Sugar Me Sunshine

Introduction / Overview

Sugar Me Sunshine is a vibrant, small business bakery based in Fort Myers, Florida, dedicated to crafting delightful, made-to-order treats with a huge amount of heart and creativity. Far from a typical walk-in shop, this establishment specializes in custom orders, delivery, and pickup, providing a personal touch that resonates deeply with the local community.

What makes Sugar Me Sunshine a standout in the Southwest Florida dessert scene is its remarkable ability to create treats that are both visually stunning and incredibly delicious, particularly their highly-praised gluten-free offerings. Customers rave about the quality of the baked goods, noting that you would "never know" they were gluten-free by the taste. Items like the Galactic Butter Bomb and Hazelnut Supreme cookies are described as "next-level delicious," being super soft, rich, and absolutely packed with flavor.

The business, run by the dedicated baker Ryan, prides itself on personalized customer service and a true passion for baking, which shines through in every custom cake and cookie. Whether you are seeking a meticulously designed cake for a major celebration, a box of flavorful cookies for a quick treat, or a specialty dessert that caters to specific dietary needs, Sugar Me Sunshine is recognized as a truly special local find, delivering happiness and "sunshine in every bite."

Location and Accessibility

Though primarily operating on a made-to-order basis, Sugar Me Sunshine is centrally located in the Fort Myers area, allowing for convenient local pickup and delivery arrangements throughout the region.

The location is associated with the:

Forum Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33905, USA

This general area provides excellent accessibility for residents in Fort Myers and surrounding Florida communities. The business model is focused on ensuring a smooth, convenient transaction process, which is reflected in the logistics for customers:

• Wheelchair Accessible Entrance: The designated pickup location ensures an accessible entrance.
• Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot: Accessible parking spots are available for easy in-and-out access during the pickup process.
• Arrangements for Picking Up: The owner is highly praised for being "super responsive and very helpful with arrangements," ensuring the pickup process is organized and efficient.
• Payment Convenience: Accepts Credit cards and Debit cards, offering flexibility for all orders.
• Quick Visit Planning: The focus on arranged pickups means the process is designed for maximum efficiency, perfect for customers on a tight schedule.

Services Offered

As a dedicated, custom small business bakery, Sugar Me Sunshine offers service options centered on convenience and personalization for the local Florida community.

• Custom Celebration Cakes: Bespoke cakes created for all occasions, including First Communions, birthdays, and other milestones, with a focus on fulfilling specific customer design requests (e.g., favorite colors, custom decorations like edible butterflies).
• Specialty Cookies and Dessert Bars: Offers unique, high-flavor cookies such as the Galactic Butter Bomb, Hazelnut Supreme, and various dessert bars, often available in gluten-free formats.
• Cake Pops and Cake Bites: Small, decadent treats noted for their stunning appearance (e.g., pink and white swirls) and perfect, moist texture.
• Delivery: Orders can be delivered locally within the Fort Myers area, providing exceptional convenience for customers.
• In-store Pickup: Offers a convenient option for customers to collect their pre-arranged orders directly.
• Takeout: All custom baked goods are prepared and packaged for easy takeout.
• Personalized Ordering: The business thrives on personalized communication, ensuring customers receive the exact product they envision, with the owner being highly praised for her responsiveness and helpfulness.

Features / Highlights

Sugar Me Sunshine is distinguished by its quality, creativity, and customer-focused approach, making it a favorite among Southwest Florida locals.

• Exceptional Gluten-Free Baking: The most significant highlight is the quality of the gluten-free desserts. Customers are "blown away" that the treats, including the much-loved cookies and coffee cake, taste so rich and flavorful, making them undetectable as special diet items. This is a massive plus for anyone in Florida with gluten sensitivities or allergies.
• Customization Excellence: The bakery excels at transforming a customer's vision into reality, as evidenced by the creation of a First Communion cake featuring specific favorite colors and meaningful edible decorations like butterflies.
• "Next-Level Delicious" Specialty Cookies: The unique and creatively named cookies, like the Galactic Butter Bomb, are super-soft, rich, and "absolutely packed with flavor," establishing them as a must-try signature item.
• Passionate Small Business Owner: The heart of the business is the owner, Ryan, whose "baking is definitely her passion" and whose customer service is highlighted as one of her core strengths. This personal investment ensures high quality and care in every order.
• Moist and Sweet Texture: Products like the cake pops and the coffee cake are consistently complimented for having the "perfect texture"—moist and sweet without being overly cloying.
• Beautiful Presentation and Packaging: The treats are not only delicious but also "stunning" and "beautifully packaged," ensuring the entire experience, from unwrapping to the first bite, feels like a special luxury.

Contact Information

To place a custom order or inquire about treats and arrangements:

Address (General Area): Forum Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33905, USA

Phone: (908) 938-2012

Mobile Phone: +1 908-938-2012

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Sugar Me Sunshine is worth it for any Florida resident who values quality, customization, and inclusivity in their desserts. This small business offers a level of personal care and attention to detail that is often absent in larger commercial bakeries.

The primary reason to choose this Fort Myers bakery is its unparalleled expertise in delicious special-diet baking. For those who must eat gluten-free, or are serving guests with dietary restrictions, the ability to order treats like the Galactic Butter Bomb or coffee cake—where the gluten-free status is completely unnoticeable—is a game-changer and a huge source of relief. This inclusive approach ensures no one feels left out of a celebration.

Furthermore, if you are planning a milestone event, the dedication to custom cake design sets Sugar Me Sunshine apart. The baker’s ability to flawlessly execute specific themes, colors, and meaningful details—like the edible butterflies added for a First Communion—means your centerpiece dessert will truly capture the spirit of your special day.

Finally, the exceptional customer service provided by the owner, Ryan, makes the ordering and pickup process stress-free and pleasant. Customers are already "planning next order" due to this combination of mouth-watering, highly creative treats and top-tier professionalism. When you choose Sugar Me Sunshine, you are choosing treats baked with love, packaged beautifully, and delivered with genuine care.

Sugar Me Sunshine

Forum Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33905, USA