The Cat and Rabbitt Cake Shop

Introduction / Overview

In the heart of Puyallup, Washington, lies a true local gem that has rapidly built a reputation across the South Sound for delivering exceptional, gourmet baked goods: The Cat and Rabbitt Cake Shop. This is not just a bakery; it is a destination for cake enthusiasts seeking the kind of moist, flavorful, and beautifully balanced slices that redefine the dessert experience. Identifying proudly as a women-owned small business, The Cat and Rabbitt Cake Shop has cemented its place in the Washington culinary scene by focusing intently on one specialty: scratch-made, multi-layered cakes, served primarily by the slice.

Co-owners Julia Brown (The Cat) and Terryn Abbitt (The Rabbitt) have a philosophy rooted in passion, quality, and creativity. They are committed to crafting cakes that are both decadent and surprisingly nuanced, often praised by customers for having perfectly calibrated sweetness—rich without being overly sugary. This dedication to balance is evident in their famous cream cheese frosting, which complements the cake flavors perfectly. The shop is renowned for its continuously rotating and inventive slice menu, featuring staple classics alongside wildly popular, unique flavors like the Honey Sweet Corn Cake, Brown Sugar Peach Cake, and Raspberry Biscoff. This constant flow of new flavors, combined with a core of popular items, ensures that every visit offers something new and exciting.

More than just a place to grab a treat, the shop provides a warm, welcoming, and casual atmosphere, complete with charming indoor and outdoor seating options where you can relax and savor your dessert and coffee. It has quickly become a beloved and essential stop for anyone in the Puyallup and greater Tacoma area looking for a high-quality sweet treat, elevating the act of eating a simple slice of cake into a delightful, memorable occasion.

Location and Accessibility

The Cat and Rabbitt Cake Shop is conveniently located in Puyallup at 111 E Stewart Ave, WA 98371, placing it in a prime, easily accessible spot within the downtown area. Its location is a significant draw for local patrons, with many commenting on the ease of integrating a visit into their day.

The bakery is clearly committed to being an inclusive and accessible space for all members of the Washington community. Accessibility features are thoughtfully integrated throughout the location, including a wheelchair accessible entrance, designated wheelchair accessible parking lot spaces, and accessible seating options within the shop. Patrons will also find a clean, wheelchair accessible restroom available. When planning a visit, customers have several convenient parking options to choose from, which is a major benefit in the downtown core: there is a free parking lot adjacent to the shop, along with the availability of free street parking, and an additional paid parking lot nearby. This variety of parking ensures a smooth and hassle-free arrival, reinforcing the bakery's welcoming nature for everyone seeking a quick visit or a relaxing dine-in experience.

Services Offered

• In-Store Shopping: Browse and select from the daily selection of cakes by the slice, specialty coffee, and other house-made baked goods, often featuring seasonal and unique flavors.
• Dine-In Seating: Enjoy your dessert and coffee in the charming, cozy setting, with cute seating options available both indoors and outdoors.
• Takeout Service: Quick and friendly counter service for ordering slices to-go, perfect for taking home or to an event.
• Onsite Services: The business offers whole cakes for special occasions, with specific flavors and signature decor available upon request (note: custom designs, tiered, and wedding cakes are generally not accepted, and require advanced notice).
• Specialty Coffee Bar: A full range of espresso-based drinks, including Lattes, Mochas, and White Chocolate Mochas, is available to perfectly complement the cakes.
• Weekend Specials: The shop is famous for offering large, house-made Cinnamon Rolls exclusively on Saturdays and Sundays.

Features / Highlights

• Decadent Cake by the Slice: The core offering is their celebrated, multi-layered cake (often six to seven layers), known for being incredibly moist and available in generous, ready-to-enjoy slices.
• Inventive and Rotating Flavor Menu: The cake selection changes frequently, introducing highly unique and popular flavors such as Honey Sweet Corn, Brown Sugar Peach, Berry Lime, and Chocolate Espresso, ensuring a fresh experience with every visit.
• Woman-Owned Small Business: The shop is proudly led by two local master pastry chefs, Julia Brown and Terryn Abbitt, emphasizing quality and community focus.
• Welcoming and Inclusive Environment: The atmosphere is noted for being warm, friendly, and kind, and the business actively identifies as LGBTQ+ friendly.
• Perfectly Balanced Sweetness: Customer reviews frequently highlight that the cakes, especially the cream cheese frosting, are wonderfully rich and flavorful without being overly sweet, providing a superior taste experience compared to others in the region.

Contact Information

Address: 111 E Stewart Ave, Puyallup, WA 98371, USA

Phone: (253) 693-9463

What is Worth Choosing

If you are located in the Washington area and find yourself in need of a truly exceptional sweet experience, The Cat and Rabbitt Cake Shop in Puyallup is an essential destination. What makes this bakery worth choosing is its unwavering focus on making a flawless product, particularly its cake. Customers often compare the quality to high-end bakeries in larger metropolitan areas, indicating that the value and craftsmanship are truly top-tier.

For a first-time visit, the highest recommendation is to try one of their Signature Cake Slices. The Carrot Cake Slice is frequently mentioned as a favorite—moist, perfectly spiced, and featuring a cream cheese frosting that is lauded for its smooth texture and restrained sweetness. Another excellent choice is the Chocolate Cream Cheese Cake Slice, which offers a deep, satisfying cocoa flavor. For the adventurous local user, seek out the Honey Sweet Corn Cake Slice, a surprisingly delicious blend of corn cake, brown sugar butter, and salted honey cream cheese buttercream that has earned a devoted cult following.

Beyond the daily slices, planning a weekend visit specifically for the Cinnamon Rolls is a known community secret; these huge, decadent rolls are only available on Saturdays and Sundays and are widely considered one of the best sweet treats available in the South Sound. Paired with a freshly brewed Latte or Mocha from their coffee bar, a visit to The Cat and Rabbitt Cake Shop promises a delightful indulgence that is worth the drive from anywhere in the Washington region. You are not just buying dessert; you are supporting a dedicated, local small business that genuinely cares about quality and community.

The Cat and Rabbitt Cake Shop

111 E Stewart Ave, Puyallup, WA 98371, USA