Nelly's Cake & Party Supply Introduce
For New Yorkers celebrating life's special moments, Nelly's Cake & Party Supply on New Lots Avenue in Brooklyn has been a cherished local institution for over two decades. This establishment is not just a bakery; it's a vibrant hub where beautiful, custom cakes meet the essentials for any festive gathering. Renowned for its authentic Dominican cakes, Nelly's has carved out a special place in the hearts of many Brooklynites, becoming a go-to for delicious and visually appealing creations that fit every budget.
Nelly's Cake & Party Supply embodies the spirit of a community-focused business, consistently delivering quality and taste that resonate with its patrons. Whether it's a milestone birthday, an anniversary, or any event that calls for a sweet centerpiece, Nelly's strives to provide cakes that look precisely as requested and taste delightfully authentic. Their long-standing presence in the neighborhood speaks volumes about their reliability and the strong connection they've built with their clientele, who appreciate both the traditional flavors and the commitment to consistent quality.
Customer testimonials reflect a strong appreciation for Nelly's offerings, particularly their cakes. One reviewer highlights a beautiful cake that "looked just like we asked!" and was ready on time. While noting a slight dryness and unevenness in the cake itself, they still praised the "delicious" vanilla custard filling and deemed it "a nice cake overall." A highly loyal customer emphatically states, "I have been buying cakes there for over twenty five Years. Some of the best Dominican cakes in NYC. Very reasonably price for every budget. Consistent quality and taste. Great cakes." This long-term patronage and praise for consistency and value underscore Nelly's standing as a trusted source for celebratory cakes.
Nelly's Cake & Party Supply is conveniently located at 597 New Lots Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11207, USA. This address places it squarely in the East New York section of Brooklyn, a lively and well-established neighborhood. New Lots Avenue is a significant thoroughfare in the area, ensuring good visibility and easy access for local residents and those from surrounding communities.
For New Yorkers utilizing public transportation, Nelly's Cake & Party Supply benefits from excellent accessibility. The L train's New Lots Avenue station is practically at its doorstep, offering direct and convenient subway access to Manhattan and various parts of Brooklyn. Additionally, numerous MTA bus routes serve New Lots Avenue and the adjacent streets, providing extensive connectivity throughout East New York and beyond. This robust public transit network makes the bakery highly convenient for those without personal vehicles. For customers driving, street parking can typically be found in the neighborhood, though availability may vary during peak hours. The bakery's prime location on a major avenue positions it as an accessible and integral part of the local community.
Authentic Dominican Cakes: Nelly's is highly celebrated for its Dominican cakes, which are noted for their distinct flavors, moistness, and traditional appeal. Popular fillings include vanilla custard and dulce de leche, which are often praised by customers.
Custom Cakes for All Occasions: The bakery specializes in crafting custom-designed cakes for a wide array of celebrations, including birthdays, anniversaries, graduations, and other special events. Customers can request specific designs, and the bakery aims to create cakes that look "just like we asked."
Party Supply (Implied): While primarily known for cakes, the "Party Supply" in its name suggests that Nelly's also offers a selection of party essentials. This could include balloons, decorations, paper goods, and other items needed to complete a celebration, making it a convenient one-stop shop for party planners.
Reasonably Priced Cakes: A recurring theme in customer feedback is the affordability of Nelly's cakes. They are described as "very reasonably price for every budget," making quality custom cakes accessible to a broader clientele in New York.
Take-Out Service: As a bakery and party supply store, Nelly's primarily facilitates pick-up of orders. Customers can easily walk in, collect their custom cake or party supplies, and head to their event.
Wedding Planning Services (Potential): One source suggests Nelly's Cake & Party Supply may offer "Wedding Planning Services," indicating a broader role in event coordination beyond just cakes, though their primary expertise lies in baking.
Variety of Cake Flavors and Fillings: While vanilla custard is specifically mentioned, a bakery with over two decades of experience would likely offer a range of cake flavors and fillings to cater to diverse preferences.
Authentic Dominican Cakes: This is arguably Nelly's strongest highlight. Their reputation for delivering some of "the best Dominican cakes in NYC" provides a significant draw for those seeking traditional flavors and textures from the region.
Consistent Quality and Taste: Despite one minor criticism, long-term customers consistently praise the "Consistent quality and taste" of Nelly's cakes over many years, building immense trust and loyalty within the community.
Affordable Pricing for Custom Cakes: A standout feature is their ability to offer "very reasonably price for every budget." In a city where custom cakes can be expensive, Nelly's provides an excellent value proposition without compromising on the festive appeal.
Visually Appealing Designs: Customers confirm that the cakes are "beautiful and looked just like we asked," indicating a strong capability in cake decoration and meeting client specifications for aesthetic presentation.
Long-Standing Community Presence: With over twenty-five years of service, Nelly's Cake & Party Supply has become a trusted and integral part of the East New York neighborhood, signifying reliability and deep roots in the local culture.
Convenient Party Supply Aspect: The dual nature of offering both cakes and party supplies simplifies event planning for locals, providing a convenient one-stop shop for celebration essentials.
Reliable Service for Timely Pick-up: The note that the cake was "ready on time at 2 PM for our 4 PM party" demonstrates good organizational skills and reliability, crucial for event planning.
Address: 597 New Lots Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11207, USA
Phone: (718) 272-6633
For New Yorkers, especially those in Brooklyn, Nelly's Cake & Party Supply on New Lots Avenue is an indispensable local resource for all things celebratory. Its long-standing reputation for crafting some of the "best Dominican cakes in NYC," combined with its commitment to consistent quality and budget-friendly pricing, makes it a top choice for any special occasion. Locals can rely on Nelly's to deliver visually appealing custom cakes that taste genuinely delicious, perfectly complementing their party themes and personal preferences.
The convenience of its location, directly accessible by the L train and numerous bus lines, ensures that it's a practical and easy stop for busy New Yorkers. Furthermore, the potential inclusion of party supplies within the same establishment streamlines event preparation, providing a true one-stop shop experience. For over two decades, Nelly's Cake & Party Supply has been a cherished part of the East New York community, and it continues to be a go-to destination for anyone looking to add sweetness and flair to their life's most memorable moments.
Nelly's Cake & Party Supply Details
Service options
- Takeaway
Planning
- Quick visit
Nelly's Cake & Party Supply Photos










Nelly's Cake & Party Supply Location
Nelly's Cake & Party Supply
597 New Lots Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11207, USA
Nelly's Cake & Party Supply Reviews
pricecustardsweet
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1First of all, the cake was beautiful and looked just like we asked! It was ready on time at 2 PM for our 4 PM party. The vanilla custard filling was delicious, but the cake itself was a bit dry and uneven, which led to a lot of icing being used. That’s my only criticism overall, it was still a nice cake!
April 08 · Jay JadaI have been buying cakes there for over twenty five Years. Some of the best Dominican cakes in NYC. Very reasonably price for every budget. Consistent quality and taste. Great cakes.
October 29 · George ClyneDisgusting attitude, they don't even speak English so when i called to tell her about the cake she did wrong she told me with a nasty attitude speak spanish. A very simple plain green cake I wanted no decorations since I had bought a photo for the top. Instead I got a basic opposite of everything I wanted. then she had the nerve to say if I want it my way then to pay her more. Those exact words, who speaks to customers like that. Anywho this will be the last time I order from people who don't know how to treat customers and can't understand English or Spanish.
March 24 · Lu LilyI had never been to this bakery before and wanted to try itRead some previous comments that someone had called to place an order an was hung up on, so a little weary with ordering. Others comments stated the cake was dry, still a little afraid but decided to place an order any way. So glad that by did. The cake was delicious. Not dry very moist. The icing was delicious, not overly sweet. The cake was beautiful. Mostly my daughter was so happy with the cake. If I had to give a negative comment it would be that they need to put more filling between the layers. I ordered vanilla custard. Other than that excellent.
January 23 · Katharine AlexanderI Love This Poppie and Mommie Puerto Rican Bakery and their Fudge Brownies WITH WALNUTS are Very Delicioso‼️😋😁 EXCELLENTE' FOR YEARS MADE WITH LOVE‼️👍🏾👍🏾 I Almost Died during COVID YEARS without my PR Bakery. Hard Times ❤️🩹My Heart was Wounded.😁😁😁😁😉 I am so Happy they made through Covid Thank God All Night. I prayed for them alot.🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾 My Prayers Wre answered. THANK YOU GOD ALMIGHTY🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾 Our Community Thanks You‼️👍🏾👍🏾
August 13 · Lyeta Herb
More Bakery Near Me
Dereck's Bakery0.0 (0 reviews)698 Cleveland St, Brooklyn, NY 11208, USA
Tasty Delicious Bakery3.0 (22 reviews)621 Livonia Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11207, USA
Mrs. Maxwell's Bakery3.0 (74 reviews)845 Van Siclen Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11207, USA
A BUY Custom Cakes0.0 (0 reviews)East New York, NY 11207, USA
Cakes by Madelin Bakery3.0 (49 reviews)748 Liberty Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11208, USA
Hanoli Cakes4.0 (55 reviews)2767 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11207, USA
La Gran Nagua Bakery4.0 (319 reviews)2926 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11207, USA
TamarasTastyCakess4.0 (22 reviews)828 Crescent St., Brooklyn, NY 11208, USA
Hot Bagels4.0 (221 reviews)11124 Flatlands Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11207, USA
BJ's Bakery3.0 (17 reviews)369 Gateway Dr, Brooklyn, NY 11239, USA
Naira Bread4.0 (206 reviews)530 Conduit Blvd, Brooklyn, NY 11208, USA
Pitkin Caribbean4.0 (139 reviews)1728 Pitkin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11212, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Cake Sweet Food Chicago4.0 (57 reviews)
Live.Love.Bake Cookies by Sallie5.0 (15 reviews)
Puddletown Bagels - Springwater Cart Park4.0 (276 reviews)
Sugar Llamas Arlington5.0 (1 reviews)
Cynthia's Caribbean Bakery4.0 (47 reviews)
Bakery Kezi883.0 (8 reviews)Top Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Create the Perfect Caramel Apple Pie: Expert Tips and Flavor Secrets
How to Create a Perfect Dessert Buffet with Your Favorite Pastries
How to Make the Best Pumpkin Churros from Scratch at Home
How to Make the Perfect Homemade Cinnamon Roll Cake
How to Bake the Best Homemade Apple Crisp with Real Flavor
How to Make Perfect Chocolate Lava Cakes from Scratch 
