Great American Cookies & Creamery: Custom Cookie Cakes & Ice Cream in Bethlehem, GA 30620

Great American Cookies Introduce

For families and individuals across Barrow County, Georgia, and particularly those in the 30620 zip code, a celebration is never complete without a centerpiece dessert that is as fun as it is delicious. Great American Cookies in Bethlehem has established itself as the premier destination for just that, offering much more than its name suggests. This is not only a top-tier cookie shop renowned for its iconic Cookie Cakes and signature treats like the Double Doozie$^{text{®}}$, but also a full-service creamery featuring homemade ice cream, shakes, and sundaes.^{text{®}}$, and for instant gratification.^{text{®}}$ and the classic cookies are well-known favorites that ensure a consistent, beloved taste for return customers.

Convenient Service and Payment: Offering Delivery and supporting modern payment methods (NFC mobile payments) streamlines the process for busy customers, aligning with the "Quick visit" planning.

Friendly and Reliable Staff: Customer reviews highlight that the people working at the store are "friendly" and contribute to a "good experience," reinforcing the local appeal and pleasant atmosphere.

Contact Information

For residents of Bethlehem, GA, and the 30620 area interested in ordering a custom Cookie Cake, checking ice cream flavors, or arranging delivery, the business can be contacted using the following information:

Address:

656 Exchange Cir Suite #400, Bethlehem, GA 30620, USA

Phone Numbers:

Primary Phone: (470) 997-3004

Mobile Phone: +1 470-997-3004

The dual phone contact information provides flexibility for local customers to reach the shop and discuss their dessert needs effectively.

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Great American Cookies in Bethlehem, GA, is a smart decision for any local resident prioritizing quality, variety, and celebration-ready convenience. The most compelling reason to choose this spot is its specialization in creating Custom, Celebration-Focused Desserts. For every birthday, graduation, holiday, or work event, the ability to order a personalized, perfectly designed Cookie Cake eliminates the stress of finding a unique centerpiece dessert. The sheer breadth of their design catalog means you can always find the right theme to match your occasion in Barrow County.

The second powerful reason is the Exceptional Quality of the Combined Offerings. Unlike places that only offer cookies or only offer ice cream, this location excels at both. The ice cream is "homemade," offering a superior texture and flavor that elevates the entire menu. The ability to combine this homemade ice cream with their classic cookies—creating amazing shakes, sundaes, and sandwiches—provides an unmatched level of indulgence and value, making the slightly higher price points worth the quality, as noted by customer feedback.

Finally, the convenience of Full Service and Accessibility makes the entire process seamless. With delivery options, easy in-store pickup, full wheelchair accessibility, and acceptance of modern payment methods (including NFC mobile payments), Great American Cookies is built to serve the busy Georgia customer efficiently. It is the perfect local business to turn to for reliable, high-quality, and deeply satisfying desserts, solidifying its place as the go-to spot for sweets in the 30620 area.

Great American Cookies Menu

Create Your Own Cookie Cake
Create Your Own Cookie Cake
Create your perfect Cookie Cake! Choose your favorite Cookie Cake shape and flavor, then customize your message with any of our icing colors. For an additional charge, add a design or extras!

Birthday
Balloons - B1030
Dude, You're OLD - B1041
Birthday Fish - B1042
Birthday Horse - B1043
Island Birthday - B1045
Tractor - B1046
Rocket Ship - B1047
Unicorn - B1048
Birthday Bouquet - B1049
Groovy Birthday - B1050
Taco Birthday - B1051
Mermaid Tail - B1052
Level Up - B1053
Forever 29 - B1038
Happy Birthday Jenny - B1037
Birthday BBall - B1039
1st Birthday - B1025
Butterflies - B1006

Father's Day
Coolest Pop - HS2427
#1 Dad Coffee Mug - HS2428
Youre the MVP - HS2426
Dad You're Reely Great - HS2423
Happy Father's Day Football - HS2420
You're Flippin Awesome Dad - HS2419

Sports
Score Basketball - S3509
Good Luck Team Baseball - S3508
Go Team Helmet - S3506
Goal! - S3505
Football Field - S3504
Football Fever! - S3503
Great Season - S3502
Pickleball is Life - S3511

Special Occasion & Thank You
Pink Ribbon - O4052
Thanks A Latte - O4040
Family Reunion Watermelon - O4030
Best Friends Forever - O4016
Prom? - O4024

Baby
Ahoy It’s a Boy! - O4037
He or She - O4036
Welcome Baby - O4004
It’s a Girl Elephant - O4038

Work Occasions
Boss Latte - O4050
Happy Boss's Day Pennant - O4051
Happy Boss’s Day - O4027
Happy Nurse's Day - O4022
You're The Best! - O4011

Summer & Patriotic
4th Of July Flag - HS2507
Happy 4th of July - HS2506
Happy Summer Pool - O4049
Fourth of July - HS2503
US Flag - HS2502

School & Grad
Class of 2025 Diploma - S3026
Class of 2025 Block - S3027
We Love Elementary - S3405
Back to School - S3404
Graduate and Diploma - S3025
Congratulations Grad! - S3005
Hats off to the Grad! - S3009

Halloween
Happy Halloween Cat Ghost Candy Corn - HF2574
Have a Creepy Halloween - HF2575

Thanksgiving & Fall
Thankful Grateful Blessed - HF2659

Winter Holidays & New Years
Happy Holidays - HW2847
Tis the Season to be Jolly - HW2848
Happy New Year - HW2903
New Years Cheers - HW2904

Valentine's Day & LOVE
Bee Mine - HV2050
Love You Cherry Much - HV2051
Hooked on You - HV2034
I Love You! - HV2009
Love Rectangle- HV 2047
I'm Crazy About You! - HV2040

St. Patrick's Day
St. Patrick's Day Hat - HS2202
Kiss Me I'm Irish! - HS2201

Mother's Day
Best Mom Ever – HS2326
Mom, Mommy, Mama – HS2327
Happy Mother's Day Flower Ring - HS2325
Mother’s Day - HS2321

Ice Cream
ICE CREAM CUPS
Our small batch Ice Cream, made fresh in-store daily. Choose your favorite Ice Cream Flavor and FREE Mix-Ins to create infinite Ice Cream possibilities!
HAND-PACKED PINTS $10.99
Take the ice-cream experience home with you. Choose your favorite Ice Cream Flavor and FREE Mix-Ins to create infinite Ice Cream possibilities!
HAND-PACKED QUARTS $14.99
Take the ice-cream experience home with you. Choose your favorite Ice Cream Flavor and FREE Mix-Ins to create infinite Ice Cream possibilities!

Classic Favorites
Birthday Bash
Birthday Cake Ice Cream, Yellow Cake, Rainbow Sprinkles, Mallo Creme
Coffee Crunch
Coffee Ice Cream, Heath Bar Pieces, Sundae Nuts, Fudge Sauce
S'MORES
Sweet Cream Ice Cream, Mini Marshmallows, Graham Cracker Crumbs, Fudge Topping
Candy Bar Blast
Sweet Cream Ice Cream, Mini Marshmallows, Graham Cracker Crumbs, Fudge Topping
ROCKY ROAD
Chocolate Ice Cream, Chocolate Chips, Mini Marshmallows & Mixed Nuts.
COOKIE DOUGH SURPRISE
Birthday Cake Ice Cream, Cookie Dough, Oreo® Cookie Pieces & Fudge Topping.
CHOCOLATE CARAMEL BUTTER PECAN
Butter Pecan Ice Cream, Chocolate Chips, Pecans & Caramel Topping.
COTTON CANDY CARNIVAL
Cotton Candy Ice Cream, Mini M&M's®, Mini Marshmallows & Mallo Creme.
COOKIES 'N CREAM
Sweet Cream Ice Cream, Oreo® Cookie Pieces & Mallo Creme.
STRAWBERRY CARAMEL CHEESECAKE
Cheesecake Ice Cream, Strawberries, Graham Crackers & Caramel Topping.

Ice Cream Cakes
COOKIE JAR CHAOS
This Ice Cream Cake features two layers of chocolate cake and two layers of Sweet Cream® Ice Cream with Oreo® Cookie Pieces and cookie dough pieces, covered in Vanilla Crème Icing and Oreo® Cookie Pieces, then topped with mini chocolate chip cookies, cookie dough pieces, and more Oreo® Cookies Pieces.
STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE
A total classic – with an Ice Cream Twist. Indulge in two layers of yellow cake, drizzled with strawberry puree, and two layers of Sweet Cream® Ice Cream, covered with Whipped Vanilla Crème Icing and topped with Fresh Strawberries and Strawberry Puree.
CHOCOLATE HEAVEN
This rich, indulgent chocolate cake features two layers of Chocolate Ice Cream in between two layers of chocolate cake and is covered in Whipped Chocolate Crème Icing and then topped with Hershey’s® Kisses."
SPRINKLE
This mouthwatering Ice Cream Cake is sprinkled with two layers of yellow cake and two layers of Birthday Cake Ice Cream with rainbow sprinkles. Then, covered in Whipped Vanilla Crème Icing and even more rainbow sprinkles. It’s a party on every plate!
CLASSIC COOKIES & CREAM
Move over cookies and milk — this delicious Ice Cream Cake is the best of both worlds. Sandwiched in between two chocolate cake layers is two layers of Sweet Cream® Ice Cream and Oreo® Cookie Pieces covered with Whipped Vanilla Crème Icing and more Oreo® Cookies Pieces.

Cookies & Brownies
Regular Cookies
Double Doozies®
The Double Doozie® is made with our delectable icing sandwiched between your favorite cookies.
Cookie Cake by the Slice
A slice of our signature Original Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake topped with your choice of chocolate or vanilla icing.

Shakes
STRAWBERRY SHAKE
Marshmallow cream swirl and Strawberry Ice Cream topped with whipped cream and garnished with a strawberry.
COTTON CANDY SHAKE
Marshmallow cream swirl and Blue Cotton Candy Ice Cream topped with whip cream and mini M&M’s®.
COFFEE SHAKE
Hershey’s® chocolate swirl, Sweet Cream Ice Cream and coffee mixture topped with whipped cream and Hershey’s® chocolate syrup.
SNICKERS SHAKE
Caramel swirl, Snickers®, and Sweet Cream Ice Cream topped with whipped cream, Hershey’s® chocolate syrup, and crushed Snickers ® bar.
COOKIES & CREAM SHAKE
Hershey’s® chocolate swirl, Oreo® cookie pieces, and Sweet Cream Ice Cream topped with whipped cream and crushed Oreo® cookies.
CREATE YOUR OWN SHAKE
Create your own Ice Cream Shake. Choose your favorite Ice Cream and Mix-Ins like fruit, candy bars, fudge, cookies, nuts, and more.

Sundaes
CLASSIC SUNDAE $7.79
Vanilla ice cream with choice of fudge or caramel, topped with whipped cream, chopped peanuts, and a cherry.
FUDGE BROWNIE SUNDAE $7.99
Vanilla Ice Cream with fudge brownie pieces and fudge, topped with whipped cream, chopped peanuts, and a cherry.
STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE SUNDAE $7.99
Sweet Cream Ice Cream, yellow cake pieces, and strawberry syrup, topped with whipped cream and fresh strawberries.

Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches
Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich

Beverages
Bottled Beverages

Add-Ons
Cookies & Cream Stuffed Cookie made with Oreo® Cookie
Our Cookies & Cream Cookie stuffed with an Oreo(R) Cookie.

Add-Ons
Cookies & Cream Stuffed Cookie made with Oreo® Cookie
Our Cookies & Cream Cookie stuffed with an Oreo(R) Cookie.

Great American Cookies Details

Service options
Delivery

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Dining options
Dessert

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments

Great American Cookies Photos

Great American Cookies Location

Great American Cookies

Georgia Barrow County Bethlehem Exchange Circle

656 Exchange Cir Suite #400, Bethlehem, GA 30620, USA

Great American Cookies Reviews

An average rating of ★4.5 from 27 user reviews.

cookie cakekidspricesshakeartselection

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

My son and I had a good experience. He had a desire for some ice cream. I tried a sneaker shake and a cookie. It was delicious. Prices were pricey, but quality was good. People were friendly.
March 23 · Latasha J.
So we wanted ice cream. It is homemade which I liked. The small cup includes add in "s ( pecans, chocolate chips and a bunch of other items). One scoop with toppings was $6.95. You can get this in a homemade waffle cone or a cup My husband got a regular size shake. It was $7.95. It was pretty good. We will be back.
June 21 · Keli Jelinek
My wife picked up a cookie cake from Great American Cookie co in Bethlehem for my Brother -in-law and my co-birthday party and it came out amazing. Great art work and it tasted great. Thank you to the owner Anthony and his family for the amazing work they do. I would recommend them to everyone needing something special for their get together. My family is going back tomorrow for ice cream with the kids.
June 09 · Matthew Askins
It’s hit or miss on the art quality depending on who decorates the cake….But they charge a ridiculous art fee, which I have never experienced before in my life until this location. I have ordered a cookie cake every year for all my children’s birthdays and they have never charged an art fee at other locations.
May 15 · J S
I can’t not express how much of a great job and service I received! From ordering, to picking up, to eating it, was all 100% worth every penny. My son was so amazed and happy when he saw his cookie cake 💙. Thank you so much
March 31 · Jackelyn Garcia