Bagel Masters in Shrewsbury, NJ: Home of Vegan Cream Cheese, Mini Bagels, and Local Charm

Bagel Masters Introduce

Introduction / Overview

For New Jersey residents, particularly those in Monmouth County, finding a truly great, authentic bagel shop is a weekend ritual, and **Bagel Masters** in **Shrewsbury, NJ**, consistently stands out as a destination worth the trip. This local spot has established itself as a cornerstone of the community, known for providing the essential breakfast and lunch fix, but with some crucial, modern twists that cater to a wider range of dietary needs and preferences.

The essence of Bagel Masters is clear: quality bagels and a bustling, authentic local atmosphere. Customers frequently describe the shop as a "nice local spot" that is "always packed with good reason." This high volume of loyal patronage speaks volumes about the freshness of the product and the community's affinity for the establishment. While the core offering is, of course, the classic New Jersey bagel—chewy on the inside and perfectly crisp on the outside—it is the thoughtful inclusion of specialized offerings that truly elevates its status in the region.

What sets Bagel Masters apart and makes it a must-visit for Shrewsbury locals and beyond is its dedication to inclusivity, particularly for those with dietary restrictions. The availability of **vegan cream cheese** alongside regular and vegetable varieties is a major highlight, a feature that provides essential and delicious options for those managing dairy allergies or maintaining a vegan lifestyle. Furthermore, the innovative choice to offer **mini bagels** provides a perfect, less overwhelming size option, proving that great taste can come in smaller packages.

Location and Accessibility

Bagel Masters enjoys a prime location in the heart of **Shrewsbury, New Jersey**, a highly desirable area in Monmouth County. Situated at **661 Broad St, Shrewsbury, NJ 07702, USA**, the shop is conveniently located on a main thoroughfare, making it an easy stop for those beginning their daily commute, running weekend errands, or simply looking for a quality local meal.

The location on Broad Street places it within easy reach of surrounding communities, drawing customers from Red Bank, Little Silver, and beyond. As a busy, popular local destination, accessibility is key to maintaining customer satisfaction. While specific details on physical accessibility (like ramps or accessible parking) are not provided, its status as a well-patronized local establishment suggests it integrates well into the town's commercial landscape. Customers are drawn to its central location, knowing they can find a consistently great product there.

For local users, the address signifies a quick and convenient stop. The sheer popularity—being "always packed"—is a testament to the fact that people are willing to make the effort to visit this location, recognizing the superior quality that awaits them inside this beloved Shrewsbury spot. Its presence anchors this section of Broad Street as a culinary stop, positioning it perfectly for high visibility and regular local foot traffic.

Services Offered

Bagel Masters focuses on streamlined services that prioritize quick access to fresh, high-quality food, catering perfectly to the needs of the fast-paced New Jersey lifestyle. The key services reflect the priorities of a busy, popular morning establishment.

Takeout Service: The primary model of the business is fast and efficient takeout, allowing customers to quickly place their order, whether for a single bagel and coffee or a dozen for the office, and be on their way.

Self-Serve Coffee Station: A unique and appreciated feature is the **make-your-own coffee** setup. This allows customers to customize their coffee exactly to their liking in terms of strength, creamers, and sugars, creating a more personalized and relaxed beverage experience.

Wide Range of Bagel Types: The shop offers a diverse selection of bagels, including the standard sizes and, notably, **mini bagels in different flavors**, catering to different appetites and preferences.

Full Cream Cheese Selection: The array of cream cheese options includes plain, vegetable, and the highly sought-after **vegan cream cheese**, ensuring that all customers, including those with dairy allergies, have delicious spread options.

Customized Breakfast Sandwiches: Customers can order classic breakfast sandwiches (like egg and cheese, and bacon egg and cheese), which are a staple of the New Jersey breakfast routine.

Features / Highlights

The features that distinguish Bagel Masters and make it an exceptional choice for the New Jersey bagel connoisseur are deeply rooted in its product offerings and thoughtful service options.

Dairy-Free and Vegan Cream Cheese Alternative: This is arguably the most significant highlight. The availability of **vegan cream cheese**—described by customers as tasting "just like regular cream cheese"—is a critical feature for a significant portion of the population dealing with **dairy allergy** issues or choosing plant-based diets. This inclusive offering positions Bagel Masters as a forward-thinking and accommodating local business.

The Mini Bagel Advantage: Offering **mini bagels** is a major draw. For many, a regular bagel is too large, but the mini size provides the perfect, satisfying portion. Customers love that the mini bagels still come in different flavors, allowing for variety without excess. The mini bagel is "just enough," according to local patrons.

Customizable Coffee Experience: The **make your own coffee** station is a fantastic feature. It gives patrons autonomy over their morning brew, ensuring the coffee is exactly as strong or as creamy as they prefer, adding a level of personalized service that enhances the overall visit.

High Local Popularity: The shop is described as being "Always packed with good reason." This high traffic is a testament to the quality and consistency of the food, signaling to new customers that this is a vetted, trusted, and highly-rated local spot.

Great Sandwiches and Bagel Quality: Despite a minor reported oversight in a takeout order (getting bacon instead of plain egg and cheese), the underlying quality of the bagels and sandwiches is repeatedly affirmed by customers, ensuring that the main products are excellent.

Contact Information

To reach out to Bagel Masters for inquiries or to place an order ahead of time, please use the following contact details:

Address: 661 Broad St, Shrewsbury, NJ 07702, USA

Phone: (732) 224-0333

Mobile Phone: +1 732-224-0333

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing **Bagel Masters** means choosing a Shrewsbury institution known for both adhering to classic New Jersey bagel quality and thoughtfully innovating to meet modern dietary demands. What makes this establishment definitively worth choosing is its dual commitment to high product quality and exceptional customer accommodation.

The single most compelling reason to choose this shop, particularly for a large segment of the New Jersey population, is the **availability of delicious, high-quality vegan and dairy-free options**. For those with **dairy allergies** or who maintain a plant-based diet, finding a bagel shop that offers a vegan cream cheese that tastes "just like regular" is a huge victory and a powerful reason for repeat business. This feature removes the headache of dietary restrictions, allowing everyone to enjoy the full bagel experience, from the perfect bread to the creamy spread.

Furthermore, the practical genius of the **mini bagels** cannot be overstated. In a world where food portions often skew large, offering a perfectly sized, satisfying mini option in various flavors is a unique selling proposition. It is a smart choice for children, those seeking lighter options, or those who simply want to try more than one flavor without overindulging. This attention to portion control and variety highlights the shop's dedication to its customers' needs.

While one customer noted a minor error on a complex order, the overall local praise and the fact that the shop is "always packed" confirm its status as a reliable provider of great sandwiches and bagels. When you combine the convenience of the **make-your-own coffee station**, the deliciousness of their core product, and the essential, inclusive option of vegan cream cheese, Bagel Masters stands out as a top-tier local choice. It is the destination in Shrewsbury where great quality meets great consideration for all dietary needs, making it an excellent, reliable, and thoughtful choice for any New Jersey resident.

Bagel Masters Photos

Bagel Masters Location

Bagel Masters

New Jersey Monmouth County Shrewsbury Broad Street

661 Broad St, Shrewsbury, NJ 07702, USA

Bagel Masters Reviews

Ordered an egg and cheese and got a bacon egg and cheese so didn’t like the lack of attention to detail but I do appreciate they have mini bagels in diff flavors. Make your own coffee too which was cool. Nice local spot
August 06 · M- T-
Love this place! Always packed with good reason. Having a dairy allergy it’s hard finding alternatives for cheeses/cream cheeses especially with bagel shops but they have vegan cream cheese, regular and vegetable too! Tastes just like regular cream cheese. And of course the bagels/ sandwiches are great as well. I love that they offer mini bagels because honestly the mini ones are just enough. Definitely the spot to come.
December 02 · Alessandra Loffredo
My wife and kids absolutely love this place. It’s our go to spot for bagels. They’re always fresh and delicious. I’ve brought their bagel platters into the office a few times and they’re always a hit. Everyone asks where they’re from. Great place all around.
July 01 · John Majeski
This is/was our go-to bagel place for many years, we love it. Did something happen with the staff? The last two orders (a dozen bagels) we placed recently were a little off. Around Memorial Day we ordered bagels and the texture was very different (kind of spongey), and there was no salt in the dough. The last time we ordered, the texture was better but there was no salt in the dough! We definitely don't want to find a new bagel place and love BagelMasters but are wondering what happened, if they have a new team, if they switched anything up, etc. :(
June 30 · Erica R
This needs to be saidThere are many bagel places I have tried in the Red Bank area, but BAGEL MASTERS is by far the best.And being the best comes with consequences. The parking is very limited and during rush hour or weekend mornings, the place is a mob scene and it's impossible to park.I have learned to go at opening where I order a few bagels to make my own egg sandwiches at home. The texture of these freshly made bagels are incredible and there are many times I get one right out of the oven where I am warned about handling it out of the bag.The staff is very nice. Never had a problem or a bad bagel here and as I said, I get in at opening and never have to wait.
April 27 · Ron Epstein