Fit for a Cookie: Atlanta's Premium, Black-Owned Gourmet Cookie Shop in Midtown

Fit for a Cookie Introduce

Introduction / Overview

For residents and visitors in the Georgia region, especially those navigating the vibrant heart of Atlanta, satisfying a serious sweet craving just got an upgrade. Fit for a Cookie is a premier destination for those who believe a cookie should be more than just a snack—it should be an experience. This establishment is not your typical cookie shop; it is a dedicated Black-owned small business that specializes in hand-rolled, premium gourmet cookies designed to be a reward worth savoring. Located in the bustling Midtown area, Fit for a Cookie has carved out a dedicated following by focusing on large, uniquely flavored desserts that strike a perfect balance of texture and richness.

The philosophy behind Fit for a Cookie centers on crafting a luxurious dessert experience. Each cookie is described as being baked to satisfy your sweet side without the guilt, focusing on rich flavors and a perfect texture. The owners take pride in their distinctive methodology, which involves meticulous attention to detail, from making their own butter to blending four kinds of vanilla and four types of chocolate in some of their signature cookies. They aim to deliver a product that is "more than a cookie... It's an experience," offering a nostalgic yet sophisticated bite that feels both homemade and entirely premium.

Fit for a Cookie invites you to indulge in the cozy charm of classics reinvented and exciting new flavor combinations. They are the ideal stop for a Quick visit to grab a delightful Dessert after work, during a shopping trip, or simply when a craving for something truly special hits. This local Atlanta gem is a must-try for anyone in the Georgia area seeking a high-quality treat and an opportunity to support a dedicated small business in the community.

Location and Accessibility

Fit for a Cookie is strategically located in the heart of Atlanta’s dynamic Midtown neighborhood, making it incredibly accessible for people traveling from all parts of the Georgia metro area. The shop is housed within the popular Politan Row at Colony Square food hall, offering a central and exciting dining environment.

Address: 1197 Peachtree St NE Suite 150, Atlanta, GA 30361, USA

For customers concerned about city parking, the location offers a significant convenience. Visitors to Politan Row at Colony Square are eligible for validated parking in the Colony Square parking garage, typically offering up to two hours free. Customers simply need to bring their parking ticket to the Ambassador's Stand within the food hall for validation before exiting.

The business is also committed to ensuring ease of access for all patrons. Key accessibility features confirmed for the location include a Wheelchair accessible entrance and a Wheelchair accessible parking lot, underscoring its welcome to the entire community. This central location, combined with convenient parking and accessibility features, solidifies Fit for a Cookie as an easy and rewarding stop in your Midtown Atlanta itinerary.

Services Offered

Fit for a Cookie focuses on providing high-quality gourmet desserts with efficient service options tailored for the busy urban customer.

Gourmet Cookie Sales: Offering large, individually priced, hand-rolled cookies baked fresh daily.
In-Store Pickup: Customers can easily retrieve their pre-ordered or on-site purchases.
Takeout: Quick service for grabbing a treat to enjoy on the go or at home.
Dessert Dining: The location within Politan Row at Colony Square provides a perfect spot for an immediate sweet indulgence.
Coffee Offerings: Serving coffee to pair perfectly with their decadent cookies.
Convenient Payments: Accepting major Credit cards and Debit cards.
Parking Validation: Providing Free Validate Parking for customers in the Colony Square garage.
Specialty Desserts: The popular Cookie Sundae is a signature offering, featuring a warm cookie paired with ice cream.

Features and Highlights

What truly sets this Midtown bakery apart is its combination of quality, unique flavor profiles, and community identity.

Black-Owned Small Business: A point of pride and a great way for local customers to support minority entrepreneurship in the Atlanta community.
Premium, Gourmet Cookies: Each cookie is a substantial, hand-rolled dessert, often featuring multiple layers and blends of high-quality ingredients, like four types of chocolate in the Vanilla Bean Chocolate Chip cookie.
Signature Flavors: Must-try creations like the Oreo Chocolate Chip Cookie (layered with white chocolate ganache and Oreo crumble) and the Toasted S'mores Cookie (infused with cinnamon graham cracker dough and topped with toasted marshmallows).
The Cookie Sundae: A customer-favorite dessert combining a warm, gooey cookie base with a scoop of premium ice cream for the ultimate summer treat.
Perfect Texture: Customers consistently praise the cookies for achieving the ideal balance of crispy outer edges and a soft, moist center, elevated by a rich brown sugar base.
Prime Midtown Location: Located within the trendy Politan Row at Colony Square food hall, making it a great stop for professionals and families alike.

Contact Information

To plan your visit or place an order for in-store pickup, use the contact details below.

Address: 1197 Peachtree St NE Suite 150, Atlanta, GA 30361, USA
Phone Number: (678) 245-9562

What is Worth Choosing

For anyone in Georgia looking for a truly rewarding dessert, Fit for a Cookie is definitely worth seeking out. The core of their appeal lies in the quality of the product—they elevate a simple cookie into a decadent experience. Customers often describe the taste as authentically "homemade," suggesting that the dedication of the executive baker and owner, Craig Bravo, truly comes through in the final product.

The most highly recommended menu item is the Cookie Sundae. While the preparation of the cookie's warmth can sometimes be inconsistent, the concept of a molten, rich cookie paired with a scoop of cold ice cream like BlueBell is a perfect combination and a highly craveable Dessert option. For a pure cookie experience, locals frequently gravitate toward the creative and comforting flavors. The Vanilla Bean Chocolate Chip Cookie, which incorporates a blend of four different types of chocolate, is often cited as the ultimate version of a classic. Similarly, the The Lovely Red Velvet Cookie, with its Dutch red velvet cocoa base and white chocolate chips, is a standout for flavor and color.

Moreover, by choosing Fit for a Cookie, you are actively supporting a valuable member of the Black-owned small business community in Atlanta. The combination of easy Midtown access with validated parking, a passionate owner, and cookies that truly live up to the promise of being a "reward" makes this shop an essential visit. Whether you crave the cozy spice of an Oatmeal White Chocolate Chip Cookie or the indulgent layers of the Toasted S'mores Cookie, every bite at Fit for a Cookie is an intentional, flavorful indulgence designed to make your day a little sweeter.

Fit for a Cookie Menu

Cookies
Oreo Chocolate Chip Cookie $6.89
Cookies and cream taken to another level!! This cookie is layered with white chocolate ganache, Oreo cookie crumble and, milk chocolate chips.
The Lovely Red Velvet Cookie $6.89
The lovely red velvet has a Dutch red velvet coca base, layered with white chocolate chips and vanilla wafers.
Toasted S'mores Cookie $6.89
A soft-baked, cinnamon graham cracker-infused cookie dough, topped with toasted marshmallows, a marshmallow filling, and milk chocolates layered throughout the cookie dough.
Vanilla Bean Chocolate Chip Cookie $6.89
The ultimate chocolate chip cookie! A beautiful, soft textured cookie incorporated with a blend of 4 different types of chocolate chips and vanilla extract.
Oatmeal White Chocolate Chip Cookie $6.89
Old fashion rolled oats soaked in vanilla extract; blended into a brown cinnamon sugar cookie dough, layered with white chocolate chips.

Fit for a Cookie Details

From the business
Identifies as Black-owned
Small business

Service options
In-store pickup
Takeout

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Dessert

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards

Fit for a Cookie Photos

Fit for a Cookie Location

Fit for a Cookie

Georgia Fulton County Atlanta Midtown Atlanta Peachtree Street Northeast

1197 Peachtree St NE Suite 150, Atlanta, GA 30361, USA

Fit for a Cookie Reviews

An average rating of ★4.6 from 138 user reviews.

chocolate chipvanillaoreored velvetoatmealwhite chocolateflavordoughcookie sundaefood court

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

🅿️ Free Validate Parking🍨 Must Try their Cookie Sundae, such a perfect dessert for the summer.🍪 Where every bite is a reward worth craving. From the nostalgic crunch of Oreo Chocolate Chip, to the dreamy swirl of Lovely Red Velvet, the cookies are baked to satisfy your sweet side--without the guilt. Indulge in the cozy charm of Oatmeal White Chocolate Chip, or savor the rich smoothness of Vanilla Bean Chocolate Chip and 🍓 shortcake cookie. Each cookie is a little celebration--crafted with love, packed with flavor, and always fit for a cookie kind of day.Fit for a Cookie is the kind of treat that makes you pause mid-bite just to savor the moment. These cookies strike the perfect balance between crispy edges and a soft, moist center, with a rich brown sugar base that adds a warm, caramelized depth to every bite. You can tell they’re homemade—not just in taste, but in the feeling they leave behind. There’s a cozy, heartfelt quality to them that tastes like someone baked love right into the dough. Whether you’re craving comfort or just a seriously good cookie, Fit for a Cookie delivers in every way.
June 03 · Maitran Le
I had the cookie sundae because a molten cookie with BlueBell sounded good. I dove in immediately and the cookie was soft at best, not molten, and the bottom was rock hard. The ice cream was good. The service was great.My score is strictly because the cookie was just edible, solidly in the "just fine" category. For the price, I'll skip the cookie next time.
September 06 · Andrew Mildahl
Finally got to try Fit For a Cookie in Midtown Atlanta and wow… this place is a *must* for cookie lovers. 🍪✨ From the second you walk in, the smell alone tells you you’re in for something special. And fun fact: they even make their own butter for the dough! How’s that for dedication to the perfect cookie? Here’s what I tried (and yes, I’d order them all again):• Oreo Chocolate Chip x Vanilla Bean Chocolate Chip – four types of vanilla + four kinds of chocolate = dreamy and rich.• The Lovely Red Velvet – soft Dutch cocoa cookie layered with white chocolate chips and Vanilla Wafers.• Oatmeal White Chocolate Chip – buttery, chewy, and nostalgic in the best way.• Strawberry Shortcake Cookie – a seasonal fave that’s light, fruity, and sweet.• Dulce de Leche Cookie – white chocolate ganache, Oreo crumble, and milk chocolate chips all in one thick, gooey bite.• Cookie Milk – literally tastes like melted cookie magic.• Cookie Sundae – topped with rainbow sprinkles and straight-up fun in a bowl. 🍨Every cookie is thick, golden on the edges, and soft in the center — baked fresh daily at Politan Row inside Colony Square
April 17 · Serving Looks ATL
Update. Fit for a cookie has 10/10 customer service. I contacted them to verify if they deliver or have delivery with uber eats or door dash. They don’t but they made it right for me. I placed the order and because I couldn’t leave work during the time they are open. They delivered 6 fresh baked cookies to me. My order was for 6 cookies. I have shared the with my family and friends. Thank you for the outstanding customer service. They communicated from the time I placed the order until they were delivered. Very professional. Go treat yourself with some of these cookies 🥰❤️😊
July 17 · Ms. G Wms
The cookie i had was the vanilla bean, it's like your typical chocolate chip cookie, it was a warm dough in the middle. It's very decadent so make sure you have water or milk but it is tasty
July 20 · Dee Fletcher