Cowboy David's Special Order Bakery: Wisconsin's Premier Choice for Custom Wedding Cakes and Innovative Desserts

Cowboy David's Special Order Bakery Introduce

Cowboy David's Special Order Bakery: Beyond the Ordinary in La Farge, Wisconsin

In the scenic Kickapoo Valley region of Southwestern Wisconsin, a local bakery is setting an extraordinarily high bar for custom confections.

Cowboy David's Special Order Bakery

, rooted in La Farge, is not your average corner bake shop. It is a custom baking design studio renowned across the Midwest for its inventive flavor combinations, unmatched attention to detail, and a commitment to making every special occasion truly unforgettable. Under the guidance of "Cowboy Joe," the bakery has cultivated a reputation not just for producing edible works of art, but for offering an exemplary, fun, and inclusive customer experience.

Specializing in custom cakes, cupcakes, and their signature line of innovative treats—such as the massive

Supermuffins™

and decadent

Superbrownies™

—this establishment has become a destination vendor for couples planning their weddings and individuals organizing major events throughout Wisconsin. Their dedication to using the finest ingredients and a clear passion for their craft shines through in every bite, transforming classic recipes into next-level deliciousness. Furthermore, they are committed to inclusivity and accessibility, offering a broad cross-section of alternatives that are just as incredible as their traditional counterparts, ensuring all guests, including those with dietary restrictions, can indulge.

Introduction / Overview

Cowboy David's Special Order Bakery

is an award-winning, licensed, inspected, and insured specialty bakery located in La Farge, Wisconsin. Known primarily as a premier

Cake shop

and

Cupcake shop

focusing on large events and custom orders, the bakery's reputation is built on delivering breathtaking artistry combined with out-of-this-world flavor profiles. Owner Joe is frequently cited in customer reviews as an "absolute delight" and "treasure," praised for his exceptional customer service, collaborative approach, and professional delivery and setup for weddings. Their menu is famous for going beyond the standard fare, featuring signature items like the massive

Supermuffins™

, the indulgent

Superbrownies™

, and an array of unique candied confections and cookies. The bakery proudly serves the local community in Vernon County and provides extensive delivery and catering services far beyond, covering much of Wisconsin and the wider Midwest. They are also notably

LGBTQ+ friendly

, contributing to a welcoming and inclusive vendor environment for all Wisconsin couples.

Location and Accessibility

The bakery is conveniently located at

E11761 Co Rd P, La Farge, WI 54639, USA

, positioning it in the beautiful, rolling hills of the Driftless Area of Wisconsin. This area is known for its stunning natural scenery and charming small towns, making it a fitting home for a bakery focused on artistry and quality. As a dedicated special order business, while it maintains a physical presence for order fulfillment, its operations are geared towards maximum customer convenience. The facility is fully equipped with an

Accessibility

feature including a

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

, making visits for in-store pickup, consultations, or in-store shopping smooth and hassle-free. The location is strategically positioned to allow for efficient delivery logistics to regional event venues, from local La Farge gatherings to weddings in La Crosse, the Wisconsin Dells, and beyond.

Services Offered

Custom Wedding and Event Desserts: Specializing in tiered wedding cakes, custom cupcakes, and dessert bars tailored to the unique vision of each event, including highly detailed design execution.
Signature Baked Goods: Offering unique, trademarked products including large-format
Supermuffins™
(e.g.,
Orange Cranberry
,
Spinach Feta Butternut Squash
) and rich
Superbrownies™
(e.g.,
The Chocolate Coma Ii™
).
Advanced Flavor Profiles: Featuring a premium collection of gourmet and unusual flavors such as
Strawberry Basil With Balsamic Caramel Sauce
,
Spicy Mexican Chocolate
, and
Lemon Almond Blueberry
.
Accommodating Dietary Needs: Providing excellent, delicious alternatives, including noted
gluten free choices
which ensure guests with food allergies can enjoy the desserts without compromise.
Comprehensive Order Fulfillment: Offering flexible service options including
Curbside pickup
,
Delivery
,
In-store pickup
,
In-store shopping
, and
Takeout
.
Beverage Service: Providing
Coffee
as a simple offering to complement baked goods during in-store services.

Features / Highlights

Unmatched Customer Service and Professionalism: Owner Joe is celebrated for being an "absolute delight" to work with, providing an exceptional level of detail, timeliness, and customer-focused attention that is "truly unmatched."
Wide-Ranging Event Delivery and Setup: Proven capability to travel long distances for delivery and to professionally set up dessert displays—including event cups and cakes—creating a visually stunning presentation with attention to detail.
Inclusivity and Welcoming Environment: Explicitly noted as
LGBTQ+ friendly
, fostering a supportive and affirming experience for all clients in Wisconsin.
Innovative and Delicious Product Lines: Creation of distinct, highly-praised product names like
Supermuffins™
,
Superbrownies™
, and
Chocolate Tangle Pecans™
, ensuring a memorable and high-quality taste experience for all guests.
Flexible Payment Options: Accepting
Checks
and
Debit cards
for customer convenience.

Contact Information

Address: E11761 Co Rd P, La Farge, WI 54639, USA

Phone: (608) 625-6222

What is worth choosing

For anyone in Wisconsin seeking the highest standard in event dessert catering,

Cowboy David's Special Order Bakery

is worth choosing because it masterfully combines culinary innovation with exemplary service. It's an ideal choice for the Wisconsin resident who values both an incredible, gourmet product and a stress-free planning process.

What truly sets this La Farge bakery apart is the commitment to turning a "vision and execution" into a perfect reality. The customer reviews repeatedly highlight that the desserts are not just good—they are

delicious

, with guests raving about the flavor. The fact that the bakery offers such delicious

gluten free choices

is a significant benefit, showing a thoughtful commitment to accommodating every guest at a wedding or large gathering. No longer do guests with food allergies have to settle for less; here, the alternatives are just as incredible.

Furthermore, the professionalism of "Cowboy Joe" is a major selling point. Planning an event, especially a wedding, involves countless moving parts. Choosing a vendor who is described as a "treasure," with "attention to detail and timeliness" that are "truly unmatched," provides immense peace of mind. Knowing that your cake and dessert display will be

executed perfectly

and

delivered a long way

without issue is invaluable. Finally, the bakery's welcoming nature, being explicitly

LGBTQ+ friendly

, ensures a comfortable and respectful experience for all Wisconsin couples looking for their perfect wedding vendor. For extraordinary flavors, stunning displays, and absolute reliability,

Cowboy David's Special Order Bakery

is Wisconsin's choice for baking excellence.

Cowboy David's Special Order Bakery Wedding cake

Supermuffins™
Orange Cranberry
Creamy Blueberry Peach
Peanut Butter Turtle
Pineapple Zucchini
Hot & Spicy Triple Chocolate
Spinach Feta Butternut Squash

Superbrownies™
The Chocolate Coma Ii™
Rocky Road

Candied Confections
Candied Peanuts
Chocolate Tangle Pecans™
Chocolate Tangle Almonds™

Cookies
Oatmeal Raisin Caramel Apple

Premium Collection
Chocolate Raspberry With Rasberry Curd
Chocolate Caramel Toffee
Strawberry Basil With Balsamic Caramel Sauce
Cannoli Cake
Spicy Mexican Chocolate

Others
The Granola Muffin™
Raspberry Dark Chocolate
Lemon Almond Blueberry
Salted Caramel Milk Chocolate Swirl
Dark Chocolate Mint

Cowboy David's Special Order Bakery Details

Service options
Curbside pickup
Delivery
In-store pickup
In-store shopping
Takeout
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Crowd
LGBTQ+ friendly

Payments
Checks
Debit cards
Credit cards

Cowboy David's Special Order Bakery Photos

Cowboy David's Special Order Bakery Picture 1

Cowboy David's Special Order Bakery Picture 2

Cowboy David's Special Order Bakery Picture 3

Cowboy David's Special Order Bakery Picture 4

Cowboy David's Special Order Bakery Picture 5

Cowboy David's Special Order Bakery Picture 6

Cowboy David's Special Order Bakery Picture 7

Cowboy David's Special Order Bakery Picture 8

Cowboy David's Special Order Bakery Picture 9

Cowboy David's Special Order Bakery Location

Cowboy David's Special Order Bakery

Wisconsin Vernon County La Farge County Road P

E11761 Co Rd P, La Farge, WI 54639, USA

Cowboy David's Special Order Bakery Reviews

An average rating of ★4.6 from 52 user reviews.

weddingcupcakescookiesmuffinsvanillagluten freebehaviorgingercashewtasting

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

We loved working with Cowboy David’s Bakery for our wedding! Joe is an absolute delight to work with-he took our vision and executed it perfectly. He drove a long way to deliver and set up our cake and event cups. Everything was delicious, and our guests raved about how delicious our desserts were. Joe’s attention to detail and timeliness are both truly unmatched. Thank you for making our day so special!! 🤍
August 01 · Asia Weyenberg
From our first interaction to the last Joe has been an absolute treasure. We are so very grateful he did our wedding desserts!The gluten free choices were delicious and we were so glad we could accommodate our guests with food allergies ❤️Joe is so much fun to work with, he did an absolutely fantastic job with the display and we hope to get cake again soon!
January 14 · Hannah Mansmith
Ordered a cake for my wedding. Everyone loved it! We were very impressed. My now husband and I were a little hesitant in the wedding planning stage because it was difficult to have steady contact with Joe at Cowboy David. He doesn't reach out to you for updates, payment dues, etc. We had to reach out to him. By phone. Not always responsive to our emails. All in all though, it was worth it!
July 19 · Elizabeth Schwantes
I am honestly amazed that people who behave this way are allowed to own a business in our community. Their recent public statement celebrating the assassination of Charlie Kirk in front of his family was shocking and completely unacceptable. Regardless of anyone’s political beliefs, publicly endorsing violence crosses a line that should never be crossed.Owning a business comes with responsibilities—not just to customers, but to the community as a whole. Celebrating harm to another human being demonstrates a lack of judgment, empathy, and basic decency. It’s hard to imagine trusting a business that openly condones violence in any form.This kind of behavior reflects poorly on the community and raises serious questions about the character of the people running this business. I cannot, in good conscience, support or recommend them.
September 16 · Junior Ellefson
David and his team crafted a beautiful, delicious cake for our wedding. I cannot have dairy, which didn't faze David for an instant. He provided delightful tasting options and we ended up opting for Madagascar vanilla and lemon poppyseed. I sent him a few inspiration photos and he turned them into the wedding cake of my dreams. Our guests loved the cake and I look forward to ordering more special occasion cakes from David in the future!(For some reason Google won't let me upload photos!)
May 14 · Rebecca Share