Everyday Bagel: A Local's Guide to Your New Favorite Bagel Shop in St. James

Everyday Bagel Introduce

For many New Yorkers, a bagel isn't just a pastry; it's a way of life. The perfect bagel, with its crisp exterior and soft, chewy inside, is the foundation of a great morning. On Long Island, the search for that perfect bite often leads locals to Everyday Bagel, a beloved spot in St. James. This article will provide a comprehensive look at what makes Everyday Bagel a staple for many in the community, from its convenient location to its extensive menu and services that cater to a busy New York lifestyle. We'll explore why this shop has become a go-to for daily breakfast and lunch, and what you can expect when you walk through its doors or place an order.

The essence of a great bagel shop lies in its ability to consistently deliver quality, flavor, and service. Everyday Bagel has built a reputation on these principles, offering a wide array of options that go beyond the basic bagel and cream cheese. Whether you're in the mood for a classic breakfast sandwich, a hearty lunch wrap, or a simple bagel to take home for the family, this place aims to have something for everyone. With a focus on fresh ingredients and a menu that evolves to include new and exciting items, Everyday Bagel maintains its position as a top choice for those who value both tradition and innovation in their food. This deep dive into the shop will give you all the information you need to make it your next stop for a truly satisfying meal.

While the bagel is the star of the show, it's the full experience that keeps customers coming back. We'll cover everything from their service options, which include online ordering for both pickup and delivery, to the other items on their menu that have earned a loyal following. The convenience of a local spot that understands the needs of its community is invaluable. For the busy professional grabbing a quick bite before work, or the family looking for a weekend brunch, Everyday Bagel has adapted to provide seamless service. This guide is crafted to help you understand all the facets of this local gem, ensuring you know exactly what to expect and why it's worth a visit.

In the following sections, we will delve into the specifics that make Everyday Bagel a standout establishment. We’ll cover their precise location, detailing how easy it is to find and access. We'll also break down their extensive menu and list of services, providing a clear picture of all the delicious offerings available. By the end of this article, you will have a complete understanding of why this bagel shop is a favorite among St. James residents and a must-try for anyone in the area looking for an authentic, delicious bagel experience.

Everyday Bagel is conveniently situated at 731 Middle Country Road in St. James, New York. This location places it right in the heart of a bustling area, making it an easy and accessible stop for anyone traveling through or living in the vicinity. The shop is located on a main thoroughfare, which means it's a quick and simple detour for those on their daily commute or running errands. The proximity to other local businesses and residential areas makes it a natural gathering spot for the community. Ample parking is typically available, so you won't have to worry about a difficult search for a spot. Its central location makes it an ideal place to grab a quick breakfast on the way to work or school, or to stop by for a leisurely lunch.

For those who prefer to have their food delivered, Everyday Bagel has partnered with popular delivery services. This allows customers to enjoy their favorite bagels and sandwiches from the comfort of their own homes or offices. The shop's integration with these platforms ensures that a fresh, hot meal is just a few clicks away. Similarly, for those who are on a tight schedule, the option to order online for pickup is a game-changer. This service lets you place your order ahead of time, ensuring it's ready and waiting for you when you arrive. This eliminates the need to wait in line, making your trip to the bagel shop as efficient as possible. The blend of a physical location with modern digital convenience is a key part of what makes Everyday Bagel so accessible to the local New York community.

Services Offered

Online Ordering: Place your order for pickup or delivery through various online platforms. This service allows you to customize your order and pay in advance, saving you valuable time.
Delivery: Partnering with several food delivery services, Everyday Bagel ensures you can get your favorite items brought right to your door.
Takeout: For a quick and easy option, you can order and pick up your food directly from the counter.
Catering: The shop offers options for catering, making it a great choice for local events, parties, and office breakfasts.
In-Store Dining: Enjoy your meal in a cozy and friendly atmosphere. While the shop is a popular spot for takeout, it also offers a nice environment for those who wish to eat there.

Features and Highlights

Wide Variety of Bagels: Everyday Bagel is known for its extensive selection of bagels, with over 20 varieties. You can find everything from classic plain and sesame bagels to more unique flavors like jalapeño and chocolate chip. They also offer gluten-free options to accommodate various dietary needs.
Specialty Cream Cheeses: To complement their bagels, they offer a range of specialty cream cheeses. Options include sun-dried tomato, bacon herb, and plain, ensuring there's a perfect spread for every bagel.
Diverse Menu: Beyond bagels, the menu features a wide selection of other items. You can find breakfast sandwiches with a choice of meat, eggs, and cheese, specialty heroes and wraps for lunch, and a variety of salads. They also serve muffins, croissants, and other baked goods.
Coffee and Beverages: The shop serves a variety of expertly brewed coffees and other beverages, including homemade iced tea and a selection of juices. This makes it a great spot for a morning coffee run.
Breakfast and Lunch Options: Whether you're craving a classic bacon, egg, and cheese on a bagel or a hearty honey maple turkey sandwich for lunch, Everyday Bagel has you covered. Their menu is designed to provide delicious meals throughout the day.

Contact Information

Address: 731 Middle Country Rd, St James, NY 11780, USA
Phone: (631) 320-3378

In conclusion, Everyday Bagel is more than just a place to get breakfast; it's an integral part of the St. James community. For New Yorkers in the area, it offers the perfect combination of classic bagel shop tradition and modern convenience. The wide-ranging menu ensures that whether you’re a purist who sticks to a toasted everything bagel with plain cream cheese, or someone who loves to try new and exciting flavors, you’ll find something to love. The shop’s commitment to providing an array of services, including online ordering, delivery, and catering, makes it a suitable choice for everyone, from busy professionals to families on the go.

Its friendly, professional tone is reflected in both its service and its food quality. The fact that it caters to diverse tastes with gluten-free bagels and a wide variety of menu items, from breakfast sandwiches to lunch wraps and salads, shows that it truly aims to be a place for everyone in the neighborhood. This focus on variety, combined with its accessible location on a major road, cements its status as a local favorite. When you're looking for a reliably delicious meal that feels quintessentially New York, Everyday Bagel provides a solid option that’s both convenient and satisfying.

The reputation of a local business is built one customer at a time, and Everyday Bagel’s presence in St. James speaks to its ability to meet the daily needs of the community. It’s a reliable spot for your daily dose of carbs, a quick cup of coffee, or a hearty lunch. For anyone living on Long Island or just passing through, this bagel shop offers a true taste of the New York bagel experience, proving why it's a staple for locals.

Everyday Bagel Services

Potato chips, Snacks
Frito Lays US$3.69
A crispy, flavorful mix of Doritos, Fritos, Lays, and Ruffles. Perfect for sharing and enjoying a variety of textures and tastes in one satisfying snack.
Halls Potato Chips US$3.29

Sides
Home Fries US$5.49
Bacon US$4.49
3 pieces
Home Fries (Large) US$9.49
Turkey Bacon (6 Pieces) US$9.44
6 pieces
Bacon (6 Pieces) US$8.99
6 pieces
Avacado US$3.49
French Fries US$6.49
small
Hash Browns (1 Pc) US$3.66
Sausage US$2.99
Onion Rings US$5.99

Regular Sandwiches
Bologna US$14.69
Succulent and savory bologna served on your choice of bread. Pair with coleslaw, macaroni salad, or potato salad. Choose from roll, seedless rye, white bread, or whole wheat bread.
Honey Maple Turkey US$14.69
Sweet and savory honey maple turkey with a choice of roll, seedless rye, white bread, or whole wheat bread. Pair with coleslaw, macaroni salad, or potato salad.
Roast Beef US$15.74
Tender beef roasted to perfection. Choose from coleslaw, macaroni salad, or potato salad. Enjoy with a roll, seedless rye, white bread, or whole wheat bread.
Chicken Cutlet Sandwich US$14.69
Crispy chicken cutlet on choice of bread with creamy coleslaw, tangy macaroni salad, or flavorful potato salad. Satisfying sandwich option.
Oven Gold Turkey US$14.69
Roasted turkey with herb-infused seasoning. Juicy and tender. Served with your choice of coleslaw, macaroni salad, or potato salad and roll, seedless rye, white bread, or whole wheat bread.
Salami US$14.69
Tantalizing salami sandwich on your choice of roll, seedless rye, white, or wheat bread. Pair it with coleslaw, macaroni salad, or potato salad.
Tuna Salad Sandwich US$14.69
Flavorful tuna salad sandwich on choice of roll, seedless rye, white, or whole wheat bread. Served with coleslaw, macaroni salad, or potato salad.
Egg Salad Sandwich US$14.69
Satisfying sandwich with creamy egg salad. Choose from rolls, seedless rye, white or whole wheat bread. Options of coleslaw, macaroni salad, or potato salad on the side.
BLT US$14.69
Savory bacon with crisp lettuce and ripe tomato on choice of bread. Served with options of coleslaw, macaroni salad, or potato salad. A classic favorite for a satisfying meal.
Ham Sandwich US$14.69
Choose a side: Coleslaw, Macaroni Salad, Potato Salad. Select a bread: Roll, Seedless Rye, White Bread, Whole Wheat Bread. Enjoy a classic sandwich with tender ham.
Lox&Cream Cheese US$14.69
Smooth cream cheese with savory lox on your choice of roll, seedless rye, white, or whole wheat bread. Served with coleslaw, macaroni salad, or potato salad.
Chicken Salad Sandwich US$14.69
Freshly grilled chicken salad served on choice of roll, seedless rye, white, or whole wheat bread. Sides: coleslaw, macaroni salad, or potato salad. Flavorful and satisfying.
Grilled Chicken US$14.69
Options: Choose from coleslaw, macaroni salad, or potato salad for a side. Pick a roll, seedless rye, white bread, or whole wheat bread. Grilled chicken: juicy and flavorful.
Pastrami US$14.69
Slow-roasted, savory pastrami served on your choice of bread. Side options include coleslaw, macaroni salad, or potato salad. Enjoy a classic deli favorite.

Acai Bowl
Smoothie 32oz US$13.99
Acai Bowl US$16.79
Acai ,granola , strawberry ,blueberry coconut ,honey

Specialty Wraps
#6. Tuna Wrap US$13.99
Lettuce and roasted red peppers.
#10. Chicken Cutlet Wrap US$13.99
Melted American, bacon and bbq sauce.
#8. Sausalito Turkey Wrap US$13.99
Melted cheddar, lettuce and avocado.
#5. Grilled Eggplant Wrap US$13.99
Zucchini, roasted red peppers, melted mozzarella & grated romano cheese.
#1. Caesar Wrap US$13.99
Marinated grilled chicken, crisp romaine lettuce, croutons & caesar salad dressing.
#7. Roast Beef Wrap US$13.99
White cheddar, lettuce, tomato, red onions & horse radish mayo.
#9. Grilled Chicken Wrap US$13.99
Melted American, bacon, lettuce & tomato.
#2. Hot Pastrami Wrap US$13.99
Hot roast beef, creamy coleslaw & thousand island dressing.
#4. Honey Maple Turkey Wrap US$13.99
Cheddar cheese, sliced green apple & honey mustard.
#3. Diced Chicken Cutlet Wrap US$13.99
Crisp lettuce, tomatoes, onions & red wine vinaigrette.

Drinks
Vitamin Water US$3.94
xxx Energy Focus power c
16 Onz Hot Tea US$3.19
12 Oz Tropicana Apple Juice US$3.94
16 Onz Hot Coffe US$3.35
Essentia Water (Sport Pack Or 33.8 Oz) US$3.94
sport bottle 700 ml
Poland Spring 1 Liter US$3.68
1 1/2 liter
Joe`S Lemon Ice Tea US$4.19
Red Bull Energy Drink US$4.80
12. onz
Nesquick US$3.94
Choclate , Double Choclate , strawberry Vanilla,
Core Water US$3.98
707 ml sport bottle
12 Onz Hot Tea US$3.14
Smart Water US$3.94
sport bottle
Gingerale US$3.94
20 onz bottle
Poland Spring Water US$3.50
1 liter
Gatorade US$3.94
Thirst-quenching Gatorade available in Lemon, Fruit Punch, Orange, light blue, or Dark blue flavors. Refreshing, tangy, and energizing choices to hydrate and replenish.
12 Onz Hot Coffe US$3.14
Core Water US$4.19
900 ml plastic bottle
20 Onz Ice Coffe US$4.19
32 Onz Ice Coffe US$6.29
Snapple US$3.94
lemon,d.lemon,peach, d.peach,Green tea, D.green tea,Rasberry, D. rasberry, half and half
32 Oz Home Made Ice Tea US$6.29
12 Oz Tropicana Orange Juice US$3.94
Joe`S Peach Ice Tea US$3.99
Yoo Hoo Choclate Drink US$3.94
20 onz glass bottle
Pepsi US$3.94
The bold, refreshing, robust cola
Sprite US$3.94
20onz bottle
Coke US$3.94
20 onz bottle
Smart Water US$4.19
1 Liter
Red Bull Energy Drink US$3.99
8.4 onz
Monster Energy Drink US$4.75
Joe`S Rasberry Ice Tea US$4.19
44 Onz Ice Coffe US$7.34
Essentia Water 1 Liter US$4.19
1 liter plastic bottle
22 Onz Hot Coffe US$3.45
A generous 22-ounce delight of freshly brewed coffee.
22onz Hot Tea US$3.45
Powerade Drink US$3.94
Vibrant orange, bold red, refreshing blue options for a Powerade drink. Quench your thirst with a flavorful, energizing beverage.

3 Egg Omelette
Cheese Omelette US$15.98
Fluffy omelette filled with your choice of melted Swiss, American, or cheddar cheese.
3 Roads Omelette US$16.98
Four egg whites, sliced turkey, swiss.
Mediterranean Omelette US$16.98
Spinach, onions, black olives, tomatoes, feta cheese.
Greek Omelette US$16.98
Cheesy omelette with spinach and onions. Served With Feta Cheese.
Western Omelette US$16.98
Savory omelette packed with diced ham, peppers, and onions. Served with your choice of drink and side addition of hash browns or home fries. Tangy, flavorful, and satisfying.
House Omelette US$16.98
Potatoes, ham, bacon and American cheese.
Garden Omelette US$16.98
Fresh garden vegetables cooked into a fluffy omelette.

Salad Bar
Greek Salad US$14.99
Hearty Greek salad with crisp lettuce, cucumbers, green peppers, onions, kalamata olives, pepperoncini, and feta cheese. Available in Large or Small sizes.
Smoothies US$11.99
Gorgonzola Salad US$9.99
Mixed greens, walnuts, sundried cranberries, topped with gorgonzola cheese and raspberry vinaigrette.
Acai Bowl US$15.99
Sweet acai blend topped with crunchy granola, fresh strawberries, blueberries, and shredded coconut. Drizzled with honey for a delightful and refreshing breakfast or snack.
Garden Salad US$14.99
Crisp lettuce, ripe tomatoes, crunchy cucumbers, green pepper, and zesty onions in your choice of dressing: Balsamic, Blue Cheese, Creamy Caesar, Creamy Italian, French, Lite Italian, Oil & Vinegar, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Red Wine Vinaigrette, Russian, or Thousand Island.
Chef Salad US$15.99
Fresh crisp lettuce with tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers, and hard boiled egg. Topped with pinwheels of roast beef, turkey, ham, swiss, and American cheese. Choose from a variety of dressings.
Caesar Salad US$14.99
Crisp romaine lettuce with garlic croutons, hard-boiled egg, and grated romano cheese. Available in large or small sizes.
Mesclun Salad US$10.99
Mixed greens, shredded mozzarella and roasted red peppers.

Fresh Homemade Salads
Cole Slaw (1/2 Lb) US$7.99
Macaroni Salad (1/2 Lb) US$7.99
Potato Salad (1/2 Lb) US$7.99
Egg Salad (1/2 Lb) US$10.99
Chicken Salad (1/2 Lb) US$10.99
Tuna Salad (1/2 Lb) US$10.99

Grilled Cheese
Triple Grilled Cheese US$10.49
With American cheese.Three sileced butter toasted bread

Bagels
Croissant With Flavored Cream Cheese US$5.99
Croissant With Butter US$5.24
Bagel With Bacon. US$8.91
6 Pieces
Bagel With Sausage & Cheese US$8.39
Bagel With Jelly US$4.19
Bagel With Cream Cheese & Jelly US$5.24
Bagel With Pb & Jelly US$5.03
Bagel With Butter US$4.49
Plain Cream Cheese (1/2 Lb) US$8.91
Muffin With Butter US$5.24
Gluten Free Bagel Plain US$4.73
Gluten Free Bagels (1 Pc) US$4.73
Bagels US$2.35
Muffin With Cream Cheese US$5.24
Croissant US$3.99
Dozen Bagel US$25.00
Buy Dozen Get 3 Free Bagel
Bagel With Cream Cheese 2 Slices Of Ham US$8.91
Bagel With Sausage & Cream Cheese US$8.39
Half Dozen Bagels ( Get 1 Free) US$12.50
Mini Bagels US$1.42
Flavored Cream Cheese (1/2 Lb) US$9.44
Velvety cream cheese with a choice of flavorful options like bacon herb, jalapeno, or sun dried tomato. Perfect spread for your bagel or toast. Flavorful and creamy.
Croissant With Cream Cheese US$5.24
Bagel With Flavored Cream Cheese US$5.76
Gluten Free Bagel With Butter US$5.24
Muffin With Flavored Cream Cheese US$5.76
Bagel With Butter & Jelly US$5.55
Muffin US$5.78
Blueberry Choclate Chip Double Choclate Chip Banana Nut Corn Muffin Red Velvet Pistachio
Bagel Bundle US$49.99
Fifteen freshly baked sliced bagels with one pound of cream cheese and one pound of butter.
Butter (1/2 Lb) US$8.39
Bagel With Cream Cheese US$4.71
Bagel With Peanut Butter US$4.19
Gluten Free Bagel With Cream Cheese US$5.76

French Toast / Pancakes
Pancakes US$15.74
Fluffy jumbo pancakes drizzled with maple syrup. Add extra syrup or pair with bacon, ham, sausage, or turkey for a savory twist.
Old Fashion French Toast US$15.74
Tender slices of French toast drizzled with maple syrup and butter. Add more syrup or top with bacon, ham, sausage, or turkey for a savory twist.

Specialty Heros
#19. Grilled Chicken Hero US$12.99
Roasted red peppers, lettuce, tomato, onions & balsamic vinegar on a toasted hero.
#9. Roast Beef Hero US$15.99
Sautéed onions, pepper jack, jalapeno sour cream sauce.
#8. Cajun Style Seasoning US$14.99
Roast beef, melted mozzarella & steak sauce on a garlic hero.
#4. Cracked Pepper Turkey Hero US$14.99
Melted cheddar, lettuce, tomato & zesty salsa.
#7. Honey Maple Turkey US$14.99
Crisp bacon, melted cheddar & honey mustard.
#5. Hot Roast Beef Hero US$14.99
Crisp bacon, melted mozzarella & brown gravy on a garlic hero.
#1. Salami Hero US$14.99
Pepperoni, ham, cappi, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, oil & vinegar.
#6. Pastrami Hero US$14.99
Melted swiss, creamy coleslaw & russian dressing.
#18. Pastrami Hero US$14.99
Corned beef, melted swiss, coleslaw & russian dressing.
#21. BLT Bacon Hero US$14.99
Lettuce and tomato.
#3. Oven Gold Turkey Hero US$14.99
Melted swiss, crisp bacon, sauteed onions & russian dressing.
#20. BLT Sliced Turkey Hero US$14.99
Bacon, lettuce and tomato.
#11. Chicken Cutlet Hero US$14.99
Melted American, creamy coleslaw & russian dressing.
#13. Chicken Cutlet Hero US$14.99
Bacon, mozzarella, coleslaw & russian dressing on a toasted garlic hero.
#12. Chicken Cutlet Hero US$14.99
Melted cheddar, bacon and bbq sauce.
#16. Chicken Salad Hero US$14.99
Melted American cheese, bacon, lettuce & tomato.
#14. Roast Beef Hero US$14.99
Mozzarella, on a toasted garlic hero.
#17. Oven Gold Turkey Hero US$14.99
Coleslaw and melted swiss.
#2. Roast Beef Hero US$15.99
Turkey, ham, American cheese, lettuce, tomato & onion.
#10. Hot Pastrami Hero US$15.99
Sauerkraut and deli mustard.
#15. Honey Maple TurkeyHero US$14.99
Bacon, mozzarella, cheddar, lettuce & honey mustard.
#22. Philly Cheesesteak US$15.99
Grilled roast beef, Melted provolone & sauteed onions.

Breakfast Sandwiches
The Hungryman 0n A Roll US$14.99
Three eggs, ham, bacon, sausage and cheese.
3 Egg Any Style US$8.39
2 Egg Any Style US$7.86
Egg And Cheese Sandwich On A Roll Or Bagel US$8.99
Fluffy scrambled eggs paired with melty cheese, nestled in your choice of a soft roll or a chewy bagel.
Bacon Egg Cheese US$13.98
roll or bagel
1 Egg Any Style US$6.29
TurkeyBacon/Egg/Cheese On A Roll Or Any Bagel US$12.99
Sausage ,Egg And Cheese On A Roll Or Bagel US$11.99
Savory sausage, creamy cheese, and a fresh egg nestled together on your choice of a roll or bagel.

Paninis
#5. Maple Turkey Panini US$14.99
Panini Virginia ham, alpine swiss & honey mustard on a flatbread panini.
#4. Bacon Panini US$14.99
Ham, sausage, mozzarella cheese, lettuce.
#3. Turkey Panini US$14.99
Swiss, lettuce, tomatoes.
#6. Chicken Cutlet Panini US$14.99
Crispy bacon, cheddar, and chipotle bbq source on a flatbread panini.
#2. Roast Beef Panini US$14.99
Provolone, lettuce, tomatoes.
#1. Grilled Chicken Panini US$14.99
Mozzarella cheese, roasted red peppers, lettuce, tomatoes.

Freshly Cooked Chicken
Chicken Cutlet (1/2 Lb) US$9.99
Grilled Chicken (1/2 Lb) US$9.99

Quesadilla
Chicken Quesadilla US$13.99
Grilled chicken and cheddar melted between crispy tortillas with zesty salsa and cool sour cream. Flavorful, cheesy, and satisfying.

Everyday Bagel Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pick-up
Takeaway
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot

Everyday Bagel Photos

Everyday Bagel Location

Everyday Bagel

New York Suffolk County Saint James Middle Country Road

731 Middle Country Rd, St James, NY 11780, USA

Everyday Bagel Reviews

An average rating of ★3.6 from 91 user reviews.

pricesegg sandwichesbreakfastbacon egg and cheesedeliverywraprolllakegluten freepay

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

If I could give 0 stars I would. This place is price gouging! Save your money. There are too many options all within 5 minutes of this place. I was charged $9.77 plus tax for a BEC!!! When I asked why I was charged so much they hung up on me. A bacon egg and cheese outside of Manhattan or the Hamptons should not cost $10! I suggest everyone report them. And avoid this place.
November 22 · Martius Seymore
Ordered on Uber eats. They false advertise a free item with purchase. I bought $118 worth of breakfast, they claimed on Uber eats that you get a free item with purchase. They conveniently didn't deliver the free item, then when you try to tell Uber eats you didn't get it, Uber eats says the item is not eligible for refund because it was a promo. I'm sure the store is well aware that they get away with this. Beware the "free item" is a complete scam. Theres a reason this place has a 3 rating. They purposely didn't include the free item, they pull this scam to get you to buy from them then there is no recourse when the don't deliver it through the food sites.
July 20 · mandy d
it’s very overpriced for sandwiches. $10+ for a BEC? and now they’re surcharging for eggs, per egg. the foods good but not for that price. and they can never seems to get my order right if i’m ordering for multiple people, i.e. i was heavy toasted and they want lightly toasted and both of ours will not be toasted at all.
April 12 · Dana Slattery
Great customer service! Great Bagels and Egg Sammie’s!! Super clean and lots of beverages to choose from!You would think Açaí bowls wouldn’t be good at a deli/bagel store but here they are 10/10 I recommend!
July 31 · Dave Keyz
$6.51 for a yogurt parfait. two layers of yogurt, some oats and like 5 berries... $6.51!!!!!!! out of their MIND- and it was definitely left over from the day before. ROBBERY
December 08 · Ashley F