East End Bagel Cafe: The North Fork's Go-To for Bagels and Deli Fare

East End Bagel Cafe Introduce

Nestled on the scenic North Fork of Long Island, where the pace is a little slower and the community spirit is strong, you’ll find a true local gem: East End Bagel Cafe. This establishment is more than just a place to grab a morning bagel; it's a community hub that serves as a vital part of the daily routine for many residents. Known for its solid, dependable bagels and a full deli counter, it has rightfully earned its reputation as the "working man's bagel place." Whether you're a local starting your day with a classic bagel and coffee or a visitor stopping by for a hearty lunch sandwich, East End Bagel Cafe offers a taste of authentic North Fork life. The friendly atmosphere and straightforward, no-fuss approach to great food make it a beloved spot for a quick and satisfying meal.

For those who live and work on the North Fork, East End Bagel Cafe is an essential part of the local landscape. The cafe's robust menu, which extends beyond just bagels to include a full deli, makes it a versatile choice for any meal. The honest, hardworking staff reflects the community it serves, and the steady stream of customers, from service professionals to local families, is a testament to its consistent quality. While some might describe the bagels as "a bit bready," they are widely considered to be a strong contender for the best bagels on the North Fork. It’s this balance of being a reliable, everyday spot while still delivering high-quality food that makes East End Bagel Cafe so special. It's the kind of place where everyone feels welcome and where a good meal is always guaranteed.

East End Bagel Cafe's location at 46455 County Rd 48, Southold, NY 11971, USA, is a key factor in its popularity and accessibility. Situated on a main road, the cafe is easy to spot from the street, making it a convenient stop for anyone traveling through the North Fork. One of the major highlights, and a point often mentioned by customers, is the easy and ample parking. This is a significant advantage in a region where parking can sometimes be a challenge, especially during peak season. The convenient location and plentiful parking make it a hassle-free destination, whether you're quickly running in for a coffee and bagel or grabbing lunch to go. It’s perfectly positioned for locals on their way to work or for visitors exploring the vineyards and farms that dot the area.

The accessibility of the cafe is enhanced by its straightforward layout. Customers can easily walk in, place their order, and grab their food, making for an efficient experience even during busy times. The location on County Rd 48 makes it a natural stop for commuters and a go-to for many of the local businesses in need of catering or a quick bite. This prime spot ensures that East End Bagel Cafe remains a central part of the community’s daily rhythm. The simplicity and convenience of its location contribute to its identity as a welcoming and no-fuss establishment that prioritizes good food and efficient service. It’s an easy decision for anyone in the area looking for a reliable and satisfying meal.

Services Offered

Fresh Bagels: A wide selection of bagels, including popular choices like cinnamon raisin, baked fresh daily.
Deli Counter: A full-service deli offering a wide variety of sandwiches and other lunch options.
Bagel Sandwiches: Custom bagel sandwiches with various toppings and fillings, including classic cream cheeses and deli meats.
Coffee and Beverages: A good selection of coffee and other drinks to complement your meal.
Quick-Service Breakfast and Lunch: The cafe is set up for efficient service, making it an excellent option for those on a tight schedule.
Catering: The full deli menu makes it a great option for catering small events, business lunches, or family gatherings.

Features / Highlights

Highly-Rated Bagels: The bagels are consistently praised by locals as some of the best on the North Fork, known for their solid taste and texture.
Friendly and Kind Staff: Customer reviews frequently mention the kind and welcoming nature of the people working at the cafe, creating a pleasant and inviting atmosphere.
Full Deli Menu: The inclusion of a full deli is a major highlight, offering customers a much broader range of options beyond just bagels, from breakfast to lunch.
Easy Parking: Ample and convenient parking is a significant feature, making it a stress-free visit for customers, especially on busy days.
Good Location: The cafe is well-situated on a main road, making it easy to find and a natural stop for both residents and visitors exploring the North Fork.
Efficient Service: While service can be slow during peak hours due to high demand and limited staff, the team works hard to get orders out as quickly as possible.
Community Hub: The cafe has a distinct "working man's bagel place" feel, which is a major highlight for locals who appreciate the down-to-earth and community-focused atmosphere.

Contact Information

Address: 46455 County Rd 48, Southold, NY 11971, USA

Phone: (631) 765-1642

Conclusion: Why East End Bagel Cafe is Suitable for Locals

For the residents of Southold and the wider North Fork community, East End Bagel Cafe is a perfect fit. It embodies the straightforward, high-quality, and community-oriented spirit of the area. The cafe’s reliable bagels, full deli menu, and welcoming staff make it a go-to for daily needs, from a quick morning coffee to a satisfying lunch. The easy parking and convenient location further solidify its role as a local institution, making it a hassle-free stop for everyone in the area.

The cafe is a place where you're likely to see familiar faces and feel a sense of belonging. The dedicated staff, despite being stretched thin during busy times, are praised for their kindness and hard work. This genuine, local feel is a huge part of its appeal. East End Bagel Cafe isn't trying to be a fancy, city-style establishment; it's simply focused on providing excellent, honest food in a friendly environment. This dedication to quality and community is precisely what makes it an indispensable part of life on the North Fork and why it will continue to be a cherished spot for many years to come.

East End Bagel Cafe Food & drink

Muffins
Orange Cranberry US$3.38
Carrot Frosted US$3.38
Lemon Poppy US$3.38
Raisin Bran US$3.38
Blueberry Crumb US$3.38
Apple Strudel US$3.38
Chocolate Chip US$3.38
Corn US$3.38
Banana Chip US$3.38
Dutch Chocolate US$3.38
Red Velvet US$3.38

Salads
Garden Salad US$10.50
Vegetarian. Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots, peppers, red onions, radishes, olives.
Chef Salad US$11.50
Ham, turkey, Swiss cheese, hard boiled egg, red onion, cucumber, black olives, tomatoes.
Spinach Salad US$12.50
Chopped spinach, hard boiled egg, bacon, mushroom, cucumber, black olives and red onion.
Chicken Garden Salad US$13.50
Breaded or grilled chicken cutlet, mixed greens, tomatoes, olives, red onions, and cucumber.

Omelette
Leo US$11.50
Nova lox, onions, tomato.
Cheesy US$10.50
American, cheddar, Swiss.
Polish US$10.50
Kielbasa, Swiss cheese, home fries.
Caprise US$10.50
Turkey, spinach, mozzarella.
Veggie US$10.50
Mushrooms, peppers, onions.
Western US$10.50
Ham, peppers, onions.
South Western US$10.50
Turkey, cheddar, salsa.

Pastries
Plain Croissant US$3.38
Cheese Horn US$3.38
Black And White Cookie US$3.38
Chocolate Crumb Cake US$3.38
Cheese Pocket US$3.38
Crumb Cake US$3.38
Half - Dipped Cookie US$3.38
Chocolate Croissant US$3.38
Cherry Turnover US$3.38
Apple Turnover US$3.38

Drinks
20oz Diet Pepsi US$2.86
A crisp tasting, refreshing pop of sweet, fizzy bubbles without calories.
20oz Coke US$2.63
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
Dr. Pepper 20oz US$2.63
Diet Dr.Pepper US$2.63
Nesquik US$2.75
Small Iced Coffee 16 Oz US$3.12
Iced Coffee Large 32oz US$5.20
Med Iced Coffee 24oz US$4.16
20oz Diet Coke US$2.63
A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
Poland Spring Waters US$2.08
Tropicana Juice US$0.00
20oz Pepsi US$2.63
The bold, refreshing, robust cola
Snapples US$2.86

Bagels and Rolls
Onion US$1.56
Sun-Dried Tomato US$1.56
French Toast US$1.56
Everything Cheddar Bagel US$1.56
Cinnamon Raisin US$1.56
Strawberry US$1.56
Multi-Grain US$1.56
Bacon And Egg US$1.56
Poppy Roll US$1.56
Rye US$1.56
Blueberry US$1.56
Plain Roll US$1.56
Garlic US$1.56
Plain US$1.56
Everything Roll US$1.56
Asiago US$1.56
Egg US$1.56
Pumpernickel US$1.56
Rainbow US$1.56
Sunflower US$1.56
Marble US$1.56
Salt US$1.56
Sesame US$1.56
Whole Wheat US$1.56
Whole Wheat Everything US$1.56
Everything US$1.56
Onion Roll US$1.56
Oat US$1.56
Sesame Roll US$1.56
Poppy US$1.56
Egg Everything US$1.56

Paninis
Turkey Avocado Melt US$12.50
Turkey, bacon, avocado, layered with melted cheddar on rustic panini bread with chipotle aioli.
Rueben US$12.50
Pastrami, Swiss, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing on rye bread.
Veggie Panini US$11.50
Vegetarian. Avocado, mozzarella, tomato, spinach on rustic panini bread with balsamic vinegar.
Chicken Pesto US$13.50
Grilled chicken cutlet, spinach, tomato, provolone cheese and pesto sauce on ciabatta bread.
Chicken Vodka US$13.50
Breaded chicken cutlet, mozzarella & vodka sauce served on ciabatta bread.
Cheesy Beef US$12.50
Roast beef, cheddar cheese, sautéed onions and horseradish on ciabatta bread.

Breakfast Heroes and Wraps
Garden Wrap US$10.50
Spinach, mushrooms, peppers, onions, Swiss cheese
Hungry Man Hero US$10.50
Bacon, sausage, ham, cheese.
BST Wrap US$10.50
Bacon, spinach, tomato.
East Ender Hero US$10.50
Ham, turkey, Swiss.
American Hero US$10.50
Roast beef, bacon, American cheese, onions.
Burrito Wrap US$10.50
Sausage, cheddar, jalapeño, salsa.
Healthy Man Wrap US$10.50
Turkey, swiss, spinach.
Loaded Wrap US$13.50
Bacon, sausage, home fries, cheddar, spinach, onions, salsa.

Cream cheese & butter
Nova Lox Sandwich US$13.00
Thin sliced smoked salmon, cream cheese, red onion, tomato, capers on a bagel of your choice
Bagel With Butter US$3.48
Bagel W/ Cream Cheese US$0.00
Everything spread, garlic and herb, olive pimento, strawberry, apple cinnamon, bacon and herb, cucumber dill, & jalapeño.

Heroes
Scooby US$12.50
Turkey, bacon, melted Swiss, coleslaw and relish.
B.L.T Hero US$12.50
Bacon, lettuce, tomato.
American US$13.50
Roast beef, turkey, ham, American cheese, lettuce, tomato.
Philly Cheese US$12.50
Roast beef, peppers, onions, and provolone cheese on a toasted garlic hero.
Chicken Blue US$13.50
Breaded chicken cutlet, ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, blue cheese dressing.
Italian Chicken US$13.50
Breaded chicken cutlet, mozzarella cheese, sun dried tomatoes, red onions, mixed greens and oil and vinegar
Italian Hero US$13.50
Genoa salami, ham capicola, pepperoni, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, roasted red peppers, balsamic vinegar and olive oil.
Spicy Turkey US$13.50
Spicy. Turkey, pepper Jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, jalapeño, and spicy jalapeño aioli.

Breakfast Sandwhiches
2 Egg Whites US$7.00
Two Eggs Only US$7.00
One Egg, Meat And Cheese US$8.00
Two Eggs And Meat US$7.25
Bacon Egg Cheese And Hash Brown US$10.50
Meat, Two Eggs And Cheese US$8.75
Start your day right with our delicious breakfast sandwiches. Choose from bacon, sausage, or ham, paired with a variety of cheeses, all served on your choice bread
Two Eggs And Cheese US$6.75

Lunch Specials
Chicken Fajita Wrap US$13.50
Grilled chicken cutlet, melted pepper Jack cheese, sautéed onions, green peppers and salsa.
B.L.T US$9.00
Country Chicken Salad US$12.50
Chicken salad, topped with walnuts and cranberries, lettuce, tomato, and red onions.
Teriyaki Chicken US$13.50
Teriyaki sauce, mixed greens, cucumber + topped with sunflower seeds.
Another Pastrami US$12.50
Pastrami served cold, Swiss cheese, coleslaw, pickles and Russian dressing.
Veggie Veggie Wrap US$11.50
Grilled mushrooms, red roasted peppers, red onions, spinach, tomato, melted provolone served hot with balsamic vinegar and olive oil on a wrap of your choice
House Special US$12.50
Grilled roast beef, onions, mushrooms, melted cheddar, topped with everything season and chipotle aioli.
California Club US$12.50
Turkey, Swiss cheese, bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato, Russian dressing.

Cream Cheese by the Pound
Bacon And Herb US$3.00
Strawberry US$3.00
Cucumber Dill US$3.00
Plain Cream Cheese US$2.75
Walnut Raisin US$3.00
Jalapeño US$3.00
Scallion US$3.00
Olive Pimento US$3.00
Garlic And Herb US$3.00
Everything US$3.00
Nova Lox US$3.25
Vegetable US$3.00
Scallion Bacon US$3.00
Apple Cinnamon US$3.00
Almond Honey US$3.00

East End Bagel Cafe Details

Service options
Kerbside pickup
Delivery
In-store pick-up
In-store shopping
On-site services
Takeaway
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Amenities
Toilet

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

East End Bagel Cafe Photos

East End Bagel Cafe Location

East End Bagel Cafe

New York Suffolk County Southold North Fork County Road 48

46455 County Rd 48, Southold, NY 11971, USA

East End Bagel Cafe Reviews

An average rating of ★4.2 from 152 user reviews.

eggscream cheesebreakfast sandwichesferrynew york bagelcinnamonatmosphereglovesraisin

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

East End Bagel Cafe was our last stop in our search for the best bagel on North Fork LI. I would call this the working man's bagel place since there are a lot of service outsole doing in for their breakfast. They also look to have a full deli which would be great for lunch. Bagels were solid although not the quintessential NYC bagel as a bit bready.bread. service was a little slow too but it looked like their was one person taking the orders and helping the grill person. So not a lot of help in the kitchen. Solid though and a good place to get bagels and bagel sandwiches.
November 05 · Millie Kwan
The best bagels on the North fork.Parking is easy, it's easy to see from the street, and it's a good location.I usually get cinnamon raisin toasted with strawberry cream cheese from here.The people are very kind!Good coffee as well.Have a great day!
August 07 · Jeremiah
awesome spot with really great counter service, they're on top of making sure your order is made how you would like and the whole staff is knowledgeable with the menu and checking orders out, or it seems.both sandwiches were on bagels and they were basically as perfect as you could expect a new york bagel to be. super soft and fluffy on the inside with a nice seasoned crust on the outside (both were everything bagels). basically a perfect pit stop if you're en route to or from the ferry.also i love how long islands standard for BEC's is a runny fried egg.
January 01 · o o
The East End bagels are fantastic. Just had two bagels for breakfast and bought 14 more bagels for the rest of the week they were that good!!! 💯
June 21 · Karl Davis
East End Bagels, the charming little bagel store nestled in Southold's North Road, is a true gem that has become an integral part of our family's summer tradition. This delightful family-owned and operated deli has mastered the art of crafting their own delectable bagels and cream cheese, making it a haven for bagel enthusiasts and breakfast lovers alike.As soon as we arrive in Southold for the summer months, visiting East End Bagels becomes a ritual we eagerly anticipate. The aroma of freshly baked bagels wafting through the air is enough to awaken the senses and whet the appetite. The warm and inviting atmosphere adds to the overall experience, making each visit feel like a homecoming.The bagel selection at East End Bagels is nothing short of impressive. While my son swears by their perfectly toasted and slightly crispy egg bagels, the rest of our family can't resist the temptation of their delectable cinnamon raisin bagels. Our friends who join us for a weekend getaway have become ardent fans of the everything bagels, boasting about their irresistible blend of flavors.But the real star of the show is the freshly made cream cheese that complements the bagels exquisitely. I have a soft spot for the walnut raisin cream cheese, which is an absolute treat, boasting a delightful balance of sweet and nutty flavors. Each bite feels like a gourmet experience, and it's hard to resist indulging in seconds.Beyond the exceptional food, the staff at East End Bagels plays a crucial role in making this establishment truly outstanding. From the moment you walk in, you are greeted with warm smiles and a genuine eagerness to serve. The staff is not only cordial and professional but also exudes a sense of camaraderie that makes you feel like you're among friends. Their passion for their craft is evident in the care they put into each order, making it an all-around enjoyable experience.The word about East End Bagels' excellence has spread like wildfire among our friends who visit us during the summer. Many of them have now become loyal patrons, and they, too, embark on a pilgrimage to this quaint deli every time they return to Southold. It has become a tradition for our extended circle to gather around the breakfast table, indulging in the heavenly bagels and cream cheese, and relishing in the memories we create together.If you find yourself in the North Fork area, East End Bagels is an absolute must-stop destination. Whether you're a local resident or a visitor passing through, the quality of their bagels and the warmth of their hospitality will leave an indelible mark on your heart. East End Bagels has become more than just a breakfast joint; it's a place that captures the essence of community and family, making it an experience we cherish year after year.
August 01 · Pedro Rodriguez