of the reality of any long-standing business in a high-volume environment. Despite these occasional challenges, the positive instances of breathtaking and delicious custom cakes indicate a strong potential for excellence within the bakery. For locals, knowing that Sal & Dom's possesses the artistic skill to produce such "stunning" and "delicious" custom cakes means they remain a viable option for those truly special occasions where a visual masterpiece is desired. Their longevity in the Bronx community also suggests a foundational level of quality that keeps many customers returning for their broader selection of Italian pastries and everyday treats.
Sal & Dom's Pastry Shop is conveniently located at 1108 Allerton Ave, Bronx, NY 10469, USA. This prime location places it in a busy and accessible part of the Bronx, making it a familiar and practical destination for residents across the borough and surrounding areas. Allerton Avenue is a well-known thoroughfare, ensuring that finding Sal & Dom's is a straightforward endeavor, whether you're navigating by car or utilizing public transportation.
The accessibility of Sal & Dom's is a significant advantage for its patrons in New York City. Being situated on a recognizable avenue means it's not hidden away, allowing for relatively quick and efficient stops, which is crucial in a bustling urban environment. For those driving, street parking can be typical for Bronx neighborhoods; while it might require some searching during peak hours, the general area is usually manageable. For public transport users, the location on Allerton Avenue is generally well-served by local bus routes, and its proximity to subway lines (such as the 2 and 5 trains at Allerton Avenue station) further enhances its accessibility for many New Yorkers who rely on mass transit. This ease of access contributes significantly to its popularity, as locals prioritize both the quality of their food and the convenience of acquiring it.
Furthermore, its placement in the 10469 zip code within the Bronx positions Sal & Dom's as a key local business serving the daily needs and celebratory occasions of its residents. It's an ideal spot to pick up pastries for a family gathering, grab a dessert after dinner, or place an order for a custom cake for a significant life event. The familiar surroundings of Allerton Avenue integrate it seamlessly into the local routine for many, reinforcing its status as a long-standing neighborhood institution. For anyone in the surrounding Bronx communities, Sal & Dom's Pastry Shop truly represents a convenient and well-known option for Italian pastries and custom cakes.
- Custom Cakes: Specializes in highly customized cakes for all major occasions, including bridal showers, weddings, birthdays, anniversaries, and other special events, with a focus on intricate designs and personalized themes.
- Italian Pastries: A wide selection of traditional Italian pastries such as cannolis, sfogliatelle, zeppole, cream puffs, pignoli cookies, and various other classic Italian-American sweet treats.
- Cookies and Biscotti: A diverse assortment of traditional Italian cookies and biscotti, suitable for coffee pairing or dessert platters.
- Assorted Cakes and Pies: Offers a variety of other ready-made cakes, tarts, and potentially seasonal pies for grab-and-go options.
- Catering Platters: Provides trays and platters of assorted pastries and cookies, ideal for parties, corporate events, or family gatherings.
- Coffee and Beverages: Likely offers coffee and other standard beverages to complement their baked goods.
- Exceptional Custom Cake Design: Highly praised for their ability to bring complex and detailed cake visions to life, creating stunning and artistic centerpieces for special occasions.
- Authentic Italian-American Pastries: Offers a wide array of classic Italian pastries, beloved by the local community for their traditional flavors and quality.
- Fresh and Delicious Taste (for successful orders): When executed well, custom cakes are noted for being "fresh, moist, and absolutely delicious," contributing positively to guest experiences.
- Long-Standing Community Presence: Has been a known establishment in the Bronx for many years, indicating its longevity and integration into the local fabric.
Address: 1108 Allerton Ave, Bronx, NY 10469, USA
Phone: (718) 515-3344
Mobile Phone: +1 718-515-3344
For residents of the Bronx and surrounding areas in New York, Sal & Dom's Pastry Shop remains a significant local option, particularly when it comes to celebrating life's special moments with a custom cake. Its established presence on Allerton Avenue makes it a familiar and accessible destination for anyone in need of Italian pastries or a centerpiece for their event. While customer experiences can vary, the bakery has clearly demonstrated its capability to produce "stunning" and "delicious" custom cakes, transforming personal visions into edible works of art.
The bakery's strength lies in its specialized offerings, notably its highly detailed custom cakes, as well as its wide selection of classic Italian-American pastries. For locals who prioritize unique designs and traditional flavors, Sal & Dom's offers a compelling choice. Despite any mixed feedback, the fact that customers continue to turn to them for significant celebrations speaks to their reputation and ability to deliver on specific, high-stakes orders. As a long-standing fixture in the Bronx, Sal & Dom's Pastry Shop continues to serve its community by providing those special touches that make celebrations memorable, making it a go-to spot for many in our vibrant New York neighborhood.
Sal & Dom's Pastry Shop Food & drink
Italian Ias
- Lemon Ias
- Chocolate Ias
- Vanilla Ias
- Almonds Ias
- Mango Ias
- Strawberry Ias
Sal & Dom's Pastry Shop Details
Service options
- In-store pick-up
- In-store shopping
- On-site services
- Takeaway
- Delivery
- Dine-in
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
Offerings
- Coffee
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Parking
- Free of charge street parking
Sal & Dom's Pastry Shop Photos










Sal & Dom's Pastry Shop Location
Sal & Dom's Pastry Shop
1108 Allerton Ave, Bronx, NY 10469, USA
Sal & Dom's Pastry Shop Reviews
dessertscannoliwedding cakeitalianflavorspartycakes, cookiestiramisured velvet cakeflan
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Sal and Dom’s went above and beyond in creating the perfect cake for my bridal shower! From start to finish, they were incredibly helpful, turning my vision into a stunning reality. The book-themed design was breathtaking, with intricate details, delicate florals, and elegant gold accents. It was truly a work of art!Not only was the cake beautiful, but it was also fresh, moist, and absolutely delicious. Every guest raved about both the look and the taste! Sal and Dom’s exceeded all expectations, and I couldn’t be happier. Highly recommend them for any special occasion!
February 24 · Kristina BoyerINCOMPETENT, UNPROFESSIONAL, HOSTILE!The cake collapsed and so did the professionalism. What followed was the most condescending and defensive interaction I’ve ever had with a business and that includes the the baker, Carlo writing me scathing emails accusing me of being “prejudicial and dishonest” for sharing my own experience! I had to block him because it was basically harassment and deflecting with performative victimhood!I ordered a birthday cake that collapsed before it was even cut, had the wrong filling, and was slathered with an overwhelming amount of whipped cream. It was inedible. I politely emailed with photos, explained the issues, and brought the cake back in person. While I was given a refund, the owner Carlo chose to hide in the back instead of apologizing face-to-face. Initially, he told me on the phone that my initial 5 minute review “kept him up all night,” but showed zero concern for how he ruined our celebration.Rather than apologizing outright, he lectured me on “cake physics,” talked over me about how long his bakery has existed, and blamed the issue on the cake not being “cooled in time”, a problem he knew about but still sent out. He even claimed maybe my family just doesn’t like sweets, completely ignoring the fact that the cake didn’t meet the order specifications and fell apart.What pushed this over the edge was his unhinged follow-up emails, where he doubled down instead of showing an ounce of accountability. He falsely claimed I lied, completely misrepresented the facts, and painted himself as the victim, all because I dared to post review with photos after receiving the refund. The refund was never contingent on me removing the review. To be clear, I decided to post this review because of his aggressive disrespectful behavior afterwards. His version of professionalism seems to be rage emailing a customer for telling the truth.The elitism is also hard to ignore. When I first came to place the order, the woman at the counter acted like she was doing me a favor just by taking it. Her tone only changed when she realized I knew the Westchester nail salon she snobbishly name dropped. The way this bakery treats people varies depending on your name, your background, and whether they think you belong. Just check how they respond to reviews, polite and courteous to some, defensive and rude to others.A refund doesn’t excuse poor service, condescension, and public gaslighting. I’ve been a customer here for decades and expected more. If Carlo had simply apologized sincerely and handled the situation professionally, this review wouldn’t exist. But his arrogance and lack of accountability speak louder than any cake ever could.My advice? Spend your money somewhere that respects both the occasion and the customer. This place doesn’t.
July 23 · K KThis place has been around for a long time, and it's slowly declining. I gave it two stars because their Tiramisu is delicious, but their cookies are like rocks with sprinkles. I spent 2 dollars on a large sprinkled cookie. I went to take a bite and I could have cracked a tooth. I banged it on my kitchen counter and it barely made crumbs. The cookie remained close to intact. Ask the girls behind the counter how long the cookies have been sitting there for before purchasing. My mistake for not doing so. If they say the same day, then they must use too much baking soda. Save your dentures or veneers folks! Be wary about them cookies.
June 11 · Out SpokenExcellent cakes and pastries, light and moist just like outta be. Happen to be in the area? This is a place that you must visit, highly recommended. Saluti!!!
November 03 · GaetanoThe best birthday cake by far, I have to thank Carlos for taking the order. I am just so happy its everything I wanted and so beautiful!!!!
April 05 · Bloodlust Raven
More Bakery Near Me
ASHxSWEETS5.0 (30 reviews)No Physical Location, Bronx, NY 10469, USA
MDV Custom Cakes, llc4.0 (36 reviews)Bronx, NY 10469, USA
National Bakery3.0 (353 reviews)767 Allerton Ave, Bronx, NY 10467, USA
Ela Postres3.0 (11 reviews)2770 Morgan Ave, Bronx, NY 10469, USA
Central Caribbean Bakery & Central Seafood Restaurant4.0 (270 reviews)1322 E Gun Hill Rd, Bronx, NY 10469, USA
HoneyBee Bakery3.0 (43 reviews)1355 E Gun Hill Rd, Bronx, NY 10469, USA
Cibao Bakery3.0 (11 reviews)2546 White Plains Rd, Bronx, NY 10467, USA
Ana's Bakery & Cafe4.0 (114 reviews)2127 Williamsbridge Rd, Bronx, NY 10461, USA
J E Bakery4.0 (20 reviews)743 Astor Ave, Bronx, NY 10467, USA
Moses Bagels & More4.0 (19 reviews)674 Allerton Ave, Bronx, NY 10467, USA
Monie's Sweet Shop LLC5.0 (1 reviews)1500 Astor Ave 2ND FLOOR, Bronx, NY 10469, USA
Prime Time Caribbean Bakery4.0 (38 reviews)3418 Boston Rd, Bronx, NY 10469, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Bagels & Brew4.0 (30 reviews)
Bagel & Deli Creations4.0 (542 reviews)
BCakeNY4.0 (247 reviews)
Daily Kneads Bakery5.0 (2 reviews)
Bagelmakers4.0 (197 reviews)
Moni’s Bakery2.0 (2 reviews)Top Bakery Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Bake Homemade Bread with Minimal Effort: Simple and Delicious Recipes
How to Bake the Best Classic Chocolate Chip Muffins at Home
How to Create the Perfect Chocolate Drizzle for Cakes | Expert Tips & Recipes
How to Make the Best Strawberry Cream Cheese Danish
How to Make Bakery-Style Cupcakes with Cream Cheese Frosting: A Step-by-Step Guide
Best Ways to Make Fresh Homemade Cream Puffs with Pastry Cream
