Mainstay Introduce
For those living on the South Shore of Massachusetts, Mainstay is a name that whispers of a delicious, well-kept secret. This unique bakery, nestled in a residential area of Scituate, operates on a pre-order basis and has earned a devoted following for its incredible, high-quality baked goods. Unlike a traditional storefront, Mainstay provides a more personal and exclusive experience, feeling more like a private invitation than a public business. This distinctive model is what makes it so special to its regular patrons. It’s a place where the community knows to plan ahead for their weekend treats, securing their spot in line for some of the best pastries, breads, and pies around.
The article you are about to read will shed light on what makes Mainstay such a treasured local spot. From its unique operational style to the rave reviews about its phenomenal pastries, we'll explore what you can expect when you visit. This bakery is not just a place to buy bread; it's a part of a local ritual for many. The sense of community is strong, and the friendly atmosphere, even in a crowded line, is a testament to the bakery's positive impact on its customers. While the experience may feel different from a typical bakery, the quality of the food is consistently praised, solidifying its reputation as a top-notch establishment in the region.
Mainstay's popularity has grown organically through word of mouth, a true sign of a business that is doing something right. Its success is built on the foundation of delicious, meticulously crafted goods. The fact that customers are willing to order a week in advance and brave the sometimes-crowded parking and lines speaks volumes about the quality of the products. This is a place where the food truly speaks for itself, drawing a loyal customer base that values quality over convenience. Mainstay’s approach to baking and selling their goods creates a fun, almost treasure-hunt-like experience that makes every visit memorable. It's a true hidden gem that many locals are proud to share with their friends and family, making it an essential part of the Scituate food scene.
The unique charm of Mainstay lies in its unassuming nature. From the street, it appears to be a typical residential home, but once you pull into the driveway, you discover the bustling, vibrant bakery operating in the backyard. This surprising discovery is part of the fun and is a key part of its appeal. The small, dedicated operation allows the bakers to focus on quality, ensuring every item is baked to perfection. This personalized approach is something you simply don't find at larger, more commercial bakeries. The dedication to their craft is what makes Mainstay a true mainstay for its local clientele.
Mainstay is situated at 599 Country Way in Scituate, a charming coastal town on the South Shore of Massachusetts. The location itself is part of the bakery's mystique, as it's not a traditional commercial storefront but rather a small, dedicated space operating out of a residential property. This unique setting makes the bakery feel like a private, exclusive find.
Accessibility can be a bit of a departure from a standard retail experience. Customers arriving will notice that it looks like they are pulling into a residential driveway. Parking, as noted by customers, can be quite crowded, which is a testament to the bakery's popularity. The line of friendly patrons waiting for their pre-ordered goods or hoping for "extras" on a given day is a common sight. Despite the residential setting, the bakery is easily found via GPS and is located on a well-known road in Scituate. The address, 599 Country Way, Scituate, MA 02066, USA, is a point of destination for many who have discovered this local secret. The bakery’s unique location and operational model make a visit feel like you’re part of an exclusive club, adding to the overall charm and allure.
The services offered by Mainstay are highly focused on quality and custom orders, with limited availability for walk-in customers.
- Pre-Order System: Mainstay's primary service model revolves around custom pre-orders. To ensure you get the items you want, especially for a weekend pickup, it is highly recommended to place an order a week in advance. This system allows the bakers to meticulously plan their production, ensuring every item is fresh and made with care. It also helps manage the high demand for their popular goods.
- Baked Goods: The bakery is renowned for a wide variety of baked goods, including breads, pies, and an array of sweets. Customers consistently rave about the quality of their pastries, describing them as phenomenal. The pies are also highly praised, and the bread is considered top-notch.
- "Extras" for Walk-Ins: For those who don't have a pre-order, there is a small sign and a designated area for "extras." These are items that were made in excess of the day's orders. While there is no guarantee of what will be available, it provides an opportunity for walk-in customers to try some of the bakery's popular items. This is a great way for new customers to get a taste of what Mainstay has to offer.
- Custom Orders: The bakery specializes in custom orders, allowing customers to get exactly what they need for special occasions or family gatherings. This personalized approach is a significant part of their business model and a key reason for their loyal customer base.
Mainstay stands out from other bakeries due to its unique features and high-quality products.
- Phenomenal Pastries: The pastries are a definite highlight. Customers frequently use words like "phenomenal" and "fantastic" to describe them, indicating a level of quality that is hard to find elsewhere.
- Top-Notch Products: Beyond the pastries, the bread, pies, and other sweets are all consistently described as being "top notch." The bakery’s commitment to excellence is evident across its entire product line.
- Unique Operational Model: The by-appointment, pre-order system is a distinguishing feature. It creates a sense of exclusivity and ensures that every product is made with care and intention. It also builds a strong sense of community among the customers who all understand and participate in this unique process.
- Friendly Community: Despite the crowded parking and lines, the atmosphere is described as friendly. This speaks to the positive culture fostered by the bakery and its loyal customers.
- A Local Secret: The "hidden gem" or "little secret" aspect is a key feature. Discovering and frequenting Mainstay feels special, like you are in on something that not everyone knows about.
For custom orders or to inquire about availability, you can contact Mainstay using the information below. It's highly recommended to call in advance for pre-orders.
Address: 599 Country Way, Scituate, MA 02066, USA
Phone: (617) 784-0906
In conclusion, Mainstay is a fantastic fit for locals in Scituate and the surrounding South Shore communities. Its unique pre-order model and the sense of community it fosters make it a cherished part of the local scene. For a population that values high-quality, handcrafted goods and is willing to plan ahead for them, Mainstay offers an unparalleled experience. The consistently excellent reviews of its pastries, breads, and pies speak for themselves, making the pre-ordering process and the crowded parking well worth the effort. It's a place that rewards its loyal customers with some of the best baked goods in the region. Mainstay is more than just a bakery; it is a local institution, a delightful secret that its patrons are proud to be a part of. For anyone in Massachusetts seeking truly exceptional baked goods and a friendly, communal experience, Mainstay is an absolute must-visit.
Mainstay Details
Service options
- Takeaway
- Delivery
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
Planning
- Quick visit
Mainstay Photos










Mainstay Location
Mainstay
599 Country Way, Scituate, MA 02066, USA
Mainstay Reviews
croissants
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1It looks like you’re pulling up into someone’s driveway, but there is a small bakery in the back yard.I had no idea that this is not a storefront per se (everyone in line had ordered a week in advance), but I came and was served anyway. There is a sign that says “extras,” and anything there is more of you can get that day.Parking is quite crowded and there is a line, but everyone was so friendly.It feels like a little secret that all the locals get their baked goods here! How fun!My three items came to $18.The pastry was phenomenal. The cookie was good but I prefer a gooey cookie to a crisper cookie. The noodles were good. I’d come back for that pastry :-)
June 08 · Kristy JohnsonThe best bakery around. Need to order early in the week for weekend pickup because it is so popular. Their bread, pies, croissants and other sweets are all top notch. You really cannot go wrong with ordering. Anything you get is going to be fantastic.
June 17 · justin shieldsFantastic small/family run business. Owner is a great baker and pastry chef. He mixes up the menu from week-to-week to keep things fresh (yes, pun intended), but when they are on the menu, the ham and cheese croissants are a great way to start your weekend! Takeout only bakery, and you must get on his list to become a customer, but well worth it.
December 31 · Shawn LOur daughter just moved to Scituate and discover Mainstay. Boy are we lucky!!The mixed berry pie was the best! Their breads and pastries are amazing! Top quality croissants!
April 11 · Carol SBest bakery in town! The baker is awesome and always kind and friendly!
November 07 · Jacqueline Kassis
More Bakery Near Me
French Memories Bakery4.0 (176 reviews)60 S Main St, Cohasset, MA 02025, USA
Boston Bonbon4.0 (50 reviews)103 Ripley Rd, Cohasset, MA 02025, USA
Gunther Tooties4.0 (71 reviews)52 Country Way, Scituate, MA 02066, USA
Knead Bakery and Bistro4.0 (55 reviews)133 Front St, Scituate, MA 02066, USA
Pour4.0 (34 reviews)686 Main St, Norwell, MA 02061, USA
Atlantic Bagel & Coffee Co4.0 (200 reviews)282 Main St, Hingham, MA 02043, USA
Breadbasket Bakery4.0 (205 reviews)307 Nantasket Ave, Hull, MA 02045, USA
Guilty Bakery4.0 (102 reviews)962 Washington St, Hanover, MA 02339, USA
Dockside Donuts4.0 (62 reviews)17 Sea St, Marshfield, MA 02050, USA
Weinberg's Bakery4.0 (255 reviews)519 Nantasket Ave, Hull, MA 02045, USA
Gunther Tooties4.0 (253 reviews)254 Church St #4, Pembroke, MA 02359, USA
Montilios Baking Co. Hanover2.0 (12 reviews)285 Columbia Rd, Hanover, MA 02339, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Voyageurs Bakehouse4.0 (211 reviews)
LaCascia's Bakery Deli & Catering4.0 (1286 reviews)
*K.P.C*~ (King PeeWee’s Cupcake’s)3.0 (5 reviews)
Legendary Doughnuts4.0 (632 reviews)
Daylight Donuts & Cafe Hilliard4.0 (476 reviews)
Nayon Evanston - Filipino Catering of Evanston5.0 (2 reviews)Top Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Create the Perfect Caramel Apple Pie: Expert Tips and Flavor Secrets
How to Create a Perfect Dessert Buffet with Your Favorite Pastries
How to Make the Best Pumpkin Churros from Scratch at Home
How to Make the Perfect Homemade Cinnamon Roll Cake
How to Bake the Best Homemade Apple Crisp with Real Flavor
How to Make Perfect Chocolate Lava Cakes from Scratch 
