Stuff a Bagel

For many residents and visitors in the greater Orlando area, finding an authentic New York-style bagel in the Sunshine State is a true quest. Stuff a Bagel in Windermere, Florida, decisively ends that search, delivering a taste of the Northeast right to the heart of Central Florida. This is more than just a bagel shop; it’s a full-fledged New York deli experience, complete with the palpable energy and incredible aroma that instantly transports patrons to a 'little hole in the wall in NYC,' as one enthusiastic local described it. The focus here is on genuine craftsmanship: bagels are celebrated for their 'fire' quality—perfectly crispy on the outside and wonderfully chewy within—and the cream cheese is proudly described as being 'made in house.'

Stuff a Bagel has rapidly carved out a niche by offering the quality and breadth of menu that defines a truly great New York-style establishment. Whether you are a Florida transplant craving the familiar flavors of a classic Bacon, Egg, & Cheese on a fresh bagel, or a local looking for a hearty, authentic lunch, this women-owned business delivers. The extensive menu goes far beyond simple spreads, featuring specialty sandwiches named after iconic New York and New Jersey landmarks, demonstrating a commitment to the regional deli culture that is often hard to replicate hundreds of miles south. This dedication to authenticity and quality makes Stuff a Bagel a must-visit destination for breakfast, brunch, and lunch in the Windermere area.

The experience is further elevated by the welcoming environment and thoughtful service model. Customers consistently rave about the 'awesome vibes' and 'friendly faces,' underscoring that while the food is authentically New York, the service retains that signature Florida warmth. This combination makes it a perfect gathering spot for locals and tourists alike. The convenience of the operation, from the ample free parking to the options for delivery and dine-in, ensures that satisfying your craving for a freshly boiled and baked bagel is always a seamless experience. Even those with specific dietary needs, such as a requirement for gluten-free options, are catered to with items that are noted for being surprisingly 'actually good,' a rare compliment in the bagel world.

The menu's depth ensures that no customer leaves unsatisfied. From the vast array of homemade cream cheeses—like veggie, maple walnut, and even cookies & cream—to the extensive list of hot and cold deli sandwiches, Stuff a Bagel provides comprehensive offerings for every meal of the day. They even thoughtfully include quintessential New York-style bakery treats like the beautiful 'Italian Rainbow Cookies' and the classic 'Homemade Crumb Cake Slice,' cementing its status as a full-service, transplanted Northeastern deli right here in Central Florida.

Location and Accessibility

Stuff a Bagel is conveniently situated to serve the growing Windermere and greater Orlando community. Its location is a key factor in its accessibility and convenience for local patrons:

Address: 13211 Reams Rd Unit 110. CBU#14, Windermere, FL 34786, USA

The location is designed for maximum ease of use for all Florida customers:

• Wheelchair Accessible Entrance: Ensures that the shop is welcoming and easily navigable for all visitors.
• Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot: Provides dedicated, accessible parking spots, adding a layer of convenience.
• Free Parking Lot: Ample, free parking is available, which is a significant amenity for a popular, high-traffic food destination in the area.
• Planning for a Quick Visit: The operational setup and service options are conducive to a 'Quick visit' for those grabbing a bite on the go.

Services Offered

Stuff a Bagel offers a comprehensive range of service options designed to meet the demands of a busy Florida community:

• Dine-in: Customers can enjoy their meal inside, soaking in the 'awesome vibes' and authentic deli atmosphere.
• Takeout: Fast and efficient service for customers wishing to grab their breakfast or lunch to go.
• Delivery: Partnered with third-party services to bring the full menu directly to homes and offices in the local area.
• In-store Pickup: Convenient option for mobile and online orders to be collected quickly.
• Onsite Services: Available for local businesses or large event orders, showcasing a commitment to catering.
• Credit and Debit Payments: Accepts all major credit and debit cards for easy transaction processing.
• NFC Mobile Payments: Supports modern, contactless payments (e.g., Apple Pay, Google Pay) for speed and security.

Features / Highlights

Stuff a Bagel distinguishes itself with several unique and appealing features:

• Authentic NY-Style Bagels: Celebrated for their perfect chewy texture, crispy exterior, and guaranteed freshness—hailed as a true taste of New York in Florida.
• Homemade Cream Cheese: Features a wide variety of spreads, including unique flavors like maple walnut, veggie, and lox spread, all noted for being made in-house.
• Specialty Deli Menu: Extensive offerings beyond standard fare, including New York-themed specialties like the 'Jersey Turnpike' (Pork Roll, Egg, & Cheese) and the 'Lox Deluxe' sandwich.
• Gluten-Free Options: Thoughtfully provides actually 'good' gluten-free bagels and sandwich choices, catering to a wider audience.
• Full Bakery Selection: Offers classic Northeastern bakery items like 'Italian Rainbow Cookies' (Tricolor Cookies), 'Giant Cinnamon Rolls,' and 'Homemade Crumb Cake Slice.'
• Women-Owned Business: Proudly identifies as a women-owned business, contributing to the diversity of local entrepreneurship in Windermere.
• Full-Service Dining: Caters to both breakfast and lunch crowds with hot melts (Reuben, Philly Cheesesteak) and cold sandwiches/salads.

Contact Information

For Florida locals looking to place an order or inquire about services:

Address: 13211 Reams Rd Unit 110. CBU#14, Windermere, FL 34786, USA

Phone: (689) 600-4989

Mobile Phone: +1 689-600-4989

What is Worth Choosing Stuff a Bagel

For any Florida resident or visitor in the Central Florida area, choosing Stuff a Bagel is choosing an experience defined by authenticity and comprehensive quality that is difficult to find outside of the Northeast. The primary reason to choose this bagel shop is the indisputable quality of the core product: the bagel itself. Customer feedback confirms that the bagels are fresh, prepared in the 'old fashioned way' (boiled and baked), and possess the superior texture—dense and chewy—that sets a truly authentic New York-style bagel apart from the common bread-like imitation. For anyone who understands and appreciates that difference, Stuff a Bagel is simply 'fire.'

Furthermore, the women-owned establishment distinguishes itself with an expansive menu that truly makes it a one-stop deli destination. You are not limited to a simple cream cheese spread; you can explore a wide variety of in-house made spreads, hearty breakfast sandwiches (like the top-selling 'Bacon, Egg, & Cheese'), or unique specialty subs (like the 'Frank The Tank'). The inclusion of authentic regional desserts like the Italian Rainbow Cookies is a delightful detail that shows the commitment to the full deli culture, making it a place where you can cater to both your breakfast needs and your sweet tooth in one visit.

Finally, the combination of excellent customer service, a welcoming 'awesome vibes' atmosphere, and practical amenities seals the deal. The staff is consistently praised for being friendly, and the operational model, featuring free parking, wheelchair accessibility, and multiple service options (dine-in, takeout, delivery), ensures a hassle-free experience. Whether you're a local starting your morning or a family grabbing lunch, Stuff a Bagel in Windermere offers the most authentic, highest-quality, and most convenient New York deli experience available in the Florida region. They even toast your bagel upon request—a small but appreciated detail that demonstrates their commitment to customer satisfaction over rigid regional tradition.

Stuff a Bagel

13211 Reams Rd Unit 110. CBU#14, Windermere, FL 34786, USA