FaNagle the Bagel

Introduction / Overview

For New Jersey residents, especially those along the Jersey Shore, the search for the perfect bagel is a serious endeavor—a quest often settled by finding a place that understands the crucial balance of chewy texture, fresh baking, and generous toppings. In Long Branch, that search frequently ends at FaNagle the Bagel, a beloved, family-owned establishment that has firmly cemented its spot as a local favorite for breakfast and deli-style lunch.

FaNagle the Bagel, run by the Bonforte and Attaway Families, prides itself on being a vibrant hub for bagel enthusiasts. It offers far more than just the basics; customers consistently rave about the "chewy texture" and "fresh ingredients" that elevate their bagels beyond the standard fare. From classic flavors like everything, plain, and poppy to a diverse menu of handcrafted spreads, the shop caters to daily regulars and summer visitors alike.

What truly distinguishes FaNagle is its reputation for crafting a spectacular "breakfast sammich" (sandwich). The staff's commitment to quality is evident, with one delighted customer proclaiming it the "BEST BREAKFAST SAMMICH PLACE EVER," where "every item is made with love." This dedication to high-quality, generously built sandwiches—whether you choose a classic egg and cheese, or one of their unique melt options—is a major draw for the local community in Monmouth County.

In a nod to modern dietary trends while maintaining an old-school charm, the bakery is noted for its diverse and inclusive menu. They thoughtfully cater to various dietary preferences by offering dedicated options for vegan and gluten-free guests, ensuring everyone can enjoy a satisfying experience. This welcoming atmosphere, combined with a positive and peaceful vibe, makes FaNagle the go-to spot for a quick, delicious start to the day near the beach.

It is crucial for visitors to note the shop’s operational policy: FaNagle the Bagel largely operates on a cash-only basis, despite some initial confusion regarding payment options. However, for customer convenience, an ATM is readily available on-site, ensuring a quick and smooth transaction even for those who prefer plastic. The overall emphasis on a quick visit, friendly staff, and consistent food quality ensures that any minor inconvenience is quickly forgotten once you take that first bite of a freshly made bagel or a hearty sandwich.

***

Location and Accessibility

FaNagle the Bagel is situated in a prime, easy-to-reach location along the Jersey Shore, making it highly convenient for both Long Branch residents and those passing through the area. Its address is a stone's throw from the coast, ideal for grabbing breakfast before a beach day.

The physical address is:

444 Ocean Blvd N, Long Branch, NJ 07740, USA

Accessibility features at the location are designed to accommodate all patrons:

• Wheelchair-accessible entrance for easy access into the deli and ordering area.
• Wheelchair-accessible car park for convenient, designated parking.
• Free-of-charge street parking is often available nearby, a significant convenience in a high-traffic shore area like Long Branch.

***

Services Offered

FaNagle the Bagel offers a comprehensive menu that goes far beyond a simple bagel with cream cheese. Their services are designed to fuel a busy New Jersey morning or provide a satisfying midday meal.

• Fresh-Baked Bagels: Classic varieties and daily fresh options, available individually, by the half-dozen, or by the dozen.
• Specialty Breakfast Sandwiches: Including the highly-rated "Finagle's Famous Egg Sandwich," "The Patriot" (grilled steak and egg), and customizable options with bacon, ham, sausage, avocado, or chorizo.
• New York Deli-Style Sandwiches: A variety of hearty lunch melts and sandwiches, such as "Finagle's Famous Smokehouse Club," Tuna Melts, and the "Chipotle Chicken Bacon Melt."
• Lox and Cream Cheese: Featuring the classic "Smoked Salmon & Cream Cheese" on a handcrafted bagel, served with red onion, tomato, and capers.
• Healthy and Specialty Options: Dedicated gluten-free bagel options, house-made vegan cream cheese varieties, and customizable healthy menu items like the "Tomato & Avocado Scrambled Egg Plate."
• Beverages: Serving a full range of hot and cold drinks, including fresh coffee, iced coffee, hot tea, iced tea, and lemonade.
• Dining Services: Available options include comfortable dine-in service, quick takeaway for customers on the go, and in-store pick-up for efficient ordering.

***

Features / Highlights

The elements that make FaNagle the Bagel a standout choice for local residents include its focus on quality, atmosphere, and inclusivity:

• Exceptional Breakfast Sandwiches: Regularly cited by customers as the "BEST" place for a breakfast sandwich, known for generous portions and fresh preparation.
• Fresh, Chewy Bagels: The core product is consistently praised for its desirable, chewy texture and fresh, made-daily quality, which is the hallmark of a true New Jersey bagel shop.
• Dietary Inclusivity: A commitment to offering dedicated gluten-free bagels and innovative vegan cream cheese options, ensuring a welcoming experience for customers with dietary restrictions.
• Cash-Only Operation with Onsite ATM: While an operational note, the cash-only policy is a defining feature of its 'old-school' charm, made convenient by the provision of an available ATM for easy access to funds.
• Positive and Efficient Service Vibe: Staff members are described as "super friendly," and the atmosphere is noted for being "peaceful & positive," leading to quick order fulfillment even during busy peak hours.

***

Contact Information

For New Jersey locals looking to grab a quick, delicious bite or inquire about large orders, here is the contact information for FaNagle the Bagel:

• Address: 444 Ocean Blvd N, Long Branch, NJ 07740, USA
• Phone: (732) 571-0066

***

What is Worth Choosing

For first-time visitors or seasoned regulars at FaNagle the Bagel, maximizing your experience means indulging in the items that the Long Branch community has celebrated for years. The following items are most definitely worth choosing:

The Breakfast Sandwich: This is the signature attraction. Whether you opt for a classic bacon, egg, and cheese or explore the unique melts, the combination of a freshly baked bagel and generously layered, high-quality ingredients makes for a truly satisfying start to your day. The popular recommendation is to try a classic egg, pepper, and ketchup on an Everything Bagel for that quintessential Jersey breakfast taste.

The Freshly Baked Everything Bagel: In New Jersey, the Everything Bagel is the yardstick by which all bagel shops are measured. FaNagle’s version consistently receives high praise for its robust flavor and chewy consistency. Order it toasted with their house-made cream cheese, or try one of the innovative vegan cream cheese options for a fresh, flavorful spread.

The Smoked Salmon & Cream Cheese Sandwich: For those seeking a classic New York deli-style experience, this sandwich is a must. Served with smoked salmon, red onion, capers, and cream cheese, it perfectly embodies the quality of the shop's handcrafted bagels and toppings.

Finally, be sure to embrace the local wisdom: as one customer advises, if it’s busy, "just walk in & place ur order," as the staff often moves with impressive speed. And, remember to bring cash or use the on-site ATM to ensure a seamless transaction, allowing you to quickly enjoy the "BEST BREAKFAST SAMMICH PLACE EVER."

FaNagle the Bagel

444 Ocean Blvd N, Long Branch, NJ 07740, USA