The Appleton Costco Bakery: Your Source for Large Format Desserts and Bulk Baked Goods in Wisconsin

Costco Bakery Introduce

Introduction / Overview

For Wisconsin families, party hosts, and local businesses in the Appleton area, the

Costco Bakery

at 5401 Integrity Way is a legendary destination for baked goods that emphasize both

quality and quantity

. As a staple within the Costco Wholesale warehouse environment, this bakery is not just an ordinary section—it is a production hub dedicated to providing fresh, large-format desserts, and staples at exceptional member value.

The bakery proudly focuses on high-demand, crowd-pleasing items. Unlike smaller, specialty shops, Costco excels at delivering massive cakes, dozens of muffins, and loaves of artisan bread designed to feed a large group, making it the perfect partner for family gatherings, holiday feasts, or stocking up your freezer.

The selection rotates seasonally but always features beloved classics. Appleton locals consistently seek out the colossal

Half-Sheet Cakes

for birthdays, the famously buttery

Croissants

, and a variety of sweet and savory breads and rolls. This is the place where value meets deliciousness, ensuring your event is well-supplied with fresh, baked goodness without breaking the bank.

Location and Accessibility

The Appleton

Costco Bakery

is conveniently located within the Costco Wholesale warehouse at 5401 Integrity Way, Appleton, WI 54913, USA. Positioned near the GRAND area, the location offers straightforward access for members traveling from various parts of the Fox Valley region. The store's proximity to major roadways ensures that picking up your bulk bakery order is an easy task.

Accessibility is a priority at the Appleton warehouse to ensure a comfortable shopping experience for all patrons:

Wheelchair Accessible Entrance: The warehouse provides a clear and spacious entrance designed for easy mobility.
Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot: Dedicated, convenient parking spaces are available near the main entrance to facilitate accessibility for members.

For payments, the bakery, like the rest of the warehouse, accepts major methods including

Credit cards

and

Debit cards

Services Offered

The Appleton

Costco Bakery

specializes in high-volume, fresh-baked goods and offers the following essential services to its members:

Custom Cake Ordering: Order large-format
Half-Sheet Cakes
(serving up to 48 people) or smaller
10-inch Round Cakes
for special events. Customization includes choice of flavor (typically white cake with vanilla cheesecake mousse filling, or chocolate with chocolate mousse filling) and personalized frosting designs/messages.
In-Store Ordering: Custom cake orders must be placed in person at the bakery counter by filling out the designated paper form and dropping it in the slot box. It is generally recommended to order at least
48 hours in advance
.
Ready-Made Desserts and Cakes: A continuous supply of popular, ready-to-buy large desserts, including the famous
Tuxedo Cake
,
Cheesecakes
, and
Pies
(like the seasonal
Pumpkin Pie
), available for immediate purchase.
Bulk Pastries and Muffins: Offers large containers of baked favorites, such as the oversized
Muffins
(Blueberry, Chocolate, etc.),
Almond Danish
, and
Gourmet Cookies
(like Chocolate Chunk), perfect for large groups or stocking up at home.
Fresh Bread and Rolls: Provides a variety of freshly baked breads, including
Baguettes
,
Ciabatta Rolls
, and specialty loaves for daily use and entertaining.
Takeout: All bakery items are packaged and ready for convenient takeout directly from the department.
In-store Pickup: Custom orders are picked up directly at the bakery counter on the scheduled date and time.

Features / Highlights

Exceptional Value and Size: The most notable feature is the massive size and low price point of the baked goods, especially the
Half-Sheet Cakes
which are one of the best values for feeding a crowd in the state of Wisconsin.
The 'Slot Box' Cake System: The unique, reliable, and entirely analog process of ordering custom cakes by filling out a form and dropping it into a box—a system trusted by members for its accuracy and consistency.
Cult-Favorite Desserts: Home to several much-loved products with dedicated local followings, including the rich
Tuxedo Cake
and various rotating mini-dessert cups and bars, which are ideal for parties.
Everyday Staples in Bulk: Provides superior quality versions of everyday items, such as the buttery
Croissants
and hefty
Bagels
, which are excellent for freezing and consuming over time.
Reliability for Large Events: The sheer volume of production ensures that the bakery can reliably supply desserts and breads for major celebrations, holidays, and corporate events without the complexity of a catering service.

Contact Information

For general inquiries, membership information, or to discuss your custom bakery order details (after the form has been submitted), you may contact the Appleton

Costco Wholesale

warehouse using the following information:

Address: 5401 Integrity Way, Appleton, WI 54913, USA

Phone: (920) 815-4500

Mobile Phone: +1 920-815-4500

What is Worth Choosing

For Wisconsin residents and Costco members, the

Costco Bakery

in Appleton is worth choosing primarily for its unrivaled combination of

scale, value, and dependable quality

. When you need to feed a crowd—whether it's 15 or 50 people—no other local bakery can match the sheer size and cost-effectiveness of their product line.

The

Custom Cake

program is the main draw for celebrations. The ability to acquire a 9.5-pound

Half-Sheet Cake

that feeds nearly 50 people for a fraction of the cost of a specialty bakery is an unparalleled benefit. Customers appreciate the classic flavor options (white with vanilla cheesecake mousse or chocolate with chocolate mousse) and the simple, effective ordering system, which, while old-school, rarely fails to deliver a delicious and perfectly decorated product.

Beyond cakes, the bakery is essential for bulk purchasing of high-quality items. The buttery

Croissants

are excellent when warmed, and the generous packages of

Gourmet Cookies

and large

Muffins

are perfect for school lunches, office break rooms, or a ready supply of breakfast treats. If your priority is maxing out quality and quantity for family events, holidays, or simply stocking your pantry with delicious, fresh-baked staples at a wholesale price, the Appleton

Costco Bakery

on Integrity Way is undeniably the smart, professional choice.