Tag's Bakery in Evanston, IL: Your Local Destination for Custom Cakes, Desserts, and the Legendary Florentine

Tag's Bakery Introduce

***

## Introduction / Overview: Tag's Bakery – A Local Evanston Institution

***

For residents of Illinois seeking a truly authentic, high-quality bakery experience, **Tag's Bakery** in Evanston stands out as a beloved local gem. More than just a simple shop, Tag's is a full-service **Bakery**, **Cake shop**, **Dessert shop**, and **Wedding bakery**, cementing its place as an essential stop for daily treats and major life celebrations alike. This women-owned establishment has built its reputation on a foundation of baking excellence, friendly service, and a clean, welcoming environment.

Tag's Bakery offers a comforting blend of classic favorites and seasonal delights, ensuring there's always something new to tempt the palate. While one side of the space is dedicated to the immaculate, well-stocked bakery display, the other half functions as a cozy café, providing a complete experience for both a quick visit and a lingering moment over coffee and a pastry. Their commitment to freshness means that their cakes and tortes are baked and assembled daily, guaranteeing a superior product whether you’re picking up a single treat or commissioning a custom centerpiece for a special event.

They cater to a diverse crowd, proudly identifying as **LGBTQ+ friendly**, and ensuring everyone feels welcome from the moment they step through the door. Whether you're a long-time Evanston local or just passing through the northern Illinois area, a visit to Tag's Bakery promises delicious rewards, especially if you’re seeking a reliable place for a **quick visit** to satisfy a sudden craving.

***

## Location and Accessibility in Evanston, IL

***

Tag's Bakery is conveniently located in Evanston, a vibrant community just north of Chicago, making it easily accessible for customers across the North Shore and the wider Illinois region. Its physical address is 2010 Central St, Evanston, IL 60201, USA. Central Street is a well-known thoroughfare, and the location provides a pleasant local shopping environment.

Accessibility is a key priority for the bakery, ensuring that all community members can enjoy their offerings. The premises feature a **Wheelchair accessible entrance**, making it easy for patrons with mobility needs to visit and shop in-store. This thoughtful approach to accessibility reflects the bakery's dedication to serving the entire local Illinois community.

***

## Services Offered

***

Tag's Bakery provides a range of services designed for maximum convenience and flexibility for their Illinois customers, whether they are planning a party or just grabbing breakfast on the go. These services include:

**Delivery:** For those who cannot make it to the store or are hosting an event, delivery options are available to bring the freshest baked goods right to your door.
**In-store shopping:** The classic experience of browsing the beautiful display cases and making selections in person, often complemented by a greeting and excellent service from the friendly staff.
**Takeout:** Perfect for a **quick visit**, allowing customers to pick up their orders or impulsive purchases easily and be on their way.
**Custom Cake Orders:** They specialize in creating bespoke cakes for special occasions, with a variety of fillings and icings to please any palate.
**Wedding Bakery Services:** Providing specialized cakes and desserts for one of the most important days in a couple's life.
**Coffee Service:** Offering a selection of **coffee** to pair perfectly with their wide variety of baked goods, available for in-store enjoyment or takeout.
**Breakfast Dining:** Providing **Breakfast** options, including classic items and savory choices like **Quiche**.
**“ESSENTIALS” Bakery Menu:** A dedicated menu for easy ordering and pick-up of staple items like Bread, Croissants, Donuts, Cookies, and Cakes.

***

## Features / Highlights

***

What truly sets Tag's Bakery apart for Illinois residents is the quality and breadth of their product line, combined with their commitment to a positive customer experience. From signature items to seasonal specials, the highlights are numerous:

**The Legendary Florentines:** Known as their signature item for over 50 years, these baked confections are originally from Vienna. They are made from honey, butter, sugar, and sliced almonds, topped with candied cherry, and coated underneath with chocolate. Many customers proclaim these to be the "best ever" Florentines.
**Extensive Cake and Torte Selection:** Their selection is impressive and includes a range of classics and unique flavors such as **Black Forest Torte**, **Caramel Macchiato Torte**, **Red Velvet Torte**, **Lemon Torte**, and **Sacher Torte**. They also offer individual **Cake Slices** like **Marzipan Cake Slice** and **German Chocolate Cake Slice**.
**Seasonal and Holiday Specials:** The bakery expertly capitalizes on holiday fun, as seen with their Halloween-themed offerings like **Spider Web Pumpkin Donut**, **Vampire Donut**, **Monster Cupcakes**, and **Halloween Drip Cakes** featuring playful ghosts. Seasonal **Pies** like **Mince Pie**, **Pecan Pie**, and **Pumpkin Pie** are also major draws.
**Diverse Breakfast Offerings:** Catering to morning commuters and local residents, their selection includes **Coffee Cake Strips**, various **Donuts**, **Individual Danish**, **Muffins**, **Croissants**, and specialty items like **Gourmet Cinnamon Buns** (available Saturdays).
**Fresh Bread and Rolls:** They offer a variety of **Breads** and **Rolls**, including **Pullman Loaves**.
**Creative Cupcakes and Desserts:** The selection of individual treats is vast, including favorites like **Red Velvet Cupcake**, **Tiramisu Cupcake**, and unique desserts like **Caracas**, **Midnight Rose**, and the seasonal **Small Coconut Bunny Pastry**.
**Sweet Savory Mix:** The menu isn't limited to sweets, offering savory items like their full **Quiche** and **8" Quiche** (order only), providing a full meal option.
**Clean and Welcoming Environment:** Customers consistently praise both the bakery and the café side for being very clean and spacious, creating a comfortable space to enjoy their treats.

***

## Contact Information

***

If you're in Illinois and ready to place a specialty order or simply inquire about their daily selections, here is the essential contact information for Tag's Bakery:

**Address:** 2010 Central St, Evanston, IL 60201, USA
**Phone:** (847) 328-1200
**Mobile Phone:** +1 847-328-1200
**Payments Accepted:** For ease of purchase, they accept a variety of payment methods including **Checks**, **Credit cards**, **Debit cards**, and **NFC mobile payments**.

***

## What Is Worth Choosing Tag's Bakery

***

For Illinois locals, especially those near the Evanston area, choosing **Tag's Bakery** is choosing a tradition of quality and community. It is a one-stop destination for virtually all baked goods and dessert needs. The distinct separation into a bakery space and a café space offers flexibility—you can grab a classic **Smiley Face Cookie** for the road or sit down for a leisurely **breakfast**. The bakery’s reputation for having the best **Florentine** cookies on earth is reason enough for a visit, cementing its status as a destination for this specific, highly-praised confection.

The vast and often seasonal product selection, from full **Tortes** and custom **Cakes** to simple **Brownies** and a variety of **Donuts**, means that both everyday cravings and special occasion requirements are met with exceptional freshness. The fact that the business is **women-owned** and **LGBTQ+ friendly** also speaks to its role as an inclusive and positive force within the local community. While the café side has a limited menu, the **bakery side** is widely acknowledged for its immaculate presentation and the sheer quality of its products. Ultimately, Tag's Bakery provides the kind of reliable, high-quality, and friendly service that makes a local business a true favorite for the Illinois residents it serves.

Tag's Bakery Display case

DONUTS
Spider Web Pumpkin Donut $1.60
Devilishly good pumpkin donut, dipped in orange colored icing and etched with a sugary glaze spider web
Spider Web Buttermilk Donut $1.60
Lucious buttermilk donut, dipped in green colored icing and etched with a sugary glaze spider web
Vampire Donut $1.75
Our tasty donut, coated in white icing, buttercream eyes, and completed with a set of vampire teeth

HALLOWEEN DRIP CAKES
Playful ghosts and colorful rosettes atop, three layers of our delectable cake, iced in colored buttercream and covered black colored chocolate drippings
6" Yellow Cake $28.95
Yellow cake, filled with lemon filling and iced in orange colored buttercream
6" Chocolate Cake $28.95
Chocolate cake filled with raspberry preserve and iced in purple colored buttercream

PASTRIES
Monster Cupcakes $3.99
Chocolate or yellow jumbo cupcake capped with swirls of brightly colored buttercream and adorned with eyes made of chocolate
Cauldron Cake Pops $2.49
Chocolate cake dipped in chocolate, candy eyes and skeleton bones swimming in a flaming cauldron of bubbling green buttercream
Coffin Cakes $3.50
Coffin shaped devil’s food cake, enrobed in dark chocolate, topped with chocolate French buttercream, sprinkled with Oreo crumbs and creepy graveyard visitors
Ghost Cups $3.49
Yellow cake, buttercream topping, dipped in white chocolate with a spooky face
Mummy Rice Krispy Treat $2.25
Rice Krispy treat with just the right amount of marshmallow gooey-ness, “wrapped” with white chocolate drizzle and completed with eyes of white and milk chocolate

ICED SUGAR COOKIES
Cats $1.99
Coffins $1.99
Ghosts $1.99
Jack O'Lantern $1.99
Witches Face $2.49

FLORENTINES
Our signature item for over 50 years! Originally from Vienna, a baked confection made from honey, butter, sugar, and sliced almonds. They are topped with a piece of candied cherry and coated underneath with chocolate. The Florentine recipe was gif...
.
Florentines

BREAKFAST ITEMS
Coffee Cake Strips
Almond, apple, apple strudel, apricot, blueberry, caramel loaf, caramel pecan loaf, cardamom, cheese, cheese with chocolate chips, cherry, cherry strudel, chocolate chip, cinnamon melt-away, open-faced apple, open-faced cherry, pecan, raisin, rasp...
Round Coffee Cakes
Almond ring, apple cinnamon, apricot-lemon, Bavarian twirl, butter ring, caramel pecan crunch, cherry cheese, pizza, raspberry-lemon, and streusel
Individual Danish $2.10
Almond, apple, apricot, blueberry, cheese, cherry, cinnamon, custard, pecan, plain, raisin, raspberry, raspberry swirl, and streusel
Donuts
Apple fritter, buttermilk, chocolate long john, chocolate, cider, cinnamon sugar twist, cinnamon twirl, coconut, custard Bismarck, double chocolate, glazed long john, glazed, plain, powdered sugar, raspberry Bismarck, and sprinkle
Donut Holes $6.00
Plain, cinnamon, powdered sugar, chocolate dipped and glazed dipped
Muffins $2.25
Apple, blueberry, cherry-almond, chocolate, chocolate-chocolate chip, chocolate chip, cranberry, lemon poppy-seed, morning glory (carrot), and pumpkin (seasonal)
Quick Breads $8.40
Apple, carrot, cranberry, lemon, lemon poppy-seed, plain, and pumpkin (seasonal)
Cinnamon Crimp
Cinnamon swirl bread rolled in cinnamon sugar with or without raisins
Cinnamon scone, $2.80
Harvest Scone $2.80
Biscuit like pastry packed with dried apricot, dried cranberries, raisins and covered with sugary glaze
Croissant $3.09
Light, buttery and flakey
Gourmet Cinnamon Buns (Saturdays) $3.95
Rolled dough spread with a sweet cinnamon mixture and iced in glaze
Mini Pecan Rolls $14.40
Bite sized cinnamon roll, coated in caramel, and topped with pecans
Quiche $18.50
Ham and Cheese Our flaky pie crust filled with a savory egg custard, loaded with ham and cheddar cheese Spinach & Mushroom Quiche Our flaky pie crust filled with a savory egg custard, loaded with spinach, mushrooms and cheddar cheese

BUNDT CAKES
Philly Fluff $12.75
butter and cream cheese pound cake dusted with powdered sugar
Cinnamon Crumb $12.75
yellow cream cake swirled and finished with cinnamon crumble topping
Louisiana Crunch $12.75
yellow cake coated with toasted coconut and a white glaze

WHAT NOTS
Brownies $1.40
Decadent chocolate-y, cake-y brownie frosted with scrumptious fudge icing
Cobbler
sugar cookie crust, filled with blueberry, cherry, apple or peach with a lattice sugar cookie top
Crunch Cup $2.50
Fluffy yellow cake encrusted with toasted coconut and ensconced in a sugary glaze
French Raisin Roll $4.40
Scratch-made custard rolled into croissant dough, sprinkled with raisins with icing or plain
Kolacky $2.10
Puffy pastry made with sour cream generously topped with assorted fruit fillings or sweetened cream cheese and lightly sprinkled with powdered sugar
Palmier $2.80
Light, crunchy, buttery pastry made from thin layers of flakey puff pastry, shaped into a palm leaf, and sprinkled with sugar
Pinwheel $3.40
Thin layers of buttery puff pastry, shaped like pinwheel, and the edges are dipped in rich dark chocolate
Pop Tart $2.80
Flakey pastry pocket filled with raspberry preserve, and then frosted with sweet sugar icing
Swedish Pretzel
Puff pastry twisted with cookie dough, showered with crystallized sugar and your choice of toasted almonds or plain
Turnover $2.80
Buttery puff pastry brimming with apple or cherry pie filling and drizzled with sugary icing
Upside Down Cup $3.99
Buttery cake that gets baked on top of a layer of pineapple slices and cherries in a brown sugar-butter mixture, and when it gets flipped over after baking, the sweet syrup infuses the pineapple upside down cake with extra flavor.

COOKIES
Butter Cookies $21.95
Wide variety of bite sized, handmade butter cookies, from the simple butter cookie to butter cookies infused with almond paste. Vast assortment of toppings and fillings that vary with the season
Smiley Face Cookie $2.29
A customer favorite! Our sugar cookie dipped in yellow colored white chocolate with a yummy fudge smiley face
Iced Sugar Cookies
Sweet sugar cookie dipped in colored chocolate and artistically decorated that vary with the season from sports to animals, and most things in between. Contact us to customize our cookie for your special occasion!
Almond Macarons $21.95
Our recipe has been around for generations, made from almond paste, egg whites and sugar
French Macarons $2.49
meringue-based cookie made with almond flour, egg whites, and sugar, then filled with buttercream. Flavors vary with the season
Large Cookies $1.70
Chocolate chip, M&M, oatmeal raisin, rainbow sprinkle and peanut butter

CUPCAKES
Yellow or Chocolate Cupcakes $1.89
Yellow or chocolate cake iced with vanilla buttercream or fudge
Red Velvet Cupcake $2.69
red velvet cake, cream cheese iced and decorated with a red rosebud.
Tiramisu Cupcake $2.69
chocolate cupcake, tiramisu buttercream iced and dusted with cocoa powder
Mint Chocolate Chip Cupcake $2.69
yellow cake with chocolate chips, mint buttercream iced and sprinkled with mini chocolate chips
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cupcake $2.69
Creamy peanut butter blended with chocolate buttercream atop a chocolate cupcake
Chocolate Chocolate Chip Cupcake $2.69
chocolate pudding cake with chocolate chips, fudge iced and sprinkled with mini chocolate chips
German Chocolate Cupcake $2.69
chocolate pudding cake, German custard with pecans and coconut, mini chocolate sprinkles around the perimeter and finished with a dollop of fudge icing

INDIVIDUAL DESSERTS
Cake Pops
chocolate or vanilla cake with decorations that vary thru the year
Cake Shots
Assortment of cakes and fillings in a shot glass complete with a mini spoon
Caracas $6.39
Mocha buttercream between layers of delicate chocolate soufflé cake that is spritzed with coffee liqueur, finished with chocolate glaze and chocolate covered mocha beans
Chocolate Éclair $3.99
Light and airy éclair shell filled with scratch-made custard and topped with chocolate icing
Fudge Cup $3.39
Vanilla buttercream sandwiched between yellow cake and iced in fudge
Fudge Square $4.99
Chocolate soufflé cake filled with chocolate French buttercream, rolled in chocolate sprinkles, capped with fudge icing, and a chocolate diamond
Midnight Rose $4.99
Chocolate soufflé cake lined with a thin layer of ganache and chocolate buttercream, dipped in chocolate, topped with French buttercream, and a fudge rose

CAKE SLICES
Carrot Cake Slice $4.99
Walnuts, carrots, apples, and raisins join flavorful carrot cake, filled with cream cheese and iced with French buttercream
Chocolate Glaze Cake Slice $4.99
Chocolate soufflé cake filled with French buttercream and enveloped in chocolate glaze
French Vanilla Cake Slice $4.95
Light yellow soufflé cake with French buttercream filling and icing
German Chocolate Cake Slice $4.99
alternating layers of coconut-pecan filling and fudge between layers of delicate chocolate soufflé, iced with fudge, and topped with coconut-pecan filling
Lemon Cake Slice $4.99
yellow soufflé cake filled with lemon curd and iced in lemon French buttercream
Marzipan Cake Slice $4.99
yellow soufflé cake filled with Bavarian cream and covered in marzipan
Raspberry Cake Slice $4.99
Yellow soufflé cake lined with raspberry preserve on top of a thin layer of vanilla buttercream, iced in raspberry French buttercream
Red Velvet Cake Slice $4.99
Rich red velvet cake, with silky cream cheese filling and iced with French buttercream

PIES
Fruit Pies with Double Crust
Apple, Blueberry, Cherry, Peach
Fruit Pies with Dutch Crust (fruit pie topped with streusel)
Cream Pies
Banana Cream, Coconut Cream, Boston Cream, Key Lime, Lemon Meringue,
French Silk $17.50

SEASONAL PIES
Mince Pie
Pecan Pie
Pumpkin Pie
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
Taffy Apple Pie
Apple pie topped with buttery streusel and drizzled with carmel

BREADS & ROLLS
Breads
Pullman Loaves
Rolls

TORTES
Black Forest Torte
Chocolate cake with cherry filling, whip cream icing, chocolate shavings on the side, & topped with almond & maraschino cherries
Caramel Macchiato Torte
Yellow cake, filled & iced with coffee whip cream, and caramel poured over the top.
Chocolate Lace Torte
Devil's food cake, French buttercream filling, iced with ganache, white chocolate lace encircle the sides & fresh fruit garnish,
Dobosh Torte
Six layers of yellow cake, chocolate buttercream filling, iced with fudge or ganache, crowned with fudge adornments.
Florentine Torte
Yellow Cake, Florentine French buttercream, coated in ganache icing with Florentine garnish.
Lemon Torte
Yellow cake, lemon curd filling, lemon buttercream icing, with an array of yellow rosebuds.
Oreo Torte
Chocolate cake with Oreo buttercream filling, vanilla buttercream icing, garnished with Oreo cookies.
Raspberry Mousse Torte
Yellow cake with raspberry mousse filling and icing, seasonal decor.
Red Velvet Torte
Red Velvet cake with cream cheese filling and icing with a single red rose and red velvet crumbs on the side.
Sacher Torte
Chocolate cake with a raspberry preserve filling, iced in ganache, embossed with white roses.
Tiramisu Torte
Yellow cake, sprinkled with a coffee liquor simple syrup, filled and iced with a light Italian coffee mousse, lightly dusted with cocoa powder and trimmed with whip cream rosettes & mocha beans.

CAKES
Our cakes and tortes are baked and assembled fresh daily. We have a variety of fillings and icings to please any palate. Choose from our cakes in store or customize a cake for your special occasion.
.

HOURS - Effective April 2020
.
Regular Hours
Holiday (Easter Week)

"ESSENTIALS" BAKERY MENU
FOR ORDER AND PICK UP.
Bread
Croissants
Filled Croissants
French Raisin Rolls
Donuts
Danish
Muffins
Coffee Cakes
LIMITED KINDS AND FLAVORS AVAILABLE FOR PICKUP. CUSTOM KINDS TO ORDER ONLY---CALL AND CHECK WITH SALES CLERK.
Smile Cookies
Large Cookies
Pie Slices
Packed in individual plastic containers.
Florentines
Assorted Butter Cookies (Limited Variety)
Bundt Cakes
Cupcakes (Regular Size)
Extra Large "Treat Yo-Self" Cupcakes
Individual Desserts & Pastries
Swedish Pretzels
Hot Cross Buns
Pop Tarts *AVAILABLE ONLY ON TUESDAY*
Gourmet Cinnamon Buns *FOR ORDER ONLY*
Cakes
8" Quiche *ORDER ONLY*
Small Coconut Bunny Pastry $4.79
Yellow cake, white buttercream icing, covered in coconut with a bunny face and a fluffy pink tail. FOR ORDER. LIMITED AMOUNTS AVAILABLE FOR PICK-UP.
Small Cake Egg Pastry $4.79
Yellow cake, buttercream filling, dipped in chocolate and decorated with tulips. FOR ORDER. LIMITED AMOUNTS AVAILABLE FOR PICK-UP.
Lop-Eared Bunny Cake 6" $37.95
Bavarian cream between layers of yellow cake and iced in white buttercream decorated with a buttercream face, complete with paws, a fluffy tail and topped with fondant floppy ears. FOR ORDER. LIMITED AMOUNTS AVAILABLE FOR PICK-UP.
Cookies
FOR ORDER. LIMITED AMOUNTS AVAILABLE FOR PICK-UP.
Cupcakes
FOR ORDER. LIMITED AMOUNTS AVAILABLE FOR PICK-UP.
Lamb Cake $31.95
Light textured yellow cream cake finished with vanilla buttercream, coconut buttercream or chocolate fudge icing. FOR ORDER. LIMITED AMOUNTS AVAILABLE FOR PICK-UP.
Almond & Coconut Macaroons
April 2020
8" Flourless Chocolate Cakes

Tag's Bakery Details

From the business
Identifies as women-owned

Service options
Delivery
In-store shopping
Takeout
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Crowd
LGBTQ+ friendly

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Checks
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Tag's Bakery Photos

Tag's Bakery Location

Tag's Bakery

Illinois Cook County Evanston Central Street

2010 Central St, Evanston, IL 60201, USA

Tag's Bakery Reviews

An average rating of ★4.3 from 105 user reviews.

florentinecookiescafepricescherryalmondsraspberrycoffee cakesmiley cookiebridal shower

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Incredible bakery you must go visit! Half of the location is a bit green and the other half is a café. When I walked in, I was greeted with the smile and excellent service. I let them know. This is my first time visiting. They suggested a few of their most popular treats I picked up a few cookies to try And the friendly woman behind the counter, offered me a complementary cookie on the house. Not only was the service, great, and the cookies were delicious, but the interior space was immaculate. I will definitely come back and will recommend this location to any of my fellow Bakery lovers, thank you
April 04 · Benjamin
This place is two stores back-to-back. The bakery is one side and it is home to the best ever Florentine cookies on earth. I also purchased 2 danish which were very fresh but a tad skimpy on the cherry filling and pecans.The second store is the cafe. The menu is limited and many of the dishes seem to have a lot going on in them so if you are in search of something simple, you probably won’t find it. I chose the basic breakfast sandwich. This was an egg “patty” with your choice of bread, meat and cheese. For as amazing as the bakery is, this sandwich was not very good and it was all because of the rubbery egg patty.That being said, the staff on both sides weren’t very friendly and just tolerated the customers. The cafe is a very cute space. Both are very clean And spacious.Definitely worth returning for the bakery but I will pass on the cafe.
April 01 · Donna Crocker
Came here for the Florentine Biscuit/Cookie and it was delectable! Each cookie is about the size of an Oreo. They charge by weight, but each cost about $0.61 with tax.Florentine cookies are toasted almonds covered in caramel with a small dried cherry covered with hard caramel with one side smeared in milk chocolate.They do them well here! Service was prompt and courteous. I have not tried anything else here, but the rest of the sweets look promising!
May 04 · George Zakharia
Tag’s is a wonderful family owned bakery with fun, delicious treats. The holiday themed baked goods are clever and scrumptious, and the cakes are always fantastic.
November 27 · chelsea brown
It was our first time needing to order a cake since living in Evanston and we live near Central St so we wanted to support local. It felt like a risk ordering a cake for 50 people without ever having their cake before but it did not disappoint! Everyone wanted to know where we got our cake from.Our party was Sunday so I picked up Saturday since they’re closed Sunday and it stayed perfect.I brought in a picture of a cake I saw online elsewhere and they were able to recreate it perfectly.I will say we got the 14” round for 50 people, but we had quite a bit left over even with just about everyone having a piece.
August 02 · Christine M Savas