The Cakery Introduce
In the heart of Elmira, New York, there’s a culinary gem that has quietly but surely carved out a special place in the community: **The Cakery**. Far more than just a place to buy a sweet treat, The Cakery is a testament to passion, freshness, and a warm, inviting atmosphere. This local establishment, known for its truly exceptional custom cakes, also delights patrons with a surprisingly robust and delicious lunch menu, making it a multifaceted destination for food lovers across the Southern Tier.
At its core, The Cakery is a celebration of baking artistry. The owner, Lisa, pours her love for baking into every creation, and this dedication is evident in the stunning and unique specialty cakes that have become a hallmark of the business. These aren't just cakes; they are edible works of art, meticulously crafted to be both visually beautiful and incredibly delicious. For New Yorkers planning special events, from bridal showers to birthdays, The Cakery offers bespoke creations that truly make an impression.
Beyond the impressive world of custom cakes, The Cakery has also garnered a loyal following for its fresh and tasty lunch offerings. Imagine stepping into a cozy space, filled with the aroma of freshly baked goods, and settling down to enjoy a perfectly made Reuben sandwich, accompanied by a refreshingly zesty fresh lemonade. This commitment to fresh ingredients and flavorful combinations ensures that every lunch experience is as delightful as the desserts.
The ambiance at The Cakery is frequently praised by visitors, described as a "very comfy space" with a charming decor that often includes Big Band music, adding a touch of nostalgic elegance. This inviting environment, coupled with the friendly service provided by the staff, creates a truly pleasant escape from the everyday. It's the kind of local spot where you can unwind, enjoy a delicious meal, and feel genuinely welcomed – a true asset to the Elmira community.
What truly sets The Cakery apart is its identity as a **woman-owned business**. This aspect resonates deeply with many patrons, adding an extra layer of appreciation for the dedication and hard work that goes into running such a successful and beloved establishment. The personal touch and evident passion of the owner, Lisa, shine through in every aspect of the business, from the quality of the food to the warm customer interactions.
For those in New York seeking a reliable caterer for events, The Cakery's reputation for delicious food extends beyond its cakes. Dishes like their chicken salad and quiche have received rave reviews, proving that their culinary expertise isn't limited to sweet confections. This versatility makes them an excellent choice for bridal showers, corporate events, or any gathering where fresh, high-quality food is desired.
The efficiency of service, even during busy periods, is another noteworthy feature. Customers consistently report that lunch is served quickly without compromising on freshness or taste, a testament to the well-managed operations at The Cakery. This ensures that even those on a tight schedule can enjoy a quality meal without a long wait.
In summary, The Cakery in Elmira is a multifaceted gem that excels in every area it touches. From its breathtaking custom cakes to its wholesome and flavorful lunch options, and from its welcoming atmosphere to its friendly service, it provides a consistently high-quality experience. It's a testament to the power of passion in small business and a true asset to the local culinary landscape of Elmira, New York.
The consistent positive feedback regarding both the food and the service at The Cakery underscores its suitability as a premier dining and baking destination for locals. It’s a place where quality ingredients meet skillful preparation, all delivered with a genuine smile. This combination fosters loyalty and encourages repeat visits, making it a true community cornerstone in Elmira. For residents of New York who value freshness, flavor, and a personal touch, The Cakery is an undeniable standout.
The unique charm of The Cakery, with its delightful decor and choice of music, adds to the overall experience, making it more than just a place to eat. It becomes a small escape, a moment of relaxation and enjoyment. This attention to detail in creating a comforting ambiance alongside excellent food is what elevates The Cakery from a simple bakery to a cherished local favorite. It’s a perfect example of how a small business can have a significant positive impact on its community.
Introduction / Overview
The Cakery is a distinguished and beloved local business situated in Elmira, New York, celebrated for its exceptional custom cakes and surprisingly robust, fresh lunch offerings. Owned and operated by a passionate baker, Lisa, The Cakery blends artistic confectionery with delightful savory options, creating a unique culinary destination in the Southern Tier. It's a place where creativity meets quality, providing patrons with everything from exquisitely designed celebratory cakes to satisfying, freshly prepared sandwiches and quiches, all within a warm and inviting atmosphere that encourages relaxation and enjoyment.
Location and Accessibility
The Cakery is conveniently located at 116 Baldwin St, Elmira, NY 14901, USA. This address places it in a central and easily accessible part of Elmira, making it a convenient stop for locals and visitors alike. Baldwin Street is a well-known thoroughfare, ensuring that reaching The Cakery is straightforward, whether you're coming from within Elmira or from surrounding areas in New York. Its accessible location contributes to its popularity as a go-to spot for both quick lunches and pre-ordered custom cakes, seamlessly integrating into the daily routines of the community.
Services Offered
- Custom Specialty Cakes: Expertly designed and baked cakes for all occasions, including weddings, bridal showers, birthdays, and other celebrations, with a focus on unique and beautiful creations.
- Fresh Lunch Menu: Offers a variety of freshly prepared lunch items, including sandwiches (like the popular Reuben), quiches, and salads (such as chicken salad).
- Bakery Items: Provides a selection of fresh and delicious baked goods, including tarts and other desserts.
- Fresh Beverages: Serves refreshing drinks like fresh lemonade to complement meals and treats.
- Catering Services: Offers food options suitable for catering events, with positive feedback on items like chicken salad and quiche.
Features / Highlights
- Woman-Owned Business: A proud woman-owned establishment, reflecting the passion and dedication of its owner, Lisa.
- Exceptional Freshness and Taste: Consistently praised for the freshness and deliciousness of all its menu items, from sandwiches to desserts.
- Artistic Cake Design: Renowned for unique and lovely specialty cakes that are not only tasty but also visually stunning.
- Comfortable and Welcoming Ambiance: Features a "very comfy space" with appealing decor and a pleasant atmosphere, often enhanced by Big Band music, contributing to a relaxing experience.
- Friendly and Efficient Service: Customers frequently commend the friendly staff and quick service, even during busy periods.
- Versatile Offerings: Successfully combines the roles of a gourmet bakery and a quality lunch spot, catering to diverse customer needs.
Contact Information
Address: 116 Baldwin St, Elmira, NY 14901, USA
Phone: (607) 731-6118
Mobile Phone: +1 607-731-6118
Conclusion: Why this place is suitable for locals
The Cakery stands out as an exceptional local business perfectly tailored for the residents of Elmira, New York. Its appeal lies in its dual strength as both a premier custom cake bakery and a delightful lunch spot. For locals planning significant life events, the ability to commission a truly unique and delicious cake, crafted with evident love and artistry, is an invaluable resource. Beyond celebrations, The Cakery offers a refreshing and consistently satisfying lunch experience, providing fresh, high-quality sandwiches, quiches, and salads in a charming and comfortable setting. This makes it an ideal spot for a quick and pleasant meal during the workday or a leisurely lunch with friends.
The fact that it is a woman-owned business, coupled with the consistently friendly and efficient service, fosters a strong sense of community support and personal connection that larger establishments often lack. The inviting atmosphere, complete with thoughtful decor and music, adds to the overall enjoyment, transforming a simple meal or pick-up into a genuinely pleasant experience. The Cakery truly enriches the local culinary landscape of Elmira, offering both everyday delights and special occasion masterpieces, making it an indispensable and much-loved part of the New York community.
The Cakery Details
Service options
- In-store pick-up
- Takeaway
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
The Cakery Photos










The Cakery Location
The Cakery Reviews
birthdaylunch
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1I went here for lunch and had the Rueben sandwich, a fresh lemonade, and a slice of chocolate torte(?) Everything was extremely fresh and tasty. I loved the decor! Very comfy space. I loved that it was a woman-owned business and the young lady at the counter was very friendly. Lunch was served quickly, even though the shop was busy. Big Band music was playing, which made me think of my parents and how they always loved to go dancing. Would highly recommend. She loves baking and I saw photos of her specialty cakes - they are unique and quite lovely.
March 14 · Theresa St. JohnI had heard about the Cakery from a friend and ordered a cake and some other food for my daughters bridal shower - the cake was absolutely beautiful and delicious! Everyone loved the chicken salad and quiche and Lisa was a dream to work with. 5+ stars all around!
July 21 · Heather SThe Cakery Elmira recently made my wedding cake and did an amazing job! Lisa saw my vision and turned it into reality. It was difficult to find a bakery that did Gluten Free cakes, but once we tried Lisa's we knew this was the bakery we needed to go with. The cake was moist and amazing, and the cake delivery to the venue went smooth. Highly recommend.
September 27 · Alyssa KinneyThis place is great you have to check it out 💖 it's so cute and I love that we finally have something like this around here 😀 it doesn't matter if you are looking for a little coffee/tea house or a new place to have lunch or even amazing sweets. This place really does have it all! They do custom cakes anything from wedding 💒 to just something you want to put on ur table for dessert. You can also buy the yummy sweets by the slice ( which I think is awesome) they have ☕ and tea (even the fancier stuff ) they also have savory, it looks like it would be a great place to have lunch. I'll be trying that the next time 😁
April 24 · Dawn SeeleyMy wife and i went there fir my birthday as a date an i was full, but they where kind enough to give me a free pineapple cake! She was even sweet enough to let me blow out a candle. Really good birthday.
May 31 · Sarah Mitchell
More Bakery Near Me
Light's Coffee Shop and Pizza4.0 (605 reviews)211 W 2nd St, Elmira, NY 14901, USA
Kountry Krullers4.0 (88 reviews)415 S Walnut St, Elmira, NY 14904, USA
Honeyduke Confections4.0 (59 reviews)1849 W Water St Unit 7, Elmira, NY 14905, USA
Desirae's Creations5.0 (12 reviews)1015 Kendall St, Horseheads, NY 14845, USA
Walmart Bakery1.0 (2 reviews)1400 County Rd 64, Horseheads, NY 14845, USA
P's Macarons4.0 (56 reviews)18 Old Ithaca Rd, Horseheads, NY 14845, USA
Cafe Tanino4.0 (28 reviews)1 Old Ithaca Rd Off, Horseheads, NY 14845, USA
Sam's Club Bakery5.0 (1 reviews)830 County Rd 64, Elmira, NY 14903, USA
Great American Cookies4.0 (104 reviews)3300 Chambers Rd Space K-8, Horseheads, NY 14845, USA
Auntie Anne's3.0 (22 reviews)3300 Chambers Rd, Horseheads, NY 14845, USA
Bagels and Blarney4.0 (85 reviews)2898 Westinghouse Rd, Horseheads, NY 14845, USA
Liberty and Laurel Bakery0.0 (0 reviews)47 Liberty Way, Horseheads, NY 14845, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Baby Diaper Cakes & Gifts5.0 (1 reviews)
Chans Donuts4.0 (63 reviews)
Giant Eagle4.0 (12 reviews)
Crush Sweets5.0 (3 reviews)
Vons Bakery0.0 (0 reviews)
La purisima4.0 (4 reviews)Top Bakery Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
Discover the Best Bakeries for Cupcakes and Frosting Lovers Across the U.S.
How to Make Bakery-Style Lemon Pound Cake from Scratch: A Step-by-Step Guide
How to Make the Best Homemade Banana Pudding: A Simple, Delicious Recipe
How to Bake the Best Homemade Chocolate Eclairs
How to Make Homemade Apple Cider Donuts | Easy Fall Recipe
How to Create the Perfect Caramel Apple Pie: A Delicious and Easy Recipe
