Frosty's cake + ice cream

Introduction / Overview

For residents across the Ohio region, particularly those in the Greater Cleveland area, Frosty's Cake + Ice Cream in Lakewood has become a destination that redefines modern dessert indulgence. Operating since 2022, this is not just another local bakery; it is a dedicated, 100% vegan, scratch bakery and ice cream shop that proudly serves treats that are indistinguishable from their traditional counterparts—often surpassing them in flavor and texture. Located on the bustling Madison Avenue, this small business has quickly earned a loyal following by creating desserts that are not only "gorgeous but delicious also!"

Frosty's success lies in its commitment to baking everything fresh daily and using its own scratch-made ingredients, including batter, buttercream, fruit compotes, and caramel. This dedication to quality ensures that every bite, whether of a custom cake, a slice of the rotating menu, a cookie, or a scoop of ice cream, is rich, moist, and perfectly balanced. A crucial aspect that draws in a wide range of Ohio customers is the fact that the entire shop is **100% vegan**, meaning all desserts are made without any animal byproducts. This commitment has been praised by both vegan and non-vegan patrons, with many expressing shock that the quality and flavor of the desserts are entirely plant-based.

The in-store experience is vibrant and varied, offering a constantly changing rotation of cake-by-the-slice and mini-cakes. While classic flavors like vanilla bean, chocolate, and Funfetti are always in demand, the shop frequently surprises visitors with unique seasonal and deluxe options such as Banana-Strawberry, Raspberry Coconut Zinger, and Mocha. The owner, Amanda Orlando, and her staff, are passionate about custom creations, happily accommodating unique flavor requests for celebration and wedding cakes. The shop also features a full ice cream menu, including soft serve (which rotates flavors like passion fruit and seasonal pumpkin spice) and scooped ice cream, offering a full suite of frosty treats to satisfy any sweet tooth in Lakewood.

The bakery’s reputation is built on specific, highly-rated items. Customers consistently rave about the "perfect cake to frosting ratio" and the amazing texture of the cakes. A particular standout that garners extreme praise is the oatmeal cream pie cookie, described as a "10 out of 10" item with a delightful "gingerbread cookie vibe"—a must-try for any local Ohio user. This combination of a welcoming atmosphere, professional and helpful staff, and consistently amazing, high-quality vegan desserts makes Frosty’s Cake + Ice Cream a premier stop on the Cleveland-area dessert map.

Location and Accessibility

Frosty's Cake + Ice Cream is located in the heart of the community at

13343 Madison Ave, Lakewood, OH 44107, USA

For customers driving to the location, the business is well-situated to cater to a quick visit. Parking options include both **Free street parking** and **Paid street parking**, providing flexible convenience regardless of the time of day. This is a vital feature in a dense urban setting like Lakewood, ensuring that patrons can easily stop in to grab a slice, pick up a custom cake, or enjoy a scoop of ice cream. The overall accessibility of the location makes it a go-to spot for locals running errands or for those making a special trip from other parts of the Cleveland metropolitan area to pick up a celebration cake.

Services Offered

• In-Store Shopping: Offering a variety of daily-baked goods, including rotating flavors of cake-by-the-slice, cupcakes, cookies, and brownies for immediate purchase.
• Custom Cake Orders: Specializing in customized celebration cakes, wedding cakes, and cupcakes, with an extensive guide for flavors, fillings, and sizes.
• Ice Cream Service: Serving both scooped ice cream and soft serve (with weekly rotating flavors), often in custom combinations like sundaes.
• Onsite Services: Providing a space for customers to enjoy their treats immediately within the shop.
• Takeout: Offering quick and convenient packaging for all menu items, including ice cream in cups or pints.
• Deluxe and Specialty Flavors: Catering to unique requests with a wide array of premium cake and filling flavors, from Caramel Raspberry to Mocha and Pistachio Cream.
• Digital Payment Options: Accepting Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for a fast and hassle-free transaction experience.

Features / Highlights

• 100% Vegan Menu: A defining feature, offering a fully plant-based selection of cakes, ice cream, cookies, and brownies that delights all customers, regardless of their diet.
• Scratch Bakery Commitment: All ingredients, including batter, buttercream, and fillings (fruit compote, caramel), are made fresh daily in-house, ensuring superior quality and flavor.
• Highly-Rated Signature Items: Famous for the amazing Oatmeal Cream Pie cookie and cakes with "perfect cake to frosting ratio" and great texture.
• Custom Cake Expertise: Specializing in high-quality, "gorgeous" custom celebration and wedding cakes, with an extensive flavor list for personalization (e.g., Key Lime, Cassata, Chocolate Pretzel Praline).
• Rotating Daily Menu: Offering daily "cake-by-the-slice" and mini-cake flavors that change constantly, providing variety and encouraging repeat visits.
• Small Business Integrity: A locally owned and operated small business that is actively invested in the community and provides professional, helpful service.
• Dual Dessert Focus: Excelling equally in both baked goods (cakes, cookies) and frozen treats (scooped ice cream, soft serve), ensuring a comprehensive dessert experience.

Contact Information

Address: 13343 Madison Ave, Lakewood, OH 44107, USA

Phone: (440) 857-0845

What is Worth Choosing

For residents across Ohio, choosing Frosty's Cake + Ice Cream is an excellent decision driven by three key factors: **Uncompromising Vegan Quality, Custom Creation Mastery, and Signature Item Excellence.**

The **Uncompromising Vegan Quality** is the main differentiator. Frosty's is not just vegan-friendly; it is 100% vegan, yet the taste and texture of its treats are so exceptional that customers often can’t believe they are eating plant-based desserts. This dedication ensures that people with dietary restrictions (including those avoiding dairy or egg) can safely enjoy every item without sacrificing flavor. This commitment elevates the bakery from a simple dessert spot to an inclusive culinary destination in the Cleveland area.

The bakery’s reputation for **Custom Creation Mastery** is another major draw. For Ohio users planning a wedding, birthday, or any special celebration, Frosty's is the trusted partner for a centerpiece dessert. They are known for creating custom cakes that are not only "gorgeous" but also delicious, offering deluxe flavors and unique combinations. The staff’s willingness to create every component—from the batter to the buttercream—from scratch guarantees a level of freshness and customization far beyond standard commercial bakeries. This personalized service is invaluable when planning important events.

Finally, the **Signature Item Excellence** means the daily offerings are just as good as the custom orders. The cakes are renowned for their perfect "cake to frosting ratio" and moist texture, proving that quality is maintained even in slices sold in-store. The legendary Oatmeal Cream Pie cookie—praised for its 10/10 spice blend—is reason enough for a dedicated visit. Coupled with the professional, helpful staff and the convenience of its Madison Avenue location, Frosty’s Cake + Ice Cream provides a consistently amazing experience that makes it a highly recommended and essential stop for any dessert lover in the Ohio region.

Frosty's cake + ice cream

13343 Madison Ave, Lakewood, OH 44107, USA