Bagel Market: A Downtown Staple for Fresh Bagels and Friendly Service

Bagel Market Introduce

For many New Yorkers, the morning bagel is a sacred ritual, a quick and delicious way to fuel up for the city's relentless pace. In a city where bagel shops are on nearly every corner, finding a true standout can be a challenge. Bagel Market, located on William Street, has earned its place as one of these cherished local institutions. This is a place that lives up to its name, offering a bounty of fresh, expertly made bagels and an array of classic New York-style deli items. Despite being a "small place," as one customer noted, it is "big on taste and atmosphere," proving that in New York, the best things often come in modest packages. It's the kind of spot that feels both new and familiar, a dependable part of a downtown local's routine.

The quality of the bagels themselves is the undisputed star of the show. One reviewer declared them to be "far and away the best and freshest I have ever tasted." This kind of high praise is not given lightly by New Yorkers, who are famously discerning about their bagels. The commitment to freshness and taste is a key factor that keeps people coming back, so much so that "sometimes the line is out the door!" This is a clear indicator of the shop’s popularity and the high demand for its products. A customer’s detailed review further illustrates this, praising the food as "always fresh and delicious" and specifically highlighting a favorite combination: "White fish salad on a toasted onion bagel with my cold brew coffee. That's awesome." This kind of specific, personal recommendation is a powerful testament to a menu item’s quality and the shop’s ability to create memorable culinary experiences.

Beyond the food, the atmosphere and service at Bagel Market are a major part of its appeal. Reviews consistently mention the "super friendly and very professional" staff. Another customer review, presumably from a child, noted the "very polite workers" who are "attentive." This friendly and efficient service is crucial in a fast-paced environment like the Financial District. For a local on their morning commute, knowing that you can get reliable, polite, and quick service is invaluable. The shop's ability to maintain this level of service even when the line is long is a testament to its well-run operation and its commitment to its customers. The review from a long-time customer who makes it their "first stop on my Friday commute" perfectly encapsulates this relationship, built on "reliable and polite service" and "fresh and delicious" food. The "window sitting" is another thoughtful feature, offering a small, but cherished, spot to watch the city go by.

The menu at Bagel Market is extensive, offering "everything you want to eat." While bagels are the main attraction, the shop also provides a full range of spreads, salads, and deli items. The standout whitefish salad is just one example of the quality of these offerings. They also offer a full coffee menu, with a cold brew coffee being a noted favorite. This comprehensive selection ensures that Bagel Market can cater to a wide range of tastes and meal times, from a simple bagel with cream cheese to a more substantial breakfast sandwich or a healthy salad. This versatility makes it a perfect stop for both a quick bite and a more leisurely break, serving the diverse needs of the downtown community. The fact that the shop can manage to maintain high quality across such a varied menu is a significant achievement and a major reason for its success.

In conclusion, Bagel Market is a quintessential New York bagel shop that has rightfully earned its stellar reputation. It's a place where exceptional food, friendly service, and a warm atmosphere come together to create a beloved local institution. The overwhelming praise for the bagels’ freshness and taste, combined with the consistent positive feedback on the staff, makes it a must-visit for anyone in the downtown area. It's a place that has built its success on the simple, yet powerful, combination of quality and community. For a local looking for the best and freshest bagels, reliable service, and a friendly face to start their day, Bagel Market is the clear choice. It is the kind of place that makes a neighborhood feel more like a home, one perfectly toasted onion bagel at a time.

Location and Accessibility

Bagel Market is located at 168 William St, New York, NY 10038, USA. This places it squarely in the bustling Financial District, an area known for its high concentration of businesses, residential buildings, and historical sites. Its location on William Street makes it easily accessible for a steady stream of locals, commuters, and tourists.

The bakery’s accessibility is a major advantage, as it is situated in a key transit hub. It is within a very short walking distance of several major subway stations. The Fulton Street station, a large transit center, provides access to the 2, 3, 4, 5, A, C, J, and Z trains, making it an incredibly convenient stop for customers coming from all parts of the city. The J and Z trains also have a stop at Broad Street, and the 2 and 3 trains at Wall Street, all of which are just a few blocks away. This multi-line access ensures that Bagel Market is an easy and quick stop for thousands of daily commuters.

In addition to the subway, the area is well-served by numerous bus routes, with stops on nearby streets like Broadway and Pearl Street. The highly walkable nature of the Financial District means that Bagel Market is a simple stroll from countless office buildings and residential apartments. The location is perfect for those who work in the area and need a quick breakfast or lunch break. The shop's presence in such a high-traffic, well-connected spot solidifies its role as a central and dependable part of the local food scene.

Services Offered

Fresh Bagels: The main highlight, praised for being the "best and freshest."
Bagel Sandwiches: A variety of classic and creative bagel sandwiches, including breakfast and deli options.
Deli Salads: Such as the highly recommended whitefish salad.
Coffee and Beverages: A full coffee menu, including cold brew, to complement the bagels.
Takeout Service: Designed for quick and efficient grab-and-go orders.
Limited Seating: Features "window sitting" for those who wish to briefly sit and enjoy their food.
Catering: Based on the nature of the business, they likely offer catering for office events.

Features / Highlights

Best and Freshest Bagels: The bagels are consistently praised as being top-tier in terms of freshness and taste.
Super Friendly and Professional Staff: The service is a major highlight, with staff being described as polite, friendly, and attentive.
Delicious Whitefish Salad: A specific menu item that has received high praise from a regular customer.
Reliable Service: A long-time customer notes that they come for "reliable and polite service" as part of their weekly routine.
Great Atmosphere: Despite being a small place, it is noted for having a positive and welcoming atmosphere.
Window Seating: A thoughtful touch that provides a nice spot for a quick break.

Contact Information

For those who want to visit or contact Bagel Market, here is the information:

Address: 168 William St, New York, NY 10038, USA

Phone: (212) 681-6303

Conclusion: Why this place is suitable for locals

Bagel Market is perfectly suited for the New York local for its exceptional blend of product quality, efficient service, and welcoming atmosphere. The shop’s ability to consistently deliver the "best and freshest" bagels, as highlighted in customer reviews, makes it a reliable and trustworthy choice in a city with no shortage of options. The fact that a local makes it a "first stop on my Friday commute" is the strongest possible endorsement, showcasing its role as a dependable and cherished part of a daily routine.

The staff’s friendliness and professionalism are also crucial. In a city that can sometimes feel impersonal, a place that offers polite and attentive service stands out and fosters a loyal customer base. The love for specific items like the whitefish salad and the cold brew coffee shows that Bagel Market excels not just at bagels, but at creating a complete and satisfying meal. For a local, this is more than just a place to eat; it's a small, daily pleasure that makes city life better. Bagel Market is a shining example of a local business that has earned its place through sheer quality and a genuine commitment to its community, making it a must-visit for any New Yorker in the downtown area.

Bagel Market Menu

Beverages
Vitamin Water Acai US$3.45
Small Essentia US$3.45
Large Essentia US$5.45
Vitamin Water Blueberry US$3.45
Hal’s Seltzer Bottle US$3.45
Peach Snapple US$3.15
Peach Snapple Zero US$3.15
Vitamin Water Pomegranate US$3.45
Ginger Ale Can US$2.90
Vitamin Water Tropical Citrus US$3.45
Orange Snapple US$3.15
Diet Coke Bottle US$3.45
Lemon Snapple US$3.15
Apple Snapple US$3.15
Tropicana Apple US$3.75
Poland Spring Bottle US$2.90
Sprite Can US$2.90
Coke Bottle US$3.45
Tropicana Cranberry US$3.75
Lemon Snapple Zero US$3.15
Tropicana Lemon US$3.75
Tropicana Orange US$3.75
Vitamin Water Dragon Fruit US$3.45
Sprite Bottle US$3.45
Ginger Ale Bottle US$3.45
Seltzer Can US$2.90
Fruit Punch Snapple US$3.15
Topicana Cranberry US$2.90
Coke Can US$2.90
Diet Coke Can US$2.90

Egg Legends
Rainbolt US$11.20
Egg, avocado and cheese on everything bagel
Central US$10.65
egg whites, turkey bacon & swiss cheese
Geneva US$11.80
maple turkey, egg, swiss cheese & avocado
Grilled Cheese US$7.20
American & cheddar cheese on your choice of bagel
GC Club US$14.10
chicken salad, cheddar, bacon, tomato, romaine & dijon mustard
Bern US$10.65
turkey sausage, egg, gruyere cheese & tomato
H&C US$8.35
ham & melted cheese
Cali US$10.65
eggs, american cheese, avocado & tomato
Leo US$17.20
Nova Salmon, scrambled eggs & plain cream cheese on your choice of bagel
Jersey US$10.65
taylor ham, eggs & american cheese
Vermont US$10.65
bacon, eggs & vermont cheddar cheese

Individual Fruit
Orange US$1.45
Banana US$0.85
Apple US$1.45

Salad Sandwiches
Tuna Salad US$10.65
Avacado Salad US$10.30
Smoked Whitefish Salad US$12.60
Egg Salad US$9.50
Baked Salmon Salad US$12.60
Chicken Salad US$10.65

Wraps
Mediterranean Wrap US$16.05
grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, red onions, tomatoes, and feta cheese, in a whole wheat wrap with balsamic vinaigrette
Caesar Wrap US$16.05
grilled chicken and romaine lettuce, in a whole wheat wrap with caesar dressing
Tuna Salad Wrap US$16.05
shredded carrots, celery and mayo, in a plain wrap
Cajun Wrap US$16.05
grilled cajun chicken, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, chipotle mayo, in a sun-dried tomato wrap
Vegetable Wrap US$16.05
grilled eggplant, zucchini, mushrooms, red and green peppers, and red onions, in a spinach wrap with balsamic dressing
Fajita Wrap US$16.05
grilled chicken, roasted onions, peppers, and salsa, in a sun-dried tomato wrap with cheddar cheese
Turkey Club Wrap US$16.05
roasted turkey, bacon, american cheese, lettuce, and mayo, in a plain wrap

Deli Meats Selection
Honey Glazed Turkey US$11.20
Pastrami US$11.20
Chicken Cutlet US$11.20
Black Forest Ham US$11.20
Prosciutto US$11.20
Salami US$11.20
Top Round Roast Beef US$11.20
Ham US$11.20
Grilled Chicken US$11.20
Pepper Turkey US$11.20
Smoked Turkey US$11.20
Roast Beef US$11.20
Turkey US$11.20

Oatmeal Favorites
Banana Berry Oats US$7.50
Bananas, strawberries, blueberries & granola
Tropical Oats US$7.50
Bananas, mango, strawberries, coconut flakes & pineapple
Greenilicious Oats US$7.50
Green apples, pistachio, honey, chia seeds & walnuts
Power Oats US$7.50
Bananas, chia seeds, blueberries, almonds & peanuts

Assorted Bagel Selection
Assorted Bagel Selection US$2.00

Create Your Own Yogurt
Create Your Own Yogurt US$7.15
Create your very own Greek yogurt bowl with your choice of toppings

Cookies
Black & White US$3.40
Over Arts Cookie US$4.05
Chocolate Chuck US$3.95
Chocolate Candy Cookie US$3.95
Oatmeal Raisin US$3.40

Beverages Catering
Tea Service US$34.50
Hot water box served with assortment of flavored and English teas. Includes milk and assortment of sweeteners. Serves up to 10 people.
Fresh Brewed Ice Tea US$34.50
Available in lemon, peach or unsweetened. Served with separate pitcher of ice. Serves up to 10 people.
Fresh Brewed Coffee US$34.50
Freshly brewed Sega Freddo coffee, served hot or iced (with separate pitcher of ice). Includes milk and assortment of sweeteners. Serves up to 10 people
Office Pantry (Dairy) US$4.60
Fresh Orange Juice (Quart) US$25.90
Quart of freshly squeezed orange juice

Hot Drinks
Hot Chocolate US$4.30
Cocoa powder, milk
Latte US$4.90
Steamed Milk, Espresso
Tea US$3.40
English & herbal teas
Macha Latte US$4.90
Americano US$3.75
Hot water, espresso
Cup Cold US$2.25
Cappuccino US$4.90
Milk foam, espresso
Large Ice Cup US$1.15
Cup Hot Milk US$2.25
Mocha US$4.90
Steamed milk, chocolate syrup, espresso
House Blend Drip US$2.60
Also available in hazelnut, French vanilla & caramel
Espresso US$2.70
Single, double, triple or quad shot
Small Ice Cup US$0.60

Create Your Grilled Cheese
Create Your Grilled Cheese US$7.20

Set Favorites Platters
Cheese Omelette US$9.50
Western Omelette US$13.75
ham, peppers, onions, tomatoes & cheddar over potatoes
Tex Mex US$14.90
scrambled eggs, jack cheese, black beans & avocado over quinoa
The Lox US$16.40
Lox, eggs over easy & goat cheese over kale
Avocado Breakfast US$14.90
fried eggs, avocado & bacon over baby greens
Meat Lover US$16.10
Ham, sausage & bacon over potatoes
3 Eggs Omelette US$9.50
served with potatoes and toast
Vegetable Omelette US$13.75
egg whites, onion, mushrooms & spinach over grilled veggies
Greek Omelette US$13.75
feta, spinach, tomatoes & onion over quinoa
Farmer's Breakfast US$16.10
over easy eggs, bacon, ham & sausage over potatoes
Keto Breakfast US$15.80
eggs, feta, spinach & sausage over grilled veggies

Create Your Own Acai
Create Your Own Acai US$8.45
Create your very own acai bowl with your choice of toppings

Lunch Catering
Lunch Sandwich Package US$96.60
An assortment of our most popular deli sandwiches, arranged on bagels, wraps or bread. Served with chips.
Salad Bowl Small (Serves 5-7) US$56.35
Salads are served with mini garlic bread bagels. Choose from the following salads. 1. Caesar Salad Romaine, parmesan cheese, homemade croutons & creamy caesar dressing. 2. Santa Fe Salad Kale, romaine, avocado, corn, Jack & cheddar cheese, tomatoes, onions & chipotle-lime vinaigrette dressing. 3. Greek Salad Cucumbers, tomatoes, onions, olives, feta cheese, extra virgin olive oil vinaigrette dressing. 4. Garden Salad Romaine, cucumbers, tomatoes, onions, extra virgin olive oil vina...
Salad Bowl Large (Serves 8-10) US$80.50
Pasta Salad Large (Serves 8-10) US$69.00
Pasta Salad Small (Serves 5-7) US$48.30
Choice of house-made cold pasta dishes, served with mini garlic bread bagels. Choose from the following pasta salads: 1. Pasta Primavera Fusilli - with broccoli, red onions, mushrooms, zucchini and roasted peppers in a light Italian dressing 2. Pasta Pesto Penne - with fresh mozzarella, fusilli with sun-dried tomatoes, yellow squash and pesto sauce. 3. Pasta Fresco - with sun-dried tomatoes and garlic in extra virgin olive oil 4. Sun-dried Tomato Pasta penne - with black olives,...

Freshly Squeezed Juices
Orange Juice US$7.99
Freshly squeezed orange

Club Sandwiches
Turkey Club US$16.05
with bacon, lettuce, tomato & russian dressing
Bacon Avocado Grilled Chicken Club US$16.05
with lettuce, tomato & chipotle mayo
Roast Beef Club US$16.05
with cheddar, lettuce, tomato & coleslaw
Chicken Salad Club US$16.05
with bacon, lettuce, tomato & mayo
White Tuna Salad Club US$16.05
with hard-boiled eggs, lettuce, tomatoes & mayo

Yogurt Favorites
Chocolate Orange Yogurt US$9.15
oranges, pistachio & dark chocolate
Blueberry Superpower Yogurt US$9.15
fresh blueberries, granola & honey
Strawberry Kiwi Yogurt US$9.15
fresh strawberries & kiwi
Classic Greek Yogurt US$9.15
walnuts & honey

Deli Salads Side (8oz)
Chicken Salad US$9.50
Avocado Egg Salad US$8.35
Lox US$21.80
Tuna Salad US$9.50
Salmon Salad US$12.60
Egg Salad US$8.35
Smoke Whitefish Salad US$12.60

Yogurt/Pudding
Strawberry Greek US$6.35
Rice Pudding US$4.00
Greek Yogurt Parfait US$6.35
Chocolate Pudding US$3.40

Sweets & Fruits
Seasonal Fruit Bowl US$48.30
Fresh cut watermelon, pineapple, strawberries, melon and grapes.
Yogurt & Granola US$64.40
Low fat Greek yogurt, served with honey and granola
Sweets & Treats Platter US$48.30
An assortment of homemade cookies, pound cake, brownies & specialty bars.
Mixed Berry Bowl US$64.40
Strawberries, blueberries and raspberries (subject to seasonal availability
Seasonal Sliced Fruit Platter US$64.40
Freshly sliced watermelon, pineapple, strawberries, melon and grapes.

Croissants
Plain Croissant US$3.75
Almond Croissant US$3.75

Muffins
Pistachio Muffin US$4.05
Corn Muffin US$4.05
Blueberry Muffin US$4.05
Marble Muffin US$4.05
Double Chocolate Muffin US$4.05
Banana Muffin US$4.05

The legends
Spicy Pig US$8.90
Chipotle cream cheese & sliced bacon on your choice of bagel
Classic Lox US$18.69
nova salmon, scallion cream cheese, capers & tomato
Grand US$18.69
Everything seeded salmon, scallion cream cheese & avocado on your choice of bagel
Max US$12.95
smoked whitefish salad, tomatoes & red onion
AB&J US$7.20
almond butter & strawberry jam
Bagel Ambassador US$5.45
Extra scallion cream cheese on everything Bagel (Not Toasted)
Bella US$18.69
nova salmon, scallion cream cheese, onions, capers & arugula
Nocacado US$18.69
lox, onions, capers, tomato, lemon juice & avocado
Milk & Honey US$8.35
ricotta, apple & honey
Spicy BLT US$11.80
bacon, lettuce, tomato & chipotle cream cheese
Traditional US$18.69
Nova Salmon, plain cream cheese, tomato, red onions & capers on your choice of bagel
Elvis US$9.50
peanut butter, jelly & bacon

Paninis
Chicken Parm US$16.10
breaded chicken with fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, fresh basil & parmesan
Cubano US$16.10
roast pork ham, pickles, swiss cheese, mustard, spinach pesto & gruyere cheese
Tuna Melt US$16.10
solid white tuna with celery, mayo, cheddar cheese, lettuce, & tomatoes
Fajita US$16.10
grilled chicken, peppers, onions, cheddar & salsa

Combo Deals
The Ultimate Bagel Breakfast US$11.49
Vermont Bagel & House Blend Drip
The Big Bagel Energy US$22.99
(x2) Eggs on bagel + (x2) Fresh Brewed Coffee
The Protein & Berry Booster US$22.99
Central + Power Acai + Fresh Brewed Coffee
The Sweet & Salty Duo US$11.49
Elvis Bagel & Hot chocolate
The Double Midtown Munch US$22.99
(x2) Sausage & Scrambled egg + (x2) Fresh Brewed Coffee

Bakers Dozen (12+1 Bagels)
Bakers Dozen (12+1 Bagels) US$25.30
your selection of bagels in a bag

Danishes
Cheese Danish US$3.95

Create Your Own Bagel
Create Your Own Bagel US$2.00

Acai Favorites
Power Acai US$10.30
bananas, chia seeds, blueberries, almonds & peanuts
Greenilicious Acai US$10.30
green apple, pistachio, honey, chia seeds & walnuts
Banana Berry Acai US$10.30
bananas, strawberries, blueberries & granola
Tropical Paradise Acai US$10.30
bananas, mango, strawberries, coconut flakes & pineapple

Create Your Own Oatmeal
Create Your Own Oatmeal US$5.20
Create your very own oatmeal bowl with your choice of toppings

Deli Sandwiches
#10 Salami & Ham US$16.05
with roasted peppers, provolone, lettuce & italian vinaigrette
#2 Smoked Turkey & Cheddar US$16.05
with avocado, tomatoes & chipotle spread
#8 Grilled Chicken US$16.05
with lettuce, tomatoes & italian dressing
#11 Tuna Salad US$16.05
with red onions, arugula & avocado
#6 Roast Beef & Coleslaw US$16.05
with swiss cheese & russian dressing
#4 Fresh Mozzarella & Pesto US$16.05
with sun-dried tomatoes
#9 BBQ Chicken US$16.05
with muenster cheese, roasted red peppers & lettuce
#3 Roast Beef & Cheddar US$16.05
with caramelized onions & thousand island dressing
#12 Prosciutto US$16.05
with hot peppers & arugula
#7 Assorted Grilled Veg US$16.05
with mozzarella cheese
#5 Smoked Turkey & Brie US$16.05
With lettuce, tomatoes & honey mustard on your choice of bread
#1 Crispy Chicken & Mozzarella US$16.05
with artichokes, arugula, sun-dried tomatoes & pesto

Grilled Cheese
The Classic US$10.65
american & cheddar cheese
Maple Bacon US$13.75
bacon, cheddar & gruyere cheese
The Truffle Melt US$10.65
muenster, mixed greens & black pepper
Tijuana US$13.75
bacon, guacamole, jack & cheddar cheese
Alps US$10.65
sauteed mushroom & onions & gruyere cheese

Spreads 8oz
Low Fat Scallion Cream Cheese (8oz) US$8.80
Green Olive Pimento Cream Cheese (8oz) US$8.80
Scallion Tofu Cream Cheese (8oz) US$8.80
Chipotle Bacon Cream Cheese (8oz) US$8.80
Lox Spread (8oz) US$10.08
Cinnamon Walnut Raisin (8oz) US$4.75
Bacon Scallion Cream Cheese (8oz) US$8.80
Low Fat Plain Cream Cheese (8oz) US$4.75
Jelly (8oz) US$5.45
Roasted Garlic Jalapeno Cream Cheese (8oz) US$8.80
Smoked Nova Salmon (8oz) US$21.95
Fresh Strawberry Cream Cheese (8oz) US$8.80
Raisin Cream Cheese (8oz) US$4.75
Plain Cream Cheese (8oz) US$7.50
Scallion Cream Cheese (8oz) US$8.80
Cinnamon Butter (8oz) US$5.45
Peanut Butter (8oz) US$5.45
Cinnamon Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese (8oz) US$8.80
Chipotle Cream Cheese (8oz) US$8.80
Lox Scallion Cream Cheese (8oz) US$10.08
Blueberry Cream Cheese (8oz) US$8.80
Plain Tofu Cream Cheese (8oz) US$8.80
Honey Pecan Butter (8oz) US$5.45
Raw Honey Almond Cream Cheese (8oz) US$8.80
Cheddar Jalapeno Cream Cheese (8oz) US$8.80
Roasted Garlic & Herb Butter (8oz) US$5.45
Jam (8oz) US$5.45
Scallion Dill Cream Cheese (8oz) US$8.80
Cannoli Cream Cheese (8oz) US$8.80
Almond Butter (8oz) US$5.45
Vegetable Cream Cheese (8oz) US$8.80
Scallion Dill (8oz) US$4.75
Plant Based Cc (8 Oz) US$5.75
Veggie Tofu Cream Cheese (8oz) US$8.80
Butter (8oz) US$4.30
Maple Bacon Butter (8oz) US$6.05
Kalamata Olive Cream Cheese (8oz) US$8.80
Nutella (8oz) US$8.65
Garlic And Herb Cream Cheese (8oz) US$8.80
Low Fat Veggie Cream Cheese (8oz) US$8.80

Side Orders
Bacon US$5.45
Hardboiled Egg US$1.75
Hashbrown (2) US$4.30
Cheese French Fries US$6.35
Patty Sausage US$5.45
French Fries US$4.60
Avocado US$5.45
Sausage US$5.45
Home Fries US$5.45
Turkey Bacon US$5.45

Indulgence Ultimate Bagels
#5 Philly Cheesesteak US$14.90
Thinly sliced ribeye steak, caramelized onion, and provolone cheese
#1 Sweet BBQ Pulled Pork US$14.90
Pulled pork in a sweet BBQ sauce with lettuce, carrot & onion
#4 Cheesy Fried Chicken US$14.90
Fried chicken fillet, crispy bacon, cheese, lettuce, tomato & onion
#3 Corn Beef US$14.90
Slow cooked beef brisket, mustard & pickle
#6 The J-Frost US$14.90
Chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, mixed greens, mayo, on bagel of choice
#2 Bacon Cheeseburger US$14.90
Two Angus beef patties, crispy bacon, cheese, lettuce, tomato & coleslaw

Create Your Own Platter
Create Your Own Platter US$0.00
Create your very own egg platters, with your choice of eggs, fillings and base

Fruit Cups
Sliced Pineapple US$5.45
Sliced Grapefruit US$5.45
Melon Salad US$5.45
Watermelon US$5.45
Fruit Salad US$5.99
Mixed Berries US$5.99

Spreads 2oz
Honey Pecan Butter (2oz) US$2.60
Almond Butter (2oz) US$2.60
Butter (2oz) US$1.45
Kalamata Olive Cream Cheese (2oz) US$2.90
Plain Tofu Cream Cheese (2oz) US$2.60
Roasted Garlic Jalapeno Cream Cheese (2oz) US$2.60
Garlic And Herb Cream Cheese (2oz) US$2.60
Jam (2oz) US$2.60
Scallion Cream Cheese (2oz) US$2.60
Chipotle Bacon Cream Cheese (2oz) US$2.90
Veggie Tofu Cream Cheese (2oz) US$2.60
Lox Scallion Cream Cheese (2oz) US$2.60
Vegetable Cream Cheese (2oz) US$2.60
Bacon Scallion Cream Cheese (2oz) US$2.90
Green Olive Pimento Cream Cheese (2oz) US$2.60
Low Fat Veggie Cream Cheese (2oz) US$2.60
Maple Bacon Butter (2oz) US$2.90
Cheddar Jalapeno Cream Cheese (2oz) US$2.60
Nutella (2oz) US$2.60
Lox Spread (2oz) US$4.30
Cinnamon Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese (2oz) US$2.60
Jelly (2oz) US$2.60
Scallion Dill Cream Cheese (2oz) US$2.60
Raw Honey Almond Cream Cheese (2oz) US$2.60
Scallion Tofu Cream Cheese (2oz) US$2.60
Blueberry Cream Cheese (2oz) US$2.60
Cannoli Cream Cheese (2oz) US$2.60
Chipotle Cream Cheese (2oz) US$2.60
Peanut Butter (2oz) US$2.60
Plain Cream Cheese (2oz) US$2.60
Roasted Garlic & Herb Butter (2oz) US$2.60
Low Fat Scallion Cream Cheese (2oz) US$2.60
Cinnamon Butter (2oz) US$2.60
Fresh Strawberry Cream Cheese (2oz) US$2.60

Cold Drinks
Greek-Style Freddo Cappuccino US$4.90
Ice, espresso milk, blended in frother
Ice House Blend Coffee US$3.75
Also available in hazelnut, French vanilla & caramel
Iced Macha Latte US$4.90
Iced Cappuccino US$4.90
Ice, espresso, frothed milk
Iced Americano US$3.75
Water, ice, espresso
Iced Mocha US$4.90
Ice, milk, chocolate syrup
Greek Frappe US$4.90
Greek instant coffee, whipped
Iced Tea US$3.75
Available in peach, lemon & unsweetened
Iced Latte US$4.90
Ice, espresso, frothed milk
Iced Espresso US$2.70
Ice, espresso
Greek-Style Freddo Espresso US$4.90
Ice, espresso, blended in frother

Set Favorites
#1 Bacon, Sausage & Egg US$13.55
with american cheese
#6 Spinach Omelette US$10.65
with tomato & swiss cheese
#2 Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato US$10.65
with american cheese & mayo
#4 Sausage & Egg US$10.65
with american cheese
#3 Salmon, Avocado & Egg US$16.39
with cream cheese
#5 Avocado Egg Salad US$11.80
with red onion & mayo

Breakfast Catering
Bagels & Spreads US$0.00
an assortment of our most popular bagels served with your choice of spreads, butter and jelly.
Breakfast Sandwich Package US$69.00
an assortment of our most popular breakfast egg sandwiches, arranged on bagels or wraps.
Bagel Market Package US$0.00
an assortment of freshly baked pastries and bagels arranged on a platter with choice of spreads, butter and jelly.
Baker’s Dozen (13) Bagel Bag US$48.30
An assortment of our most popular bagels served in a paper bag with your choice of cream cheese and jelly.
Continental Package US$0.00
an assortment of freshly baked pastries and bagels arranged on a platter with choice of spreads, butter, and jelly. Served with freshly brewed coffee and orange juice.
Smoked Fish Package US$0.00
thinly sliced nova scotia smoked salmon served with an assortment of bagels, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, capers, and your choice of spreads.
Breakfast Buffet Package US$96.60
scrambled eggs served with bacon, sausage, home fries and an assortment of our most popular bagels.

Deli Cheese Selection
Pepper Jack US$6.60
Brie US$7.50
Swiss US$6.60
Fresh Mozzarella US$7.50
American US$6.60
Provolone US$6.60
Muenster US$6.60

Bagel Market Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pick-up
In-store shopping
Takeaway
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Paid street parking

Bagel Market Photos

Bagel Market Location

Bagel Market

New York New York County New York William Street

168 William St, New York, NY 10038, USA

Bagel Market Reviews

An average rating of ★4.5 from 278 user reviews.

cream cheeseavocadolunchsalmonspreadsmorningsausagechoicebaconthe register

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Small place but big on taste and atmosphere. These bagels are far and away the best and freshest I have ever tasted. Staff are super friendly and very professional. If you want to grab a bagel or a nice breakfast, come to the Bagel Market. Trust me, sometimes the line is out the door!
May 11 · A HDEZ
Daughter's review:Very tasty bagels! Very polite workers, and the workers are attentive.My review:Have been coming to this place for a little while. It it the first stop on my Friday commute to work. I come for reliable and polite service. The food is always fresh and delicious. I love their White fish salad on a toasted onion bagel with my cold brew coffee. That's awesome. Their offerings have everything you want to eat. Love their window sitting.
May 01 · Leo (Tech & Lifestyle)
I’ve been coming to this place for awhile. Bagels have been good. Got a sandwich for the first time, cmon. I’m sure another paper thin slice of Taylor ham on their sandwiches won’t hurt margins that bad.
June 19 · Dylan Murphy
I highly recommended this place for a delicious, and healthy breakfast or lunch. The food is great the interior is nice, but what I think makes this place really stand out are the people. The team is very nice and helpful, special remarks to the older lady and the register.
June 04 · Denys P.
The bagels are GREAT here, always hot and fresh. The staff is super friendly and customer-oriented. We usually get the bakers’ dozen, but the specialties are fantastic too (try the egg & avocado — VERY yummy)! FiDi has been starved for good bagels for decades now — but we’re lucky to have TWO Bagel Markets (the one at Wall St next to Westville is the same owner). They’re the best.
April 23 · Patrick Kennell