The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard, OH: The Ultimate Destination for Creative, Scratch-Made Cheesecakes

The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard Introduce

Introduction / Overview

For Ohio dessert enthusiasts, The Cheesecake Girl in Hilliard is far more than a simple bakery—it’s a destination for decadent, flavor-forward, and imaginative cheesecake creations. Located in the heart of Hilliard at the bustling Center Street Market, this specialty shop has firmly established itself as a Central Ohio favorite, recognized for turning the classic dessert into a canvas for culinary creativity.

The core concept of The Cheesecake Girl revolves around transforming traditional cheesecake into accessible, exciting, and varied formats. They are known for their signature mini cheesecakes, which offer a perfect, guilt-free bite-sized indulgence, allowing Hilliard patrons to sample several unique flavors in one visit. This approach eliminates the commitment of a whole cake while maximizing the flavor adventure. The bakery’s commitment to rich, creamy texture and a buttery shortbread crust ensures a consistently high-quality base for all their creations.

What truly sets The Cheesecake Girl apart for local Ohio customers is its incredible variety and commitment to unique, often regionally inspired, flavors. Beyond the classic Original Mini Cheesecake ($3.75) and Original Cheesecake Slice ($9.00), the menu bursts with inventive options like the Buckeye Mini Cheesecake ($4.25), Glazed Donut Cheesecake Slice ($10.00), and seasonal specialties such as Pumpkin Spice Latte Mini Cheesecake ($4.25) or the creative Elf Maple Spaghetti Mini Cheesecake ($4.25). This constant rotation of slices and minis ensures that there is always something new and exciting for regulars to try, fostering a loyal following in the Columbus metro area.

Furthermore, The Cheesecake Girl extends its creativity beyond traditional slices and minis. They offer innovative items like the Red Velvet Oreo Cheesecake Trifle Jar ($12.00) and large-format Cookie Sandwiches, such as the Oatmeal Cream Pie ($7.50), blending the creamy richness of cheesecake with other beloved dessert formats. Their scratch-made philosophy and focus on rich, creamy flavors without being excessively sweet are key reasons why they are a must-visit bakery in the Hilliard area.

Location and Accessibility

The Hilliard location of The Cheesecake Girl is strategically placed at 5354 Center St, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA. This address places it inside the popular Center Street Market, a vibrant hub that also houses a brewery and other local vendors, creating an engaging and lively atmosphere for a dessert run. Its location in this community market makes it easily accessible for residents across Hilliard and nearby Dublin, Plain City, and Galloway.

Accessibility for all customers is a priority at this location, which is a major convenience factor for Ohio families and visitors:

Wheelchair Accessible Entrance: The location, situated within the market, offers a completely accessible entrance, ensuring easy access for everyone.
Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot: Dedicated, clearly marked accessible parking spaces are available nearby, simplifying the journey from vehicle to dessert counter.

The shop is designed for a “Quick visit” experience, perfect for grabbing a slice or a dozen minis on the go, or as a final sweet stop after enjoying a meal or a drink within the Center Street Market. Its central location within Hilliard's growing downtown district makes it an ideal spot to meet up or make a swift indulgence part of your routine.

Services Offered

The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard offers several service options to ensure maximum convenience for its Central Ohio clientele, from walk-in purchases to event planning.

Delivery: Customers can enjoy their favorite cheesecake slices, minis, and other treats delivered directly to their door via local delivery partnerships.
In-Store Pickup: Pre-orders, including large quantities of mini cheesecakes or full-size custom cakes (available via inquiry, though not listed on the immediate menu), can be picked up efficiently inside the shop.
In-Store Shopping: The primary service, allowing patrons to browse the daily selection of rotating flavors displayed in the case and choose immediate indulgence.
Onsite Services: Being located in the Center Street Market, customers can enjoy their dessert right there on-site in the communal dining area.
Takeout: All items are packaged professionally for easy and secure transport.
Payment Versatility: Accepts modern payment methods including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for a quick checkout.

Features / Highlights

The distinct offerings and specializations of The Cheesecake Girl make it a unique and compelling bakery choice in the Hilliard and greater Columbus area.

Signature Mini Cheesecakes: The variety of single-serving mini cheesecakes, priced at $3.75–$4.25 each, is a major draw. This format is perfect for personal indulgence or for creating custom dessert samplers (6 Assorted Mini Cheesecakes for $25.00, 1 Dozen for $45.00).
Incredible Flavor Creativity: Highlights include unique, fun, and rotating specialty flavors such as Buckeye, Key Lime Raspberry, Brownie Bottom Pecan Pie, and Carrot Cake, often inspired by classic desserts or seasonal ingredients.
Specialty Trifle Jars: Innovative grab-and-go desserts like the Pumpkin Bread Cheesecake Trifle Jar ($12.00) offer a layered, spoonable option combining cake, cheesecake, and crumble textures.
OSU Cheesecake Slice: A local favorite, the OSU Cheesecake Slice ($9.25) features red velvet cake and Buckeye-themed toppings, a definite highlight for Ohio State fans.
Scratch-Made Commitment: The bakery focuses on using local ingredients and making their cheesecakes from scratch, ensuring a rich, dense, and super-flavorful product.
Cookie Sandwiches: The Cookie Sandwiches, like the classic Oatmeal Cream Pie ($7.50), filled with creamy cheesecake, offer a delightful twist on a familiar treat.
Gluten-Friendly Options: The availability of a Gluten Friendly Mini Cheesecake Pack ($18.00) ensures that customers with dietary restrictions can also enjoy their delicious treats.

Contact Information

To reach The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard, customers can use the following information:

Address: 5354 Center St, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA

Phone: (614) 787-1753

What is Worth Choosing

The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard is an exceptional choice for Ohio residents and is especially worth choosing for several compelling reasons, primarily centered on flavor innovation and personal indulgence. Unlike traditional bakeries that might offer a limited selection of cheesecake, this shop specializes in a vast, constantly rotating catalog of flavors that cater to every possible craving—from classic tastes to boundary-pushing seasonal creations.

The Mini Cheesecake concept is a true game-changer for dessert lovers. It solves the common dilemma of wanting to try multiple flavors or enjoy a perfectly portioned treat without committing to a full slice or cake. This makes it the ideal spot for individuals, couples, or anyone planning a party where a dessert bar featuring assorted flavors is desired. The price point of the minis is an attractive feature for Ohio consumers looking for a high-quality, artisan dessert experience that is still budget-conscious.

Furthermore, the focus on local and state pride through items like the Buckeye Mini Cheesecake and the OSU Cheesecake Slice resonates deeply with the Central Ohio community. This commitment to fun, familiar, and locally relevant flavors adds a layer of community connection to an already delicious product.

In short, if you are an Ohioan looking for a rich, dense, and inventive cheesecake in a convenient, friendly, and accessible setting, The Cheesecake Girl in Hilliard is the premier destination. It is the perfect place for a quick sweet fix, a custom dessert platter for an event, or simply to satisfy a craving for one of the most creatively flavored cheesecakes in the region.

The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard Services

Minis
Original Mini Cheesecake $3.75
Shortbread crust, original cheesecake (bite size).
Red Velvet Mini Cheesecake $4.25
red velvet cake crust, original cheesecake, topped with cream cheese icing and red velvet cake crumble.
Specialty Mini Cheesecake $4.25
rotating flavors, call our store to inquire what we have! or, we can surprise you!
Cookie Butter Mini Cheesecake $4.25
shortbread crust, biscoff cookie butter cheesecake, topped with a cookie butter drizzle and biscoff cookie crumble.
Cherry Cobbler Mini Cheesecake $4.25
shortbread crust, original cheesecake, topped with cherry reduction, and a cobbler crumble.
Brownie Bottom Butterfinger Mini Cheesecake $4.25
Brownie crust, butterfinger cheesecake, topped with a chocolate drizzle.
Sea Salt Brown Butter Brownie Mini Cheesecake $4.25
2025 Cheesecake Madness winner! brownie crust, brown butter cheesecake with chocolate chips, topped with a brown butter glaze and flaky sea salt
Buckeye Mini Cheesecake $4.25
Chocolate shortbread crust, peanut butter chocolate chip cheesecake, topped with a chocolate drizzle and mini buckeye (bite size).
Devils Food Cake Mini Cheesecake $4.25
chocolate cake crust, chocolate cheesecake, topped with chocolate topping!
6 Assorted Mini Cheesecakes $25.00
any 6 minis that are in our case today. please call our Dublin store or look at our instagram to see what flavors we have today. include your choices in the notes!
Pumpkin Spice Mini Cheesecake $4.25
cinnamon shortbread crust, pumpkin pie cheesecake, topped with cinnamon buttercream.
Brownie Bottom Birthday Mini Cheesecake $4.25
brownie crust, sprinkle cheesecake, topped with chocolate topping and more sprinkles.
Blackberry Fields Mini Cheesecake $4.25
graham cracker crust, blackberry cheesecake, topped with lemon whipped cream
Key Lime Raspberry Mini Cheesecake $4.25
our original shortbread crust, key lime cheesecake, topped with raspberry
Carrot Cake Mini Cheesecake $4.25
carrot cake crust, vanilla bean cheesecake, topped with cream cheese icing and a cinnamon sprinkle. **carrot cake contains pineapple and coconut**
Oatmeal Cream Pie Mini Cheesecake $4.25
oatmeal cookie crust, original cheesecake, topped with cream cheese icing and a cinnamon sprinkle.
Brownie Cookie Dough Mini Cheesecake $4.25
Brownie crust, original cheesecake, topped with an eggless chocolate chip cookie dough (bite size).
Wedding Cake Mini Cheesecake $4.25
yellow cake crust, raspberry cheesecake, topped with amaretto buttercream and more yellow cake sprinkle!
Pumpkin Cookies And Cream Mini Cheesecake $4.25
oreo crust, pumpkin spice cheesecake, topped with a dollop of cool whip and crushed oreos!
Chocolate Pie Mini Cheesecake $4.25
oreo crust, chocolate cheesecake topped with whipped cream topping.
Cookies And Cream Mini Cheesecake $4.25
Chocolate shortbread crust, cookies and cream cheesecake topped with a buttercream dollop and oreo sprinkle
Coconut Cream Pie Mini Cheesecake $4.25
Shortbread crust, coconut cheesecake, topped with coconut pudding and toasted coconut.
Pumpkin Spice Latte $4.25
our take on everyone's favorite drink. spice cake crust, pumpkin cheesecake, topped with espresso flavored whipped topping!
Brownie Bottom Pecan Pie Mini Cheesecake $4.25
brownie crust, original cheesecake, topped with a homemade pecan pie topping
Drumstick Mini Cheesecake $4.25
waffle cone graham cracker crust, caramel cheesecake, topped with chocolate magic shell and crushed peanuts. *contains coconut oil*
Oatmeal Cream Pie Mini Cheesecake $4.25
oatmeal cookie crust, original cheesecake, topped with cream cheese icing and a cinnamon sprinkle!
Orange Creamsicle Mini Cheesecake $4.25
shortbread crust, orange cheesecake, topped with cool whip.
Brownie Cookie Butter Mini Cheesecake $4.25
brownie crust, cookie butter cheesecake, topped with a dollop of cookie butter buttercream.
Brownie Bottom Birthday Mini Cheesecake $4.25
brownie bottom cheesecake crust, sprinkle cheesecake, topped with chocolate topping and more sprinkles!
Brownie Bottom Pecan Pie Mini Cheesecake $4.25
brownie crust, original cheesecake topped with pecan pie topping.
Peanut Butter Pie Mini Cheesecake $4.25
oreo crust, peanut butter cheesecake, topped with whipped cream and oreo crumble
Mango Tajin Mini Cheesecake $4.25
Shortbread crust, mango cheesecake, topped with mango buttercream and a sprinkle of tajin seasoning (bite size).
Lemon Raspberry Mini Cheesecake $4.25
Shortbread crust, raspberry cheesecake, topped with lemon curd (bite size).
Elf Maple Spaghetti Mini Cheesecake $4.25
shortbread crust, maple flavored cheesecake, topped with maple buttercream and a hot fudge pop-tart piece!
Caramel Apple Pie Mini Cheesecake $4.25
shortbread crust, caramel apple cheesecake, topped with apple reduction and a caramel drizzle!
White Chocolate Raspberry Mini Cheesecake $4.25
shortbread crust, raspberry white chocolate chip cheesecake, topped with raspberry and more mini white chocolate chips!
Vanilla Bean Berry Mini Cheesecake $4.25
shortbread crust, vanilla bean cheesecake, topped with a homemade berry compote. the berry compote is made up of fresh blackberries, strawberries, and blueberries!
Strawberry Shortcake Mini Cheesecake $4.25
Shortbread crust, strawberry cheesecake, topped with strawberry buttercream and strawberry shortcake topping.
Strawberry Sugar Cookie Mini Cheesecake $4.25
Sugar cookie crust, with strawberry cheesecake, topped with a strawberry buttercream dollop and sprinkles.
1 Dozen Assorted Mini Cheesecakes $45.00
any 12 minis that are in our case today. please call our Dublin store or look at our instagram to see what flavors we have today. include your choices in the notes!
Lemon Surprise Mini Cheesecake $4.25
graham cracker crust, lemon cheesecake, topped with lemon buttercream and a lemon glaze!
Caramel Apple Pie Mini Cheesecake $4.25
shortbread crust, caramel cheesecake with apple reduction and cinnamon, topped with apple reduction.
Black Raspberry Chip Mini Cheesecake $4.25
Chocolate shortbread crust, black raspberry chocolate chip cheesecake, topped with chocolate and mini chocolate chips (bite size).

Other Treats
Gluten Friendly Mini Cheesecake Pack $18.00
4 gluten friendly mini cheesecakes - birthday cookies and cream, chocolate chip, strawberry and blueberry lemon! These flavors unfortunately cannot be changed!
Red Velvet Oreo Cheesecake Trifle Jar $12.00
Layers of red velvet chocolate chip cake, chocolate chip cheesecake, and cookies and cream crumble all stacked in a 16oz jar.
Pumpkin Bread Cheesecake Trifle Jar $12.00
layers of pumpkin bread, cinnamon roll no bake cheesecake, and graham cracker crust. you won't want to miss this, as they leave the menu after November!
Puppy Donuts $3.75
Peanut butter and pumpkin dog friendly donuts, dipped in peanut butter with a milk bone sprinkle.
Carrot Cake Cheesecake Trifle Jar $12.00
layers of carrot cake, original no bake, and crushed vanilla wafers. *carrot cake contains pineapple and coconut*

Slices
Birthday Cookies And Cream Cheesecake Slice $9.50
chocolate shortbread crust, oreo cheesecake with sprinkles, topped with oreo buttercream and sprinkles.
Original Cheesecake Slice $9.00
Shortbread crust, original cheesecake.
Caramel And Cookies Cheesecake Slice $9.50
chocolate shortbread crust, caramel cheesecake with oreos, topped with caramel buttercream, a caramel drizzle and more oreo pieces!
Maple Pancake Cheesecake Slice $9.50
shortbread crust, maple cheesecake with a layer of pancakes in the middle. topped with maple buttercream, a syrup drizzle and crumbled pancakes!
Carnival Cheesecake Slice $9.50
shortbread crust, original cheesecake with golden oreo and sprinkles mixed in. topped with original buttercream with sprinkles and golden oreos around the edge.
Glazed Donut Cheesecake Slice $10.00
Shortbread crust, original cheesecake with a layer of chipped up glazed donuts in the middle, topped with buttercream and a donut glaze drizzle with crumbled donut pieces around the edges.
Blackberry Fields Cheesecake Slice $9.50
Graham cracker crust, blackberry cheesecake, topped with lemon zest cool whip and a blackberry on each slice.
Kentucky Butter Cake Cheesecake Slice $9.50
Shortbread crust, vanilla butter cheesecake, with a layer of Kentucky buttercake in the middle. Topped with buttercream and more crumble of Kentucky buttercake!
Sugar Cookie Cheesecake Slice $9.50
sugar cookie crust, original cheesecake layered with christmas sugar cookies. topped with red buttercream and sprinkles
Chocolate Pie Cheesecake Slice $9.50
oreo crust, chocolate cheesecake, topped with whipped cream.
Banana Split Cheesecake Slice $9.25
chocolate shortbread crust, banana cheesecake, topped with banana pudding, a whipped cream dollop with a cherry and crushed peanuts.
Cinnamon Roll Cheesecake Slice $9.50
Graham cracker crust, original cheesecake with chunks of cinnamon roll filling mixed inside, topped with buttercream lattice and cinnamon sprinkle.
Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake Slice $9.50
our classic pumpkin flavor - cinnamon shortbread crust, pumpkin cheesecake topped with a layer of buttercream and a sprinkle of pumpkin pie spice!
Key Lime Pie Cheesecake Slice $9.50
Graham cracker crust, key lime cheesecake topped with whipped cream and graham cracker crumb.
Pumpkin Spice Cheesecake Slice $9.50
cinnamon shortbread crust, pumpkin spice cheesecake, topped with buttercream and a cinnamon sprinkle.
Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake Slice $9.50
chocolate shortbread crust, peanut butter with reeses cheesecake, topped with peanut butter buttercream and chopped reeses!
Sundae Twist $9.50
Chocolate shortbread, an original cheesecake layer, with Oreos and chocolate ganache in the middle, topped off with a layer of chocolate cheesecake topped with buttercream and sprinkles.
Chocolate Chip Cheesecake Slice $9.50
chocolate shortbread crust, chocolate chip cheesecake, topped with chocolate ganache, and mini chocolate chips.
OSU Cheesecake Slice $9.25
oreo crust, plain cheesecake, with a layer of red velvet cake in the middle topped with oreo buttercream and an edible buckeye leaf.
PB&J Cheesecake Slice $9.50
graham cracker crust, peanut butter cheesecake, topped with strawberry jam!
Hot Fudge Sundae Cheesecake Slice $9.50
chocolate shortbread crust, original cheesecake layered with birthday cake, topped with chocolate ganache a dollop of whipped cream and rainbow sprinkles.
Blueberry Cobbler Cheesecake Slice $9.50
shortbread crust, original cheesecake, topped with blueberry pie filling, and a crunchy streusel topping.
Oreo Peppermint Cheesecake Slice $9.50
chocolate crust, oreo peppermint cheesecake topped with chocolate topping and peppermint candy pieces!
Peanut Butter Pie Cheesecake Slice $9.50
TCG's take on your favorite peanut butter pie! oreo crust, peanut butter cheesecake, topped with cool whip and crushed oreos!
Caramel Apple Crunch Cheesecake Slice $9.50
shortbread crust, caramel cheesecake, topped with apple reduction and cobbler topping
Peach Cobbler Cheesecake Slice $9.50
shortbread crust, original cheesecake topped with homemade peach topping and cobbler topping!
Lemon Ricotta Cheesecake Slice $9.50
graham cracker crust, lemon ricotta cheesecake topped with lemon buttercream
Banana Pudding Cheesecake Slice $9.50
shortbread crust, banana cheesecake topped with banana pudding a cool whip dollop and a sprinkle of cobbler!
Blueberry Donut Cheesecake Slice $10.00
shortbread crust, original cheesecake, layered with Little Donut Factory's blueberry cake donuts, topped with blueberry buttercream and more crumbled donut!
Maple Pecan Cheesecake Slice $9.50
shortbread crust, maple cheesecake, topped with maple buttercream and toasted pecans.
Cookies And Cream Cheesecake Slice $9.50
Chocolate shortbread crust, oreo cheesecake, topped with oreo buttercream and crushed oreos.
Strawberry Dream Cheesecake Slice $9.50
shortbread crust, strawberry golden oreo cheesecake, topped with strawberry buttercream and golden oreos.
Strawberry Whip Cheesecake Slice $9.50
graham cracker crust, strawberry cheesecake, topped with fresh whipped cream!
Raspberry Zinger Cheesecake Slice $9.50
inspired by the hostess raspberry zinger bar - shortbread crust, raspberry cheesecake layered with yellow cake and topped with coconut whipped cream and pink shredded coconut.

Cookie Sandwiches
Oatmeal Cream Pie $7.50
Oatmeal cookies with a cheesecake filling.
Birthday Cookie Sandwich $7.50
Sugar cookies with sprinkles and cheesecake filling.

The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
In-store shopping
Onsite services
Takeout

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard Photos

The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard Picture 1

The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard Picture 2

The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard Picture 3

The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard Picture 4

The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard Picture 5

The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard Picture 6

The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard Picture 7

The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard Picture 8

The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard Picture 9

The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard Location

The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard

Ohio Franklin County Hilliard Center Street

5354 Center St, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA

The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard Reviews

An average rating of ★4.3 from 119 user reviews.

flavorspricecookiemenucrustcreativeweddingvendoroatmealbuckeye

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Ordered through doordash. The order was delivered from the Dublin store. Got a slice of blueberry donut and caramel Oreo cookies and cream. Didn't really care for the chocolate shortbread on the latter, and would have liked a stronger caramel taste. The blueberry donut was good, though. However, the experience was clouded by the fact we found a hair in the box.I called the store to let them know, and it kind of sounded like they didn't believe me. I made it clear I wasn't looking for a refund, and she said, "oh... Okay, sorry about that." And that was the end of the conversation. So, that's my first experience with them.
August 18 · Charles Mims Jr
The cheesecake is delicious. They are very creative with their ingredients and it makes for a very tasty dessert. I received a Little Debbie Christmas Tree cheesecake for Christmas and it was amazing. The flavors were rich and creamy without being too sweet.
January 05 · Shad Gilbert
The atmosphere is nice, the service was polite, and the shop was very clean. I tried the cheesecake filled oatmeal cookie sandwich and a small buckeye cheesecake. The cookies were dry and too salty. The buckeye cheesecake didn't have a strong peanut butter or chocolate flavor (the cheesecake equivalent to Anthony Thomas's buckeyes). When I think of small bites, I think of amuse bouche that's loaded with flavor. This wasn't that. For both items the cheesecake did not have the same density as "normal" cheesecake. Instead, it was a lighter almost whipped version of cheesecake. Both flavors of cheesecake were too salty, as well. The bill wasn't cheap, at $12 total.
May 10 · William Smith
The cheesecake was decent quality, service was bad. The woman behind the counter didn't acknowledge me at all when I walked to the counter. No "hello", "how can I help you?", nothing. After almost 5 minutes, I said "hello, are you busy?". I was hoping it wasn't a race issue, seeing I was the only black person in the building that day.
July 05 · Shalena B.
Visited “The cheesecake girl” in Budd Dairy Hall.We had a red velvet cookie crunch cheesecake jar.So rich and creamy, it was a jar of heaven…well worth the $10 price tag, I shared it with my sister and we both had a good size serving.Highly recommended!
November 09 · MA W