Captain Cookie & the Milk Man

Introduction / Overview

For anyone in North Carolina with a serious sweet tooth, particularly for the timeless pairing of warm cookies and cold milk, Captain Cookie & the Milk Man offers a nostalgic and high-quality experience right in the heart of Raleigh. Located within the bustling Transfer Co. Food Hall, this small, locally-focused business specializes in a simple, yet perfected menu: scratch-made cookies, local ice cream, and the iconic combination of the two.

The concept is built on a simple foundation, but the execution is gourmet. The founders, who met at UNC Chapel Hill, perfected their cookie recipes over decades, resulting in classic flavors like the Chocolate Chip, Confetti, and Snickerdoodle that consistently draw rave reviews for tasting "almost like homemade." They elevate the experience further by sourcing all their dairy—including the milk and ice cream—from esteemed local North Carolina creameries, such as Homeland Creamery. This dedication to local partnerships ensures maximum freshness and quality in every single offering, from a simple glass of milk to a deluxe, custom ice cream sandwich.

Captain Cookie & the Milk Man is more than just a cookie shop; it's a dedicated dessert destination offering everything from edible cookie dough for immediate gratification to convenient "Bake at Home" kits for cozy nights in. It caters to a quick visit model but fosters a famously friendly atmosphere, proudly serving the entire Raleigh community, including being an established LGBTQ+ friendly and Transgender safespace. This blend of community focus, high-quality, and nostalgic treats makes it a must-visit in downtown Raleigh, NC.

Location and Accessibility

Captain Cookie & the Milk Man enjoys a prime, easily accessible location within one of Raleigh’s most exciting culinary hubs: the Transfer Co. Food Hall. The shop's address is 500 E Davie St, Raleigh, NC 27601, USA. Its position inside the food hall means visitors can easily pair their dessert with a meal from any of the hall’s diverse vendors.

Accessibility is a major highlight, demonstrating a strong commitment to serving all members of the North Carolina community. The location provides a wheelchair accessible entrance, a wheelchair accessible parking lot, and a wheelchair accessible restroom, ensuring a comfortable experience for every patron. For those driving to the food hall, ample free parking is available, including a free parking lot and free street parking, which is a significant convenience for a downtown Raleigh location. With Wi-Fi and restrooms available as food hall amenities, it’s a comfortable, quick-visit spot designed for ease and convenience.

Services Offered

The service model at Captain Cookie & the Milk Man is designed for maximum convenience and flexibility, catering to individual cravings, family treats, and large event needs across the Raleigh area.

• In-Store Shopping / Takeout: Customers can walk up and purchase fresh, scratch-made cookies, ice cream, and drinks for immediate takeout.
• Made-to-Order Ice Cream Sandwiches: Their signature service allows customers to choose any two cookies and a local ice cream flavor to create a custom, fresh sandwich (often referred to as a "chipwich").
• Delivery: All treats, from single cookies to family-sized boxes, are available for local delivery, ensuring the entire menu is accessible from home or office.
• Bulk/Group Orders: Specialized options like the Assorted Half Dozen, Assorted Baker's Dozen ($25.00), and Cookies For A Crowd (Box Of 25) ($50.00) are available for parties, meetings, and events.
• Bake at Home Kits: Selling pre-made, ready-to-bake cookie dough in Dozen ($15.40) and Two Dozen ($28.60) kits, allowing customers to enjoy the aroma and taste of fresh cookies at home.
• Edible Cookie Dough: Offering Cookie Dough (Small - 4oz) ($5.00) and (Large - 8 Oz) ($9.00), safely made with pasteurized eggs and heat-treated flour for a guilt-free raw treat.
• Full Beverage Menu: Serving a variety of beverages including local Milk ($4.00), creamy Milkshakes ($8.80), classic Soda Floats ($6.00), and Coffee, perfectly complementing their desserts.
• Payment Flexibility: Accepting all major methods including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for a quick transaction.

Features / Highlights

Captain Cookie & the Milk Man stands out in the North Carolina dessert scene thanks to its commitment to quality, community, and the perfect combination of classic treats.

• The Iconic Ice Cream Sandwich: Their signature item is a custom-made ice cream sandwich featuring two freshly baked cookies and high-quality local ice cream. The perfect balance—creamy ice cream that doesn't melt too quickly, and a cookie that isn't too hard—is a customer favorite.
• Commitment to Local Dairy: The use of local NC creameries, such as Homeland Creamery, for all milk, milkshakes, and ice cream ensures a superior, farm-fresh dairy experience that supports other North Carolina small businesses.
• Scratch-Made Quality: Cookies are made from scratch daily using time-honored, perfected recipes, guaranteeing a consistent, high-quality, and 'homemade' taste that customers love.
• Community-Focused Space: The business proudly identifies as an LGBTQ+ friendly and Transgender safespace, fostering an inclusive and welcoming environment for all patrons in the Raleigh area.
• Vegan and Gluten-Friendly Options: They offer a dedicated Vegan Chocolate Chip cookie and can provide gluten-friendly options, showing a conscious effort to accommodate various dietary needs while maintaining quality.
• Variety in Format: Offering cookies in three formats (freshly baked, edible raw dough, and bake-at-home kits) provides unique convenience and caters to every type of craving or event planning need.

Contact Information

Whether you need a quick dessert at the food hall or a large order delivered for a party in the Triangle, you can reach Captain Cookie & the Milk Man at their downtown Raleigh location.

Address: 500 E Davie St, Raleigh, NC 27601, USA

Phone: (919) 909-6965

What is Worth Choosing

For North Carolina locals, Captain Cookie & the Milk Man is absolutely worth choosing because it delivers a perfected, nostalgic treat experience backed by a strong commitment to quality and community. This isn't just a basic cookie shop; it's a specialist in the ultimate comfort food duo. You should choose this spot because every element is top-tier: the cookies are scratch-made and fresh out of the oven, and the ice cream and milk are sourced locally from respected North Carolina creameries.

The ability to fully customize your experience, whether it's building your perfect ice cream sandwich, grabbing a jar of safe-to-eat cookie dough, or easily ordering a large party box, makes them the most convenient option for satisfying a powerful sweet craving or handling dessert for a group. Furthermore, by choosing Captain Cookie, you are supporting an inclusive small business that makes accessibility and community friendliness a clear priority, all while enjoying the simple perfection of a classic Chocolate Chip cookie and a cold glass of local milk.

Captain Cookie & the Milk Man

500 E Davie St, Raleigh, NC 27601, USA