Buttercooky Bakery & Café: A Floral Park Gem for Coffee and Desserts

Buttercooky Bakery & Café Introduce

Welcome to Buttercooky Bakery & Café, a beloved and prominent culinary landmark in Floral Park, New York. For New Yorkers with a discerning palate for high-quality baked goods and exceptional coffee, Buttercooky Bakery & Café stands out as a premier destination. This establishment has garnered a reputation for its impressive variety of desserts, meticulously crafted pastries, and expertly prepared coffee drinks, making it a go-to spot for daily treats and special occasions alike. This article aims to provide a clear, engaging, and informative overview of what makes Buttercooky Bakery & Café a cherished institution in the Floral Park community and a must-visit for anyone seeking a delightful experience.

Buttercooky Bakery & Café is more than just a place to grab a quick bite; it's an experience designed to delight the senses. From the moment you step through its doors, you are greeted by the enticing aroma of fresh coffee and sweet pastries, and a dessert case brimming with visually stunning creations. The bakery is celebrated for its commitment to both taste and presentation, ensuring that every item, from a simple butter cookie to an elaborate multi-layered cake, is a testament to their dedication to baking excellence. While the vast majority of customer experiences are overwhelmingly positive, highlighting the consistent quality and friendly service, it’s important for any business to acknowledge and learn from all feedback. The overwhelming sentiment remains that Buttercooky is a place where quality ingredients and expert craftsmanship come together to create truly memorable treats for the community, solidifying its place as one of the best bakeries in Floral Park.

Buttercooky Bakery & Café is conveniently located at 217 Jericho Tpke, Floral Park, NY 11001, USA. This prominent location on Jericho Turnpike makes it highly accessible for residents of Floral Park and surrounding communities in Nassau County, Long Island, and even parts of Queens. Jericho Turnpike is a major thoroughfare, ensuring that the bakery is easy to find whether you’re driving from nearby towns like New Hyde Park, Bellerose, or Garden City. The visibility and ease of access from this main road are significant advantages for New Yorkers looking for a reliable and high-quality bakery without having to venture into more congested urban areas.

For those relying on public transportation, Jericho Turnpike is well-served by various Nassau Inter-County Express (NICE) bus routes, with stops often within a comfortable walking distance of the bakery. This ensures that Buttercooky Bakery & Café is readily accessible for a broad spectrum of the community, catering to diverse transportation needs. Its strategic placement within a vibrant commercial and residential area also means it’s a natural stop for commuters, shoppers, and local residents. The ease with which customers can reach Buttercooky Bakery & Café underscores its suitability as a consistent and high-quality destination for coffee and baked goods in the Floral Park neighborhood.

Buttercooky Bakery & Café offers an extensive array of services and products, catering to a wide range of preferences and occasions. Their offerings go beyond typical bakery fare, incorporating a full café experience. Here’s a detailed look at what they provide:

Impressive Variety of Desserts and Pastries: Their dessert case is famously "packed with favorites" including:
- Cakes: Tres Leches Cake, Strawberry Shortcake, Chocolate Mousse.
- Individual Pastries: Pistachio Pastries, Mini Eclairs, Fruit Tarts.
- Unique Treats: The popular Dubai Chocolate Donut.
- Classic Cookies: Classic Butter Cookies.
- Seasonal Treats: Offerings that change with the seasons, making every visit special.
High-Quality Coffee and Espresso Drinks: They serve "rich and smooth espresso drinks" and "high-quality coffee," making it a perfect spot for coffee enthusiasts looking for a premium brew to accompany their dessert.
Custom Cake Orders: While a review mentioned a specific issue with packaging, the fact that a custom "4” Vanilla Mini Birthday Cake" was ordered for a "big milestone" indicates that they do offer custom cake services for various events. This service is crucial for birthdays, anniversaries, and other significant celebrations.
Savory Options: While the focus is heavily on desserts, many cafés of this caliber offer light savory options like sandwiches or quiches, though specific details for this location are not provided.
Take-out and Dine-in: The "warm atmosphere" suggests both options are available for customers to enjoy their treats on-site or to take them home.

What truly distinguishes Buttercooky Bakery & Café and contributes to its strong reputation among New Yorkers are its distinctive features and highlights. These elements collectively create a memorable and highly satisfying customer experience, despite any isolated incidents.

Exceptional Dessert Variety: The sheer breadth and depth of their dessert offerings, from classic cakes to unique pastries like the Dubai chocolate donut, make it a true dessert paradise. This extensive selection caters to virtually every sweet craving.
High-Quality Coffee Program: The emphasis on "high-quality coffee and an impressive variety of espresso drinks" positions them not just as a bakery but as a reputable café, drawing in coffee connoisseurs alongside dessert lovers.
Consistent Taste and Presentation: Customers consistently praise the bakery for delivering on both "taste and presentation," indicating a strong commitment to the aesthetic and culinary excellence of their products.
Warm and Inviting Atmosphere: The "warm atmosphere" and "friendly service" contribute to a comfortable and welcoming environment, making it an enjoyable place to relax and savor your treats.
Long-Standing Reputation: While not explicitly stated in the provided reviews, the fact that a customer "ordered from them in the past and have been fans of their pastries" suggests a long-standing positive reputation within the community.
Specialty and Classic Offerings: The bakery successfully balances classic favorites like butter cookies and mini eclairs with more contemporary or trending items such as the Dubai chocolate donut, appealing to a broad demographic.
Commitment to Quality Ingredients: The "rich and smooth" coffee and "beautifully crafted" pastries imply a dedication to using high-quality ingredients and skilled baking techniques.

For a delightful coffee and dessert experience or any inquiries, you can easily connect with Buttercooky Bakery & Café. Their dedicated team is ready to assist you.

Address: 217 Jericho Tpke, Floral Park, NY 11001, USA

Phone: (516) 354-3831

Mobile Phone: +1 516-354-3831

In conclusion, Buttercooky Bakery & Café is an exceptionally suitable choice for locals in the New York region, particularly those residing in Floral Park and surrounding areas of Long Island and Queens. Its accessible location on Jericho Turnpike, complete with convenient parking and public transport options, makes it an effortless destination for anyone seeking high-quality baked goods and coffee. This ease of access is a significant advantage for busy New Yorkers.

The bakery truly stands out for its extraordinary variety and consistent quality of desserts. From beloved classics like Tres Leches and Strawberry Shortcake to unique offerings such as the Dubai chocolate donut, the dessert case is a treasure trove designed to satisfy every sweet craving. The emphasis on "rich and smooth espresso drinks" further enhances its appeal, making it a comprehensive spot for both coffee aficionados and dessert lovers. While acknowledging a rare instance of packaging concern, the overwhelming sentiment from customers reinforces the consistently "excellent offerings" and their overall satisfaction with the taste and presentation of the products.

Furthermore, the "warm atmosphere" and "friendly service" create a welcoming environment that encourages repeat visits, fostering a sense of community. For any New Yorker in the Floral Park area looking for a premium bakery and café experience that combines impressive variety, high-quality products, and a comfortable setting, Buttercooky Bakery & Café is undeniably a top-tier local choice. It’s a place where you can confidently find a delightful treat to brighten your day or celebrate a special occasion.

Buttercooky Bakery & Café Menu

DUBAI CHOCOLATE TREATS <3
The Dubai Chocolate Croissant US$9.25
Pistachio & Kunafa Filling
The Dubai Chocolate Donut US$8.00
Pistachio & Kunafa Filling
The Dubai Chocolate Cannoli US$9.95
Cannoli with Pistachio and Kunafa filling dipped in chocolate
The Dubai Chocolate Brownie US$11.25
The Dubai Chocolate Mousse Cake US$47.75
Chocolate Sponge, Dark Chocolate Mousse, Chocolate Ganache filled with Pistachio and Kunafa— the Dubai chocolate specialty

Breakfast Pastries
Large Apple Turnover US$7.20
Flaky pastry filled with sweet apple filling, topped with a light drizzle of icing.
Chocolate Cigar US$5.95
(puff pastry dough)
Small Apple Turnover US$4.45
Flaky pastry filled with sweet apple compote, topped with a drizzle of white icing.
Prune Danish US$6.60
Flaky pastry filled with sweet prune compote.
Crumb Cake Slice US$4.05
Soft, moist cake topped with a generous layer of sweet, buttery crumb, dusted with powdered sugar.
Corn Muffin US$5.65
Golden-brown corn muffin with a slightly crisp exterior and a moist, tender crumb.
Chocolate Chip Muffin US$5.65
Soft, moist muffin generously studded with rich chocolate chips.
Peach Boat US$6.85
Flaky pastry filled with caramelized peach slices.
Sfogliatella US$6.85
Italian filled pastry with sweet cheese.
Apple Crumb Muffim US$5.65
Soft muffin topped with a generous apple crumb mixture, offering a blend of sweet apple and crunchy topping in every bite.
Blueberry Muffin US$5.65
Bursting with blueberries and topped with a crumbly streusel, this muffin offers a sweet, fruity bite.
Elephant Ear US$7.80
A flaky, golden-brown pastry with a caramelized sugar coating, shaped like an elephant ear.
Banana Nut Muffin US$5.65
Moist muffin packed with ripe bananas and crunchy nuts.
Apricot Danish US$6.60
Golden, flaky pastry filled with sweet apricot preserves.
Apple Boat US$6.85
Flaky pastry filled with caramelized apple slices, creating a sweet and buttery treat.
Pecan Danish US$6.60
Flaky pastry with a rich, buttery texture, topped with caramelized pecans.
Bran Muffin US$5.65
Rich and moist bran muffin with a slightly crispy top, offering a hearty and wholesome start to your day.
Raspberry Cigar US$5.95
Delicate pastry filled with raspberry jam, topped with toasted coconut flakes and a hint of caramelized sugar.
Raspberry Hamantaschen US$5.95
A triangular pastry filled with sweet raspberry jam, encased in a golden, flaky crust.
Apricot Hamantaschen US$5.95
A triangular pastry filled with sweet apricot jam, encased in a crumbly, golden-brown dough.
Prune Hamantaschen US$5.95
Triangular pastry filled with sweet prune jam.
Russian Tea Cake US$6.25
Rich chocolate center encased in a crumbly, golden-brown pastry, topped with delicate, piped meringue, and dipped in a smooth, dark chocolate coating.
Railroad Bar US$7.45
Layers of flaky pastry with a sweet fruit filling, topped with sliced almonds.
Cheese Danish US$6.55
Flaky pastry filled with creamy cheese, featuring a golden-brown, buttery exterior.
Almond Cheese Danish US$6.60
Flaky pastry filled with creamy cheese and topped with sliced almonds.

Croissants
Biscoff Croissant US$9.00
Biscoff Filling inside topped with biscoff cookie
The CROOKIE Croissant US$9.00
Soft chocolate Chip Cookie on top and inside (Best if heated 30 seconds)
Tres Leches Croissant US$9.00
Delicate croissant topped with whipped cream, fresh strawberries, and blueberries, infused with a rich tres leches flavor.
Almond Croissant US$9.00
Flaky croissant filled with almond paste, topped with sliced almonds and a dusting of powdered sugar.
Creme Brulee Croissant US$9.00
Buttery croissant filled with creamy custard, topped with a caramelized sugar crust.
Dulce De Leche Croissant US$9.00
Layers of flaky pastry filled with rich, caramel-like dulce de leche, topped with a smooth dulce de leche glaze.
Chocolate Croissant US$9.00
Flaky, golden-brown pastry with a rich, chocolate filling.
Nutella Toasted Hazelnut Croissant US$9.00
Layers of flaky croissant dough filled with Nutella and topped with toasted hazelnuts.
Plain Croissant US$6.20
Layers of golden, flaky pastry with a light, buttery interior.
Pain Au Raisins US$9.00
Raisin and Vanilla Creme Patissiere Croissant
Pecan Croissant US$9.00
Flaky croissant filled with crunchy pecans, topped with a light drizzle of icing.
Banana Pudding Croissant US$9.00
Flaky croissant filled with creamy banana pudding, topped with whipped cream and crisp vanilla wafers.
Jelly Cronut Croissant US$9.00
Buttery, flaky croissant filled with sweet jelly, lightly dusted with sugar.
Carrot Croissant US$9.00
Delicate croissant topped with a smooth, creamy carrot glaze and garnished with crunchy bits.
Apple Croissant US$9.00
Fresh Apple Filling
Apricot Croissant US$9.00
Flaky croissant topped with crumbly streusel and filled with sweet apricot preserves.
Strawberry Almond Glazed Croissant US$9.00
Fresh Strawberries and almonds inside lattice croissant
Pain Au Suisse Croissant US$9.00
Layers of buttery pastry filled with a rich vanilla custard and dark chocolate pieces.

Bread/Bagels
Plain Bagel US$2.20
Golden-brown bagel with a chewy texture and a subtly crisp crust.
Everything Bagel US$2.20
A dense, chewy bagel topped with a mix of sesame seeds, poppy seeds, garlic, onion, and salt.
Sesame Bagel US$2.20
A chewy, golden-brown bagel topped with a generous sprinkling of sesame seeds.
Plain Roll US$1.25
Soft, golden-brown bread roll with a slightly crisp crust and tender, fluffy interior.
Poppy Roll US$1.25
Golden-brown bread roll topped with a generous sprinkle of crunchy poppy seeds.
Sesame Roll US$1.25
A soft, golden-brown roll generously topped with toasted sesame seeds.
Egg Roll US$1.25
Crispy and flavorful roll filled with egg and a savory blend of ingredients.
Italian Bread US$3.75
French Baguette US$3.75
Rye Bread US$7.85
Ciabatta Bread US$5.95
Semolina Bread US$3.75

Brownies & Donuts
Jelly Donut US$5.60
Soft and fluffy donut filled with sweet jelly, lightly dusted with granulated sugar.
Glazed Vanilla Donut US$3.15
Soft, fluffy donut with a sweet vanilla glaze.
Vanilla French Cruller US$3.15
Light and airy pastry with a delicate vanilla glaze.
Oreo Brownie US$7.20
Rich brownie topped with crushed Oreo cookies and a dusting of powdered sugar.
Chocolate French Cruller US$3.15
Delicate, airy cruller donut coated in rich, smooth chocolate glaze.
Pecan Brownie US$7.20
Rich chocolate brownie topped with a generous layer of crunchy pecans.
Fudge Brownie US$5.95
Rich, dense brownie with a smooth, glossy fudge topping, offering a decadent chocolate experience in every bite.

Rings/Horns
Large Chocolate Horn US$19.00
Buttery, flaky pastry horn generously dusted with powdered sugar and drizzled with rich chocolate.
Large Pecan Ring US$19.00
Topped with pecans and drizzled with icing, this large ring-shaped pastry offers a sweet and nutty flavor.
Large Hard Icing Apple Horn US$19.00
Golden-brown pastry horn filled with apple and topped with a layer of hard icing.
Large Crystalized Sugar Apple Horn US$19.00
Delicate, flaky pastry horn generously coated with crystalized sugar and filled with a sweet apple filling.
Large Apple Crumb Horn US$19.00
Flaky pastry horn filled with sweet apple filling, topped with a generous layer of crumb topping and dusted with powdered sugar.
Large Fruit Ring US$19.00
A large ring-shaped pastry topped with assorted fruit preserves and drizzled with white icing.
Powdered Almond Horn Horn US$7.20
Dusted with powdered sugar, this almond horn features a crisp exterior and a soft, nutty interior.
Chocolate Dipped Almond Horn US$7.20
Covered in crunchy almond slices and dipped in rich chocolate, this almond horn offers a delightful combination of textures and flavors.

Showcase Cakes
Strawberry Shortcake US$36.00
Pillowy-soft whipped cream loaded with freshly chopped strawberries set atop thin layers of vanilla cake lightly soaked in strawberry syrup, garnished with vanilla chantilly cream and fresh strawberries
Carrot Cake US$36.85
Smooth and silky cream cheese sandwiched between moist layers of carrot cake baked golden with raisins, finished with luscious cream cheese icing, walnuts, marzipan carrots and lathered in toasted coconut flakes
Cannoli Cake US$46.85
Our signature cannoli filling set atop layers of moist vanilla cake, enclosed by a thin ring of rainbow cookies, finished with a light coating of raspberry jam and a crispy fried shell filled with sweet ricotta cheese
Large 7-Layer Cake US$32.25
Seven thin layers of Vanilla Cake alternating with a thin layer of Chocolate Buttercream and topped with hard chocolate icing
Funfetti Cake US$35.00
Smooth and silky vanilla buttercream set atop thin layers of funfetti cake baked golden and moist, finished with a wave of funfetti colors and lathered in funfetti sprinkles
Biscoff Cake US$41.15
Vanilla Cake Biscoff Cookie Cream Biscoff Buttercream Caramel Drip Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"
Dulce De Leche Cake US$35.00
Vanilla Cake Ducle de Leche Ducle de leche Buttercream
Large Fruit Torte US$47.50
Pastry shell lined with chocolate and vanilla custard topped with fresh fruit
Black Chocolate Truffle Cake US$44.95
Creamy whipped chocolate ganache with chocolate chips mixed in set atop of moist chocolate sponge iced in chocolate fudge and finished with chocolate drip and chocolate cake crumbs on top Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"
Fresh Fruit Salad Cake US$41.00
Pillowy-soft whipped cream loaded with freshly chopped strawberries, bananas, peaches, and pineapples set atop thin layers of vanilla cake lightly soaked in simple syrup, garnished with dashes of vanilla chantilly cream and fresh berries
4" Vanilla Mini Birthday Cake US$17.45
Sweet vanilla buttercream set atop thin layers of moist vanilla cake iced in smooth vanilla buttercream, garnished with colorful buttercream balloons and funfetti sprinkles
Vanilla And Chocolate Flower Cake US$35.00
Light and rich chocolate pudding set atop thin layers of moist vanilla cake iced in cream chocolate fudge finished with three buttercream flowers and vanilla cake crumbs
Small 7 Layer Cake US$16.50
Seven thin layers of Vanilla Cake alternating with a thin layer of Chocolate Buttercream and topped with hard chocolate icing
4" Chocolate Mini Birthday Cake US$17.45
Rich chocolate buttercream set atop thin layers of moist chocolate cake iced in smooth chocolate buttercream, garnished with colorful buttercream balloons and funfetti sprinkles
Black Forest Cake US$35.00
Chocolate cake filled with chocolate whipped cream and black cherries, topped with cherries, whipped cream and chocolate shavings
Mocha Cake US$35.00
Vanilla cake soaked in coffee syrup with mocha buttercream topped with sliced almonds.
Chocolate Shadow Cake US$32.50
Rich chocolate buttercream set atop alternating layers of soft chocolate and vanilla cake, finished with a chocolate ganache swirl resting on smooth chocolate buttercream icing
Vanilla Shadow Cake US$32.50
Vanilla and chocolate cake filled with vanilla buttercream topped with vanilla buttercream icing and a chocolate ganache drizzle
Oreo Buttercream Cake US$34.95
Smooth and creamy buttercream loaded with chunks of Oreo set atop thin layers of moist chocolate cake, iced in Oreo Buttercream and a chocolate ganache drip with mini Oreos on top
Golden Oreo Buttercream Cake US$34.95
Smooth and creamy buttercream, loaded with chunks of golden Oreo set atop thin layers of moist vanilla cake iced in buttercream and a white ganache drip with golden Oreos on top Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"
Checkerboard Log Cake US$34.95
Creamy chocolate fudge sandwiched between alternating layers of moist vanilla and chocolate cake creating a checkerboard pattern, finished with rich chocolate buttercream icing and chocolate cake crumbs Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"
Chocolate Flower Celebration Cake US$35.00
Chocolate Cake Chocolate Pudding Filling Chocolate Fudge Icing 3 Buttercream Roses on top Please indicate inscription in special instructions
Vanilla Flower Celebration Cake US$35.00
Vanilla Cake Vanilla Buttercream Filling Vanilla Buttercream Icing 3 Buttercream Roses on top Please indicate inscription in special instructions

Mousse Cakes
Tres Leche US$47.75
Silky smooth custard cream and dulce de leche set atop ultra-moist vanilla sponge famous for being soaked in our specially crafted 3-milk mixture blend, iced with pillowy-soft whipped cream and topped with fresh strawberries, peaches, raspberries, blackberries, and blueberries
Small Tres Leche US$12.35
Silky smooth custard cream and dulce de leche set atop ultra-moist vanilla sponge famous for being soaked in our specially crafted 3-milk mixture blend, iced with pillowy-soft whipped cream and topped with fresh strawberries, peaches, raspberries, blackberries, and blueberries
Red Velvet Mousse US$46.45
Pillowy-soft cream cheese set atop thin layers of moist velvet cake coated in smooth cream cheese icing, finished with ruby red chocolate ganache drip, vanilla buttercream, and red velvet cake crumbs
Hazelnut Chocolate Mousse US$46.45
Hazelnut and chocolate mousse set atop a thin layer of soft chocolate cake, finished with rich chocolate ganache, hazelnut whipped ganache, chocolate triangles and toasted hazelnuts
Silk & Satin Mousse US$46.45
Silky chocolate mousse infused with our famous NY style cheesecake set atop a thin moist chocolate cake, finished with a nest of chocolate ganache, gold dusted lines and lathered in roasted almond slices
Traditional Tiramisu US$46.45
Light and airy mascarpone cheese layered with ever-so-soft moist lady finger vanilla cake soaked in freshly brewed espresso coffee and a hint of coffee syrup, finished with a low peak of vanilla whipped cream dusted with cocoa powder and enclosed with lady fingers.
Raspberry & Chocolate Mousse US$46.45
Ever-so-slight raspberry cremeux and dark chocolate mousse set atop raspberry-soaked vanilla cake finished with chocolate ganache and raspberry cocoa powder, garnished with fresh berries and white chocolate twine
French Strawberry Shortcake US$46.45
Vanilla Cake with Fresh Strawberries and Bavarian Cream topped with Marzipan
Vanilla Chocolate Mousse US$46.45
Light and airy chocolate mousse set atop a thin layer of soft vanilla cake glazed with rich chocolate ganache, topped with mountainous vanilla creme and white chocolate crunchies Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"
Large Fruit Torte US$47.50
Pastry shell lined with chocolate and vanilla custard topped with fresh fruit
Chocolate Mousse Cake US$46.45
Light and airy chocolate mousse set atop a thin layer of soft chocolate cake, finished with rich chocolate ganache, a dark chocolate pencil and chocolate cake crumbs
Chocolate Tiramisu US$46.45
Espresso soaked Chocolate Cake filled with Chocolate Mascarpone Cheese and chocolate chips topped with Lady fingers, Whipped Cream and Chocolate Ganache icing with Chocolate shavings on top

Individual Slices
Carrot Cake Slice US$7.45
Moist carrot cake slice with a creamy frosting, topped with a decorative carrot-shaped icing.
Napoleon Slice US$7.45
Layers of crisp puff pastry, creamy custard, and a light glaze with chocolate drizzle.
Tiramisu Slice US$8.25
Layers of coffee-soaked sponge cake and mascarpone cheese, dusted with cocoa powder.
7-Layer Cake Slice US$7.45
Rich, moist layers of yellow cake interspersed with smooth chocolate frosting, finished with a glossy chocolate glaze.

Cheesecakes
7" Strawberry Cheesecake (Gluten Free) US$33.45
Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"
7" Red Velvet Cheesecake US$29.95
Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"
10" NY Cheesecake US$50.25
Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"
Individual NY Cheesecake (Gluten Free) US$6.25
Smooth and silky cream cheese (gluten-free).
Raspberry Cheesecake French Pastry US$8.45
New York Style Cheesecake set atop of graham cracker crust with a raspberry preserve on top and garnished with fresh raspberries
Individual Strawberry Cheesecake (Gluten Free) US$8.10
Smooth and silky cream cheese finished with fluffy whipped cream and a fresh strawberry (gluten-free).
Individual Oreo Cheesecake US$8.15
Smooth and silky cream cheese loaded with chunks of Oreo is set atop a thin layer of Oreo cookie crust, finished with chocolate fudge, chocolate ganache, and an Oreo.
7" Chocolate Fudge Cheesecake US$31.00
Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"
7" Oreo Cheesecake US$32.00
Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"
7" Pumpkin Cheesecake US$33.45
Creamy baked pumpkin cheesecake finished with whipped cinnamon cream cheese and toasted pumpkin seeds
10" Chocolate Fudge Cheesecake US$55.30
Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"
10" Strawberry Cheesecake US$67.80
Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"
7" NY Cheesecake (Gluten Free) US$28.15
Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"
7" Italian Cheesecake US$37.45
Creamy Italian cheesecake with a golden-brown crust, topped with a powdered sugar lattice pattern.

Cupcakes
Pink Rose Cupcake Vanilla US$5.00
Pink Rose Cupcake Chocolate US$5.00
Rainbow Cookie Cupcake Vanilla US$4.40
A vanilla cupcake topped with a rainbow cookie piece, adorned with colorful sprinkles.
Red Velvet Cupcake US$3.75
Moist red velvet cupcake topped with cream cheese frosting and decorated with colorful icing flowers.
Minnie Mouse Cupcake Vanilla US$4.40
Vanilla cupcake topped with pink buttercream, chocolate cookie ears, and a pink bow-shaped fondant.
Spiderman Cupcake Vanilla US$4.40
Vanilla cupcake adorned with red sprinkles, blue web icing, and white eyes, inspired by Spiderman.
Strawberry Cupcake US$4.40
Soft, moist cupcake topped with swirled strawberry frosting and a dollop of strawberry jam.
Fudge Brownie Cupcake US$4.40
Rich chocolate cupcake topped with smooth chocolate frosting and a piece of fudge brownie.
Carrot Cake Cupcake US$3.75
Moist carrot cake cupcake topped with creamy frosting, shredded carrots, and a decorative marzipan carrot.
Minnie Mouse Cupcake Chocolate US$4.40
Chocolate cupcake topped with pink buttercream, a fondant bow, Oreo ears, and white sprinkles.
Mickey Mouse Cupcake Vanilla US$4.40
Swirled red vanilla frosting topped with mini chocolate cookies and yellow candy buttons.
Mickey Mouse Cupcake Chocolate US$4.40
Rich chocolate cupcake topped with vibrant red frosting, adorned with mini chocolate cookies and yellow candy buttons.
Spiderman Cupcake Chocolate US$4.40
Chocolate cupcake with red frosting, blue web design, and white fondant eyes.
Oreo Cupcake Vanilla US$3.75
Vanilla cupcake topped with creamy frosting, crushed Oreo cookies, and a whole Oreo cookie.
Oreo Cupcake Chocolate US$3.75
Rich chocolate cupcake topped with creamy Oreo frosting and a whole Oreo cookie.
Cookie Monster Cupcake Vanilla US$4.40
Vanilla cupcake topped with blue frosting, featuring large candy eyes and a cookie for a playful design.
Cookie Monster Cupcake Chocolate US$4.40
Rich chocolate cupcake topped with blue frosting, adorned with candy eyes and a cookie mouth, inspired by the Cookie Monster.
Elmo Cupcake Vanilla US$4.40
Vanilla cupcake topped with red frosting, a cookie mouth, and candy eyes and nose, resembling a playful character.
Elmo Cupcake Chocolate US$4.40
Rich chocolate cupcake topped with red icing, an orange candy nose, and an Oreo cookie mouth, resembling a playful character.
Vanilla Classic Cupcake US$3.15
Soft vanilla cupcake topped with smooth white frosting, colorful sprinkles, and a cherry.
Chocolate Classic Cupcake US$3.15
Rich chocolate cupcake topped with smooth chocolate frosting, colorful sprinkles, and a cherry.

Cake Pops
Vanilla Cake Pop US$3.70
A round vanilla cake pop coated in white chocolate with decorative white sprinkles.
Funfetti Cake Pop US$3.70
Covered in white chocolate and adorned with colorful sprinkles, this funfetti cake pop offers a bite-sized treat with a burst of sweetness.
Red Velvet Cake Pop US$3.70
Covered in a red velvet crumb coating, this cake pop offers a bite-sized indulgence of moist red velvet cake on a convenient stick.
Seasonal/Holiday Cake Pop US$4.15
Chocolate Cake Pop US$3.70
Rich chocolate cake pop coated in smooth chocolate and topped with chocolate sprinkles.
Oreo Cake Pop US$3.70
Coated in white chocolate and topped with crushed Oreo cookies, this cake pop offers a delightful blend of creamy and crunchy textures.

French Pastries, Tarts, Eclairs
Red Velvet French Pastry US$8.45
Pillowy-soft cream cheese set atop a thin moist velvet cake, finished with a dollop of fluffy cream cheese frosting.
Blueberry Tartlet US$9.75
Madagascar vanilla cremeux in a buttery vanilla lemon zest sable tart, topped with fresh blueberries
Oreo Mousse French Pastry US$8.45
Rich and creamy cookies n' cream loaded with chunks of oreo set atop a buttery oreo sablé cookie, finished with vanilla whipped ganache and studded with vanilla & dark chocolate shards
Traditional Cannoli US$5.65
Crispy fried shell filled with sweet ricotta cheese and chocolate chip, topped with a dusting of powdered sugar
Opera French Pastry US$8.45
Espresso whipped ganache and dark chocolate crémeux set between layers of chocolate biscuit cake lathered in espresso syrup, finished with dark chocolate glaze & crunchy chocolate wafer
Silk & Satin French Pastry US$8.45
Silky chocolate mousse infused with our famous New York style cheesecake set atop a buttery chocolate shortbread cookie, finished with chocolate ganache and lightly lathered in chocolate cake crumbs.
Chocolate Tiramisu French Pastry US$8.45
Light and airy chocolate mascarpone cheese loaded with chunks of chocolate chips layered with ever-so-soft moist lady finger chocolate cake soaked in freshly brewed espresso coffee and a hint of coffee syrup, finished with a dark chocolate curl & chocolate cake crumbs.
Pistachio Sunflower French Pastry US$8.45
Pistachio mousse dipped in crunchy pistachio wafer chocolate set beneath a raspberry crémeux sphere, resting on soft vanilla cake & a buttery vanilla sablé cookie finished with a handcrafted white chocolate sunflower and a dollop of raspberry jam
Tres Leches Eclair US$8.95
Delicate √©clair filled with creamy tres leches, topped with fresh strawberries, blackberries, raspberries, and blueberries.
Cheesecake Brownie French Pastry US$8.45
A rich fudgy chocolate brownie topped with a layer of new york style cheesecake, finished with a smooth silky white chocolate ganache
Black Forest French Pastry US$8.45
Silky chocolate mousse infused with sweet and tart black cherries set between layers of soft chocolate cake with cherry syrup
Apple Crumble Tart US$9.75
Freshly diced apples doused in our special cinnamon sugar blend resting in a vanilla sable tart shell topped with baked golden buttery crumble
Lemon Meringue Torte US$9.75
Lemon curd with lemon meringue frosting
Biscoff French Pastry US$8.45
Creamy biscoff cookie butter set atop layers of moist vanilla cake topped with caramel glaze, finished with a Lotus Biscoff cookie, biscoff cookie crumble & a fresh strawberry
Black & White French Pastry US$8.45
Dual layer chocolate and vanilla mousse
Chocolate Cannoli US$6.20
Crispy fried shell dipped in chocolate filled with sweet ricotta cheese and chocolate chip, topped with a dusting of powdered sugar
Custard Eclair US$8.95
Pâte á Choux filled with madagascar vanilla crémeux, topped with dark chocolate whipped ganache & a white chocolate plaque
S'MORES Cream Puff US$8.45
A Cream puff filled with light and airy milk chocolate mousse dipped in rich milk chocolate rolled in graham cracker crumble and finished with a peak of toasted marshmallow fluff
Piece Of Cake French Pastry (Gluten Free) US$8.45
Nutella mousse and salted caramel crémeux glazed in rich chocolate ganache, garnished with caramel chocolate discs and gold leaf (Gluten-Free)
Strawberry Mousse French Pastry US$8.45
Light and airy strawberry crémeux and strawberry jam set atop layers of lemon vanilla cake dipped in strawberry white chocolate & finished with strawberry and vanilla whipped ganache
Passion Fruit Mango French Pastry US$8.95
Tropically sweet yet tangy passion fruit mousse, mango cremeux and vanilla cake set atop a buttery vanilla sable cookie topped with whipped vanilla ganache and passion fruit jelly, enclosed in white chocolate and studded with gold leaf
Hazelnut Chocolate Mousse French Pastry US$8.45
Hazelnut mousse dipped in crunchy hazelnut wafer chocolate setatout whipped gaolate sablé cookie, finished with hazelnut whipped ganache
Bread Pudding US$7.00
Rich, decadent pudding with a warm, fluffy texture, served with a creamy sauce.
Creme Brulee US$9.00
Slowly baked custard cream perfectly doused in sugar that is torched to a golden brittle crust finished with an assortment of fresh berries.
Tropical Tart Coconut Passion Fruit Tartlet US$9.75
Passion fruit mousse set atop vanilla cake in a white chocolate dipped tart
Raspberry Cheesecake French Pastry US$8.45
New York Style Cheesecake set atop of graham cracker crust with a raspberry preserve on top and garnished with fresh raspberries
Salted Caramel Brownie French Pastry US$8.45
A soft chocolate brownie base with one layer of chocolate truly topped with a layer of our famous salted caramel crémeux, studded with roasted buckwheat and a chocolate triangle.
Lemon Strawberry Shortcake French Pastry US$8.45
Vanilla creme infused with strawberry glee loaded with freshly chopped strawberries set atop lemon cake lightly marinated in strawberry syrup, finished with strawberry jam and a strawberry
MatchaMisu (Matcha & Tiramisu) US$8.45
Lady finger matcha cake soaked in matcha syrup set between layers of matcha whipped ganache and mascarpone cheese, finished with dollops of vanilla whipped ganache, matcha glaze & dipped in crunchy pistachio chocolate
Charlotte Royale French Pastry US$8.45
Vanilla Cake, Vanilla French creme, white chocolate ganache icing, and fresh berries on top
Banana Milk Chocolate Bar US$8.45
Banana bread topped with a trio of burnt banana mousse, caramel cremeux & milky chocolate whipped ganache, finished in crunchy hazelnut brittle studded with vanilla diplomat cream and banana chip
Saint Honore Eclair (Vanilla & Praline) US$8.95
Pâte á Choux dual filled with vanilla diplomat crème and nutty praline crémeux, topped with vanilla whipped ganache & salted caramel cream puffs
Lobster Tail US$8.95
Crispy flaky shell baked gorgeously golden filled with light and delicious Bavarian cream.
Pofiteroles French Pastry US$12.25
Chocolate Mousse and Bavarian Cream set inside pastry bowl and finished with whipped cream and chocolate drizzle, garnished with cream puffs

Large Cookies & Sweets
Linzer Tart Cookie US$6.20
Buttery cookie filled with sweet raspberry jam, topped with a dusting of powdered sugar.
Chocolate Chip Cookie US$5.65
Rich, golden-brown cookie studded with semi-sweet chocolate chips.
M&M Cookie US$5.65
A large cookie studded with colorful M&M candies, offering a sweet and crunchy bite in every mouthful.
Chocolate Sprinkle Cookie US$5.65
Covered in chocolate sprinkles, this large cookie offers a delightful crunch with every bite.
Sugar Cookie US$5.65
A large, round sugar cookie with a crisp edge and a generous sprinkle of sugar on top.
Plain Chinese Cookie US$5.60
Delicate, crumbly cookie topped with a rich chocolate center.
Chocolate Marble Chinese Cookie US$5.60
Swirled vanilla and chocolate cookie topped with a rich chocolate center.
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie US$5.65
A hearty oatmeal cookie featuring chewy raisins, offering a classic blend of wholesome oats and sweet dried fruit.
Black & White Cookie US$5.95
A large cookie with one half coated in rich chocolate icing and the other half in sweet vanilla icing.
Rainbow Sprinkle Cookie US$5.65
A soft, round cookie generously covered in colorful rainbow sprinkles.

Cookies by the Pound
2 Pound Assorted Butter Cookie Tray US$67.80
A variety of butter cookies, including classic shapes and flavors, totaling two pounds.
7 Piece Assorted Macaroon Box US$27.45
A selection of seven assorted macaroons featuring a variety of flavors and colors, perfect for a delightful treat.
1.5 Pound Assorted Butter Cookie Tray US$52.40
Assorted butter cookies in various shapes and flavors, baked with butter for a rich, tender texture.

Pies
Mini Pecan Pie US$10.00
Rich, buttery crust filled with a sweet, gooey mixture of caramelized pecans.
Mini Key Lime Pie US$8.75
Creamy key lime pie filling set atop the most wonderful crunchy, sweet and buttery bed of graham cracker crust, finished with whipped cream and decorative lime sugar pieces.
Mini Blueberry Lattice Pie US$10.00
Golden lattice crust envelops a rich, sweet blueberry filling.
Mini Apple Crumb Pie US$10.00
Buttery, crumbly topping over sweet, spiced apple filling in a mini pie.
Mini Cherry Lattice Pie US$10.00
Golden-brown lattice crust with sweet cherry filling, topped with a light sugar sprinkle.
8" Blueberry Lattice Pie US$28.75
Golden-brown lattice crust with sweet, juicy blueberry filling.
8" Cherry Lattice US$28.75
Sweet cherries encased in a flaky, golden lattice crust, topped with a sprinkle of sugar.
Mini Apple Lattice Pie US$10.00
Golden, flaky lattice crust enveloping a sweet, spiced apple filling.
8" Apple Lattice Pie US$28.75
Tender apple slices encased in a golden, flaky lattice crust with a hint of cinnamon and sugar.
8" Pecan Pie US$36.10
Rich, buttery filling topped with toasted pecans in a flaky, golden crust.
Raspberry Torte US$37.45

Coffee / Espresso/ Tea / Hot Coco
Small Hot Chocolate US$4.40
Large Hot Chocolate US$6.90
Small Cold Brew US$6.60
Large Cold Brew US$7.20
Small Hot Coffee US$3.75
Large Hot Coffee US$4.95
Small Iced Coffee US$5.65
Large Iced Coffee US$6.70
Small Hot Latte US$6.25
Large Hot Latte US$6.70
Small Oat Milk Draft Latte US$7.20
Large Oat Milk Draft Latte US$8.15
Small Brown Sugar Oat Milk Draft Latte US$8.70
Large Brown Sugar Oat Milk Draft Latte US$9.70
Small Iced Americano US$5.65
Large Iced Americano US$6.60
Small Cappuccino US$6.00
Large Cappuccino US$6.60
Single Espresso US$4.40
Double Espresso US$5.15
Rich, bold double shot espresso, perfectly concentrated for a robust coffee experience.
Small Iced Macchiato US$5.65
Large Iced Macchiato US$6.20
Small Hot Macchiato US$4.40
Large Hot Macchiato US$5.65
Small Herbal Tea US$3.75
Large Herbal Tea US$4.40
Small Iced Herbal Tea US$4.70
Large Iced Herbal Tea US$5.35

Candles
Number 1 Candle US$5.30
Number 2 Candle US$5.30
Number 6 Candle US$5.30
Number 3 Candle US$5.30
Number 4 Candle US$5.30
Number 5 Candle US$5.30
Number 7 Candle US$5.30
Number 8 Candle US$5.30
Number 9 Candle US$5.30
Number 0 Candle US$5.30
Gold "Happy Birthday" Letter Candles US$5.30
16 Packaged White, Light Pink, Hot Pink, Gold Candles US$5.30
16 Packaged White, Light Blue, Dark Blue, Gold Candles US$5.30
10 Packaged Gold Spiral Candles US$5.30
Multi-Color Balloon Candles US$5.30

Custom Order (Cake, Bread, Cupcakes, Cookies, ETC...)
CUSTOM PICK-UP ORDER ONLY US$10.00
Please note: This is SOLEY for custom orders (items that were already purchased through our custom order department) that are unable to be picked up by the customer themselves - call store (via phone [516-354-3831]) to confirm custom cake is ready for pick up before purchasing this option. This option is NOT for purchasing store items, as the order will not be fulfilled. Please provide us with the following information: 1) Full name on order form 2) Invoice Number 3) Brief description of order details

Father's Day 2025
Tuxedo Cake US$39.95
Vanilla Cake Strawberry & Fresh Cream Tuxedo Decoration
Father's Day Cookie US$6.45

Buttercooky Bakery & Café Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pick-up
In-store shopping
On-site services
Takeaway
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Amenities
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free of charge street parking
Paid street parking

Buttercooky Bakery & Café Photos

Buttercooky Bakery & Café Location

Buttercooky Bakery & Café

New York Nassau County Floral Park Jericho Turnpike

217 Jericho Tpke, Floral Park, NY 11001, USA

Buttercooky Bakery & Café Reviews

An average rating of ★4.3 from 3674 user reviews.

tres lechescakes, cookiesstrawberry shortcakecannolilobsterbutter cookierainbow cookieschocolate moussefruit saladfruit tart

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Buttercooky Bakery & Café in Floral Park is a standout destination for anyone craving high-quality coffee and an impressive variety of desserts. From rich and smooth espresso drinks to beautifully crafted pastries, this bakery delivers on both taste and presentation. Their dessert case is packed with favorites like tres leches cake, strawberry shortcake, pistachio pastries, chocolate mousse, and the popular Dubai chocolate donut. You’ll also find classic butter cookies, mini eclairs, fruit tarts, and seasonal treats that make every visit feel special. With its warm atmosphere, friendly service, and consistently excellent offerings, Buttercooky is easily one of the best bakeries in Floral Park.
July 10 · George Panagopoulos at Douglas Elliman Realestate
We ordered a small 4” Vanilla Mini Birthday Cake from Buttercooky for my son’s 1st birthday cake smash. I was excited to use Buttercooky for this big milestone bc we have ordered from them in the past and have been fans of their pastries. Unfortunately, we were very disappointed to see the lack of care and thought in packaging the cake.The cake itself was placed in a box that was clearly too small/short for the cake, which caused the cake to shift, slide and smear against the sides of the box and the frosting/decoration on the top of the cake became smushed and deformed by the box top.Overall, we were unable to salvage the cake for his birthday cake smash and ended up ordering from another bakery. We do not recommended entrusting Buttercooky for important milestones/events as is evident by the poor packaging of their baked goods.
July 05 · Jennifer C
If you are a chocolate lover try the chocolate tiramisu from Butter Cooky Bakery. The cake is chocolate heaven. The cake has the right amount of sweetness. The cake is moist and decadent. I enjoyed every bite of it. I love tiramisu so this is my first having the chocolate. Did not regret it.The prices are comparable to other bakeries.
June 05 · NUBIAN ASMR
Excellent baked goods. The cannolis are awesome. The staff here are great and friendly.
July 08 · D. Abraham
This was my go to place for decades.I loved this place. Would have had said 5 stars for 30 years.The new layout is no longer conducive to really getting a feel for what you want.Asked for a toasted bagel. No toaster?The cups are terrible.Went to pick up and coffee is now all over my car and shirt.Happened twice.The bagel recipe changed and they are less chewy and more doughy or cake like.Somewhat an insult to a traditional Ny bagel.I’m disappointed all around at a childhood favorite.
June 17 · D W