Sammi Sweetz

Introduction / Overview

In the dynamic and highly competitive culinary landscape of New York City, where a great bakery is a treasured local asset, Sammi Sweetz has carved out a unique and celebrated space, particularly on Staten Island. This is not your average neighborhood pastry shop; Sammi Sweetz operates as a boutique, women-owned bakery specializing in the creation of visually stunning, bespoke cakes and an array of high-end desserts for all of life's significant events. It is a true custom cake studio, bringing a professional, artistic, and deeply personal touch to the world of baking. The owner, Sammi, is a professional pastry chef and a graduate of the prestigious ICE Culinary School, which speaks volumes about the level of skill and dedication brought to every creation.

Sammi Sweetz is much more than a simple cake shop; it is a full-service dessert provider, classified publicly as a Cake shop, Cookie shop, Cupcake shop, Pastry shop, Pie shop, and, most notably, a Wedding bakery. This extensive classification reflects a versatile skill set capable of handling everything from a simple "Quick visit" for a delicious treat to the intricate planning required for a large-scale wedding dessert table. What truly sets the business apart is its focus on custom design and using only the finest ingredients to ensure every order is made from scratch. Customer testimonials consistently praise the breathtaking designs—from elegant, fresh-flowered wedding cakes to perfectly themed baby shower goodies—and universally agree that the taste is every bit as impressive as the look. The bakery prides itself on creating a one-of-a-kind centerpiece that is both delicious and stunning, a commitment that has earned the loyalty of New York clients for years.

This establishment deeply understands the importance of inclusivity and community support, proudly identifying as both LGBTQ+ friendly and a Transgender safespace. This welcoming environment, combined with the professionalism of the staff and the high-quality product, solidifies Sammi Sweetz as a valued and reliable local vendor within the New York Metro Area. Whether a patron is seeking a decadent gourmet cupcake to satisfy an immediate craving or is embarking on the journey of designing a multi-tiered wedding cake, the foundation of fresh ingredients, artistic execution, and dedicated service remains consistent. The range of products, from oversized stuffed cookies and chocolate-dipped strawberries to intricately decorated Pop Tartz and cheesecake minis, ensures that Sammi Sweetz is the go-to specialist for any sweet need, big or small.

Location and Accessibility

Sammi Sweetz is conveniently located at 128 Rose Ave, Staten Island, NY 10306, USA. While the bakery serves the entire New York City Metro Area, its physical location on Staten Island makes it a local gem for residents of the borough and surrounding areas. The address provides a central point for local customers to utilize the variety of pickup options available, from in-store to curbside service.

As a business that caters heavily to custom orders and major events, direct location accessibility is complemented by comprehensive delivery options. While large custom orders are typically requested two weeks in advance, the bakery’s robust service model, including delivery and "on-site services" for events, means the reach of Sammi Sweetz extends far beyond the immediate Rose Avenue neighborhood. The emphasis on accommodating various payment methods, including Checks, Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, also contributes to a seamless and accessible customer experience for quick transactions.

Services Offered

• Custom Cake Design and Baking: Specializing in bespoke cakes for all major life events, including weddings, bridal showers, baby showers, and birthdays. This service includes consultations to discuss themes, colors, and flavors.
• Wedding Bakery Services: As a certified wedding bakery, they provide specialized services for couples, including the creation of wedding cakes, groom's cakes, and comprehensive dessert buffets.
• Curbside Pickup: A convenient option for New Yorkers on the go, allowing for quick retrieval of orders without having to enter the store.
• Delivery: Offering delivery services, with a noted preference for larger orders, ensuring baked goods arrive fresh and on-time across the New York Metro Area.
• In-store Pickup and Shopping: Allowing customers to collect pre-orders or shop for treats available for immediate purchase, making it suitable for a 'Quick visit.'
• Onsite Services: Providing professional setup and presentation of dessert tables and cakes at event venues, taking the stress out of event day logistics for the client.
• Dietary Accommodations: The bakery can accommodate various dietary needs for custom orders, including gluten-free and nut-free requests, making their desserts accessible to more guests.

Features / Highlights

• Bespoke Cake and Dessert Expertise: The primary highlight is the unparalleled artistic skill in creating custom desserts, with the baker being a graduate of the ICE Culinary School. This ensures both professional-grade baking quality and stunning visual design, from 'naked cakes adorn with fresh flowers' to intricately decorated sugar cookies.
• Diverse Dessert Portfolio: The shop offers a wide range of products beyond traditional cakes, including Gourmet Cupcakes, Cupcake Shooters, oversized Gourmet Stuffed & Oversized Cookies, Cheesecake Minis, Chocolate Dipped Strawberries, Browniez, Cakesiclez, Pop Tartz, and Trufflez.
• Specialized Event Services: Sammi Sweetz excels in creating full dessert tables and dessert buffets for events like bridal showers, sweet sixteens, and baby showers, ensuring a cohesive and delicious sweet display that is often described as the "center piece of the room."
• Inclusivity and Community Focus: The business proudly identifies as a women-owned enterprise and an LGBTQ+ friendly and Transgender safespace, fostering a welcoming environment for all New York patrons.
• Commitment to Fresh, Premium Ingredients: All orders are custom-made from scratch using the finest ingredients, reflecting a commitment to quality that is evident in the positive customer feedback regarding the freshness and deliciousness of the treats.
• Seasonal and Promotional Offerings: The bakery runs popular weekly promotions, such as "$2 TUESDAYS" for gourmet cupcakes in rotating flavors, providing an affordable way for local New Yorkers to sample the high-end products.

Contact Information

Whether you are scheduling a consultation for a large event or simply placing an order for a decadent treat, here is the contact information for Sammi Sweetz:

Address: 128 Rose Ave, Staten Island, NY 10306, USA

Phone: (973) 688-1020

What is Worth Choosing

If you are located in the New York area, particularly on Staten Island, and are planning any significant event—from a bridal shower to a major wedding—Sammi Sweetz should be your first choice for custom desserts. The most compelling reason to choose this bakery is the combination of highly skilled, professional artistry and exceptional taste. Customer reviews repeatedly highlight the stunning and unique designs of the custom cakes, but they are equally enthusiastic about the delicious, fresh flavors. Unlike places where appearance can overshadow substance, Sammi Sweetz is lauded for delivering both.

Specifically, patrons should consider ordering one of their bespoke, multi-occasion cakes, as the business truly shines when creating a centerpiece dessert. The testimony of one customer—who used Sammi for a bridal shower, a wedding cake (a beautiful naked cake), and a baby shower—perfectly illustrates the consistent quality and deep trust the bakery inspires. Beyond the main cake, their specialty items for dessert tables are highly recommended. Choosing a selection of their Gourmet Cupcakes (especially on a value-driven "$2 TUESDAY"), Cheesecake Minis, or the fun, creative items like Cakesiclez and Gourmet Stuffed & Oversized Cookies, would provide a delightful and varied dessert experience for any gathering. For a simple indulgence or a small gift, the handcrafted Cream Cheese-Stuffed Gourmet Apples or Dozen Chocolate Dipped Strawberries are perfect, providing a moment of luxury that reflects the baker’s dedication and passion for her craft. The commitment to using premium ingredients and the personal, attentive service ensures that whatever you choose, it will be a memorable and high-quality New York sweet treat.

Sammi Sweetz

128 Rose Ave, Staten Island, NY 10306, USA