The Great Cookie - White Marsh Mall

Since 1979, The Great Cookie has been a beloved local institution in Maryland, starting its journey in Ocean City and quickly expanding to become a staple in the busiest shopping centers across the Baltimore metropolitan area. The White Marsh Mall location continues this proud tradition, serving the Nottingham, Perry Hall, and greater Baltimore County communities with a delightful array of freshly baked goods and custom celebration options.

At its core, The Great Cookie is renowned for a simple, yet powerful commitment: delivering high-quality, fresh-baked products. It is celebrated as the home of the 13-inch (or 16-inch jumbo) Custom Cookie Cake and the famous Snickerdoodle cookie. While other traditional items like the Chocolate Chip cookie are popular, the Snickerdoodle—an all-butter sugar cookie rolled in cinnamon sugar with a crispy edge and a soft, chewy center—is an original, perfected recipe that has historically outsold chocolate chip by a significant margin.

The White Marsh Mall shop offers a quick, convenient stop for anyone craving a satisfying dessert, a unique gift, or a personalized centerpiece for a special event. It provides a sweet alternative to traditional cakes and pastries, focusing on classic, crowd-pleasing cookie flavors that have delighted Maryland families for generations. The bakery continues to prioritize freshness, with a baking process dedicated to checking each batch for optimal taste, texture, and consistency.

Whether you are looking for a small treat during a shopping trip, a large platter for an office party, or a fully customized birthday surprise, The Great Cookie is equipped to handle your needs. It represents a piece of Maryland's local bakery history, bringing a consistent, high-volume operation to a convenient mall setting.

It is important for local patrons to note that while the business is widely celebrated for its core products like the Snickerdoodle and custom cakes, some long-time customers have expressed disappointment regarding the quality and freshness of certain other specialty items, such as the Mini Black Bottoms, at various times. The focus remains, however, on the items that have made them famous: their cookies and custom cookie cakes.

Location and Accessibility

The Great Cookie is strategically located within one of Baltimore County’s major retail destinations, making it easily accessible for customers across Nottingham, White Marsh, and the surrounding areas.

The shop can be found at: 8200 Perry Hall Blvd #2365, Nottingham, MD 21236, USA.

As a key tenant of the White Marsh Mall, accessing the bakery is straightforward. Visitors should note the following accessibility and convenience information:

• Location Within Mall: The store is situated inside the White Marsh Mall, offering a convenient stop for shoppers.
• Wheelchair Accessible Entrance: The mall itself and the store location are designed to be fully accessible.
• Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot: Plenty of dedicated accessible parking spots are available in the mall's general parking lot.

The location is geared toward a quick visit, allowing patrons to easily pick up their custom orders or spontaneous treats while enjoying the mall environment.

Services Offered

The Great Cookie specializes in a focused range of celebratory desserts and convenient cookie packages, with a strong emphasis on customization and volume:

• Custom Cookie Cakes: Offering 16-inch jumbo chocolate chip or Snickerdoodle cookie cakes personalized with custom messages and icing designs for occasions like Happy Birthday, Get Well Soon, and Congratulations ($35.00 each), as well as plain options ($30.00).
• Cookie Packages: Available in Small Bag Of Cookies ($10.00) and Medium Bag Of Cookies ($15.00), allowing customers to select a variety of their favorite flavors.
• Bulk Assortments: The highly popular Cookie Bucket ($25.00) offers a delightful assortment of cookies, including favorites like chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, peanut butter, and M&M cookies.
• Catering Platters: Offering ready-made assortments for events with the Small Platter ($60.00, choosing up to 8 cookies) and Large Platter ($100.00, choosing up to 13 cookies).
• Beverages: Offering a simple selection of drinks, including the 24 Oz Large Deer Park Sport Bottle ($2.25).
• Service Options: Providing convenient shopping with In-store pickup and Takeout options.
• Payment Methods: Accepting modern payment options, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, alongside traditional methods.
• E-commerce Service: The business also operates an extensive online platform, allowing customers across the country to order and ship their famous cookies and cookie cakes.

Features / Highlights

What makes The Great Cookie a distinctive presence in the Baltimore County dessert scene is its combination of heritage, focus, and popular core products:

• The Famous Snickerdoodle: This old-time recipe, an all-butter sugar cookie, is a major draw and remains the most popular cookie, having earned a nationwide following.
• The Custom Cookie Cake: As the original and popular alternative to traditional sponge cake, the jumbo 16-inch Custom Cookie Cake provides a fun, shareable, and delicious centerpiece for any celebration, customizable for birthdays, milestones, and corporate events.
• Baltimore Bakery Heritage: The Great Cookie has been a part of the Maryland food scene since 1979, holding a recognized place in the local community for decades. Its Fudge Brownie was once even voted “Baltimore's Best.”
• The Cookie Bucket Value: The Cookie Bucket is a highly popular option, offering a large assortment of fresh-baked cookies, making it a favorite for sharing or stocking up on multiple flavors at a value price point.
• Convenient Mall Location: Situated in the White Marsh Mall, the bakery is an ideal spot for a quick, post-shopping dessert or a convenient pick-up location for large orders on the go.

Contact Information

For Maryland customers planning a visit to the White Marsh Mall location or needing to place a quick order for pickup, please use the following details:

• Address: 8200 Perry Hall Blvd #2365, Nottingham, MD 21236, USA (Inside White Marsh Mall)
• Phone: (410) 931-7064

What is worth choosing

For Marylanders seeking a fast, festive, and familiar dessert option, The Great Cookie at White Marsh Mall remains a solid choice, particularly for specific items that have earned their reputation.

The most compelling reason to visit this location is for their celebrated specialties. If you are looking for a guaranteed crowd-pleaser for an upcoming party, the Custom Cookie Cake is the absolute highlight. It is a large, shareable, freshly-baked dessert that serves as an excellent, fun alternative to traditional birthday or graduation cakes. Customers can personalize the message and choose the base cookie—the classic Chocolate Chip or the distinct Snickerdoodle. The cakes are baked fresh and are a guaranteed sweet centerpiece.

Additionally, the Snickerdoodle Cookies are a must-try. This particular recipe is the foundation of The Great Cookie’s legacy and is consistently praised by loyal customers as being a perfectly balanced cookie—crispy on the edge, chewy in the center, and bursting with buttery cinnamon flavor. Choosing a Small Bag or the popular Cookie Bucket full of Snickerdoodles is the best way to experience the quality that built the brand.

While some recent feedback has highlighted concerns about the freshness of smaller, less-ordered specialty items like the Black Bottoms, and the general customer service experience, focusing on the bakery’s established star products—the Custom Cookie Cake and the Snickerdoodle—will ensure the most positive and authentic Great Cookie experience. The convenience of its location within White Marsh Mall also makes it an unmatched destination for a fast, delicious dessert grab in the Nottingham area.

The Great Cookie - White Marsh Mall

8200 Perry Hall Blvd #2365, Nottingham, MD 21236, USA