Collegetown Bagels (College Ave): Ithaca's Go-To for Bagels, Sandwiches & More

Collegetown Bagels Introduce

ithaca bakery bagels

In the vibrant and bustling neighborhood of Collegetown in Ithaca, New York, intimately connected to the renowned Cornell University, stands a local institution that has become a staple for countless residents and visitors: Collegetown Bagels on College Avenue. More than just a simple bagel shop, this location serves as a lively hub, offering an impressive array of bagels, creative sandwiches, and an assortment of drinks and tempting desserts. For New Yorkers in the Finger Lakes region, particularly those in and around the academic heart of Ithaca, this Collegetown Bagels branch provides a dynamic and diverse culinary experience.

Collegetown Bagels at 420 College Ave is a place where variety truly shines. It caters to a wide range of tastes and preferences, ensuring that there’s "definitely something for everyone here." Whether you're a student grabbing a quick bite between classes, a local resident enjoying a leisurely morning, or a visitor exploring the unique charm of Ithaca, this spot offers a welcoming atmosphere. Its ability to draw a consistent crowd, even during non-peak academic seasons, speaks to its enduring appeal and quality offerings.

While some experiences may vary, particularly concerning service speed or individual interactions, the overall consensus points to Collegetown Bagels as a reliable choice for a hearty meal or a delightful treat. The charm of its outdoor seating, especially during quieter times, adds to its allure, making it a perfect spot to soak in the local ambiance. It’s a testament to the diverse and engaging food scene that thrives within Ithaca.

---

Location and Accessibility

Collegetown Bagels is conveniently situated at 420 College Ave, Ithaca, NY 14850, USA. This address places it squarely in the heart of Collegetown, the lively commercial and residential district directly adjacent to Cornell University. This location is one of the most vibrant and accessible areas in Ithaca, known for its student-centric atmosphere and a mix of shops, eateries, and academic buildings.

College Avenue itself is a central artery within Collegetown, making the bagel shop highly visible and easy to find for anyone navigating the area. For students and faculty of Cornell University, it's typically within comfortable walking distance from dorms, academic buildings, and campus facilities. For other residents of Ithaca, the location is well-served by local public transportation, and while street parking in Collegetown can sometimes be competitive, various parking garages and lots are usually available within a short walk. The option for outdoor seating further enhances its appeal, especially during pleasant weather, allowing patrons to enjoy their meals while soaking in the local College Avenue vibe.

The strategic placement of Collegetown Bagels on College Avenue ensures it remains a prime destination for a wide demographic, from those exploring Ithaca's famous gorges and university grounds to those simply looking for a convenient and delicious meal in a lively urban setting.

---

Services Offered

Collegetown Bagels on College Avenue offers an expansive menu that extends far beyond traditional bagel shop fare, positioning itself as a comprehensive cafe and eatery. Their diverse offerings cater to breakfast, lunch, and snack needs throughout the day. Here’s a detailed look at their services:

Wide Variety of Bagels: As their name implies, bagels are a core offering. They provide numerous bagel varieties (e.g., Plain, Poppy, Sesame, Rosemary Salt, Long Island Everything, Whole Wheat Everything, Za'atar Sesame, Spicy Italian, Cinnamon Raisin, Granola, Honey Wheat, Salt). All bagels except the honey one are vegan.
Creative Sandwiches: Customers highlight their "creative sandwiches" as a major draw. These range from classic breakfast sandwiches with eggs and various meats (bacon, sausage, chicken sausage, pastrami, roast beef) to more elaborate lunch options like the "Zabs" (turkey, avocado, chipotle aioli on ciabatta), "Frickin' Chicken" (pesto chicken, asiago, mushrooms on focaccia), "Renwick Reuben," and many more. They also offer a "Build Your Own Sandwich" option.
Extensive Cream Cheese and Spreads: A vast selection of cream cheese flavors is available, including Plain, Chive, Scallion, Parsley Garlic, Green Olive, Cinnamon Raisin, Honey Walnut, Jalapeño, Veggie, Bacon Scallion, and Nova. Other spreads like various hummuses and a Raspberry Jalapeño Jam are also offered.
Vegetarian and Vegan Options: Collegetown Bagels is very accommodating to dietary preferences, offering a wide array of clearly labeled vegetarian and vegan options. This includes vegan bagels, vegan cream cheese (e.g., tofu cream cheese), vegan chicken salad, seitan sandwiches, Beyond Egg and Beyond Sausage options, and vegan soups, salads, and baked goods.
Salads and Bowls: They offer a range of fresh salads (e.g., Chicken Caesar, Greek, Strawberry Fields, Vegan Caesar) and warm grain bowls (e.g., Bahn Voyage with chicken or tofu, Brain Power, Brekky Bowl, Jerk-Island Vibes) providing healthier and substantial meal choices.
Soups: Daily soup selections are available, typically starting from mid-morning, with at least one vegan soup option often featured.
Coffee, Tea & Beverages: A full range of cafe beverages including coffee, espresso drinks, various teas, and smoothies are offered. Seasonal specialties like the "seasonal cookie butter chai latte" are also available.
Desserts and Baked Goods: Beyond bagels, they offer a tempting assortment of other baked goods and desserts, appealing to those with a sweet tooth.
Outdoor Seating: The location provides outdoor seating, allowing customers to enjoy their meals al fresco, which enhances the dining experience, especially during pleasant weather.

---

Features / Highlights

Collegetown Bagels on College Avenue possesses several distinctive features and highlights that contribute to its popularity and standing in the Ithaca community. These aspects create a unique and appealing experience for its patrons:

Expansive and Creative Menu: A key highlight is the sheer breadth and creativity of their menu. It goes far beyond standard bagel shop fare, offering innovative sandwich combinations, diverse salad and bowl options, and a wide array of bagels and cream cheeses. This extensive selection ensures that repeat visits always offer something new to try.
Abundant Vegetarian and Vegan Choices: For a community like Ithaca, which has a strong focus on conscious eating, the explicitly labeled and numerous vegetarian and vegan options are a significant draw. From vegan bagels and cream cheeses to plant-based proteins in sandwiches and salads, they cater comprehensively to these dietary needs.
Vibrant College Town Atmosphere: The location itself contributes to the experience. When school is in session, it's bustling with student life, and even "with school out of session," it maintains a "quiet" and charming "calm summer vibe," making it adaptable to different times of the year and preferences.
Outdoor Seating: The availability of "outdoor sitting" is a major plus, allowing customers to enjoy the fresh air and the "good location vibe," which is particularly appreciated during pleasant weather.
Community Hub: As an "icon and community space," Collegetown Bagels serves as more than just an eatery; it's a meeting point, a place for study breaks, and an integral part of the Cornell and Ithaca culture.
Freshly Prepared Ingredients: While one review noted that "the taste of sandwiches were pretty average," the general sentiment and the variety of fresh ingredients available suggest a commitment to using good quality components.
"Something for Everyone": This frequently echoed sentiment highlights the inclusivity of their menu, making it suitable for groups with diverse preferences.

While some customers have noted occasional issues with slow service or staff demeanor, the overall positive feedback on menu variety, quality of options, and the general ambiance remains strong, making these points notable highlights.

---

Contact Information

To experience the wide array of offerings at Collegetown Bagels on College Avenue, or for any inquiries, you can use the following contact details:

Address: 420 College Ave, Ithaca, NY 14850, USA

Phone: (607) 273-0982

---

Conclusion: Why Collegetown Bagels (College Ave) is Suitable for Locals

For residents of Ithaca, particularly those living in or frequently visiting Collegetown and the Cornell University campus, Collegetown Bagels at 420 College Avenue is exceptionally suitable and a true local asset. Its multifaceted appeal caters directly to the lifestyle and preferences of the community.

Firstly, the "great variety" of meal choices is a significant draw. Locals appreciate having a single establishment where they can find an extensive selection of bagels, creative sandwiches, enticing desserts, and a wide range of beverages. This eliminates the need to visit multiple places for different cravings, making it a convenient one-stop shop for breakfast, lunch, or a quick snack. The inclusion of numerous and clearly labeled vegetarian and vegan options further solidifies its local appeal, aligning with Ithaca's progressive and health-conscious ethos, ensuring that diverse dietary needs are well met.

Secondly, the vibrant atmosphere and outdoor seating options contribute significantly to its suitability. Whether it's the bustling energy during the academic year or the "calm summer vibes" when school is out, the location provides a comfortable and engaging environment for dining, socializing, or even studying. For locals, having a pleasant spot to sit outside and enjoy a meal in the heart of Collegetown is a cherished amenity, enhancing their daily routine.

While some reviews mention occasional issues with slow service or individual staff interactions, the overall consistent popularity and the core strength of its diverse menu maintain its standing as a favored local spot. The ability to find "something for everyone here" makes it an ideal choice for friends, families, and colleagues with varying tastes, simplifying meal decisions and fostering a sense of community gathering.

In essence, Collegetown Bagels on College Avenue is more than just a place to eat; it's a reflection of Ithaca's dynamic spirit. It offers convenience, variety, and an appealing atmosphere that resonates deeply with the needs and values of its local patrons, solidifying its role as an indispensable part of the Collegetown experience.

Collegetown Bagels Menu

Breakfast
Served All Day!
6 Mile Creek US$14.25
Sourdough toast with avocado, aioli dressing, tomatoes, onions, and capers topped with lox
Big Buck US$7.05
Cage-free egg, green peppers, red onion and sausage in a whole wheat wrap
Big Sur
Sausage, cage-free egg, tomato and melted Pepper Jack cheese on a bagel
Bronx Bagel
Cage-free egg with sausage on a bagel
Bronx With American Cheese
Cage-free egg with sausage and American cheese on a bagel
Brooklyn Bagel
Cage-free egg with bacon on a bagel
Brooklyn With American Cheese
Cage-free egg with bacon and American cheese on a bagel
Bus Stop US$9.20
Chicken sausage, cage-free egg, tomato, & Pepper Jack cheese on oatmeal wheat bread panini pressed
California Sunrise
Cage-free egg with avocado, red onion and melted Pepper Jack cheese on a bagel
Earlybird US$9.50
Chicken sausage, cage-free egg, cream cheese, honey, apples, and melted Cheddar cheese on a sourdough bread
Eggs Christina
Cage-free egg with ham on a bagel
Eggs Melissa
Cage-free egg with melted Cheddar cheese on a bagel
Green St. US$8.50
Egg whites with arugula, pesto, tomato, and melted feta cheese on an English muffin
Huevos Sonora US$7.70
Cage-free egg, avocado, fresh salsa and Cheddar cheese in a wheat wrap
Ira's Big Fish US$15.20
Cage-free egg with lox, chive cream cheese, tomato, capers, & sprouts on buttered, toasted pumpernickel bread
Novie & The Eggs
Egg salad, lox and red onion open faced on a bagel
OK Gramps US$14.25
Nova Lox, cage-free eggs, tomato and red onion open face on a toasted bialy
Power Plant
JUST Eggs, Beyond Sausage, arugula, vegan garlic aioli dressing, and melted vegan mozzarella on a bagel
Queens
Egg salad, bacon and tomato open-faced on a bagel
Ryan's Favorite US$9.70
Cage-free egg with sausage, roasted red peppers, arugula & provolone cheese served warm on buttered toasted focaccia bread
Rise N Grind US$11.20
Pastrami, cage-free egg, jalapeno cream cheese, roasted red peppers, and melted provolone cheese on a croissant
Round House US$10.20
Cage-free egg, bacon, sausage, melted Pepper Jack and a hash brown on a rosemary salt bagel
Steak & Eggs
Roast beef, cage-free egg, roasted red peppers, & melted Pepper Jack, on a bagel of choice
Side Hash Brown US$2.00
Crispy Hash Brown
Cage-Free Egg
Cage-free egg on a bagel
Egg Whites
Egg whites on a bagel
Bacon Sandwich
Bacon Sandwich
Sausage
Pork sausage on a bagel
Chicken Sausage
Chicken sausage on a bagel
Vegan Beyond Sausage
Beyond Sausage on a bagel
Vegan JUST Eggs
JUST Eggs on a bagel

Sandwiches
AMG US$9.75
Portobello mushroom, pesto, spinach, and Cheddar panini pressed on focaccia
Autumn Sky US$12.45
Smoked turkey, spinach, apples, bacon, Cheddar cheese and whole grain mustard on sourdough bread
Bay Burger US$10.25
Veggie burger with goat cheese, house-made basil oil, sun dried tomatoes and chipolte aioli dressing on a multigrain roll
BBQ Jack US$9.45
Hot roast beef with BBQ sauce and melted Pepper Jack cheese on a sesame roll
BLT
Bacon, lettuce, and tomato on your choice of bread, bagel, or wrap
Buffalo St. US$10.45
Warm Chicken cutlet with Frank's Hot Sauce, parsley-garlic dressing, and lettuce served on a toasted sub roll.
C.T.B.L.T. US$8.45
Toasted sourdough bread with aioli dressing, avocado, bacon, lettuce and tomato
California Dreamin’ US$11.45
Smoked turkey, avocado and coleslaw on hand-sliced multigrain bread
Cayuga Croissant US$8.45
Avocado, tomato, mushrooms, sprouts and parsley-garlic dressing on a croissant
Cheese Melt
Choice of American, Provolone, Swiss, Muenster, Cheddar or Mozzarella melted open face on a bagel
Chicken Melt
Homemade chicken salad with tomato and melted Cheddar cheese on a bagel
DeWitt Melt US$6.65
House-made coleslaw, tomato & Swiss, served warm on our fresh bialy
Flat Rock US$11.00
Roast turkey, goat cheese, sun-dried tomatoes, basil oil and balsamic vinaigrette on a baguette
Freshy US$9.00
Fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, spinach, extra virgin olive oil and salt and pepper panini pressed on ciabatta
Frickin' Chickin' US$13.45
Cage free chicken breast, pesto, asiago and mushrooms panini pressed on focaccia
Havanna Breeze US$9.00
Baked ham, sliced pickles and Swiss cheese with yellow mustard & mayonnaise panini pressed on a sub roll
Javi US$11.00
Roast turkey, goat cheese, spinach, sun-dried tomatoes, sprouts, and balsamic vinaigrette on toasted sourdough bread
Jonah’s Jive US$7.45
Homemade hummus, spinach, tomato, cucumber, and parsley-garlic dressing on hand-sliced multigrain bread
Lindsey US$9.00
Roast turkey, mushrooms, parsley-garlic dressing and Muenster cheese melted on a bialy
Little Italy US$10.45
Cage free chicken breast, marinara sauce, spices & melted mozzarella cheese panini pressed on focaccia bread
Maggie's Farm US$8.75
Roast turkey, cranberry sauce, lettuce and aioli dressing on ciabatta bread
Mexican Bagel
Jalapeno cream cheese, fresh salsa, and melted Cheddar cheese on a bagel
Milanese US$12.75
Cage-free chicken breast, roasted red peppers, pesto mayonnaise, provolone & Italian herbs panini pressed on our rosemary focaccia bread
New Yorker US$12.45
Pastrami, coleslaw, and Russian dressing topped with melted Swiss on a sesame roll
Octopus US$9.15
Roast turkey breast, coleslaw, Swiss cheese, Russian dressing on pumpernickel bread
Patrick Ewing US$10.25
Roast turkey, Brie, apples and honeycup mustard on a baguette
Pinot Nawara US$12.75
Cage free chicken breast, tomato, fresh mozzarella, jalapenos, sea salt, and pesto-mayo Panini pressed on ciabatta
Pizza Big Red
Marinara Sauce with bacon, sausage, pepperoni, ham, and chicken with melted mozzarella cheese
Pizza Pesto
Pesto with melted mozzarella cheese
Pizza Red
Marinara sauce with melted mozzarella cheese
Pizza White
Garlic butter with melted mozzarella cheese
Plant Based Parm US$12.45
Vegan chicken patty panini pressed on focaccia bread with our house-made basil oil, marinara sauce and vegan mozzarella cheese.
Renwick Reuben US$10.00
Hot corned beef, sauerkraut, melted Swiss cheese and Russian dressing panini pressed on rye bread
Sheldon Court US$9.75
Smoked turkey, chipotle aioli, arugula, and Pepper Jack cheese panini pressed on southwest sourdough
Susie's Garden US$12.45
Local lemon teriyaki seitan, vegan mozzarella, avocado, lettuce, tomato, & sprouts, on our oatmeal wheat bread
Sweet Rachel US$10.00
Smoked turkey, honeycup mustard, red onion and muenster cheese on hand-sliced pumpernickel bread
T-Burg With A Twist US$10.00
Albacore tuna salad with avocado and tomato on pumpernickel bread
The Cutlet US$11.45
Chicken cutlet with Italian herbs, provolone, basil mayo & roasted red peppers served warm on our sub roll
The Italian US$11.75
Salami, prosciutto, house-made pesto, spinach, tomato & provolone panini pressed on our rosemary focaccia
The Parisian US$10.75
Roast turkey, house-made 3-fruit chutney, fresh spinach & Brie panini pressed on our sourdough bread
Tour De France US$13.45
Roast turkey, Brie, pear, bacon and honeycup mustard on hand-sliced multigrain
Tuna Melt
Albacore tuna salad with tomato and melted Cheddar cheese on a bagel
Turkey Hill BLT US$10.45
Roast turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato and aioli dressing on hand-sliced pumpernickel bread
Tuscan Verde US$12.00
Cage free chicken breast with pesto, fresh spinach, tomato and provolone cheese on rosemary focaccia bread
Ultimate Grilled Cheese US$7.25
Cheddar, mozzarella cheese, and caramelized onions panini pressed on garlic-buttered sourdough bread
Van Dorn’s Vegan US$6.75
Homemade hummus, roasted red peppers, tomato and sprouts on oatmeal wheat bread
Vegetarian Bagel
Veggie cream cheese, tomato and melted Muenster cheese on a bagel
Viva Chelsea US$8.75
Fresh mozzarella cheese and sliced tomoatoes with house-made basil oil, salt and pepper on rosemary focaccia bread
West End Melt US$9.85
Rare roast beef, honeycup mustard, tomato and melted Cheddar cheese panini pressed on pumpernickel bread
Zabs US$10.45
Roast turkey, avocado, chipotle aioli dressing and mozzarella panini pressed on ciabatta bread
Zoe US$8.75
Chicken salad with lettuce, tomato and cranberry sauce on a toasted rosemary salt bagel

Cream Cheese & Bagel Spreads
Avocado Toast US$6.30
Avocado spread on hand-sliced multigrain toast topped with olive oil, salt & pepper
Avo Toast #1 US$9.35
Our traditional Avocado Toast topped with goat cheese and sun-dried tomatoes
Avo Toast #2 US$10.05
Our traditional Avocado Toast topped with crispy bacon and feta cheese
Avo Toast #3 US$11.05
Our traditional Avocado Toast topped with arugula and cage-free eggs
Butter
Butter on your choice of a bagel
Butter & Honey
Butter & Honey on a bagel
Butter, Cinnamon & Sugar
Butter, Cinnamon & Sugar on a bagel
Cream Cheese
Cream Cheese on your choice of a bagel
Earth Balance
Earth Balance on a bagel
Flavored Cream Cheese
Choice of Flavored Cream Cheese on a bagel
Jam
Choice of Raspberry, Strawberry, Grape or Raspberry Jalapeno on a bagel
Lox & Cream Cheese
On your bagel of choice
Lox Only
Sliced Nova Lox on a toasted bagel
Nutella
Nutella on a bagel
Nutella & Banana
Nutella & Banana on a bagel
Peanut Butter
Peanut Butter (crunchy or smooth) on a bagel
Peanut Butter & Banana
Peanut Butter & Banana on a bagel
Peanut Butter & Jelly
Peanut Butter & Jelly on a bagel
San Diego Bagel
Cream cheese and raspberry jalapeno jam on a bagel
Side Hash Brown US$2.00
Crispy Hash Brown
Tofutti
Plain Toffutti on a bagel
Veggie Cream Cheese
Veggie or Veggie Lite cream cheese on a bagel
Whitefish Salad
Whitefish on a bagel

Bowls & Salads
Bahn Voyage US$11.95
Choice of Chicken or Tofu. Kale, warm grain blend (barley, wild rice, wheat berries, white quinoa, red quinoa, & olive oil), cucumbers, carrots, radish, pickled onions, cilantro, sweet sriracha mayo, brown sugar soy dressing
Brain Power US$14.95
Spring mix, quinoa, seared Ahi tuna with sesame seeds, avocado, grapes, walnuts, goat cheese, onion and balsamic vinaigrette
Brekky Bowl US$12.95
Kale, sweet potatoes, and warm grain blend (barley, wild rice, wheat berries, white quinoa, red quinoa, & olive oil) tossed with maple bacon dressing and topped with a cage-free egg, bacon, avocado, roasted sweet potatoes, and cherry tomatoes
Green Goddess US$12.95
Kale and spring mix, edamame, cucumber, avocado, cage free chicken, walnuts, sunflower seeds, Green Goddess dressing
Jerk-Island Vibes US$12.95
Kale, warm grain blend (barley, wild rice, wheat berries, white quinoa, red quinoa, & olive oil), chicken, pineapple salsa, red pepper, avocado, radish, cilantro, jerk marinade dressing
Santa Fe US$12.95
Kale, warm grain blend (barley, wild rice, wheat berries, white quinoa, red quinoa, & olive oil), avocado, roasted chicken, roasted corn, red onion, tortilla strips, tomatoes, fresh lime squeeze, radish slices, cilantro lime jalapeno vinaigrette
Build Your Own Bowl US$11.95
Grains, Greens and up to 5 toppings! Lots of premium Items available to add.
Chicken Caesar Salad US$9.95
Romaine lettuce with roasted chicken, croutons, and our own traditional Caesar dressing. *This item is prepackaged and cannot be modified.*
Greek Salad US$9.95
Chopped Romaine, grape tomatoes, feta, kalamata olives, dolmades, artichoke hearts, cucumber, with an oregano vinaigrette. *This item is prepackaged and cannot be modified.*
Strawberry Fields Salad US$9.95
Arugula, spinach, strawberries, pecans (sugar), feta, radish, pickled onions (red onions, white wine vinegar, rice vinegar, salt), Balsamic Vinaigrette. *This item is prepackaged and cannot be modified.*
Tropical Shrimp Salad US$10.95
Romaine & Arcadian blend, Tropical Grilled Shrimp (orange marmalade, lime juice, thyme, nutmeg, allspice, cinnamon, chipotle, tamari, corn oil, ginger, sugar, garlic, scallions, onions, salt, black pepper) Cucumber, Mango, Pickled Red Onion, Pineapple Salsa (pineapple, red pepper, cilantro, red pepper, jalapeno pepper, salt), Coconut Lime Vinaigrette (white wine vinegar, lime, coconut milk, honey, corn oil). *This item is prepackaged and cannot be modified.*
Vegan Caesar Salad US$10.95
Romaine, kale, red onions, tofu, grape tomatoes, almonds, crispy chick peas, Vegan Caesar Dressing (vegan mayo, Dijon mustard, capers, lemon juice, tamari, tahini, garlic, salt). *This item is prepackaged and cannot be modified.*
Tossed Salad 6oz US$4.95
Mixed greens, chickpeas, cherry tomatoes, carrots, black olives, and mushrooms with vinaigrette. *This item is prepackaged and cannot be modified.*
Hard Boiled Eggs US$2.25
2 Hard Boiled Eggs

Smoothie Bowls
Acai Of Spades US$12.95
Purple base* (blueberries, banana, acai powder, oat milk) topped with granola, strawberries, almonds, and flax seeds. *Base can not be modified.
Green Machine US$12.95
Green base* (pineapple, banana, spinach, and coconut) topped with granola, roasted pepitas, coconut chips, and banana chips. *Base can not be modified
Hulk Smash US$12.95
Green base* (pineapple, banana, spinach, and coconut) topped with strawberries, granola, roasted pepitas, and bananas. *Base can not be modified
Purple Paradise US$12.95
Purple base* (blueberries, banana, acai powder, oat milk) topped with cacao nibs, coconut chips, chopped peanuts, and banana chips. *Base can not be modified
Build Your Own Smoothie Bowl US$12.95
Build your own smoothie bowl! Choose from our Purple Base* (blueberries, banana, acai powder, oat milk) or our Green Base* (pineapple, banana, spinach, and coconut water). Choose up to 4 toppings. *Base can not be modified

Soup
Daily Small Soup US$4.95
Daily Soup available starting at 10:30am. See our available soups of the day below and let us know which one you would like!
Daily Medium Soup US$6.95
Daily Soup available starting at 10:30am. See our available soups of the day below and let us know which one you would like!
Daily Large Soup US$13.25
Daily Soup available starting at 10:30am. See our available soups of the day below and let us know which one you would like!
Ultimate Grilled Cheese Combo US$10.75
Our Ultimate Grilled Cheese Combo is paired with a Daily Small Soup of your Choice! Ultimate Grilled Cheese: Cheddar, mozzarella cheese, and caramelized onions panini pressed on garlic-buttered sourdough bread

Coffee, Tea, Espresso
Latte
Espresso shot with 2% milk. Served hot or iced
Hot Coffee
Choose from a variety of roasts.
Hot Tea
Choice of English Breakfast, Irish Breakfast, Earl Grey, Green, Peppermint, Chamomile, and many more!
Cold Brew
Cold Brew
Iced Coffee
Iced Regular or Decaf Coffee
Iced Tea
Choose from a variety of flavors
Americano
Espresso shot poured over hot or iced water.
Breve
Espresso shot with half & half. Served hot or iced
Café Au Lait
2/3 hot coffee topped with 2% steamed milk.
Cappuccino
Espresso shot with 2% steamed milk topped with foam
Cayuga Cocoa
Hot chocolate mixed with hot coffee.
Chai Tea Latte
Chai tea mixed with 2% milk. Served hot or iced
Chai Charger
Chai tea mixed with 2% milk and topped with an espresso shot. Served hot or iced
Espresso
Espresso Shot
Hot Chocolate
Hot chocolate mixed with 2% steamed milk.
Mochaccino
Espresso shot with 2% milk and chocolate. Served hot or iced
Macchiatto
Espresso shot topped with foam
Matcha
Matcha tea mixed with hot water and 2% milk. Served hot or iced
Red Eye
Espresso shot poured over hot or iced coffee.
Steamer
Steamed 2% milk. Add a flavor shot for an additional charge.
White Hot Chocolate
White hot chocolate mixed with 2% steamed milk.
Java Box
Java Box. 12 cup or 20 cup with cups, half and half, and sugar packets

Drinks & Smoothies
Choose from a varity of bottled beverages, seasonal specialty beverages, and smoothies!
Fresh Fruit Lemonade US$5.00
24oz Lemonade flavored with your choice of fresh strawberry or raspberry puree
Italian Soda
Sparkling soda with your choice of flavor.
Jeff's Java Jolt
20oz Hot or 24oz Iced quad shot latte with chocolate and vanilla. Made with 2% milk
Maple Latte
Hot or Iced Maple Latte
Twisted Sister
20oz Hot or 24oz Iced double shot latte with chocolate, caramel, and toffee nut. Made with 2% milk
Cat Woman US$6.50
Earl grey lavender tea bag steeped in steamed milk with vanilla and honey. Made with 2% milk. 20oz
Dalgona Latte US$6.25
16oz iced double shot toffee nut latte topped with honeycomb
Blossom Berry Matcha
Iced blackberry matcha with a hint of lavender. Made with 2% milk
Coconut Honey Iced Latte
Iced coconut quad shot latte sweetened with honey. Made with 2% milk
Cookie Butter Chai
24oz Iced chai with a splash of cookie butter. Made with 2% milk
Green Tea Guava Lemonade US$5.00
Green tea and lemonade swirled with guava puree
Snickers Iced Coffee
Iced coffee swirl with all the flavors of a Snickers candy bar (caramel, chocolate, and butter pecan) topped with half & half
Strawberry White Mocha
24oz Iced quad shot white mocha with a hint of strawberry. Made with 2% milk
Summer Of Love US$5.00
Iced raspberry milk tea sweetened with white chocolate. Made with half & half
Make-A-Wish US$6.00
Blueberry Lemonade. For every drink purchased, $1 will be donated to Make-A-Wish, helping make dreams come true for children in need!
Frozen Lemonade US$5.50
24oz Frozen Lemonade flavored with your choice of fresh strawberry, raspberry, or just enjoy it without fruit
Creamsicle Milkshake US$7.25
A blend of sweet vanilla ice cream and orange juice
CTB Smoothie US$7.25
Strawberry, bananas, yogurt and orange juice
Cookies & Cream Smoothie US$7.75
Blended with Oreo cookies, chocolate, espresso and vanilla ice cream. Topped with whipped cream and Oreos
Fruit Wellness Smoothie US$7.75
Strawberry, blueberry, raspberry, pineapple, yogurt, orange juice & an antioxidant supplement
Lemon Berry Smoothie US$7.75
Strawberry, Blueberry, Raspberry, Lemonade
PB & Joe Smoothie US$8.25
Banana, Chocolate, Peanut Butter, Cold Brew, Almond Milk
Build Your Own Smoothie
Build your own smoothie. Choose 2 fruits and 1 base
Milk Shakes
Choose from Vanilla, Chocolate, or Strawberry
Poland Springs Sports Cap US$2.25
Hal's New York Seltzer Original US$2.25
Hal's New York Seltzer Lemon US$2.25
Hal's New York Seltzer Black Cherry US$2.25
Natalies Orange Juice 12oz US$4.25
Natalies Strawberry Lemonade 12oz US$3.25
Joe Unsweetend Black Tea US$3.50
Joe Tea Green Tea US$3.50
Joe Tea Lemon US$3.50
Martinelli's Apple Juice 10oz Round US$3.50
Coke Bottle 20oz US$2.65
Diet Coke Bottle 20oz US$2.65
Joyba Bubble Tea Strawberry Lemonade US$3.99
Joyba Bubble Tea Mango US$3.99
Joyba Bubble Tea Blueberry US$3.99

Breakfast Pastry
Apple Puff US$3.25
Fresh baked puff pastry with apple filling and topped with cinnamon sugar
Croissant Butter US$3.25
Croissant Almond US$3.95
Croissant Chocolate Hazelnut US$3.95
Croissant Spinach Feta US$3.95
Muffin Blueberry US$2.95
Muffin Carrot Raisin US$2.95
Muffin Chocolate Chip US$2.95
Muffin Corn US$2.95
Scone Apricot US$2.95
Scone Black Currant US$2.95
Scone Coconut Raspberry (Vegan) US$2.95
Blueberry Crumb Cake US$3.75
Crumb Cake US$3.75

Cookies
Almond Crescent US$2.50
Black & White Cookie US$2.95
Half vanilla, half chocolate frosting on top of a soft vanilla cookie
Iced Cut Out Cookie US$2.50
Jumbo Chocolate Chip Cookie US$3.50
Homemade classic chocolate chip cookie
Jumbo Ginger Cookie US$3.50
Homemade soft ginger cookie
Jumbo Oatmeal Raisin Cookie US$3.50
Homemade soft oatmeal raisin cookie
Jumbo Peanut Butter Chip Cookie US$3.50
Homemade peanut butter cookie with peannut butter chips
Jumbo Triple Chocolate Cookie US$3.50
Homemade chocolate cookie with white chocolate chunks and chocolate chunks
Linzer Cookie US$3.50
*contains almonds and hazelnuts
Macaroon Shortbread Cookie US$3.50
Magic Cookie US$3.95
A delicious combination of macadamia nuts, fresh coconut and semisweet chocolate chips
Monster Cookie US$3.95
A Jumbo Cookie with Oats, Peanut Butter, M&Ms, and Chocolate Chips (No Gluten Added).
Mini Chocolate Chip Cookie 3 Pack US$3.75
Rugelach Cookies 3 Pack US$5.85
*contains walnuts and hazelnuts
Small Cut Out Cookies 3 Pack US$2.25
Sugar Cookie with Sprinkles *shape may vary*

Chips, Snacks & Sweets
Dirty Sea Salt Chips 2oz US$1.95
Dirty Cracked Pepper & Sea Salt Chips 2oz US$1.95
Dirty Salt And Vinegar Chips 2oz US$1.95
Dirty Sour Cream & Onion Chips 2oz US$1.95
Dirty Mesquite BBQ Chips 2oz US$1.95
Dirty Jalapeno Heat Chips 2oz US$1.95
Dirty Maui Onion Chips 2oz US$1.95
Dirty Funky Fusion Chips 2oz US$1.95
Hard Boiled Eggs US$2.25
2 Hard Boiled Eggs
Fresh Fruit
Select from a variety of fresh fruits
Fruit Parfait US$4.50
Yogurt, strawberries, kiwi, blueberries, granola (rolled oats, maple syrup, brown sugar, corn oil, honey, vanilla extract, salt)
Buffalo Chicken & Biscuits Snack Pack US$8.75
Buffalo Chicken Salad (chicken, mayo, celery, onion, hot sauce), Cheddar Biscuits (butter, flour, baking powder, buttermilk, cheddar, scallions, salt), lettuce, blue cheese, celery, carrots
Chicken And Egg Snack Pack US$7.95
Chicken Salad (chicken, mayonnaise, onion, celery, salt, black pepper), Hard Boiled Eggs, Grapes, Pita Chips
Mediterranean Snack Pack US$9.75
Feta, Stuffed Grape Leaves, Tapenade (stuffed green olives, kalamata olives, olive oil, capers, orange, parsley, black pepper, crushed red pepper), Pita Chips
Vanilla Cinnamon Chia Pudding US$6.99
Coconut milk, almond milk, Greek yogurt, chia seeds, cinnamon powder, vanilla extract, almonds, blueberries, honey, salt
Overnight Oats - Carrot Cake (Cont. Pecans) US$4.50
Overnight Oats - Maple Brown Sugar US$4.50
Oats, coconut milk, soy, maple syrup, salt, brown sugar, corn oil, and honey
Ithaca Bakery Honey Nut Granola US$10.95
Ithaca Bakery's Honey Nut Granola. Oats, honey, sunflower seeds, corn oil, brown sugar, flax seeds, walnuts, almonds, dried cranberries, raisins, bran flakes, maple syrup, vanilla, salt & cinnamon. 16oz
Bella's Salted Caramel Blondie US$3.50
Bella's GF Blackout Brownie US$4.95
Gluten Free
Bella's GF Blondie Bar US$4.95
Gluten Free
M&M Rice Krispie Treat US$2.25
Lemon Pound Cake US$3.75
Double Chocolate Pound Cake US$3.75
Marble Pound Cake US$3.75
Super Fudge Brownie US$2.95
Cheesecake Brownie US$3.50
Baby Vanilla Cheesecake US$5.95
Eclair US$4.50
Raspberry Crumb Bar (Vegan) US$3.50
*contains coconut
Regal Slice US$4.95
Flourless chocolate cake with a fudge consistency

Prepackaged Meals
Chicken Tenders With BBQ Sauce US$8.25
*This item is prepackaged and cannot be modified.*
Cheese Tortellini With Pesto US$11.00
*This item is prepackaged and cannot be modified.*
Mac & Cheese US$5.25
*This item is prepackaged and cannot be modified.*
Pork Chinese Dumplings US$8.50
*This item is prepackaged and cannot be modified.*
Potato Knish US$4.25
*This item is prepackaged and cannot be modified.*
Potato Latkes US$5.99
*This item is prepackaged and cannot be modified.*
Spanakopita US$8.95
*This item is prepackaged and cannot be modified.*
BBQ Chicken Wings (6pc) US$9.50
*This item is prepackaged and cannot be modified.*
Buffalo Chicken Wings (6pc) US$10.00
*This item is prepackaged and cannot be modified.*
Pork Potstickers (6pc) US$7.50
*This item is prepackaged and cannot be modified.*
Veggie Potstickers (6pc) US$7.50
*This item is prepackaged and cannot be modified.*

Bagels
1 Bagel US$1.35
Your choice of 1 freshly baked bagel in a bag
6 Bagels US$8.10
Your choice of 6 freshly baked bagels
Dozen Bagels US$12.95
Your choice of 12 freshly baked bagels. *Limited availability unless ordered for next day pickup/delivery*
Bialy
A round chewy roll with crunchy outside and a depressed middle filled with cooked onion
1 Gluten Free Bagel US$2.00
1 Gluten Free bagel. Please let us know if you have an allergy to gluten.
8oz Regular Cream Cheese US$4.25
Choose between Regular or Lite.
8oz Flavored Cream Cheese
Please choose your flavor.
Sliced Nova Lox 1/4 Lb US$8.95
Acme Smoked Salmon
Raspberry Jalapeno Jam 8oz US$6.95
House-made. A customer favorite. Top your cream cheese with our Raspberry Jalapeno Jam and create your own San Diego Bagel at home!

Deli Sandwiches
Avocado
Avocado Spread
Bacon Sandwich
Bacon Sandwich
Breaded Chicken Cutlet
Breaded Chicken Cutlet
Brie Cheese
Brie Cheese
Cage Free Chicken
Free Range Chicken
Chicken Salad
Chicken Salad
Corned Beef
Corned Beef
Deli Cheese Sandwich
4 slices of cheddar, mozzarella, Swiss, provolone, muenster, or American cheese
Egg Salad
Egg Salad
Fresh Mozzarella
Fresh Mozzarella
Goat Cheese
Goat Cheese
Ham
Ham
Hummus
Hummus
Pastrami
NY Pastrami
Pesto
Homemade pesto
Portobella Mushroom
Portobella Mushroom
Roast Beef
Roast Beef
Roast Turkey
Roast Turkey
Salami
Genoa salami
Seitan
Seitan
Smoked Turkey
Smoked Turkey
Tuna Salad
Tuna Salad (Albacore)
Vegan Chicken Patty
Vegan Chicken Patty
Veggie Sandwich
Build your own veggie sandwich

Collegetown Bagels Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pick-up
In-store shopping
On-site services
Takeaway
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Amenities
Toilet
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Crowd
LGBTQ+ friendly

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Paid street parking

Collegetown Bagels Photos

Collegetown Bagels Location

Collegetown Bagels

New York Tompkins County Ithaca Collegetown College Avenue

420 College Ave, Ithaca, NY 14850, USA

Collegetown Bagels Reviews

An average rating of ★4.3 from 1308 user reviews.

studentsbeerpatiobarrosemarycollege townsoupbaked goodsstaplesunrise

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

After a full morning of exploring Ithaca, wandering through Cornell University and chasing waters, we found ourselves a bit hungry. Collegetown Bagels and surrounding were the perfect stops. The area was quiet with school out of session, that only added to the charm. We enjoyed sitting outside and soaking in the calm summer vibes - just what we needed. CTB offers a great variety - bagels, creative sandwiches and assortment of drinks and tempting desserts. There’s definitely something for everyone here.
July 08 · Canh Vo
A lot of options and the ingredients seem pretty good. The taste of sandwiches were pretty average though. The guy at the counter seemed grumpy as well, which isn't the best interaction to start off your day in the morning. The delivery of our food was extremely slow even though we did not have people in front of us. Good location vibe and outdoor sitting.
July 06 · Woo Young Kim
My friend and I ordered each a coffee. I ordered 6 Mile CreeK and Americano.Staff friendly. Recommend
July 15 · Tatar P.
Ordered a cappuccino which was completely flat with a thin layer of foam on top (as opposed to properly frothed/steamed). It was also scalding hot (AKA over-steamed) and I burned myself trying to drink it. Got a nova lox bagel ($13) and came out to be $17 after subbing for allergens, making one addition, and tax.The additional fees for subs seems excessive and borderline exploitive to people who require these accommodations to eat, especially when the sub ingredients are likely basement price/quality (basing this off the tofutti cream cheese, which is terrible), and in consideration to the fact these are NOT additions, but substitutions.I would say overall maybe try to incorporate allergy friendly ingredients without overpricing for them and train employees to actuallymake a drink properly so people are gettingwhat they pay for instead of a hotmess (literally). I will say in light of this, the guy who helped me order my food was very easy to talk to and helpful, though he didn’t mention the additional fees for subs.
November 14 · zel
Food was okay. The sandwich was generic, we weren’t even done ordering before it was put through. I didn’t even get to say what bagel I wanted on the sandwich. She basically just wanted to rush us out. I ended up with a plain bagel, which wasn’t bad but not what I wanted. The place looks good. It’s clean and has condiments available for everyone. The “FreshFruitLemonade” was middle of the road. Wasn’t that sour or sweet. Overall 3 stars. Not from the area and don’t plan on coming back anytime soon. Maybe next year we will try again.
May 04 · Exoh Tutorials