The Better Crumb (Pre-Order Pick up & Delivery only) Introduce
For many New Yorkers, the search for a truly special, personalized dessert for a celebration often leads them to a local artisan. The Better Crumb, a pre-order and delivery-only bakery run by owner Pauline, has established itself as just such a gem in New York City. This article provides a detailed overview of what makes this bakery a go-to for locals who want to add a touch of beautiful, custom-made deliciousness to their events. With a focus on stunning designs and exceptional customer service, The Better Crumb has earned a reputation for creating memorable moments through its delectable creations.
The Better Crumb operates on a modern, customer-centric model, moving away from a traditional storefront to focus on a more personalized experience. This approach allows Pauline to dedicate her full attention to each order, ensuring every cake and cookie is crafted with meticulous care and attention to detail. This is not a place for mass-produced goods, but rather for bespoke creations that are tailored to the customer's specific vision. The bakery's specialization in custom cupcakes and cookies is a testament to this, with a focus on both visual artistry and fantastic flavor. As one customer noted, their Piped Flower cupcakes not only looked "AMAZING" but also tasted "SO GOOD," a perfect combination for any special event.
The owner, Pauline, is a central figure in the bakery's success. She is consistently praised in reviews for her responsiveness, kindness, and willingness to work closely with customers. Her ability to take a request—even a last-minute one—and turn it into a perfect product is a significant highlight. One customer, who ordered mini cupcakes for a son's birthday, appreciated not only the delicious taste but also Pauline's kind demeanor. The cakes were so well done that the teacher remarked they looked "natural and 'real,'" a clear sign that they were a step above typical supermarket fare. This personal connection and professional pride are what transform a simple transaction into a delightful and memorable experience.
Another key feature that makes The Better Crumb so appealing to locals is its flexibility and excellent pricing. For custom orders, many bakeries in the city have strict minimums or long lead times, which can be challenging for people with smaller events or last-minute needs. A customer who ordered custom birthday cookies was thrilled that Pauline was the only baker to respond quickly and could accommodate the order on time, without a minimum requirement. The fact that the cookies were also beautifully done with luxurious royal icing and excellent packaging, all at an "excellent" price point, is a testament to the value and quality offered by The Better Crumb. This combination of speed, quality, and affordability is a rare find in the bustling New York City market.
In conclusion, The Better Crumb has successfully carved out its niche by providing a personalized, high-quality, and reliable service. The rave reviews for both the taste and presentation of their products, combined with the professional and considerate nature of the owner, make it an ideal choice for anyone in New York looking for a dessert that will truly impress. The focus on pre-orders and delivery means a seamless, convenient experience for a city always on the go.
Location and Accessibility
The Better Crumb operates on a pre-order, pickup, and delivery-only model, with an address at 360 1st Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA. This location is in the Gramercy Park area of Manhattan, a vibrant and well-connected neighborhood. The business model means that customers are not visiting a traditional retail storefront. Instead, they pre-order online or via email and then arrange for a designated pickup or delivery.
For those choosing the pickup option, the location is very accessible. It is near several major public transit options. The L train at 1st Avenue and 14th Street is within walking distance, as are the 4, 5, 6, N, Q, R, and W trains at Union Square-14th Street. Additionally, numerous bus lines run along 1st Avenue and nearby streets. This makes the pickup process very convenient for a wide range of New Yorkers. The delivery service, which is also a major part of the business, provides an even greater level of accessibility, bringing the custom-baked goods directly to the customer's home or event venue. This flexibility is a huge advantage in a city where convenience is highly valued.
Services Offered
Custom Cupcakes: Specializing in beautiful, custom-designed cupcakes, including the highly-praised Piped Flower variety, for baby showers, birthdays, and other events.
Custom Decorated Cookies: The bakery creates custom cookies with luxurious royal icing, perfect for party favors, gifts, or special occasions, with no minimum order required.
Personalized Service: The owner, Pauline, works directly with clients to understand their vision and create unique, customized products that match their themes and requests.
Pre-Order System: All orders are made in advance, ensuring that each product is fresh and made specifically for the customer's event.
Delivery and Pickup: Customers have the option to have their orders delivered directly to them or to pick them up from the designated location, providing maximum convenience.
Features and Highlights
Exceptional Customer Service: The owner, Pauline, is noted for her responsiveness, kindness, and willingness to work with customer requests, even on last-minute orders.
Stunning Visual Design: The baked goods are praised for their intricate, beautiful designs, which make them perfect for the centerpiece of any celebration.
High-Quality Taste: Beyond the aesthetics, the products are consistently reviewed as being delicious, with a fresh, homestyle flavor.
No Minimum Order: Unlike many custom bakeries, The Better Crumb does not require a minimum order, making it an excellent choice for smaller events or personal treats.
Convenient Business Model: The pre-order, pickup, and delivery system is perfect for the busy New York lifestyle, saving customers time and effort.
Contact Information
Address: 360 1st Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA
Phone: (917) 382-0974
Conclusion: Why this place is suitable for locals
The Better Crumb is perfectly suited for New Yorkers because it offers a highly personalized and convenient service that is a rare find in such a large city. For a local planning a special event, the ability to work directly with a dedicated baker like Pauline to create a unique, beautiful, and delicious dessert is invaluable. The bakery's focus on quality and artistry, from the intricate piped flowers on a cupcake to the luxurious royal icing on a custom cookie, ensures that the end product is a showstopper.
The flexible business model is a major advantage for the busy New York lifestyle. The pre-order system, combined with delivery and pickup options, eliminates the need to stand in line at a traditional bakery. This saves time and provides peace of mind, knowing that a perfect dessert will be ready when you need it. The fact that the bakery is willing to accommodate smaller orders and last-minute requests, all while maintaining excellent pricing and quality, makes it a trusted and reliable resource for the community. The Better Crumb is more than just a bakery; it is a partner in celebration, making every event a little more special with its thoughtful, delicious, and beautiful creations, which is exactly what a New Yorker looks for in a local business.
The Better Crumb (Pre-Order Pick up & Delivery only) Cake
Cakes, Cupcakes, Cookies, Pies
- Cakes US$65.00
Birthday Cakes, Smash Cakes, Custom Cakes
- Cupcakes
Birthday Cupcakes, Wedding Cupcakes, Floral Cupcakes
- Pies US$45.00
Seasonal Pies
- Cookies US$36.00
Cookies, Custom Decorated Sugar Cookies
The Better Crumb (Pre-Order Pick up & Delivery only) Details
From the business
- Identifies as women-owned
Service options
- Delivery
Dining options
- Dessert
Planning
- Appointment required
The Better Crumb (Pre-Order Pick up & Delivery only) Photos










The Better Crumb (Pre-Order Pick up & Delivery only) Location
The Better Crumb (Pre-Order Pick up & Delivery only)
360 1st Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA
The Better Crumb (Pre-Order Pick up & Delivery only) Reviews
ingredientscupcakeschocolate chipdozenbirthdaygift
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1The Piped Flower cupcakes were def the WOW of my babyshower. Not only they look AMAZING, they taste SO GOOD! Pauline is very responsive, considerate and willing to work with my blue theme request. I highly recommend these cupcakes to anyone who wants beautiful deliciousness to make lovely memories ~
July 02 · Ning DingMy mouth dropped when I saw my beautiful custom birthday cookies! I grinned the whole walk to the train. They were very well done in luxurious royal icing, and they were wrapped nicely with a cohesive-colored ribbon. Out of all the bakeries I emailed about custom cookies, Pauline was the only one who responded quickly to confirm she could do them on time, and her pricing was excellent. She also didn't require a minimum order, and I only needed a dozen. They were ready right on time and perfectly packaged for the long trip home. I can't wait for my guests to see and taste these, and I will certainly be ordering again.
March 11 · Anna Laura BarilettiAn exceptional experience! As a first time customer I placed an online order, shortly after normal business hours for chocolate chip cookies. I provided the delivery address. To my surprise I received a confirmation email not long after I placed my order and asking if an 11am delivery that next morning would be acceptable. I said yes, and at 10:58am the cookies were delivered. They were delicious! Great service, delicious product!
March 25 · David SchmidtThese are honestly the best cookies I have ever had and everyone that has tried them agrees. I’m partial to the chocolate chip but they are all great, the high quality of the ingredients and the care placed in preparation is what really makes these shine. I’ve eaten a lot of cookies in my life and nothing else at any price point compares, these are rich, substantial and incredibly good. I guarantee you will become a “regular” like me after you try a box and they always arrive ultra fresh!
March 01 · Paul LoussiaThis bakery feels out of place in New York City, in a lovely way. It’s very personal, like something you’d see in a small town, where someone sells baked items out of their home. At the same time, the experience was very professional from start to finish, from the ordering experience on the website to the nice pastry box the cookies came in. I got the macadamia nut cookies and they were fantastic. Generous amounts of white chocolate and macadamia nuts, and the cookies here are made to order so they smelled incredible, literally a few minutes out of the oven. I’d order from here again, I’m curious about a few of their other items. Seems like this would also be a nice gift for a lover of baked goods.
April 05 · Xavier Aguilar
More Bakery Near Me
Tal Bagels4.0 (528 reviews)357 1st Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA
Ess-a-Bagel4.0 (1013 reviews)324 1st Ave, New York, NY 10009, USA
The Oasis Cafe0.0 (0 reviews)362 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA
Black Star Bakery&Cafe4.0 (158 reviews)241 E 24th St, New York, NY 10010, USA
David's Bagels4.0 (422 reviews)273 1st Ave, New York, NY 10003, USA
Pick A Bagel on 23rd street3.0 (249 reviews)210 E 23rd St, New York, NY 10010, USA
Bread Story4.0 (306 reviews)264 1st Ave, New York, NY 10009, USA
Gotta Getta Bagel4.0 (404 reviews)263 1st Ave, New York, NY 10003, USA
Gramercy Bagels4.0 (388 reviews)246 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA
Cinnabon0.0 (0 reviews)430 E 14th St, New York, NY 10009, USA
Bagel Express III3.0 (235 reviews)340 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA
Petit Chou4.0 (406 reviews)229 1st Ave, New York, NY 10003, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
JJ Bakery - Rowland Heights4.0 (288 reviews)
Jackie's Family Bakery4.0 (52 reviews)
Greek Habits By Eva5.0 (34 reviews)
OK Donuts4.0 (151 reviews)
Amore Italian Market and Bakery4.0 (986 reviews)
Bagelicious4.0 (221 reviews)Top Bakery Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Make the Best Homemade Biscuit Gravy
How to Make Homemade Hot Cross Buns for Easter | Delicious Recipe Guide
The Best Baking Equipment You Need for Your Home Kitchen
How to Make the Best Homemade Brioche: Step-by-Step Tips for U.S. Bakers
How to Make the Best Strawberry Cream Cheese Danish
How to Make the Best Homemade Strawberry Shortcake
