Troyer's Home Pantry

## Introduction / Overview

For residents across Wayne County and visitors exploring the heart of Ohio’s Amish Country, **Troyer's Home Pantry** in Apple Creek stands as a beloved, essential local destination. Located on West Main Street, this bakery has cultivated a reputation far beyond its immediate neighborhood for delivering genuinely homemade baked goods, crafted from original, time-honored recipes. The atmosphere is centered around simplicity, quality, and the comforting flavors of tradition.

The story of Troyer's Home Pantry begins with a classic Ohio tale of entrepreneurship and dedication to baking. Its origins trace back to the early 1960s, where the Troyer family, specifically Sarah Troyer, began baking to supplement farm income. Her creations, such as **Angel Food Cakes** (using egg whites) and homemade noodles (using yolks), quickly became famous on local egg routes. The demand for these baked goods soon outpaced the demand for eggs, evolving a humble farm kitchen endeavor into a thriving, family-managed business that continues a decades-long tradition of scratch baking.

Today, the bakery is known for its incredible variety of scratch-made products, specializing in two key areas: **Pies** and **Morning Pastries** (especially donuts and cinnamon rolls). It caters perfectly to both locals needing a daily indulgence and visitors seeking an authentic taste of the region. The bakery is designed for efficiency and convenience, making it an ideal choice for a **Quick visit**. Whether you're picking up a dozen of their legendary donuts for the office or securing a specialty pie for a holiday, Troyer's Home Pantry is an indispensable part of the Apple Creek food landscape.

---

## Location and Accessibility

The primary location of **Troyer's Home Pantry** is conveniently situated right in the village of Apple Creek, Ohio, making it easily reachable from nearby Wooster, Kidron, and the surrounding Wayne County area.

The bakery's physical address is **668 W Main St, Apple Creek, OH 44606, USA**. This spot is a regular stop for many travelers and daily shoppers, and the proprietors have ensured the facilities are welcoming and accessible to everyone in the Ohio community. Key accessibility features include:

• Wheelchair Accessible Entrance: The building offers easy entry points, ensuring smooth access for customers using wheelchairs, strollers, or other mobility aids.
• Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot: Dedicated handicapped parking spaces are provided in the free, spacious lot, located close to the entrance for maximum convenience and safety.

Furthermore, the location provides several practical amenities to enhance the customer experience. A **Free parking lot** is available right on-site, removing the stress of finding street parking. For those who wish to quickly check on orders or browse while enjoying a treat, **Wi-Fi** is also offered. Payment is simple, with the acceptance of **Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments**, making a purchase fast and effortless.

---

## Services Offered

Troyer's Home Pantry offers a wide selection of baked goods, with a strong emphasis on traditional, scratch-made quality. The menu is structured to cover both daily staples and specialty celebration items, fulfilling the needs of any local user in the Ohio region.

• Signature Pastries and Rolls: The bakery is highly reputed for its large, irresistible **Cinnamon Rolls**, often topped with a signature **Maple Frosting**. They also offer **Pecan Rolls** and are renowned for their fresh, delectable **donuts**, which are frequently praised by customers but, according to some reports, may sell out quickly due to high demand.
• Extensive Pie Selection: Troyer’s specializes in a vast array of pies, available in both 6-inch and 9-inch sizes. These include traditional fruit and baker's pies (like **Apple, Dutch Apple, Peach, Pumpkin, and Rhubarb**), a wide variety of cream pies (such as **Lemon Meringue, Coconut, Peanut Butter, and Chocolate**), and seasonal favorites like the Fresh Strawberry Pie.
• Specialty Breads: The bakery offers unique bread options, including standard white bread and their famous **Donut Bread**, which is made from their raised donut dough, giving it a distinctively light and slightly sweet texture. They also offer their popular **Cinnamon Bread**.
• Cakes and Decadent Desserts: Customers can find unique desserts like the original recipe **Pumpkin Bars** with cream cheese frosting, decadent **Fudge Brownies**, and their unique, substantial **Angel Food Cakes**, which are available in traditional white and several flavors including lemon, maple, and chocolate.
• Coffee and Beverages: For a refreshing start to the morning or a warm complement to a pastry, the bakery offers **Fresh Brewed Coffee** as a convenient offering for patrons.
• Service Options: All items are available for convenient **Takeout**, making it an ideal choice for busy individuals. Customers should call ahead to inquire about special orders or catering-style quantities, as availability can vary.

---

## Features / Highlights

What truly sets Troyer’s Home Pantry apart for Ohio users is the unique blend of its authentic history and its mastery of specific, beloved baked goods.

• The "Original Recipe" Commitment: The bakery has maintained a strong commitment to the scratch-made, old-fashioned recipes perfected by Sarah Troyer decades ago. This ensures a consistent, nostalgic flavor that local customers have relied upon for generations, offering a genuine taste of Amish Country baking tradition.
• Donut and Cinnamon Roll Mastery: The highest-praised items are frequently their donuts and cinnamon rolls. The enthusiastic customer review highlighting "I LOVE Troyer's donuts!!" underscores the exceptional quality and flavor that drives local demand. The unique **Donut Bread** is also a key feature, showcasing their expertise with the dough.
• The Pie Paradise: With over twenty different pie varieties, including multiple cream, fruit, and specialty options, the bakery is a powerhouse for dessert seekers. This vast selection ensures that whether a customer seeks a classic **Pumpkin Pie** or a unique **Elderberry Pie**, Troyer’s can likely satisfy the request.
• Transparency in Demand: One honest customer review notes that the freshly baked food, especially the donuts, often sells out quickly, leaving limited options later in the day. This fact, while potentially frustrating for latecomers, highlights the exceptionally high quality and immense local demand for their freshest products—a true testament to their popularity. This suggests planning an earlier visit is highly advisable.
• Community Heritage: The business is deeply rooted in the local community and maintains a family-managed structure. This continuous heritage contributes to the genuine, welcoming atmosphere that customers often associate with small-town Ohio excellence.

---

## Contact Information

For current operating hours (typically closed Sunday and Monday; Tuesday–Friday 6:00 AM–6:00 PM; Saturday 7:00 AM–5:00 PM) or to inquire about product availability and special orders, please use the following contact details for Troyer's Home Pantry in Apple Creek, OH.

Address: 668 W Main St, Apple Creek, OH 44606, USA

Phone: (330) 698-4182

Mobile Phone: +1 330-698-4182

---

## What is Worth Choosing

**Troyer's Home Pantry** is unequivocally worth choosing for Ohio residents seeking **authentic, high-quality, and reliable baked goods** deeply rooted in the traditions of the region.

You should choose Troyer's if your goal is to experience the very best of Amish Country baking, especially if you are interested in their highly-rated items. The bakery’s commitment to **original recipes and scratch preparation** means that staples like their cinnamon rolls, donuts, and extensive selection of pies offer a flavor profile that is distinctively rich and satisfying—a true comfort food experience.

While one piece of customer feedback mentioned disappointment with a specific rhubarb pie due to a thick crust and a 'doughy mixture,' this is the exception, not the rule, for a bakery with a decades-long history of exceptional praise, particularly for its other varieties of pies and baked goods. The overwhelming evidence, including the wide selection and the passionate loyalty of donut and cinnamon roll fans, suggests that the bakery's strengths lie in its perfected specialties.

Ultimately, the main reason to choose Troyer's is for the **convenience of a quick visit combined with premium, homemade quality**. Plan to arrive earlier in the day to secure the freshest and most popular items, particularly their famous donuts, before they inevitably sell out. For a taste of history, a warm cup of coffee, and a sweet treat made with genuine care, Troyer's Home Pantry delivers a cherished local experience right on West Main Street.

Troyer's Home Pantry

668 W Main St, Apple Creek, OH 44606, USA