Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie

In the charming, somewhat tucked-away neighborhood of Red Hook, Brooklyn, lies a true New York culinary institution: Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie. This isn't just any bakery; it's a dedicated haven for those who appreciate the perfect balance of sweet and tart in a classic key lime pie. For years, Steve's has been a go-to destination for locals and visitors alike, drawn by the promise of genuine, handcrafted pies that transport you straight to the Florida Keys with every bite. The commitment to authenticity and quality is evident in every aspect, from the fresh-squeezed key lime juice to the handmade graham cracker crusts. It's a place where the focus is singular, yet the experience is multifaceted, offering not just a dessert but a slice of a uniquely Brooklyn experience, especially with its picturesque waterfront setting.

Customers consistently rave about the deliciousness and authenticity of Steve's Key Lime Pie. Many have waited eagerly to try this iconic spot and are rarely disappointed, describing the pies as "pretty good and delicious" and notably "nice and tart." The "Swingle," a unique take on their classic pie, is frequently highlighted as a delightful and refreshing treat that often surprises first-time tasters. Patrons who have lived in places renowned for their key lime pies, like Miami, attest that Steve's product stands shoulder-to-shoulder with the very best they've encountered, a testament to its genuine quality. Beyond the pies themselves, the friendly and lovely service, as noted by customers, contributes significantly to the overall positive experience. The presence of outdoor picnic benches allows for an enjoyable dining experience with beautiful views of the New York Harbor, making it an ideal spot for warm weather days. While a line is often to be expected, especially during peak times, it's generally reported to move quickly, ensuring that the wait for a taste of authentic key lime perfection is never too long. The variety of sizes, from single-serve tarts to family-sized pies, also makes it convenient for any occasion, from a personal indulgence to a gathering with friends.

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie is perfectly situated at 185 Van Dyke St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA. This location places it in the historic and somewhat industrial yet increasingly vibrant neighborhood of Red Hook, right on the waterfront. This makes it a unique destination, often paired with a visit to the nearby Louis Valentino, Jr. Park and Pier, which offers expansive and breathtaking views of the New York Harbor, including the Statue of Liberty and the Manhattan skyline.

While Red Hook might feel a bit off the beaten path compared to other Brooklyn neighborhoods, its charm lies in its distinct character and slower pace. Public transportation to this specific area can involve a bit more planning than other parts of Brooklyn. There are bus routes that service the Red Hook area, connecting to subway lines. For many, a visit to Steve's is part of a deliberate outing, often involving a walk, bike ride, or even a ferry ride, which offers a scenic approach to the neighborhood. The journey to Red Hook often becomes part of the experience, leading to this culinary gem. The bakery’s setting directly by the water further enhances its appeal, especially on pleasant weather days when customers can enjoy their pies outdoors at picnic tables while soaking in the panoramic views.

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie maintains specific operating hours, though these can sometimes be flexible due to its unique nature and dedication to freshness. Generally, the shop is open Monday through Thursday from 12:00 PM to 7:00 PM, and on Friday, Saturday, and Sunday, they extend their hours, opening at 11:00 AM and often staying open until 8:00 PM or "sundown" during warmer months. It's always a good idea to call ahead, especially if traveling a significant distance, as their website advises checking for real-time closing hours, particularly in the summer, or if planning a visit on a "semi-closed" Monday or Tuesday.

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie focuses on one star product, but offers it in a variety of convenient formats, along with a few complementary items.

Services Offered:

• Authentic Key Lime Pies: Available in several sizes to suit individual or group needs, featuring their signature "fresh squeezed" key lime custard in a hand-formed graham cracker and butter crust.
  • 3-inch mini-tarts ("The Teaser"): Perfect for a bite-sized indulgence or tasting tables.
  • 4-inch tarts ("Single Serve"): Ideal for personal portions, often described as just enough to satisfy one person.
  • 8-inch pies: A smaller version of their classic pie, typically serving four.
  • 10-inch pies: The classic, larger size, typically serving eight.
• The Swingle™: Their renowned 4-inch key lime tart, frozen on a stick and hand-dipped in rich Belcolade Belgian chocolate, thinned with organic cocoa butter.
  • The Classic Swingle: Original chocolate-dipped version.
  • The Raspberry Swingle: Features an added layer of rich raspberry puree.
  • The Raspberry Blonde: Raspberry Swingle hand-dipped in Belcolade Belgian white chocolate.
  • The LaVictoria: Classic Swingle topped with a layer of chipotle puree for a hint of heat.
• Gluten-Free Options: They offer gluten-free versions of their classic key lime pie (10-inch, available frozen only) and the Classic Swingle, made with an in-house gluten-free crust.
• Limeade: A refreshing beverage, perfect to accompany their pies.
• Whipped Cream: Available for purchase to top your pie.
• Wholesale Orders: Catering to restaurants, events, and larger gatherings with fresh-baked pies and tarts.
• Local Delivery: Available through third-party services like Uber Eats for those within their delivery range.

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie distinguishes itself with several key features that make it a beloved local spot.

Features / Highlights:

• Truly Authentic Key Lime Pie: The primary highlight is their unwavering commitment to creating an authentic key lime pie using 100% pure, fresh-squeezed key lime juice and hand-formed, butter-rich graham cracker crusts, mirroring traditional Florida Keys methods. They emphasize not cutting corners on ingredients.
• The Iconic Swingle™: This unique invention – a chocolate-dipped, frozen key lime tart on a stick – has become a signature item, offering a novel and delicious way to enjoy their pie.
• Waterfront Location and Views: Situated directly on the Red Hook waterfront, customers can enjoy their treats at outdoor picnic tables with stunning panoramic views of the New York Harbor, including the Statue of Liberty and the Manhattan skyline, making for a memorable experience.
• Nut-Free Facility: Steve's operates in a 100% nut-free facility, a significant advantage for customers with nut allergies.
• Family-Owned and Operated: The business has a deep-rooted history in Red Hook, starting over 25 years ago, with a dedication to quality passed down through generations.
• Community Engagement: The business is known for its strong ties to the Red Hook community, including participation in local events like parades where they give out free pies.
• Focus on Quality Ingredients: They prioritize sourcing the best ingredients, including condensed milk from a Wisconsin dairy and wheat from New York's Birkett Mills, and even source locally when possible, demonstrating a commitment to their product.
• Environmentally Conscious Efforts: Steve's takes steps towards sustainability, such as offering boxed water instead of plastic bottles and using recyclable spoons.

For direct inquiries or to place an order, you can reach Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie at their Red Hook location.

Contact Information:

Address: 185 Van Dyke St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA

Phone: (718) 858-5333

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie is a quintessential Brooklyn destination that locals should absolutely experience. Its commitment to crafting a truly authentic key lime pie, which rivals those found in Florida, ensures a consistently delicious product that sets it apart. The unique "Swingle" offers a playful and refreshing alternative, perfect for warmer days. What truly makes this place suitable for New Yorkers, beyond the exceptional desserts, is its distinctive location. Nestled on the Red Hook waterfront, it provides a rare opportunity to enjoy world-class baked goods while taking in breathtaking views of the harbor and iconic landmarks. This combination of culinary excellence and a scenic, relaxed atmosphere makes it an ideal escape from the city's usual hustle. The friendly service, as highlighted by numerous customers, further enhances the welcoming vibe. Whether you're looking for a delightful treat for yourself, a unique dessert to bring to a gathering, or simply a charming spot to unwind with a view, Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie offers a truly memorable and highly recommended experience for anyone in the New York region. It’s more than a bakery; it’s a cherished local landmark.

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie

185 Van Dyke St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA