The SugarMill, Inc.

For residents of the greater Atlanta area, particularly those in Rockdale and Newton counties, The SugarMill, Inc. is a beloved local bakery that has established itself as the go-to source for truly decadent, scratch-made desserts. Located in Conyers, GA, The SugarMill is far more than a simple sweet shop; it is a specialized confectionary and Wedding Bakery that prides itself on delivering high-quality, beautifully decorated treats that make any occasion special.

The bakery is a true reflection of its owner, Cyrus Joseph, who was inspired to start baking on a dare after growing frustrated with the inconsistent quality of store-bought cakes. Coming from a modest baking background picked up from his mother, Cyrus embarked on a mission to perfect his craft and create desserts that are both delicious and consistently moist. This commitment to quality means that every cake, cheesecake, and pastry sold at The SugarMill is prepared from scratch, ensuring the high standard and decadent flavor that customers consistently rave about.

The SugarMill’s concept itself is inspired by the owner’s roots on the island of St. Croix, U.S. Virgin Islands, where historic Sugarmill structures still stand as a reminder of the island's history as a major sugar exporter. This heritage infuses the bakery’s spirit, symbolizing a commitment to core ingredients and a passion for sweet creations. The business proudly identifies as Black-owned and family-operated, embodying the dedication and personal touch of local entrepreneurship in Georgia. Whether you need a slice of Red Velvet for a midday treat or an elaborate tiered cake for a wedding, The SugarMill offers a professional, welcoming atmosphere and an assurance of premium quality.

The local patronage speaks volumes. Customers often describe the cakes as "decadent" and "worthy of the highest praise," contrasting them favorably against the dry, tasteless pastries often found elsewhere. This bakery has become the definitive choice for many in the Conyers area seeking quality and flavor that they believe is superior to what they might even find by driving all the way into Atlanta.

Location and Accessibility

The SugarMill, Inc. is conveniently situated on a major corridor, making it an easy and accessible stop for customers throughout Conyers and surrounding communities.

• Address: 1427 GA-138, Conyers, GA 30013, USA
• Bakery Hours: Tuesday – Friday, 8:00 AM – 2:30 PM (Note: Lunch is served 10:45 AM – 1:45 PM). Customers should confirm weekend hours directly, as service availability can vary.
• Parking & Amenities: The location offers convenient Free parking lot access and provides Wi-Fi for those enjoying a quick visit.
• Accessibility: The business is fully inclusive, providing a Wheelchair accessible entrance and Wheelchair accessible parking lot.
• Service Options: Flexibility is key, with options for In-store shopping, In-store pickup, Takeout, and even Delivery via third-party services.
• Payments: All standard payments are accepted, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Services Offered

The SugarMill, Inc. offers a vast and varied menu that covers everything from quick coffee pairings to custom-designed, multi-tiered wedding cakes.

• Custom Cake Services: Specializing in all custom orders, including elaborate Wedding Cakes, birthday cakes, and special event cakes. Customers are advised to call directly for custom orders.
• Gourmet Cakes (by slice or whole): Includes celebrated flavors like Red Velvet Cake, Carrot Cake, Strawberry Cake, Lemon Blueberry Cake, Vienna Cake, Chocolate Mocha Cake, and Almond Amaretto Cake (slices range from $6.75 to $7.25, whole cakes available for specialized pricing).
• Artisan Cheesecakes: A wide, decadent selection of New York Style, Oreo, Turtle, Reese’s, Sweet Potato, and Banana Pudding Cheesecakes (slices from $6.90 to $7.15).
• Pound Cakes: Moist and flavorful pound cakes with various glazes, including Lemon, Almond, Chocolate Ganache, and Caramel Glaze (slices at $5.00).
• Cupcakes: A popular, moist selection featuring Red Velvet, Key Lime, Cookies & Cream, Chocolate, Vanilla, Carrot Cake, Lemon, and Pistachio ($3.25 to $3.50).
• French Pastries & Rolls: Traditional offerings such as Butter Croissants, Almond Croissants, Caramel Cinnamon Rolls, and Creamcheese Brownies.
• Savory Pastries: Unique lunch options like the Turkey & PepperJack Croissant ($4.75).
• Coffee Service: Fresh Coffee is available to complement any morning pastry or dessert.
• Lunch Service: A dedicated lunch menu is served Tuesday through Friday from 10:45 AM to 1:45 PM.

Features / Highlights

The SugarMill’s reputation in the Georgia area is built on a few outstanding qualities that set it apart from other bakeries.

• Guaranteed Quality and Moisture: A paramount highlight is the consistent praise for the moisture and freshness of their cakes and cupcakes, with customers specifically noting the Strawberry, Red Velvet, and various Pound Cakes. The cakes are described as "decadent confections" and "absolute bliss," with icing that is "very good, but not too sweet."
• Scratch Baking Commitment: The family-owned business takes "great pride in preparing our cakes from scratch," ensuring higher quality and a superior taste compared to pre-mixed or mass-produced competitors.
• Specialty Cheesecakes: The expansive cheesecake menu, including flavors like Banana Pudding and Sweet Potato, offers unique, highly-rated dessert options that appeal to Southern palettes and gourmet tastes.
• Specialist Wedding & Custom Cake Service: Identified as a dedicated Wedding Bakery, The SugarMill provides custom creations for major life events, blending exceptional taste with decorative artistry.
• Black-Owned & Family-Run: Patrons who prioritize supporting locally-rooted, minority-owned businesses appreciate the personal touch and family structure that motivate the owner, Cyrus Joseph.
• Convenience and Accessibility: The bakery offers a multitude of service options, including delivery and a quick visit model, making it easy to access premium desserts even on a last-minute basis.

Contact Information

Whether ordering a simple slice of cheesecake or consulting on a custom wedding cake, Georgia patrons can connect with The SugarMill using the following details:

• Address: 1427 GA-138, Conyers, GA 30013, USA
• Phone: (770) 648-7760
• Note for Custom Orders: For Wedding, Birthday, and special Event Cakes, customers are strongly advised to call the phone number above directly for consultation and ordering.

What is Worth Choosing

For anyone visiting The SugarMill, Inc., the choice of what to purchase is a direct reflection of their needs—be it an immediate indulgence or a centerpiece for a grand celebration.

For immediate gratification, the Pound Cakes and Cheesecakes are the consensus winners. Customers frequently single out the Lemon Pound Cake w/ Lemon Glaze and the Red Velvet Cake as being exceptionally moist, fresh, and perfectly balanced in sweetness. The pound cakes, in particular, are described as having a glaze "to die for," while the Red Velvet cake is often called "the only bakery I use in Conyers." The diverse and highly-rated cheesecake slices, especially the rich Oreo Cheesecake and Southern favorite Banana Pudding Cheesecake, offer an approachable way to experience the high quality of the kitchen. These items represent the consistent, everyday excellence The SugarMill provides.

For event planning, choosing The SugarMill means leveraging their expertise as a dedicated Wedding Bakery. Customers can confidently rely on the staff to handle customized, large-format orders with professionalism. Knowing that the cakes are baked from scratch and are guaranteed to be moist and decadent addresses the primary concern for any celebration cake—that the center of the party tastes as good as it looks. The ease of ordering custom cakes (by phone) coupled with the guarantee of quality that surpasses standard store-bought fare makes The SugarMill, Inc. the ultimate local choice for making a cherished moment even sweeter.

The SugarMill, Inc.

1427 GA-138, Conyers, GA 30013, USA