Sweetness Cookie Company: Gourmet Cookies, Ice Cream & Cold Brew in South Elgin, IL

Sweetness Cookie Company Introduce

Introduction / Overview

For residents of the Illinois Fox Valley area and surrounding Chicago suburbs, Sweetness Cookie Company in South Elgin is a must-visit destination that lives up to its name. More than just a bakery, this local hotspot is a trifecta of deliciousness, combining a specialty Cookie Shop, a full-service Ice Cream Shop, and a quality Coffee purveyor. What began as a passionate home business specializing in intricate, custom-decorated cookies has successfully expanded into a beloved brick-and-mortar location that serves an impressive, ever-changing menu of colossal, gourmet cookies and complementary treats.

The core philosophy here is simple: go above and beyond the standard expectation for size, flavor, and creativity. Patrons rave about the massive size and intense flavor of the daily offerings, often describing them as incredibly decadent and surprisingly affordable for the quality and generous portions. From their famous Deep Dish Chocolate Chip to a rotation of nearly fifty other unique gourmet cookie flavors, Sweetness Cookie Company has cemented itself as the go-to place in South Elgin for satisfying every sweet tooth, whether for a quick daily pick-me-up or a dazzling special occasion dessert. The friendly, engaging staff and welcoming atmosphere make every visit feel like stopping in to see long-time regulars.

Location and Accessibility

Sweetness Cookie Company is strategically located in a commercial area of South Elgin, making it easily accessible for local residents and those traveling from nearby communities like Elgin, St. Charles, and Bartlett.

Address: 454 Redington Dr Suite D, South Elgin, IL 60177, USA

The location is designed for customer convenience, especially for those looking for a Quick visit:

Wheelchair Accessible Entrance: Ensures all customers can enter the facility without barrier.
Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot: Convenient, dedicated parking spaces are available for ease of access.
Proximity: Located just off Randall Road, the shop is easy to find, often situated in a strip mall area that allows for quick in-and-out visits.

Services Offered

Sweetness Cookie Company offers a wide array of products and convenient service options designed to meet various customer needs, from daily indulgence to large-scale event planning.

Gourmet Cookie Retail: Selling a massive, rotating selection of over fifty innovative and often stuffed gourmet cookie flavors, available daily.
Custom Decorated Cookies: Specializing in handcrafted, beautifully decorated sugar cookies tailored to specific themes (e.g., holidays, graduations, birthdays) for parties and events.
Ice Cream and Milkshakes: Offering a selection of premium ice cream and classic treats like Vanilla Milkshake and Chocolate Milkshake, perfect for pairing with their baked goods.
Specialty Beverages: Serving high-quality coffee, including various Cold Brew Signature Lattes and the customizable Build Your Own Energy Refresher.
Daily and Weekend Specials: Providing special, sought-after items like the enormous Cinnamon Roll (often available on Saturdays) and classic treats like Brownies, Cake Pops, and Macarons.
Takeout and In-store Pickup: Convenient service options for customers to quickly collect their orders.
Payment Flexibility: Accepting all major forms of payment, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Features / Highlights

The distinct features and highlights of Sweetness Cookie Company solidify its status as a premier dessert destination in the Illinois area.

Massive and Creative Cookie Menu: The sheer volume and originality of the gourmet cookie flavors—ranging from Creme Brulee and Deep Dish Nutella to Stuffed S'mores and Carrot Cake—ensure there is always a new, exciting taste to discover, keeping regular customers coming back weekly.
Legendary Saturday Specials: The Cinnamon Roll is a highlight often praised in customer feedback, noted for its generous size and decadent quality, making it a highly anticipated weekend treat for the local community.
The Art of Customization: The bakery excels at creating custom-decorated sugar cookies that are "little edible pieces of art," adding a highly personalized and memorable touch to any Illinois party or event.
Premium Complementary Offerings: The combination of high-quality baked goods with gourmet Ice Cream and locally-sourced Cold Brew Coffee (often brewed with beans from local roasters) makes it a complete dessert and beverage experience.
Exceptional Customer Engagement: Reviews consistently highlight the friendly, engaging, and welcoming nature of the staff, with many praising the owner's personal touch and genuine appreciation for the customers, fostering a true neighborhood feel.

Contact Information

For orders, custom inquiries, or general information, Illinois customers can reach out to the Sweetness Cookie Company directly.

Address: 454 Redington Dr Suite D, South Elgin, IL 60177, USA

Phone: (224) 238-3313

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Sweetness Cookie Company is worth it for Illinois residents because you are selecting a unique local business that perfectly blends Gourmet Innovation, Exceptional Value, and Genuine Community Spirit.

Choosing Gourmet Innovation: The bakery’s commitment to an ever-evolving menu of over fifty unique gourmet cookies ensures that your sweet tooth will never be bored. Whether you are craving the indulgence of a Deep Dish Nutella or the bright, zesty flavor of Lemon Ricotta, this company offers a rotating collection of culinary creativity that far surpasses generic alternatives. The unique flavors and stuffed varieties are a local experience in South Elgin that cannot be replicated elsewhere, making it a destination for dessert lovers across the region.

Choosing Exceptional Value: Customers repeatedly point out that the prices are "insanely cheap for the size you get." The massive, half-pound nature of the gourmet cookies, combined with the intense flavor profiles and high-quality ingredients, means you get significant value with every purchase. This generous portioning and pricing make Sweetness Cookie Company an affordable luxury for daily cravings and a standout option for catering larger events where quality and quantity matter.

Choosing Genuine Community Spirit: The friendly staff and the owner's engaging presence create a welcoming environment that makes a simple trip for a cookie feel special. This high level of customer service, combined with the ability to handle intricate custom decorated cookie orders, proves their dedication to the local Illinois community. When you choose Sweetness Cookie Company, you are choosing a local business that genuinely appreciates its patrons and works hard to deliver amazing work and amazing experiences every time.

Sweetness Cookie Company Vibe

Saturday Specials
Cinnamon Roll $7.00
Our famous cinnamon rolls are made in house every single week. Soft and chewy on the outside and a little gooey on the inside, they're over a pound each including the cream cheese frosting!
Lemon Bar $5.50
Made with a shortbread crust and dusted with powdered sugar
Millionaire Shortbread Bar $7.50
Shortbread base layer topped with a thick layer of delicious house-made caramel, a layer of chocolate ganache, and a sprinkle of sea salt

Drinks
Build Your Own Energy Refresher $7.00
Put a little extra pep in your step! Fruit flavored carbonated energy drinks
16oz Cold Brew Signature Latte $7.25
Brewed in house using locally sourced coffee from Coroco Coffee Roasters
20oz Cold Brew Signature Latte $8.25
Brewed in house using locally sourced coffee from Coroco Coffee Roasters
20oz Cold Brew $6.00
Brewed in house using locally sourced coffee from Coroco Coffee Roasters
16oz Cold Brew $5.25
Brewed in house using locally sourced coffee from Coroco Coffee Roasters

Daily Offerings
CHOCOLATE Cake Pop $4.25
Colors and decoration vary Chocolate cake pop dipped in white chocolate and decorated with sprinkles
Rice Krispie Treat $5.50
GLUTEN FRIENDLY **does contain barley malt extract** Absolutely massive, "big as your face" rice krispie treat
Puppy Chow (Muddy Buddies) 1 Pound $16.00
GLUTEN FREE! Rice chex cereal coated in chocolate & peanut butter, then dusted with powdered sugar
Brownie $5.25
XL brownie with chocolate chips, dusted with powdered sugar and topped with sprinkles
Chocolate Milkshake $8.00
16oz. milkshake made to order with real ice cream and topped with whipped cream
Puppy Chow (Muddy Buddies) 1/2 Pound $10.00
GLUTEN FREE! Rice chex cereal coated in chocolate & peanut butter, then dusted with powdered sugar
Jumbo Oreo Truffe Sandwich $5.50
Colors and decoration vary Oreo truffle dough sandwiched between two GIANT oreo wafers. Dipped in white chocolate and decorated with sprinkles
Vanilla Milkshake $8.00
16oz. milkshake made to order with real ice cream and topped with whipped cream
Mini Frosted Brownie $3.00
Colors and decoration vary Mini version of our XL brownie with chocolate chips. Topped with vanilla buttercream and sprinkles
Decorated Sugar Cookie (Assorted Designs) $6.00
VANILLA Cake Pop $4.25
Macaron $3.50
FLAVORS: -BIRTHDAY CAKE -RED VELVET -CHOCOLATE -VANILLA -FRUITY PEBBLES -STRAWBERRY CHEESECAKE -RASPBERRY ROSE -LEMON -LEMONBERRY -WILDBERRY -SALTED CARAMEL -COOKIES N CREAM -PISTACHIO -ITALIAN CREME MADE WITH ALMOND FLOUR. *GLUTEN FRIENDLY*

Gourmet Cookies
Birthday Cake $5.50
Cake batter flavored funfetti sprinkle cookie topped with vanilla buttercream and sprinkles
Creme Brulee $5.75
Shortbread-like cookie with vanilla custard topping and bruleed sugar
Stuffed S'mores $5.75
Graham cracker cookie dough with chocolate chips and a hint of cinnamon to give you that warm toasty campfire feeling. Each cookie is stuffed with a whole large marshmallow, then baked on a graham cracker. Topped with melted chocolate and toasted marshmallows.
Cookie Monster $5.75
Blue chocolate chip cookie stuffed with a whole oreo, topped with candy eyes and half a Chip's Ahoy chocolate chip cookie
Not Your Grandma's Oatmeal Cookie $5.50
Oatmeal cookie with chocolate chips and caramel bits, drizzled with salted caramel and chocolate
Raspberry Lime $5.50
Shortbread cookie topped with tart raspberry lime buttercream
Double Chocolate Oreo $5.50
Cookie made with whole oreos, topped with chocolate buttercream frosting and oreo
Strawberry Lemonade $5.50
Our buttery shortbread cookie is topped with a delightfully tart strawberry lemon buttercream made with fresh strawberries & freshly squeezed lemon juice!
Blueberry Streusel Muffin $5.75
Oatmeal cookie made with fresh blueberries, topped with vanilla glaze and streusel topping
Banana Bread $5.50
Banana bread cookie made with fresh bananas and topped with cream cheese frosting
Vanilla Latte $5.50
Espresso cookie with vanilla espresso buttercream
KitKat Krunch $5.75
Sugar cookie made with crushed kitkats, stuffed with a whole snack size kitkat, then topped with melted chocolate and even more kitkat!
Pistachio $5.50
Pistachio cookie topped with almond buttercream and a swirl of chocolate
Frosted Oatmeal $5.25
Lightly spiced cinnamon oatmeal cookie topped with vanilla buttercream frosting
Carrot Cake $5.75
Carrot cake cookie made with freshly grated carrots. Topped with cream cheese frosting and a buttercream carrot
Cookie Dough $5.50
Brown sugar cookie topped with cookie dough frosting and edible cookie dough bites
Hot Fudge Sundae $5.50
Rich chocolate cookie topped with vanilla buttercream, hot fudge, sprinkles, and a cherry on top
Cookies & Cream $5.50
Cookies and cream cookie made with oreo cookies, topped with vanilla buttercream frosting and oreo cookie crumbles.
Pineapple Delight $5.50
Pineapple cookie made with real crushed pineapple pieces, pineapple buttercream on top
White Chocolate Macadamia $5.75
Brown sugar cookie with macadamia nuts and mini white chocolate chips, drizzled with white chocolate and topped with mini white chocolate chips
Coffee Cake $5.50
Cinnamon cookie topped with vanilla glaze and streusel topping
Dubai Delight $7.00
Pistachio chocolate chip cookie topped with pistachio cream kadayif filling then covered in melty delicious chocolate
Reese’s Party $5.50
Our Reese’s peanut butter cookie topped with chocolate & peanut butter drizzle. Finished with Reese’s chunks & Reese’s Pieces candies!
Molten Lava $5.75
Rich brownie-like chocolate cookie filled with chocolate and topped with chocolate ganache and powdered sugar
Deep Dish Nutella $5.75
Extra tall chocolate chip cookie filled with nutella
Deep Dish Peanut Butter Nutella $5.75
Deep dish peanut butter cookie made with Reese's peanut butter chips. Filled with nutella
Pink Lemonade $5.25
Soft chewy sugar cookie topped with tart lemonade buttercream and a lemon candy slice
Tart Blue Raspberry $5.50
Graham cracker cookie topped with sour blue raspberry buttercream
Cinnamon Roll $5.75
Our famous cinnamon rolls in cookie form! Sugar cookie with brown sugar cinnamon filling, topped with vanilla glaze
Caramel Pretzel M&M $5.25
Chewy brown sugar cookie with pretzels and m&m's candies inside, drizzled with caramel and chocolate and topped with more pretzels and m&m's
French Silk Pie $5.75
Deep dish shortbread cookie filled with chocolate pie filing and topped with a tiny swirl of vanilla buttercream and chocolate shavings
Red Velvet Oreo $5.50
Our red velvet cookie is packed with tiny white chocolate chips. Topped with a cream cheese buttercream & a whole crushed Oreo!
Strawberry Shortcake $5.50
Strawberry cookie with vanilla buttercream and strawberry crunch topping
Stuffed Nutella KitKat $5.75
Sugar cookie stuffed with a Kinder Bueno bar (like a kitkat filled with hazelnut cream), topped with nutella buttercream and kit kat pieces
Cocoa Toffee Shortbread $5.75
Shortbread cookie with chocolate buttercream, topped with housemade toffee
Key Lime Pie $5.50
Graham cracker cookie filled with tart key lime buttercream filling, topped with a slice of lime candy
Double Chocolate Caramel $5.50
Chocolate cookie with chocolate chips and caramel bits, topped with vanilla buttercream and a drizzle of caramel
Churro $5.25
Snickerdoodle cookie topped with cinnamon buttercream frosting
Coconut Cream $5.50
Graham cracker cookie topped with coconut buttercream and freshly toasted coconut flakes
Cocoa Fluff $5.50
Rich chocolate base topped with marshmallow buttercream frosting
Watermelon Sugar $5.50
Green sugar cookie topped with sour watermelon buttercream and mini chocolate chip "seeds"
Raspberry Tart $5.50
Shortbread cookie topped with tart raspberry buttercream
Lemon Meringue Pie $5.75
Shortbread cookie filled with lemon curd and topped with lightly torched meringue
Rolo Stuffed $5.75
Sugar cookie stuffed with rolos and topped with melted chocolate, caramel, and another rolo
Rocky Road $5.75
Our rich chocolate brownie-like cookie got an upgrade! We added marshmallows and almonds to the cookie, then topped it with marshmallow buttercream frosting, a swirl of chocolate fudge, mini marshmallows, and sliced almonds
Blueberry Oat $5.50
Oatmeal cookie with blueberries and white chocolate chips, drizzled with white chocolate
Pumpkin $5.50
Pumpkin cookie with mini white chocolate chips, rolled in cinnamon sugar, then topped with cream cheese frosting and a sprinkle of pumpkin spice
Cotton Candy $5.50
Sugar cookie topped with blue and pink swirled buttercream, cotton candy sprinkles, and a puff of cotton candy
Mint Oreo $5.75
Peppermint cookie with mint fudge chips, mint oreos, and chocolate chips. Topped with melted chocolate and more mint fudge chips, mint oreos, and Andes chocolate mint candies
Puppy Chow $5.50
Chocolate chip & Reese's peanut butter chip cookie, topped with chocolate peanut butter topping and housemade puppy chow (muddy buddies)
Stuffed Strawberry Cheesecake $5.75
Strawberry cookie filled with cheesecake filling, topped with strawberry cream cheese frosting and crushed freeze-dried strawberries
Blueberry Shortcake $5.50
Blueberry base cookie with vanilla buttercream & a blueberry crunch topping!
Stuffed Twix $5.75
Sugar cookie stuffed with a whole twix bar, then topped with chocolate, caramel, and a piece of twix
Turtle $5.50
Brown sugar base cookie topped with toasted pecans, melted chocolate & caramel drizzle!
Chocolate Caramel Marshmallow $5.50
Rich chocolate cookie topped with marshmallow buttercream and drizzled with salted caramel
Lemon Frosted Shortbread $5.25
Plain shortbread cookie topped with tart lemon buttercream and a slice of lemon candy
Cookie Butter $5.50
Made with biscoff cookies and mini white chocolate chips. Topped with house-made biscoff cookie butter and a piece of biscoff cookie
Cookie Of The Day $5.75
Feeling adventurous? Trust us, this will be delicious no matter the day. If you really *need* to know, give us a call and we'll let you in on the secret
Deep Dish Chocolate Chip $5.50
Extra tall chocolate chip cookie topped with extra semi-sweet chocolate chips
Fruity Pebbles $5.50
Brown sugar cookie jam packed with fruity pebbles cereal, topped with vanilla buttercream and more fruity pebbles cereal
Cinnamon Toast Crunch $5.50
Snickerdoodle cookie topped with cinnamon toast crunch spread and cinnamon toast crunch cereal
Dirt Cake $5.75
Our rich, brownie-like chocolate cookie filled with chocolate pastry cream and topped with Oreo crumbs and gummy worms
Banana Cream Pie $5.50
Banana & Nilla wafer cookie topped with banana buttercream and a nilla wafer
Ultimate Oreo $5.75
Oreo cookie dough made with whole oreo cookies, stuffed with a whole oreo. Topped with oreo buttercream and oreo pieces
Stuffed Grinch $5.75
Green sugar cookie stuffed with a holiday (red center) oreo to represent the Grinch's heart. Frosted with almond-flavored buttercream and topped with a heart sprinkle
Peeps Sugar $5.50
Sugar cookie topped with vanilla buttercream and a whole peep marshmallow
Key Lime Pie $5.50
Deep dish graham cracker cookie filled with tart lime filling and topped with a tiny swirl of vanilla buttercream
Stuffed Buckeye $5.75
Brownie base chocolate cookie stuffed with a housemade peanut butter fudge & topped with melted chocolate, Reese's sauce & a Reese's peanut butter cup!
White Chocolate Caramel Pretzel $5.50
Brown sugar cookie dough with pretzel pieces and mini white chocolate chips. Drizzled with salted caramel and white chocolate, then topped with more mini white chocolate chips
Stuffed Lucky Charms $5.75
Sugar cookie stuffed with colored marshmallows, then topped with vanilla buttercream and lucky charms marshmallows
Tiramisu $5.75
Espresso cookie topped with mascarpone buttercream and a sprinkle of cocoa powder
Salted Caramel Cheesecake $5.50
Graham cracker cookie topped with cheesecake frosting and drizzled with salted caramel
Lemon Blueberry $5.50
Shortbread cookie topped with tart lemon & blueberry buttercream
Brown Butter Deep Dish Nutella $5.75
Deep dish salty brown butter chocolate chip cookie filled with nutella
Red Velvet $5.50
Red velvet cookie with mini white chocolate chips, topped with cream cheese frosting
Boston Cream $5.50
Shortbread cookie topped with vanilla custard and chocolate
M&M $5.50
Brown sugar cookie with m&m's candies, drizzled with chocolate and topped with more m&m's
Brown Butter Sea Salt $5.75
Brown butter chocolate chip cookie with sea salt sprinkled on top
Stuffed Golden Oreo Funfetti $5.75
Cake batter flavored funfetti cookie stuffed with a whole golden oreo and topped with vanilla buttercream and sprinkles
Cosmic Brownie $5.50
Rich chocolate brownie cookie topped with chocolate ganache and mini rainbow chocolate chips
Cherry Limeade $5.50
Plain shortbread cookie topped with tart cherry limeade buttercream and gummy candy cherries
S'mores $5.50
Graham cookie base topped with melted chocolate, mini toasty marshmallows & graham cracker crumble!
Oreo $5.50
Oreo cookie dough made with whole oreo cookies, vanilla buttercream, topped with half an oreo and crushed oreos
Espresso Brown Butter Toffee $5.75
Brown butter espresso cookie with toffee bits, topped with espresso buttercream and housemade toffee
White Chocolate Peppermint $5.50
Sugar cookie base with mini white chocolate chips and peppermint bits, topped with peppermint buttercream and peppermint bark, more peppermint bits, and a peppermint candy
Reese's Pieces $5.50
Peanut butter cookie with Reese's peanut butter chips, topped with Reese's PB sauce and mini Reese's pieces candies
Hostess Cupcake $5.50
Rich chocolate cookie topped with marshmallow buttercream, chocolate ganache, and those iconic white chocolate hostess swirls
Lemon Ricotta $5.50
Made with freshly squeezed lemons and fresh ricotta cheese, this cookie is like a lemon cake and a cookie had a delicious baby! Topped with lemon buttercream
Cinnamon Caramel Apple $5.50
Snickerdoodle cookie topped with cinnamon apples and caramel
Kitchen Sink $5.50
This cookie has everything but the kitchen sink! Chocolate chips, pretzels, m&m's candies, and caramel bits inside, and potato chips, m&m's, and pretzels on top!
Peanut Butter Chocolate Swirl $5.50
Chocolate chip cookie with Reese's PB chips. Topped with chocolate buttercream and peanut butter buttercream swirled together and a mini Reese's cup
Hot Cocoa $5.50
Chocolate cookie with micro marshmallows, topped with marshmallow buttercream, more micro marshmallows, and a sprinkle of cocoa powder
Stuffed Oreo Butterfinger $5.75
Cookies and cream cookie with crushed butterfinger bars mixed into the dough and each cookie is stuffed with a whole oreo. Topped with oreo butterfinger buttercream and crushed oreos and butterfinger bars
Confetti $5.25
Sugar cookie topped with vanilla glaze and sprinkles
Stuffed Milky Way $5.75
Sugar cookie stuffed with a milky way candy bar and topped with caramel, melted chocolate, and more milky way
Party Animal $5.50
Pink cake batter flavor funfetti cookie topped with vanilla buttercream, sprinkles, and a frosted animal cookie

Sweetness Cookie Company Details

Service options
In-store pickup
Onsite services
Takeout

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Sweetness Cookie Company Photos

Sweetness Cookie Company Location

Sweetness Cookie Company

Illinois Kane County South Elgin Redington Drive

454 Redington Dr Suite D, South Elgin, IL 60177, USA

Sweetness Cookie Company Reviews

An average rating of ★4.9 from 122 user reviews.

cookiescinnamon rollspartycake popsdesignsbaby showergraduationmacaronsdeep dish cookieannoyed

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Just stopped in a few hours ago as Ive been meaning to check it out for a while now and HOLY COW are they delicious! Texas Sheet Cake is to dieeee for, prices are insanely cheap too for the size you get! They deserve every bit of appreciation for their amazing work!!!! The lady that came out seemed to be the owner and was very engaging with the customers and super friendly!
September 19 · Nina Stryszak
What a cool little spot. My daughter and I stopped in and you would of thought we were long time regulars. The staff was great the cookies were better. Get your tail in here!!!
May 28 · stephen taylor
We have been using Vanessa and Sweetness Cookie Company long before she was a brick and mortar store! Not only are her cookies super creative they are super delicious!!!!Our party guests always look forward to snagging one of her tasty treats! Her and her team really do wonderful things here! By the way… make sure to pick up a deep dish chocolate chip cookie….it will not disappoint!!!!
October 17 · loramyers1
After a different baker cancelled on me for my baby shower cookies with only a few weeks notice, I sent an email to some other bakeries in the area to see if anyone could possibly still do a custom order for that date. Vanessa from Sweetness got back to me so quickly, and asked the details of my order to see if she might be able to fit me in even though she was booked through October. She confirmed she could manage it & wanted to make sure I wasn’t left with nothing. We picked up the cookies this morning for our shower and they were BEAUTIFUL (not to mention delicious). Everyone at my shower was so impressed with them each guest took at least one home with them. The cookies were our gender reveal and it ended up being so cute & exactly what I wanted. I would recommend this bakery to anyone and everyone, and I am SO thankful that I happened to reach out to Vanessa in my time of need. Thank you Sweetness Cookie Company!!!
March 06 · Amanda
It’s hard not to visit sweetness every week to try the weeks new flavors! The cookies are well baked and the frosting is amazing. They rarely disappoint which is impressive with how many new flavors they produce. If you have a sweet tooth this place is a must try! But be careful because once you try it, you’ll probably be back!
September 21 · Milly