Casella Bagel Coffee Shop: Your Neighborhood Guide to Fresh and Affordable Breakfast in Brooklyn

Casella Bagel Coffee Shop Introduce

In the bustling, diverse borough of Brooklyn, finding a reliable neighborhood spot that offers fresh, delicious food at a great price is a true victory for any local. Casella Bagel Coffee Shop is one such place, a cherished eatery that has become a staple for many in the Downtown Brooklyn area. Located on Willoughby Street, this friendly and relaxed cafe is a go-to for starting the day on a positive note. It's the kind of place where you can count on a satisfying meal without having to "break the bank," as one reviewer put it. This article is designed to be your comprehensive guide to Casella Bagel Coffee Shop, providing an in-depth look at what makes this place a valuable part of the community, from its accessible location to its diverse menu and welcoming atmosphere.

Casella Bagel Coffee Shop is more than just a bagel shop; it's a versatile cafe that serves a wide range of breakfast and lunch items. The business is built on a foundation of freshness and quality, with a menu that includes everything from classic New York bagels to made-to-order sandwiches and platters. Customers consistently praise the food for being "fresh and tasty," which is a testament to the care and attention that goes into each order. The atmosphere is described as "friendly and relaxed," which creates a perfect environment for a quick grab-and-go meal or a leisurely coffee break. In a city where speed and efficiency are key, Casella also stands out for its "quick" service, ensuring that even during the busiest hours, customers are served with a smile and minimal wait time.

The affordability of the menu is another major selling point. In a city with a high cost of living, finding quality food at "very reasonable" prices is a significant bonus. This combination of great food, fair pricing, and a friendly vibe makes Casella Bagel Coffee Shop a highly recommended spot for anyone in the Brooklyn area. Whether you're a student, a local resident, or just passing through, this eatery provides a solid, satisfying meal that feels both comforting and high-quality, without the pretense of a high-end restaurant. It's a place that genuinely serves its community, offering a reliable and delicious start to the day.

Location and accessibility are crucial for any successful local business, and Casella Bagel Coffee Shop is perfectly situated to serve a large population. The cafe is located at 66 Willoughby St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA. This address places it in the heart of Downtown Brooklyn, a major commercial and residential hub. The neighborhood is a bustling center of activity, home to numerous office buildings, schools, and apartment complexes, ensuring a steady stream of customers. Its placement on Willoughby Street makes it easily reachable and a natural stop for people on their way to work, school, or running errands.

The cafe is exceptionally accessible via public transportation, which is a major advantage for New Yorkers. It is within a short walking distance of several major subway stations. The Jay St–MetroTech station (A, C, F, R lines) and the DeKalb Avenue station (B, Q, R lines) are both just a few blocks away, providing connections to multiple parts of the city. The Borough Hall station (2, 3, 4, 5 lines) is also a comfortable walk, further expanding its reach. This extensive subway access makes Casella a convenient destination for anyone in Brooklyn or even Manhattan. The area is also well-served by numerous bus routes, and the streets are very walkable, making it easy to get to the cafe on foot. This prime location and ease of access ensure that Casella Bagel Coffee Shop is a reliable and convenient option for a broad customer base.

Casella Bagel Coffee Shop offers a wide and varied menu, with services that cater to the needs of its diverse clientele.

Extensive Breakfast Menu: The cafe specializes in breakfast, offering a wide variety of options including bagels with various cream cheese spreads, breakfast sandwiches, omelettes, and platters.
Made-to-Order Sandwiches and Wraps: In addition to breakfast, they provide a large selection of freshly made sandwiches and wraps, including hot sandwiches, salad sandwiches, and burritos, perfect for a satisfying lunch.
Coffee and Beverages: As a coffee shop, they serve a variety of hot and iced coffee drinks, as well as a selection of other beverages to complement their food.
Quick Service: The staff is known for being friendly and the service is described as "quick," which is ideal for customers on a tight schedule.
Dine-in and Takeaway Options: The cafe provides a relaxed atmosphere for those who want to eat in, while also offering efficient takeaway service for customers on the go.
Delivery Services: Based on public data, the business partners with delivery services like DoorDash, Seamless, and Grubhub, which makes their menu accessible to an even wider audience within the delivery zone.

These services are designed to provide a comprehensive and convenient dining experience for the local community.

Several features and highlights make Casella Bagel Coffee Shop a notable and beloved spot in Brooklyn.

Freshness and Quality: A recurring theme in customer feedback is the freshness and taste of the food. "Everything I tried was fresh and tasty," highlights their commitment to quality ingredients and preparation.
Reasonable Prices: The "very reasonable" prices are a key highlight, especially in a high-cost area like New York. This makes quality breakfast and lunch options accessible to a wider demographic.
Wide Variety of Options: The menu is extensive, offering a vast selection of breakfast platters, sandwiches, and other items. This variety ensures that every customer can find something they love, no matter their preference.
Friendly and Relaxed Atmosphere: The cafe's vibe is a major draw. A "friendly and relaxed atmosphere" makes it a pleasant place to start the day and contrasts with the often-hectic pace of the city.
Efficient Service: With "quick" and friendly service, the cafe is perfect for busy professionals and students who need a fast, yet high-quality, meal.
Neighborhood Staple: Casella Bagel Coffee Shop is a place that feels integrated into the community. It's a reliable, go-to spot that many locals depend on for their daily routines.

These features collectively contribute to the cafe's strong reputation as a local gem.

For all inquiries and to plan your visit, here is the essential contact information for Casella Bagel Coffee Shop.

Address: 66 Willoughby St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA

Phone: (718) 522-5641

For New York locals, particularly those in Brooklyn, Casella Bagel Coffee Shop is a perfect choice for many reasons. Its prime location in Downtown Brooklyn makes it easily accessible for anyone in the area, whether they are a commuter, student, or resident. The unbeatable combination of fresh, tasty food and "very reasonable" prices makes it a practical and appealing option for everyday dining. The wide variety of breakfast and lunch options ensures that there is something for every craving, from a simple bagel to a hearty platter or sandwich. The friendly and efficient service, coupled with a relaxed atmosphere, provides a much-needed moment of calm in the city's fast-paced environment. Casella is not just a place to eat; it's a reliable, comforting presence in the neighborhood that delivers a high-quality experience without any pretense. For any local seeking a solid, satisfying meal that’s both fresh and affordable, Casella Bagel Coffee Shop is a highly recommended and suitable destination.

Casella Bagel Coffee Shop Food & drink

Sandwiches
Turkey Bacon LT Sandwich US$8.50
Pastrami Sandwich US$9.00
Pastrami layered generously between choice of breads, including bagels, wraps, and toasts with selections from plain to whole wheat varieties.
Ham Sandwich US$8.00
most popular a staple in our restaurant
Turkey & Cheese Sandwich US$10.00
Turkey & cheese sandwich with a variety of bread options: bagels, wraps, toast, and croissant. select from bialy, plain to whole wheat choices.
Roast Beef Sandwich US$9.00
Roast beef swiss lettuce tomato mayo and french fries.
Turkey Sandwich US$10.00
Tuna Salad Club Sandwich US$13.00
Boiled egg, lettuce, tomato and French fries.
Turkey Club Sandwich US$15.00
Turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo and French fries.
Ham & Cheese Sandwich US$9.00
most popular a staple in our restaurant
Roast Beef Club Sandwich US$15.00
Roast beef, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, mayo and French fries.
BLT Sandwich US$7.50
most popular a staple in our restaurant
Genoa Salami Sandwich US$8.00
Genoa salami sandwich with a selection of bread including bagels, wraps, toast, and more. choice options range from bialy to whole wheat varieties.
Grilled Cheese Sandwich US$6.00
Grilled Chicken Club Sandwich US$17.00
Grilled chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo and French fries.

Breakfast Griddle Originals
Pancakes With 2 Eggs US$11.25
Pancakes served with choice of egg whites, over easy, over hard, over medium, poached, scrambled, or sunny side up.
Chocolate Chip Pancakes US$11.75
Belgian Waffle With Meat US$12.25
Belgian waffle, choice of bacon, ham, sausage varieties including beef and turkey options.
Silver Dollar Pancakes US$11.75
Pancakes With 2 Eggs & Meat US$13.75
Pancakes served with two eggs, choice of bacon, ham, sausage varieties, or turkey options. eggs prepared to preference.
French Toast With 2 Eggs US$11.25
French toast served with your choice of eggs: white, over easy/medium/hard, poached, scrambled, or sunny side up.
Belgian Waffle With 2 Eggs US$11.25
Belgian waffle served with two eggs, choice of egg whites, over easy, over hard, medium, poached, scrambled, or sunny side up.
Belgian Waffle With 2 Eggs & Meat US$13.75
Belgian waffle served with choice of two eggs prepared to preference, and a selection of bacon, ham, sausage varieties including beef or turkey.
Plain Belgian Waffle US$9.75
The ice cream is not included, only powdered sugar.
Short Stack US$7.25
Pancakes With Meat US$12.25
Pancakes served with choice of ham, various sausages including turkey and beef, or bacon.
Plain French Toast US$9.75
We also have old fashioned French toast available.
French Toast With Meat US$12.25
French toast paired with choice of bacon, ham, sausage varieties, or turkey options.
Pancakes US$9.75
French Toast With 2 Eggs & Meat US$13.75
French toast paired with two eggs, your choice of preparation, and a selection of traditional or turkey-based meats.

Beverages
Hot Chocolate US$3.00
Espresso US$3.00
Herbal Tea US$2.75
Herbal tea in large or small. choose from 14 flavors including chamomile, green tea, and peppermint among others.
Lemon Pure Leaf Tea US$3.50
Brewed using freshly picked tea leaves so every sip is as sweet as the last.
Orange Juice US$3.25
Favorite.
Bottled Water US$1.50
Cranberry Ocean Spray US$3.00
Lipton Tea US$2.00
A sunny, refreshing taste with a delicious blend of tea and tasty citrus flavor.
Iced Coffee US$3.50
Favorite.
Milkshake US$5.25
Vanilla, strawberry, chocolate.
Smart Water US$3.00
20 oz.
Coffee US$2.00
Bottled Soda US$3.00
Bottled soda available in a variety of flavors including citrus, cola, ginger ale, and sparkling grape. choose from brands like pepsi, coke, canada dry, and more.
Cappuccino US$4.50
Rich espresso topped with velvety milk foam. options for large or small.
Iced Tea US$3.50
Refreshing iced tea. options include large or small.
Snapple US$3.50
Snapple tea in various flavors including apple, diet peach, fruit punch, and more. choose from classic and diet options.
Flavored Iced Coffee US$4.50
Iced coffee available in large or small, with flavors including amaretto, banana, caramel, chocolate, french vanilla, hazelnut, irish cream, raspberry, and strawberry.
CafÃ© Mocha US$4.75
Espresso with steamed milk, chocolate, topped with whipped cream. options for large or small sizes.
Apple & Eve Juice US$3.00
Flavored Coffee US$3.00
Coffee in large or small sizes. choose from banana, caramel, chocolate, french vanilla, hazelnut, raspberry, or strawberry flavors.
Canned Soda US$2.00
Canned soda available in a variety of flavors including citrus, cola, diet options, and sparkling grape. choose from brisk, several canada dry varieties, coke, pepsi, and more.
Jarritos US$3.75
CafÃ© Latte US$4.50
Steamed milk and espresso, available in large or small.
Decaf Coffee US$2.00
Simply Juice US$2.75
Simply juice, available in mango, orange, or raspberry lemonade flavors.
Gatorade US$2.50
Sports drink available in cool blue, fruit punch, or orange flavors.
Vitamin Water US$3.50
Dragon-fruit, tropical citrus, â€‹acai-blueberry-pomegranate.

Breakfast Sandwiches
1 Egg With Meat & Cheese Sandwich US$7.00
Favorite.
Hungry Man US$12.00
Only served on hero. Bacon, ham, sausage with three eggs and home fries.
1 Egg With Cheese Sandwich US$4.50
One egg and cheese on a choice of breads, including bagels, wraps, toast, and croissants. variety of flavors like cinnamon raisin, onion, whole wheat, and sesame seed.
1 Egg With Meat Sandwich US$6.00
1 egg sandwich paired with choice of meat: bacon, ham, sausage varieties, or turkey options. select from 16 bread types, including bagels, wraps, and toasts.
1 Egg Sandwich US$3.75
One egg sandwich with a choice of bread: bagels (various types including cinnamon raisin, everything, onion, sesame seed, whole wheat), wraps (plain, spinach, whole wheat), and more (bialy, croissant, hero, roll, rye toast, white toast, whole wheat toast).

Sandwiches
Ham & Cheese Sandwich US$9.00
most popular a staple in our restaurant
Ham Sandwich US$8.00
most popular a staple in our restaurant
Tuna Salad Club Sandwich US$13.00
Boiled egg, lettuce, tomato and French fries.
Roast Beef Sandwich US$9.00
Roast beef swiss lettuce tomato mayo and french fries.
Roast Beef Club Sandwich US$15.00
Roast beef, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, mayo and French fries.
Turkey Club Sandwich US$15.00
Turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo and French fries.
Grilled Chicken Club Sandwich US$17.00
Grilled chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo and French fries.
Turkey & Cheese Sandwich US$10.00
Turkey & cheese sandwich with a variety of bread options: bagels, wraps, toast, and croissant. select from bialy, plain to whole wheat choices.
Turkey Sandwich US$9.00
Turkey sandwich with choice of bread: bagels (various), wraps (plain, spinach, whole wheat), croissant, hero, rolls, toast (rye, white, whole wheat).
Grilled Cheese Sandwich US$6.00
Pastrami Sandwich US$9.00
Pastrami layered generously between choice of breads, including bagels, wraps, and toasts with selections from plain to whole wheat varieties.
Genoa Salami Sandwich US$8.00
Genoa salami sandwich with a selection of bread including bagels, wraps, toast, and more. choice options range from bialy to whole wheat varieties.
BLT Sandwich US$7.50
most popular a staple in our restaurant
Turkey Bacon LT Sandwich US$8.50
Turkey bacon with crisp lettuce and tomato, choice of bread including bagel varieties, wraps, and toasts.

Breakfast Morning Starters
Bagel With Butter & Jelly US$3.25
Bagel served with butter & jelly. choose from bialy, cinnamon raisin, croissant, and various bagels or wraps including whole wheat options.
Bagel With Veggie Cream Cheese US$5.75
Bagel With Peanut Butter US$4.00
Bagel spread with creamy peanut butter. bread options: bialy, various bagels (cinnamon raisin + more), croissant, hero, wraps, toast (rye, white, whole wheat).
Bagel With Peanut Butter & Jelly US$4.75
Bagel served with peanut butter and jelly. choice of bread includes bagels, wraps, toast variants, and more.
Bagel With Nutella & Banana US$5.75
Bagel toasted with hazelnut spread and banana slices.
Bagel With Cream Cheese US$3.75
Muffin With Butter US$3.75
Grits US$4.00
Bagel US$2.00
Bagel With Butter US$2.50
Muffin With Butter & Jelly US$4.00
Choice of muffin: banana, blueberry, corn, honey raisin bran, or walnut. served with butter and jelly.
Bagel With Nutella US$4.50
Creamy nutella spread on a choice of breads, including bagels, croissants, wraps, and toasts with various flavors.
Muffin US$3.50
Bagel With Scallion Cream Cheese US$5.75
Oatmeal US$4.00

Breakfast Wraps
Florentine Wrap US$11.50
Ham, egg, onions, peppers, olives
Low Wrap US$11.75
Turkey, egg white, Swiss, onions, peppers
American Wrap US$11.50
Bacon, egg, cheese, home fries
Mexican Wrap US$12.25
Chicken, egg, cheese, jalapeño, onions, peppers

Gyro
Chicken Gyro Sandwich US$10.75
Gyro Sandwich US$10.75
Chicken Gyro Platter US$13.00
Gyro Platter US$13.00
Comes with small salad, small French fries, tzatziki sauce, choice of meat. No substitution isâ€‹ available.

Breakfast Platters
2 Eggs With Meat US$10.75
Price can vary depending on meat chosen and add-ons.
2 Eggs With Fish Flounder US$13.25
Two eggs, choice of preparation, paired with tender fish flounder. served with a side of french fries, grits, or home fries.
2 Eggs With Steak US$17.75
Price can vary depending on meat chosen and add-ons
2 Eggs Any Style US$9.75
Two eggs prepared to order: choose from egg whites, over easy, hard, medium, poached, scrambled, or sunny side up. served with a side: fries, grits, or home fries.

Side Orders
Green Plantains US$5.50
Onion Rings US$5.50
Ripe Plantains US$5.50
Mozzarella Sticks US$8.75
6 pcs.
Rice US$5.00
Buffalo Chicken Wings US$9.75
6 pcs.
French Fries With Cheese US$6.50
French Fries US$5.50
Beans US$5.00
Home Fries US$5.50

Hamburgers
Cheeseburger US$8.25
Bacon Burger US$8.00
Chicken Burger US$10.00
Beef Burger US$7.00
Casella Burger US$11.00
Ham, cheese, one egg and avocado.
Turkey Burger US$8.75
Salmon Burger US$8.75
Mushroom Burger US$7.00
Double Burger US$9.00

Breakfast Griddle Originals
Belgian Waffle With 2 Eggs & Meat US$13.00
Chocolate Chip Pancakes US$11.00
Short Stack US$6.25
French Toast With 2 Eggs US$10.50
French toast served with your choice of eggs: white, over easy/medium/hard, poached, scrambled, or sunny side up.
Pancakes With 2 Eggs US$10.50
Pancakes With 2 Eggs & Meat US$13.00
Pancakes served with two eggs, choice of bacon, ham, sausage varieties, or turkey options. eggs prepared to preference.
Pancakes With Meat US$11.50
Silver Dollar Pancakes US$11.00
Belgian Waffle With 2 Eggs US$10.50
Belgian Waffle With Meat US$11.50
French Toast With 2 Eggs & Meat US$13.00
French toast paired with two eggs, your choice of preparation, and a selection of traditional or turkey-based meats.
Plain French Toast US$9.00
We also have old fashioned French toast available.
French Toast With Meat US$11.50
French toast paired with choice of bacon, ham, sausage varieties, or turkey options.
Plain Belgian Waffle US$9.00
The ice cream is not included, only powdered sugar.
Pancakes US$9.00

Breakfast Morning Starters
Bagel With Butter & Jelly US$4.00
Bagel served with butter & jelly. choose from bialy, cinnamon raisin, croissant, and various bagels or wraps including whole wheat options.
Bagel With Peanut Butter & Jelly US$5.50
Bagel served with peanut butter and jelly. choice of bread includes bagels, wraps, toast variants, and more.
Bagel US$2.25
Bagel served with choice of bread, including bialy, various bagels (cinnamon raisin, everything, onion, sesame seed, plain, whole wheat), croissant, hero, wraps (plain, spinach, whole wheat), and toast options (rye, white, whole wheat).
Bagel With Veggie Cream Cheese US$6.50
Served with veggie cream cheese, choice of bread including everything, onion, sesame seed, whole wheat bagels, croissant, wraps, and various toasts.
Bagel With Peanut Butter US$4.75
Bagel spread with creamy peanut butter. bread options: bialy, various bagels (cinnamon raisin + more), croissant, hero, wraps, toast (rye, white, whole wheat).
Grits US$5.00
Muffin US$4.25
Muffin With Butter & Jelly US$4.75
Choice of muffin: banana, blueberry, corn, honey raisin bran, or walnut. served with butter and jelly.
Bagel With Scallion Cream Cheese US$6.50
Scallion cream cheese spread over choice of bread, including wraps, toasts, and bagels with various toppings.
Bagel With Nutella & Banana US$6.00
Bagel toasted with hazelnut spread and banana slices.
Oatmeal US$5.00
Bagel With Cream Cheese US$4.50
Bagel, schmeared with cream cheese, choice of bialy, various bagels, croissant, wraps, or toast options.
Bagel With Butter US$3.25
Served with butter, choice of bread includes bialy, varied bagels (cinnamon raisin, everything, onion, plain, sesame seed, whole wheat), croissant, hero, wraps (plain, spinach, whole wheat), and toast options (rye, white, whole wheat).
Bagel With Nutella US$5.25
Creamy nutella spread on a choice of breads, including bagels, croissants, wraps, and toasts with various flavors.
Muffin With Butter US$4.00
Butter-topped choice of banana, blueberry, corn, honey raisin bran, or walnut muffin.

Breakfast Wraps
Florentine Wrap US$10.75
Ham, egg, onions, peppers, olives
Low Wrap US$11.00
Turkey, egg white, Swiss, onions, peppers
Mexican Wrap US$11.50
Chicken, egg, cheese, jalapeño, onions, peppers
American Wrap US$10.75
Bacon, egg, cheese, home fries

Wraps
California Wrap US$16.25
Turkey, lettuce, tomatoes, avocado, bacon and ranch dressing.
Chicken Cheesesteak Wrap US$13.50
Grilled chicken, onions, peppers and cheese.
Tuna Salad Wrap US$11.25
Tuna salad with lettuce, tomatoes and mayo.
Philly Cheesesteak Wrap US$13.50
Steak with onions, peppers and cheese.
Chicken Salad Wrap US$11.25
Chicken salad with lettuce, tomatoes and mayo.
Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap US$12.00
Grilled chicken breast, romaine lettuce, croutons, parmesan cheese and Caesar dressing.
Grilled Chicken Wrap US$12.00
Grilled chicken breast with lettuce, tomatoes, cheese and mayo.
Vegetarian Wrap US$12.00
Lettuce, tomatoes, broccoli, mushrooms, onions, peppers and avocado.
Grilled Chicken BLT Wrap US$12.75
Grilled chicken breast with lettuce, tomato and bacon.

Breakfast Omelette Platters
Veggie Omelette US$11.00
Tomatoes, onions, peppers and mushrooms.
Avocado Omelette US$12.00
Avocado, peppers, onions and cheddar cheese.
Greek Omelette US$11.50
Feta cheese and tomato.
Spanish Omelette US$11.50
Tomatoes, onions and peppers with red sauce.
Plain Omelette US$9.00
Plain omelette served with your choice of rye, white, or whole wheat toast. select a side from french fries, grits, or home fries.
Ham Omelette US$10.50
Ham omelette served with your choice of rye, white, or whole wheat toast. choice of french fries, grits, or home fries on the side.
Western Omelette US$12.00
Ham, tomatoes, onions and peppers.
Spinach Omelette US$10.50
Tomatoes onions and peppers with red sauce.
Athenian Omelette US$15.00
Gyro meat, spinach, tomatoes, onions, peppers and feta cheese.
Turkey Bacon Omelette US$11.50
Turkey bacon mixed into fluffy eggs, served with choice of rye, white, or whole wheat toast. options for side include french fries, grits, or home fries.
Cheese Omelette US$10.50
Cheese omelette served with choice of rye, white, or whole wheat toast. includes side options of french fries, grits, or home fries.
Bacon Omelette US$10.50
Bacon omelette served with your choice of rye, white, or whole wheat toast. choose a side of french fries, grits, or home fries.
Casella Omelette US$13.00
Sliced turkey, onions, peppers and tomato.
Low Cholesterol Omelette US$11.50
Onion, peppers, mushrooms and egg whites.

Salads
Caesar Salad US$8.00
Classic caesar salad with crisp romaine, parmesan, croutons, and signature caesar dressing.
Tuna Salad US$8.75
Chicken Salad US$8.75
Chicken salad with lettuce tomatoes and mayo.
Green Salad US$5.00
Egg Salad US$7.00
Greek Salad US$10.00
Chef Salad US$12.50

Breakfast Platters
2 Eggs With Steak US$17.00
Price can vary depending on meat chosen and add-ons
2 Eggs With Fish Flounder US$12.50
Two eggs, choice of preparation, paired with tender fish flounder. served with a side of french fries, grits, or home fries.
2 Eggs With Meat US$10.00
Price can vary depending on meat chosen and add-ons.
2 Eggs Any Style US$9.00
Two eggs prepared to order: choose from egg whites, over easy, hard, medium, poached, scrambled, or sunny side up. served with a side: fries, grits, or home fries.

Beverages
Coffee US$2.00
Hot coffee, available in large or small sizes.
Orange Juice US$3.25
Favorite.
Bottled Water US$1.50
Bottled water in various sizes: 16.9 oz, 23.7 oz, 33.8 oz, 50.7 oz.
Herbal Tea US$2.75
Herbal tea in large or small. choose from 14 flavors including chamomile, green tea, and peppermint among others.
Cranberry Ocean Spray US$3.00
Flavored Iced Coffee US$4.50
Iced coffee available in large or small, with flavors including amaretto, banana, caramel, chocolate, french vanilla, hazelnut, irish cream, raspberry, and strawberry.
Apple & Eve Juice US$3.00
Bottled Soda US$3.00
Bottled soda available in a variety of flavors including citrus, cola, ginger ale, and sparkling grape. choose from brands like pepsi, coke, canada dry, and more.
Gatorade US$3.00
Sports drink available in cool blue, fruit punch, or orange flavors.
Lemon Pure Leaf Tea US$3.50
Brewed using freshly picked tea leaves so every sip is as sweet as the last.
Iced Coffee US$3.50
Favorite.
Decaf Coffee US$2.00
Vitamin Water US$3.50
Dragon-fruit, tropical citrus, â€‹acai-blueberry-pomegranate.
Snapple US$3.50
Snapple tea in various flavors including apple, diet peach, fruit punch, and more. choose from classic and diet options.
Cappuccino US$4.50
Rich espresso topped with velvety milk foam. options for large or small.
CafÃ© Latte US$4.50
Steamed milk and espresso, available in large or small.
Canned Soda US$2.00
Canned soda available in a variety of flavors including citrus, cola, diet options, and sparkling grape. choose from brisk, several canada dry varieties, coke, pepsi, and more.
Jarritos US$3.75
Mexican soda in various fruit flavors including fruit punch, citrus, mango, pineapple, or tamarind.
Smart Water US$3.00
20 oz.
Flavored Coffee US$3.00
Coffee in large or small sizes. choose from banana, caramel, chocolate, french vanilla, hazelnut, raspberry, or strawberry flavors.
Hot Chocolate US$3.00
Creamy hot chocolate, available in large or small sizes.
Simply Juice US$2.75
Simply juice, available in mango, orange, or raspberry lemonade flavors.
Lipton Tea US$2.00
Lipton tea; choice of large or small.
Espresso US$3.00
Espresso, available in double or single shots.
Milkshake US$5.25
Vanilla, strawberry, chocolate.
Iced Tea US$3.50
Refreshing iced tea. options include large or small.
CafÃ© Mocha US$4.75
Espresso with steamed milk, chocolate, topped with whipped cream. options for large or small sizes.

Hamburgers
Double Burger US$9.00
Two patties, selection of meat temperature: medium to well done.
Bacon Burger US$8.00
Bacon-topped hamburger, choice of meat temperature: from rare to well done.
Turkey Burger US$8.75
Beef Burger US$7.00
Beef burger with choice of meat temperature: medium, medium rare, medium well, rare, well done.
Chicken Burger US$10.00
Mushroom Burger US$7.00
Cheeseburger US$8.25
Cheeseburger with choice of meat temperature: medium, medium rare, medium well, rare, well done.
Salmon Burger US$8.75
Casella Burger US$11.00
Ham, cheese, one egg and avocado.

Breakfast Sandwiches
1 Egg With Cheese Sandwich US$5.25
One egg and cheese on a choice of breads, including bagels, wraps, toast, and croissants. variety of flavors like cinnamon raisin, onion, whole wheat, and sesame seed.
1 Egg With Meat & Cheese Sandwich US$7.50
Favorite.
1 Egg With Meat Sandwich US$5.50
1 egg sandwich paired with choice of meat: bacon, ham, sausage varieties, or turkey options. select from 16 bread types, including bagels, wraps, and toasts.
1 Egg Sandwich US$4.50
One egg sandwich with a choice of bread: bagels (various types including cinnamon raisin, everything, onion, sesame seed, whole wheat), wraps (plain, spinach, whole wheat), and more (bialy, croissant, hero, roll, rye toast, white toast, whole wheat toast).
Hungry Man US$12.75
Only served on hero. Bacon, ham, sausage with three eggs and home fries.

Burritos
Grilled Chicken Burrito US$12.00
The delicious burrito comes with rice, beans, lettuce, tomato, cheese, and sour cream.
Roast Pork Burrito US$12.00
This delicious burrito comes with rice, beans, lettuce, tomato, cheese, and sour cream.
Beef Steak Burrito US$14.50
The delicious burrito comes with rice, beans, lettuce, tomato, cheese, and sour cream.

Salad Sandwiches
Chicken Salad Sandwich Deluxe US$15.00
Chicken salad with a deluxe assortment of bread options including bagels, wraps, toasts, and more. choose from 16 varieties like bialy, croissant, or spinach wrap.
Tuna Salad Sandwich Deluxe US$15.00
Tuna salad sandwich with customizable bread options, including bagels, wraps, toast, and croissants. choose your favorite from a variety of flavors and types.
Tuna Salad Sandwich US$9.00
Boiled egg lettuce tomato and french fries.
Chicken Salad Sandwich US$9.00
Chicken salad with a variety of bread options, including bagels, wraps, toast, and croissants. select from classic to whole wheat varieties.
Egg Salad Sandwich US$8.00
Egg salad nestled between your choice of bread including bagels, wraps, croissants, or toast with a variety of flavors like plain, sesame seed, everything, and more.
Egg Salad Sandwich Deluxe US$15.00
Egg salad sandwich with choice of bread: bagels, wraps, toast varieties, croissant, or hero.

Hot Sandwiches
Cuban Sandwich US$13.00
Favorite. Most popular* a staple in our restaurant!.
Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich US$12.50
Most popular.
Grilled Chicken Sandwich US$9.25
Grilled chicken bacon lettuce tomato mayo and french fries.
Tuna Melt Sandwich US$10.50
Tuna melt on choice of bread: bialy to whole wheat wrap. various bagels, wraps, and toast options.
Sausage & Peppers Sandwich US$10.00
Sausage & peppers with choice of bread: including bagels, wraps, toast, and croissants.
Reuben Sandwich US$13.00
most popular a staple in our restaurant
Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich US$13.00
Comes on a hero.
Chicken Cheesesteak Sandwich US$12.50
Choice of various breads envelops tender chicken cheesesteak: from bagels and wraps to toasts and rolls. options include bialy, croissant, and more for customization.
Chicken Cutlet Sandwich US$9.25
Crispy chicken cutlet with a variety of bread options including bagels, wraps, toast, and croissants. choose from classics to whole wheat varieties.
Fish Flounder Sandwich US$11.00
Comes on a hero.
Roast Pork Sandwich US$11.00
Roast pork sandwich with multiple bread options including bagels, wraps, toast, and croissants. choose from bialy to whole wheat varieties.
Meatball Sandwich US$10.00
Grilled Cheese Sandwich US$6.00
Steak & Onions Sandwich US$11.00

Hot Sandwiches
Steak & Onions Sandwich US$11.00
Tender steak and caramelized onions on choice of bialy, various bagels, croissant, hero, wrap, roll, toast including whole wheat, spinach, and plain options.
Roast Pork Sandwich US$11.00
Roast pork sandwich with multiple bread options including bagels, wraps, toast, and croissants. choose from bialy to whole wheat varieties.
Chicken Cutlet Sandwich US$9.25
Crispy chicken cutlet with a variety of bread options including bagels, wraps, toast, and croissants. choose from classics to whole wheat varieties.
Tuna Melt Sandwich US$10.50
Tuna melt on choice of bread: bialy to whole wheat wrap. various bagels, wraps, and toast options.
Meatball Sandwich US$10.00
Meatballs nestled with marinara sauce in choice of breads including bialy, various bagels, wraps, or toast.
Sausage & Peppers Sandwich US$10.00
Sausage & peppers with choice of bread: including bagels, wraps, toast, and croissants.
Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich US$12.50
Most popular.
Fish Flounder Sandwich US$11.00
Comes on a hero.
Reuben Sandwich US$13.00
most popular a staple in our restaurant
Grilled Cheese Sandwich US$6.00
Grilled cheese on choice of bread: from classic white toast to whole wheat wrap and everything in-between, including onion and sesame seed bagels.
Cuban Sandwich US$13.00
Favorite. Most popular* a staple in our restaurant!.
Chicken Cheesesteak Sandwich US$12.50
Choice of various breads envelops tender chicken cheesesteak: from bagels and wraps to toasts and rolls. options include bialy, croissant, and more for customization.
Grilled Chicken Sandwich US$9.25
Grilled chicken bacon lettuce tomato mayo and french fries.
Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich US$13.00
Comes on a hero.

Casella Bagel Coffee Shop Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pick-up
On-site services
Takeaway
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Amenities
Toilet

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
NFC mobile payments

Parking
Paid street parking

Casella Bagel Coffee Shop Photos

Casella Bagel Coffee Shop Location

Casella Bagel Coffee Shop

New York Kings County Downtown Brooklyn Willoughby Street

66 Willoughby St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA

Casella Bagel Coffee Shop Reviews

An average rating of ★4.3 from 187 user reviews.

breakfasttake outdinerplattertunaponyfood and servicearea

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Casella Bagel is a great spot for breakfast! There’s a wide variety of options, and everything I tried was fresh and tasty.The prices are very reasonable, especially considering the quality of the food.The place has a friendly and relaxed atmosphere, perfect for starting the day on a good note.Highly recommended if you’re looking for a solid, satisfying breakfast without breaking the bank!
July 09 · Pietro Alfano
Nice little coffee shop. Food is made fresh to order, they have a lot of breakfast options and sandwiches. Staff is friendly and the service is quick.
April 06 · H L
I got FLEECED by them towards the end of their day because they didnt make their sales goal and they think Ive never been to a Dominican spot before.Charged me $26 for two large rice and beans and maduros. No one ever, especially in this dingy hole in the wall, ever charged this amount for JUST rice and beans.I heard the chef tell the hostess they need to make more maduros, which they didnt; instead of selling me one, they just put what they had in 2 containers and charged it as 2 orders. The photo is simply not $5 each of maduros. Pretended not to hear me when I told them I just want sides.The hostess called it a "veggie platter", which, frankly, is not a thing here.
January 15 · Jennifer Cheng
Get the cheese empanadas, they make them fresh and they’re so good. Crunchy and lots of cheeeese
May 09 · Michie Aranguren
Visited this place based on reviews and glad I did. The breakfast was delicious. It reminded me of diner food which I love. The staff was really sweet. I also thought the price was really reasonable as well. If I stay in this area again, I will be back!
February 21 · Brittenay Causieeetko