Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill NY: A Hamptons Staple for Authentic New York Bagels

Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill Introduce

For many New Yorkers, especially those residing in or visiting the Hamptons, the search for an authentic, perfectly crafted bagel is a quintessential experience. Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill, located at 760 Montauk Hwy Bldg #3, Water Mill, NY, stands as a beacon for bagel enthusiasts. This establishment has quickly become a beloved staple in the area, renowned for delivering that crisp-on-the-outside, chewy-on-the-inside perfection that New York bagels are famous for. It's a place where the aroma of freshly baked bread greets you at the door, promising a delicious start to your day or a satisfying meal at any time.

Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill isn't just about bagels; it's a vibrant hub that offers a comprehensive menu to satisfy various cravings. While the lines can be long, especially during peak hours, customers consistently note that the wait is worth it, a testament to the quality and popularity of their offerings. The system in place, though busy, is efficient, ensuring that the flow of customers moves steadily. This lively atmosphere, coupled with efficient and friendly customer service, creates a positive experience despite the bustling environment. For locals seeking a reliable and high-quality spot for their morning coffee, breakfast sandwich, or even a casual lunch, Goldberg's provides a dynamic and delicious option.

What truly sets Goldberg's Famous Bagels apart is their dedication to variety and their commitment to the authentic New York bagel tradition. They offer a wide selection of classic bagels, alongside unique and inventive flavors like Asiago and French toast, ensuring there's something to excite every palate. Beyond bagels, their menu expands to include unexpected delights such as pizza and ice cream, adding layers of convenience and appeal for families and individuals. This blend of traditional excellence and surprising variety makes Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill a truly unique and compelling destination for anyone in the New York region looking for a superior bagel experience and much more.

Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill is conveniently located at 760 Montauk Hwy Bldg #3, Water Mill, NY 11976, USA. This address places it directly on Montauk Highway, a primary artery connecting various towns across the Hamptons. For residents and visitors alike, this makes the bagel shop highly accessible whether driving from Southampton, Bridgehampton, or other surrounding areas. Being situated on such a prominent road ensures that finding the location is straightforward, making it a convenient stop for those on their daily commute, weekend excursions, or vacation trips throughout the Hamptons.

The location in Water Mill is described as "beautiful," suggesting a pleasant environment that enhances the overall experience of visiting the bagel shop. While the area can be bustling, particularly during peak season, the ease of access via Montauk Highway helps manage customer flow. Ample parking is generally available at such locations, which is a significant convenience in the often-crowded Hamptons. This accessibility is crucial for a local business, as it encourages repeat visits and draws in a wider customer base from across Suffolk County and beyond.

Furthermore, its presence in Water Mill, a well-known and charming part of the Hamptons, contributes to its appeal as a local gathering spot. Customers can easily incorporate a stop at Goldberg's into their errands, beach trips, or leisure activities. The building itself is part of a larger complex or building group, indicated by "Bldg #3," which might suggest a small plaza or retail cluster, further adding to its convenience. Overall, the strategic placement of Goldberg's Famous Bagels in Water Mill ensures that New Yorkers have a readily available and appealing option for their bagel and deli needs.

Services Offered:

Traditional and Unique Bagels: A vast selection of freshly baked bagels, including classic options like plain, poppy, sesame, everything, onion, and egg, as well as unique flavors such as Asiago, French toast, cinnamon raisin, garlic, salt, and pumpernickel.
Specialty Cream Cheeses: A wide array of "Famous Schmears & Spreads," including cucumber dill, sundried tomato, walnut raisin, scallion, honey cranberry, olive, and lox cream cheeses, along with low-fat and tofu options.
Breakfast Sandwiches: A popular selection of hearty breakfast sandwiches, including the "Grandstand" and "Hobo" sandwiches (with bacon, egg, cheese, and hash brown), and options to customize with various meats, eggs, and cheeses on bagels, flats, bread, or croissants.
Omelettes: Freshly made omelettes with various fillings like lox and onions (The Leo), ham, cheese, peppers, and onions (The Western), and healthy options like Farm Fresh (turkey bacon, spinach, avocado, salsa).
Deli Sandwiches and Wraps: A comprehensive menu of deli sandwiches, including classic favorites, Reubens (with "CARNEGIE DELI" corned beef and pastrami), turkey clubs, and specialty wraps like Buffalo Chicken and Pepper Turkey Fajita.
Pizza: Unexpected but highly popular pizza offerings, including pepperoni pizza bagels, providing a quick meal option.
Ice Cream: A surprising addition to their offerings, providing a sweet treat for customers.
Coffee and Creative Drinks: A selection of delicious coffee and "fun, creative drinks."
Market Area: A dedicated market area selling a wide selection of different products, including homemade salads, fish platters (Nova Scotia Salmon, Whitefish, Chubs, Baked Salmon, Sable, Sturgeons), and bakery items like Rugelach and black and white cookies.
Catering Options: Available for various events, offering platters of bagels, sandwiches, and other deli favorites.
Online Orders: Convenient online ordering for pick-up or delivery (via platforms like DoorDash and Postmates).

Features / Highlights:

Authentic New York Bagel Experience: Known for boiling and baking bagels the "old fashion way" to achieve that signature crisp outside and soft, chewy inside, delivering a quintessential New York bagel.
"Best Bagels in Tri-State Area": Customer reviews frequently praise their bagels as among the best in the wider tri-state region.
Wide Variety of Bagel Flavors: Offers both traditional and unique bagel flavors, catering to a broad range of preferences.
Exceptional Breakfast and Deli Menu: Beyond bagels, their breakfast sandwiches (e.g., The Grandstand, The Hobo) and deli offerings are highly celebrated for their size, inventiveness, and deliciousness.
Friendly and Efficient Service: Despite potentially long lines, the staff is consistently described as friendly, efficient, and very accommodating.
Lively and Bustling Atmosphere: The popularity of the shop means it's often busy, which contributes to a lively and energetic environment.
Convenient All-Day Options: Bagels are considered "great any time of day," and their extensive menu covers breakfast, lunch, and even quick snacks.
Expansive Market Area: Offers a variety of homemade salads, smoked fish, and other deli items, making it a one-stop shop for meals.
High-Quality Ingredients: Utilizes premium meats (e.g., Boar's Head), fresh ingredients, and "Elite thinly sliced nova."
Surprising Offerings: The inclusion of pizza and ice cream adds to the appeal, especially for families.

Contact Information:

Address: 760 Montauk Hwy Bldg #3, Water Mill, NY 11976, USA

Phone: (631) 726-0139

Mobile Phone: +1 631-726-0139

In conclusion, Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill, located at 760 Montauk Hwy Bldg #3, Water Mill, NY, is an essential destination for any New Yorker seeking an authentic and delightful bagel experience. Its prime location on a major Hamptons thoroughfare ensures easy accessibility for residents and visitors throughout Suffolk County. While the vibrant atmosphere can mean a bit of a wait, the consistent feedback highlights that the superior quality of their bagels and extensive menu make it unequivocally "worth the price" and the wait.

What truly makes Goldberg's suitable for locals is not just their "award-winning" bagels, baked with that perfect crisp-chewy texture and offering both traditional and unique flavors like Asiago and French toast. It's also the expansive menu that goes far beyond bagels, encompassing delicious and inventive breakfast sandwiches, comprehensive deli options with quality meats, and even unexpected delights like pizza and ice cream. Combined with friendly and efficient service, and a diverse market area offering various grab-and-go items, Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill serves as a true one-stop shop for quality food and a bustling community atmosphere, making it a highly recommended local favorite in the Hamptons.

Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill Food & drink

Quesadillas
The Annie US$16.65
Quesadilla with eggs, bacon, taylor ham, sausage, muenster cheese with a side of salsa and sour cream
Chicken Quesadilla US$16.65
Grilled chicken, muenster, chipotle mayo and salsa.
The Liza US$16.65
Grilled chicken quesadilla, eggs, peppers, mozzarella, bacon, cheese. sour cream and salsa on the side

Goldberg's drinks
Arnold Palmer US$4.00
Cold Brew US$5.00
Iced Coffee US$4.00
Strawberry Matcha Latte US$5.70
Strawberry pure, choice of milk, matcha and vanilla.
Fresh Brewed Hot Coffee US$3.00
Dermont Cloud US$4.95
Iced Hazelnut coffee with vanilla cold foam
Ocean Matcha Latte US$5.70
Blue butterfly pea tea, matcha, and your choice of milk.
Hot Tea US$3.00
Iced Golden Cream Latte US$5.30
Espresso with condensed milk and choice of almond or oat milk.
Hot Chocolate US$3.50
Chai Latte US$4.50
Caffe Latte 16 Oz. US$5.80
Iced Latte US$5.00
Lemonade US$4.00
Hot Matcha US$5.00
Iced Dulce De Leche Shaken Espresso US$5.50
Espresso shots, Dulce de Leche sauce with cinnamon, and choice of milk.
Capuccino 12oz. US$5.15
Iced Matcha Latte US$5.50
Red Eye US$4.00
Box Of Joe US$30.99
Serves up to ten cups of freshly brewed coffee.
Iced Chai Latte US$5.00
Unsweetened Iced Tea. US$4.00

Chop Salads
Greek Salad US$16.65
Chopped lettuce, tomatoes, onions, black olives, feta cheese, cucumbers, grape lives, Greek dressing.
Cobb Salad US$16.65
Bacon, hard boiled eggs, grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, cucumbers and onions.
Chicken Caesar Salad US$16.65
Chopped grilled chicken, lettuce, parmesan cheese, croutons and creamy dressing.
Spring Salad US$16.65
Walnuts, cranberries, feta cheese, spinach, lettuce and grilled chicken.
Buffalo Chicken Salad US$16.65
Chopped chicken, lettuce, red onion, blue cheese, buffalo sauce.
Tossed Salad US$15.65
Lettuce, tomato, carrots, cucumbers, onions.

Sandwiches
Italian Sub US$21.15
Served with macaroni, coleslaw or potato salad and a pickle. Ham, cappy ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato, roasted peppers, cherry peppers, garlic powder, basil, oregano, oil & vinegar.
Grilled Chicken Fresh Mozzarella US$22.45
Meatball Parm Hero US$18.65
Sausage Peppers Hero US$21.15
Chicken Parm Hero US$22.45
Goodfellas Sub US$23.65
Served with macaroni, coleslaw or potato salad and a pickle. Cappy ham, mortadella, sopressata, prosciutto, salami, pepperoni, provolone cheese, mayonnaise, lettuce, tomato, onions, roasted peppers, cherry peppers, oil and vinegar, balsamic vinegar and red sauce spread. Chicken cutlet or grilled chicken, mozzarella, roasted peppers, arugula and pesto.
Philly Cheesesteak With Onions And Peppers US$21.15
Eggplant Parm Hero US$19.95

Lunch
Riverhead US$16.15
Fried salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato, oil & vinegar.
Grilled Cheese US$9.99
Fatboy US$22.45
Roast beef, ham, turkey, cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and Russian dressing.
Goldbergs Grilled Cheese Inside Out On Everything Bagel US$11.25
Hot Dog And Fries US$8.15
Hampton Bays US$21.15
Ham, turkey, coleslaw and Russian dressing.
South Hampton US$19.95
Roast beef, melted Muenster, tomato and peter lugers sauce on a garlic hero.
Philly Chicken US$19.95
Grilled chicken, with onions, peppers, pepper jack cheese & BBQ sauce.
Springs US$21.15
Breaded chicken cutlet, bacon, lettuce and tomato.
Great Richard Sergi US$19.95
Grilled chicken, bacon, roasted peppers, hot cherry peppers, chipotle mayo.
GTO US$19.95
Honey turkey, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato and honey mustard.
Turkey US$16.15
Sagaponack US$18.65
Honey turkey, lettuce, tomato, onions and honey mustard.
Tom Catalina US$19.95
Hot roast beef, taylor ham, Muenster cheese, grilled onions and chipotle mayo.
The Gallo US$21.15
Chicken cutlet, bacon, roasted peppers, cherry peppers, chipotle mayo and pepper jack cheese.
East Hampton US$19.95
Turkey, pastrami, coleslaw and Russian dressing.
Harley & Shelby US$19.95
Grilled chicken, bacon, gouda, lettuce, tomato, chipotle mayo.
Sag Harbor US$18.65
Ham, Swiss, coleslaw and Russian dressing.
Pastrami Southwestern US$21.15
Pastrami, pepper jack cheese, honey mustard and coleslaw.
Buffalo Chicken Wrap US$19.95
Breaded cutlet, blue cheese, hot sauce and lettuce.
Mattituck US$17.45
Pepper turkey, bacon, lettuce and tomato.
Spicy Roast Beef US$21.15
Spicy. Roast beef, sautéed onions, cheddar, horseradish with mayo.
Rissiro US$21.15
Hot roast beef, bacon, mozzarella, grilled onions, BBQ sauce & chipotle mayo.
Doctor KJ US$19.95
Hot turkey, bacon, provolone, lettuce, tomato, Russian dressing.
Montauk US$21.15
Roast beef, Swiss, coleslaw and Russian dressing.
Chicken Fingers And Fries US$12.45
East Quogue US$21.15
Grilled chicken, bacon, avocado, lettuce and tomato.
Goldbergs Cheesesteak US$21.15
Hot roast beef (steak) grilled onions, peppers, melted cheese, potato salad on hero.
Spargo Special US$18.65
Tuna salad, tomato, pickles, melted cheddar, vinegar.
Road Glide US$21.15
Roast beef, turkey, cheese, roasted peppers and Russian dressing.
Quogue US$24.95
Carnegie corned beef, melted mozzarella, coleslaw and Russian dressing.
Philly Cheesesteak US$21.15
BLT US$13.75
Chop Cheese US$21.15
Chopped beef, grilled onions with sazon, adobo, grilled onions, lettuce, tomatoes, mayo and ketchup on choice of hero, goldberg’s trifold hero or roll. Add jalapeños or cherry peppers. Add avocado, sour cream & salsa, bacon, taylor ham, sausage patty, 2 hash browns for an additional charge.
Mafia Ron US$19.95
Hot turkey, provolone, hot peppers, lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo.
Cheeseburger And Fries Or Home Fries US$19.95
70 Chevelle US$19.95
Hot pepperoni, turkey, bacon, mozzarella, hot cherry peppers and chipotle mayo.
Bridgehampton US$23.65
Carnegie pastrami, corned beef, coleslaw and Russian dressing.

Reubens
Healthy Reuben US$18.95
Fresh turkey, Swiss, sauerkraut, Russian dressing on rye bread.
Pastrami Reuben US$21.95
Pastrami, Swiss, sauerkraut, Russian dressing on rye bread.
Reuben Duo US$22.15
Corned beef and pastrami, Swiss, sauerkraut, Russian dressing on rye bread.
Corned Beef Reuben US$21.95
Corned beef, Swiss, sauerkraut, Russian dressing on rye bread.

Bakery
Muffins US$5.50
Each.
Croissants US$5.00
Each.
Donuts US$3.00
Apple Friters US$4.00
Cookies US$4.00
Each. Large cookies.

Goldberg’s Market
Electrolit Fruit Punch US$4.99
Electrolit Electrolyte Drink, Fruit Punch, 21.0 oz Bottle
Muscule Milk Intense Vanilla US$6.99
Muscle Milk Pro Advanced Nutrition Intense Vanilla 40G Protein, 14 Oz Bottle
Granola Cramberries US$6.99
No artificial flavors, preservatives, or colors; No high fructose corn syrup; Non-GMO; All natural and vegan Great to eat for breakfast or added to your favorite treat. Delicious, crunchy, and always fresh Kosher Certified
Popcorn Butter US$2.99
1.0 oz Bag
Culture Pop Soda Watermelon US$3.60
Culture Pop Soda Watermelon, Probiotic Soda, 12 fl oz
Culture Pop Soda Black Cherry US$3.60
Culture Pop Soda Black Cherry, Probiotic Soda, 12fl oz
Pure Leaf Lemon US$3.25
18.5 FL OZ BOTTLE
Ryl Iced Tea, Morgan Wallen Sweet Tea US$3.60
Ryl Iced Tea, Morgan Wallen Sweet Tea, Antioxidant Super blend, Zero Sugar, Low Carb,16.0 oz, Can
Elite Must Cubes Watermelon Mango Liquid Center Sugar Free Chewing Gum US$5.95
Elite Must Cubes Watermelon Mango Liquid Center Sugar Free Chewing Gum 2 oz
Lemon Perfect Dragon Fruit Mango US$3.75
Lemon Perfect Hydrating Lemon Water 15.2oz, Zero Sugar Hydrating lemon water made with USDA Organic ingredients elicious and refreshing enhanced water beverage
David Protein Bar, Cinnamon Roll US$5.95
David Protein Bar, Cinnamon Roll 64 g
Elbows Barilla US$3.99
Barilla Pasta Elbows 16 oz Package
Just Ice Tea Lewi´S Lemon Tea US$3.85
16 FL OZ BOTTLE
Celcius Artic Vibe US$3.85
12 FL OZ CAN
Celcius Sparkling Kiwi Guava US$3.85
12 FL OZ CAN
Granola Honey US$6.99
SUNBEST HONEY ALL NATURAL GRANOLA 15 OZ
The Ryl Co Peach Iced Tea US$3.60
The Ryl Co Peach Iced Tea, 16 fl oz
Naked Mighty Mango US$4.99
Naked Juice Mighty Mango Flavored 100% Fruit Smoothie Blend, 15.2 fl oz Naked Juice Mighty Mango is an amazingly exotic, incredibly yummy smoothie made from fruits provided by Mother Nature, including mangoes, oranges, apples, banana and more Masterfully crafted, lip-smacking fruit smoothie with no sugar added: with delicious Naked Juice Mighty Mango you can pack more into your day Vegan fruit smoothie from apple juice concentrate and other quality ingredients, there are no preservatives and it's non-GMO Project verified; separation is natural - shake well before opening With no artificial flavors, this refreshing Naked Juice Mighty Mango fruit smoothie is packed with Vitamin A and contains Vitamin C and potassium
Tropicana Grape US$3.85
1 FL OZ
Ryl Iced Tea, Half & Half US$3.60
Ryl Iced ea, Half & Half, Anioxidan Superblend, Zero Sugar, Low Carb, Low Calorie Iced
Strawberry Ice Cream US$8.99
Long Island Creamery 473 ml
Starbucks Frappuccino Vanilla US$4.95
13.7 FL OZ BOTTLE
Just Ice Tea Mango White Tea US$3.85
16 FL OZ BOTTLE
David Protein Bar, Blueberry Pie US$5.95
David Protein Bar, Blueberry Pie 58 g
Spindrift Unsweetened Lime US$3.75
Spindrift Sparkling Water, Lime Flavored, Made with Real Squeezed Fruit, 16 Fluid Ounce Can
Oreo Cheescake US$8.99
Long Island Creamery 473 ml
Starbucks Frappuccino Coffee US$4.95
13.7 FL OZ BOTTLE
Culture Pop Soda Strawberry US$3.50
Culture Pop Soda Strawberry Rhubarb, Probiotic Soda, 12 fl Coz
Chips, Reduced Cool Ranch, 1 Ounce US$1.25
Once Upon A Coconut Watermelon US$4.00
Once Upon A Coconut Watermelon Coconut Water 10.8 fl oz
Electrolit Coconout US$4.99
Electrolit Electrolyte Drink, Coconut, 21.0 oz Bottle
Bagel Chips US$7.99
Vanilla Ice Cream US$8.99
Long Island Creamery 473 ml
Smore Ice Cream US$8.99
Long Island Creamery 473 ml
Muscule Milk Slammin Strawberry US$6.99
Muscle Milk Pro Advanced Nutrition Slammin' Strawberry 40G Protein, 14 Oz Bottle
Elite Must Cherry Sugar Free Chewing Gum US$6.95
Elite Must Cherry Sugar Free Chewing Gum 2.3 oz
Hal´S Sea Salt And Vinegar US$4.50
Hal's New York Kettle Cooked Potato Chips, Sea Salt & Vinegar, 5 oz
David Protein Bar, Peanut Butter Chocolate Chunk US$5.95
David Protein Bar, Peanut Butter Chocolate Chunk 58 g
Celcius Sparkling WaterMelon Lemonade US$3.85
12 FL OZ CAN
Once Upon A Coconut Coco US$4.00
Once Upon A Coconut Pure Coconut Water 10.8 fl oz
Fritos The Original Corn Chip 1 Oz US$1.25
Rainbow Cookie Ice Cream US$8.99
Long Island Creamery 473 ml
Doritos Nacho Cheese Tortilla Chips 1 Oz Bag, US$1.25
Lemon Perfect Original Lemon US$3.75
Lemon Perfect Hydrating Lemon Water 15.2oz, Zero Sugar
Whoopie Pie Chocolate US$7.99
6 Pz package
Pepsi US$3.85
Original 20 FL OZ BOTTLE
Ryl Iced Tea, Raspberry US$3.60
Ryl Iced Tea, Raspberry, Antioxidant Superblend, Zero Sugar, Low Carb, Zero Calorie Iced Tea, 16.0 Fl Oz
Spindrift Unsweetened Blood Orange Tangerine US$3.75
SPINDRIFT Blood Orange Tangerine Sparkling Water Single, 16 FZ
Heaven + Eart Popcorn Sea Salt US$6.50
Lemon Perfect Blueberry US$3.75
Lemon Perfect Hydrating Lemon Water 15.2oz, Zero Sugar
Tropicana No Pulp Orange Juice LG US$6.50
46 FL OZ 100% Orange Juice
Half And Half US$4.99
Creamer Half & Half 32 FL OZ BOTTLE
Muscule Milk Knockout Chocolate US$6.99
Muscle Milk Pro Series Protein Shake, 40g - Knockout Chocolate - 14 oz
Tropicana Pineapple Mango US$3.85
11FL OZ BOTTLE
Crumb Cake Sm US$4.99
Hahn's Old Fashioned Crumb Cake 9 OZ
Elite Tropical Fruit Sugar Free Chewing Gum Must Cubes US$6.95
Elite Tropical Fruit Sugar Free Chewing Gum Must Cubes 2 oz
Cheetos Crunchy, 1 Oz US$1.25
Baked, Lay's Barbecue Potato Crisps, 1.125 Ounce US$1.25
Tropicana Apple US$3.85
11 FL OZ
C4 Zero Sugar Strawberry US$3.50
C4 Performance Energy Drink, Strawberry Starburst™, 16oz, Single Can
Tropicana Lively Lemonade US$3.85
11 FL OZ
Canoli Chip Ice Cream US$8.99
Long Island Creamery 473 ml
David Protein Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Flavored Bar US$5.95
David Protein Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Flavored Bar 2.19 oz
Ryl Iced Tea, Green Citrus US$3.60
Ryl Iced Tea, Green Citrus, Antioxidant Superblend, Zero Sugar, Low Carb,16.0 Fl Oz, Can
LAY's® Baked Original Potato Chips, 1.125 Ounce US$1.25
Darigold Old Fashioned Chocolate US$3.50
Darigold Chocolate Milk 2 Percent - Reduced Fat Milk, Shelf Stable Milk Bottle With 9 Essential Nutrients, rsBT Free - 14 oz, (Old Fashioned Chocolate)
Pure Leaf Unseetened US$3.25
No Sugar 18.5 FL OZ BOTTLE
Ruffles Ruffles Potato Chips Cheddar & Sour Cream Flavored 1 Oz US$1.25
Electrolit Blue Raspberry US$4.99
Electrolit Electrolyte Drink, Blue Raspberry, 21.0 oz Bottle
Just Ice Tea Half Tea And Half Lemonade US$3.85
16 FL OZ BOTTLE
Spindrift Unsweetened GrapeFruit US$3.75
Spindrift Sparkling Water, 16-Fluid-Ounce Can
Hal´S Jalapeño Chips US$4.50
Hal's NY Kettle Cooked Potato Chips, Jalapeno, 5 oz Bag
Celcius Sparkling Orange US$3.85
12 FL OZ CAN
C4 Zero Sugar Frozen US$4.75
C4 Frozen Bombsicle Energy Drink Can 16 fl oz
David Protein Cake Batter Flavored Bar US$5.95
David Protein Cake Batter Flavored Bar 2.19 oz
Gatorade Lemon Lime US$3.85
20 FL OZ BOTTLE
Hal´S Original Sea Salt US$4.50
Hal's New York Kettle Cooked Potato Chips, Gluten Free, Sea Salt, 5 oz Bag
Crumb Cake Lg US$6.99
Hahn's Old Fashioned Crumb Cake 16 oz
Once Upon A Coconut Chocolate US$4.00
Once Upon A Coconut Chocolate Coconut Water 10.8 fl oz
Garofalo Organic Pasta US$3.99
Garofalo Organic Pasta 17.6 oz,
Starbucks Frappuccino Mocha US$4.95
13.7 FL OZ BOTTLE
Whoppie Pie Red Velvet US$7.99
Peanut Butter Fudge US$8.99
Long Island Creamery 473 ml
Organic Wild Maine Blueberry Jam US$18.95
Stonewall Kitchen USDA Organic Wild Maine Blueberry Fruit Spread, 30 Ounce
C4 Zero Sugar Watermelon US$3.50
C4 Performance Energy Drink Jolly Rancher Watermelon 16oz Single Can
Sauce And Dip Buttery Buffalo US$7.99
Kinder,S Wing Sauce Buttery Buffalo 23.5Oz
David Protein Bar, Salted Peanut Butter US$5.95
David Protein Bar, Salted Peanut Butter 58 g
Lemon Perfect Watermelon US$3.75
Lemon Perfect Hydrating Lemon Water 15.2oz, Zero Sugar
Elite Must Sugar Free Spearmint Gum US$6.95
Elite Must Sugar Free Spearmint Gum 2 oz
Just Ice Tea Original Black Tea US$3.85
16 FL OZ BOTTLE
Tropicana Cranberry Juice US$3.85
11 FL OZ BOTTLE
Assorted Italian Cookies US$9.99
Elite Must Sugar Free Peppermint Gum US$6.95
Elite Must Sugar Free Peppermint Gum 2oz
Hals Sour Cream And Onions US$4.50
Hal's New York Kettle Cooked Potato Chips, Gluten Free, Sour Cream & Onion, 5 oz Bag
Granola Blueberry US$6.99
SUNBEST BLUEBERRY ALL NATURAL GRANOLA 15 OZ
Elite Must Cubes Grapes Sugar Free Chewing Gum US$6.95
Elite Must Cubes Grapes Sugar Free Chewing Gum 2 oz
Cheetos Baked 50% Less Fat US$1.25
Just Ice Tea Moroccan Mint Green Tea US$3.85
16 FL OZ BOTTLE
Gatorade Fruit Punch US$3.85
20 FL OZ BOTTLE
David Protein Fudge Brownie Flavored Bar US$5.95
David Protein Fudge Brownie Flavored Bar 2.19 oz
Celcius Fizz Free Peach Mango And Green Tea US$3.85
12 FL OZ CAN Smooth, Fizz-Free Energy: Enjoy a refreshing, non-carbonated energy boost without the bloating or discomfort of carbonated drinks, making it a smooth and easy choice for hydration and performance. Green Tea + Guarana Power: Infused with natural caffeine from green tea and guarana, this drink delivers steady, long-lasting energy without the jitters or crashes associated with artificial stimulants. Metabolism-Boosting Formula: Packed with thermogenic ingredients like ginger extract and B vitamins, this formula supports an active metabolism to help you power through workouts and daily activities.
Naked Blue Machine US$4.99
Naked Juice Blue Machine Flavored 100% Juice Smoothie Blend, 15.2 fl oz Naked Juice Blue Machine is the iconic smoothie made with real fruit including apple and blueberry juice from concentrate plus banana and blackberry puree A nutritious boost with no sugar added and something extra inside: chicory root fiber to provide even more goodness A flavorful and refreshing smoothie that is also plant-based and vegan, made with no preservatives and non-GMO Project verified; the separation is natural - shake it well before opening
Tropicana Fruit Punch Refresher US$3.85
11 FL OZ
Electrolit Strawberry Kiwi US$4.99
Electrolit Electrolyte Drink, Strawberry Kiwi, 21.0 oz Bottle
Pepsi Diet US$3.85
20 FL OZ BOTTLE
C4 Zero Sugar Grape US$3.50
C4 Performance Energy Drink, Grape Popsicle, 16 oz, 1 Can
Elite Must Sugar Free Refreshing Mint Gum US$6.95
Elite Must Sugar Free Refreshing Mint Gum 2oz
Spindrift Unsweetened Raspberry Lime US$3.75
Spindrift Sparkling Water, 16-Fluid-Ounce Can
Lemon Perfect Peach Raspberry US$3.75
Lemon Perfect Hydrating Lemon Water 15.2oz, Zero Sugar
Hal´S Barbeque Chips US$4.50
Hal's New York Kettle Cooked Potato Chips, Gluten Free, BBQ, 5 oz
Ryl Iced Tea, Unsweetened Black Tea US$3.60
Ryl Iced Tea, Unsweetened Black Tea, Antioxidant Superblend, Zero Sugar, Zero Carb, Zero Calorie Iced Tea, 16.0 Fl Oz
Tropicana No Pulp Orange Juice US$3.85
11 FL OZ 100% Orange Juice
Electrolit Lemon Lime US$4.99
Electrolit Electrolyte Drink, Lemon Lime, 21.0 oz Bottle
Naked Strawberry Banana US$4.99
Naked Juice Strawberry Banana Flavored 100% Fruit Smoothie Blend, 15.2 fl oz Naked Juice Strawberry Banana: packed with more than 10 strawberries to give you an unbelievably tasty smoothie made from juice concentrate from apples, bananas, strawberries and oranges Masterfully crafted, lip-smacking fruit smoothie with no sugar added: with delicious Naked Juice Strawberry Banana, you can pack more into your day Vegan fruit smoothie from apple juice concentrate and other quality ingredients, there are no preservatives and it's non-GMO Project verified; separation is natural - shake well before opening
Culture Pop Soda Orange Mango US$3.60
Culture Pop Soda Orange Mango, Probiotic Soda, 12 fl oz
Popcorn Caramel US$3.99
1.0 oz
Celcius Peach Vibe US$3.85
12 FL OZ CAN
Naked Green Machine US$4.99
Naked Juice Green Machine Flavored 100% Juice Smoothie Blend, 15.2 fl oz Naked Juice Green Machine is the iconic smoothie made with real fruit and veggies – partially from concentrate – including apple juice concentrate, pineapple juice plus mango, banana and kiwi puree No sugar added and an extra boost of broccoli, spinach, kale, parsley, ginger, wheat grass, barley grass, alfalfa, spirulina and garlic A flavorful and refreshing green smoothie that’s also plant-based and vegan, made with no preservatives and is non-GMO Project verified Naked Juice Green Machine contains vitamins A, C and B6 and tastes amazing; the handy 15.2 fl oz bottle is easy to take on the go and enjoy its goodness inside anytime, anywhere
Lay's Classic Potato Chips Snack Chips, 1 Ounce Bag US$1.25
Lay's Classic Potato Chips Snack Chips, 1 Ounce Bag KOSHER No Preservatives Includes three ingredients: potatoes, oil, and salt U.S. gluten free product No Artificial Flavors No MSG
Darigold Chocolate US$3.50
Made with Real Cocoa 9 Essential Nutrients Excellent Source of Calcium Vitamins A & D rbST Free*
David Protein Bar Red Velvet US$5.95
David Red Velvet Bar 2.5 oz
Darigold Strawberry US$3.50
Darigold Milk, Low Fat, Strawberry

By the Pound
Specialty Cream Cheese 1/2 Pound US$9.50
Baked Salmon Salad 1 Pound US$25.00
Plain Cream Cheese 1/2 Pound US$8.50
Plain Cream Cheese
Egg Salad 1/2 Pound US$7.49
Tuna Salad 1/2 Pound US$10.00
Plain Cream Cheese 1 Pound US$17.00
1 Pound Plain Cream Cheese
Whitefish 1 Pound US$25.00
Whitefish 1/2 Pound US$12.50
Fresh Sliced Lox 1 Pound US$79.99
Specialty Cream Cheese 1 Pound US$19.00
Low Fat Veggie Tuna 1/2 Pound US$10.00
Fresh Sliced Lox 1/4 Pound US$19.99
Chicken Salad 1 Pound US$19.00
Fresh Sliced Lox 1/2 Pound US$39.99
Egg Salad 1 Pound US$14.99
Low Fat Veggie Tuna 1 Pound US$20.00
Baked Salmon Salad 1/2 Pound US$12.50
Chicken Salad 1/2 Pound US$9.50
Tuna Salad 1 Pound US$20.00

Bagels
Bagel With Baked Salmon Salad US$17.95
Veggie Hummus Bagel US$15.95
Bagel with hummus, cucumbers, tomato, onions, avocado and arugula.
The New Yorker US$19.95
Fresh sliced lox, cream cheese, capers, red onions, and tomatoes on a bagel.
Bagel With Tofu Plain Cream Cheese US$7.25
Bagel With Butter US$4.00
Bagel With Egg Salad US$10.49
12 Bagels US$30.00
Flat Bagel US$3.00
Each.
Special Bagel: French Toast Bagel, Super Cinnamon Or Cheddar Jalapeño US$3.50
Bagel With Chicken Salad US$15.95
Bagel With Low Fat Veggie Tuna US$15.95
Bagel With Tuna Salad US$15.95
Bagel With Peanut Butter US$4.99
Bagels US$2.50
Each.
Bagel With Flavored Cream Cheese US$7.25
6 Gluten Free Bagels US$21.00
Original Sunshine Gluten Free
6 Bagels US$15.00
New Jersey Sushi Bagel US$24.95
Fresh sliced lox, cream cheese, avocado, sriracha mayo and sliced cucumber on a bagel.
Bagel With Whitefish Salad US$17.95
Bagel With Plain Cream Cheese US$5.00
Bagel With California Chicken Salad US$15.95
Gluten Free Bagel US$3.50
Original Sunshine Gluten Free Bagels
Bagel With Tofu Flavored Cream Cheese US$8.25
6 Flats US$18.00

Pizza
Meats Supreme US$27.50
Meatball, pepperoni and sausage.
Meatball US$26.50
Pizza Combo US$39.99
2 18 inch Pizza Pies 12 Garlic Knots
Gran Ma Pie US$27.95
Pepperoni US$26.50
Gluten Free Pizza 12" US$14.95
6 Garlic Knots US$5.85
Chicken Ranch US$27.50
Plain US$21.50
Sausage US$26.50
Cauliflower 12" US$14.95

Omelettes
The Western US$18.65
3 eggs, ham, cheese, peppers and onions. Served with a toast and home fries.
Spinach And Feta Cheese Omelette. US$16.65
Made with 3 eggs, served with a toast and home fries.
Cheese Omelette US$13.95
Made with 3 eggs, served with a toast and home fries.
Farm Fresh US$18.65
3 egg whites, turkey bacon, spinach, avocado and salsa.Served with a toast and home fries.
The Habanero US$18.65
3 eggs, spicy ham, muenster cheese, onions, peppers and chipotle sauce.Served with a toast and home fries.
Spicy Veggie US$16.15
Spicy, vegetarian. 3 eggs, spinach, onions, peppers, mushrooms, jalapeños and salsa.Served with a toast and home fries.
South Beach US$13.95
3 egg whites, tomato, onion, olives and peppers.Served with a toast and home fries.
The Leo US$19.45
3 eggs, lox, onions. Served with a toast and home fries.
Meat Omelette US$16.45
Made with 3 eggs, served with a toast and home fries.
Loco Pollo US$18.65
3 eggs, grilled chicken, avocado, salsa and pepper jack cheese. Served with a toast and home fries.

Breakfast
Hungry Man US$14.95
Eggs, bacon, ham, sausage, cheese and hash brown on a hero.
Spicy Hobo US$13.70
Spicy. Bacon or sausage, eggs, pepper jack cheese and hash brown with hot sauce.
Power Wrap US$14.95
Eggs, grilled spinach, Swiss cheese, grilled chicken.
French Toast US$10.99
Mean Gene US$13.65
French toast bagel, bacon, sausage or taylor ham, eggs and cheese.
2 Eggs US$7.75
The Viper US$14.95
Hot roast beef, eggs, bacon, mozzarella and American cheese.
Avocado Toast US$12.45
Choice of toast with avocado, lettuce, tomato, everything seasoning and over easy egg.
Hobo US$13.70
Bacon or Sausage, eggs, cheese and hash brown.
Meat US$8.25
The Power House US$14.95
Egg whites, turkey, lettuce, tomato and hot sauce.
3 Pancakes US$12.95
Meat And Eggs US$9.85
Hungry Woman US$14.95
Egg whites, turkey bacon, spinach and Swiss on a whole wheat wrap.
The Lesley US$14.95
Turkey bacon, eggs, spinach, grilled peppers, onions, pepper jack cheese.
Heritage Softail US$14.95
Bacon, eggs, cheddar cheese, scallion cream cheese and hot honey.

Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill Details

Service options
Takeaway

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards

Parking
Free parking lot

Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill Photos

Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill Picture 1

Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill Picture 2

Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill Picture 3

Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill Picture 4

Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill Picture 5

Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill Picture 6

Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill Picture 7

Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill Picture 8

Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill Picture 9

Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill Location

Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill

New York Suffolk County Water Mill Montauk Highway

760 Montauk Hwy Bldg #3, Water Mill, NY 11976, USA

Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill Reviews

An average rating of ★4.5 from 45 user reviews.

pizzacream cheeseeverything bagelice creamselectionmarketsalad

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

So the atmosphere can be overwhelming to those who have anxiety. The long was really long but it moves along and they have a system that works, which I can appreciate. Wait total was perhaps 15 mins. Customers service was efficient and friendly, no complaints on that. On the other hand, Customers are all over the place and some bumping into each other, making this more difficult than it should be.I stepped out my comfort zone and got cucumber dill cream cheese. So freaking good. And I got an egg everything bagel toasted. It was great. Wish I could've had 2. Bagels are great any time of day. Nice fuel before we head for montauk.
July 13 · Tee
I love coming to this place! I’m so happy they are finally in Water Mill. The location is beautiful, and they have a great variety of traditional bagels, as well as unique flavors like Asiago and French toast. They even sell pizza, which was a great surprise, and they also have ice cream!Everyone is very friendly, and they have a wide selection of different products in their market area. Their coffee is delicious, and they even have some fun, creative drinks. Highly recommend!
March 02 · Fer F
I come to Goldberg’s Bagels in Water Mill all the time and it never disappoints. The bagels are always fresh and perfectly made, crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. My go-to is the bacon, egg, and cheese on an everything bagel and it hits the spot every single time. The staff already knows my order which makes the experience even better. Everyone is friendly, the service is quick, and the place is always clean. Whether I’m grabbing something to go or eating there, it’s always a solid start to my day. Easily my favorite bagel spot in the Hamptons.
July 16 · Zyaki
My boyfriend and I have been wanting to come to Goldbergs in water mill, and we are very pleased with our first visit. Our egg sandwiches are delicious so does the coffee ☕️ A great addition to Water Mill community!
February 24 · B Chaiyaoup (Becky)
Amazing!! You have everything from bagels, muffins, coffee, to salads, sandwiches and even pizza 🍕 The cream cheese was so fresh, never had anything like it. Lots of healthy options and a market place with all your home necessities like pasta, sauce, granola, cookies, oils, chips. The staff is super friendly and you can tell they love what they do!
December 24 · mykovasyl