Night Owl Cookies, Winter Park: Your Late-Night Destination for Gourmet Cookies and Desserts

Night Owl Cookies Introduce

Introduction / Overview

For Central Florida’s night owls and dessert enthusiasts, Night Owl Cookies in Winter Park is the ultimate late-night haven for high-quality, gourmet treats. More than just a traditional bakery, Night Owl Cookies specializes in large, warm, and intensely flavorful cookies, and operates with a focus on convenience that perfectly suits the busy, modern Floridian lifestyle. This beloved concept, which began in a home kitchen and grew into a statewide phenomenon, has become the go-to

Cookie shop

for those seeking a sweet fix long after other bakeries have closed.

The core appeal of Night Owl Cookies lies in its exceptional products. Every cookie is baked fresh with premium ingredients, resulting in a treat that is often described as having a chewy inside and a nice crunch on the outside. Customers rave about the product quality, with one review noting the cookies were "absolutely fantastic" and another praising the staff, including Miss K and Chino, for their "amazing" service.

The menu is a creative blend of beloved classics and inventive, signature flavors that you simply won't find anywhere else. Fan favorites like the Cuban-inspired "Ave Maria" (a guava cookie with cream cheese frosting) and the rich "Dirty Diana" (stuffed with Nutella) showcase the brand's commitment to culinary creativity. They also feature viral hits like the

Limited Time Offers

such as "White Chocolate Dubai" and "Dubai Chocolate," which customers are quick to recommend. With multiple easy ways to get your cookies, including

Delivery

and

In-store pickup

, Night Owl Cookies has cemented its place as a Central Florida dessert institution.

Location and Accessibility

Night Owl Cookies' Winter Park location is a highly visible and accessible stop for locals and visitors alike. You can find this popular cookie shop at

119 N Orlando Ave Suite 105, Winter Park, FL 32789, USA

. Situated on the bustling North Orlando Avenue, the location is easy to reach from surrounding areas in Orange County, making it a convenient destination for a

Quick visit

dessert run.

Accessibility is a priority, ensuring a smooth experience for all patrons. The facility offers a

Wheelchair accessible entrance

and

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

. These features are especially valuable in a high-traffic area, guaranteeing a comfortable and easy experience when picking up your box of warm treats.

The business is tailored for quick and easy transactions. They accept modern forms of payment, including

Credit cards

Debit cards

, and

NFC mobile payments

, allowing for speedy service whether you’re rushing in for a single cookie or picking up a large

12-PACK

order. Their operational model supports both

In-store pickup

and robust

Delivery

services, catering directly to the needs of the late-night consumer across the greater Winter Park and Orlando area.

Services Offered

Night Owl Cookies’ menu offers a full spectrum of indulgence centered around their signature baked goods, ensuring every sweet craving is met.

Gourmet Cookie Selection: Offering single cookies,
4-PACK
,
6-PACK
, and
12-PACK
options, with a diverse range of signature flavors including
Chocolate Chip
,
Red Velvet
,
Brookie
(brownie and cookie mashup),
Birthday Cake
,
Cookies & Cream
,
Oreo Brownie Cheesecake
, and the exotic
Ave Maria
(Guava-inspired).
Limited and Exclusive Flavors: The menu frequently rotates specialty and trending flavors, such as the premium
Dubai Chocolate
and
White Chocolate Dubai
, which feature unique fillings and elevated toppings like pistachio and phyllo dough.
Ultimate Dessert Mash-ups: Serving
Ice Cream
creations including delicious
Milkshake
s and their must-try
Cookie Sundae
s, where warm cookies are paired with ice cream for a perfect dessert pairing.
Additional Baked Goods: Beyond cookies, they offer other delightful treats like their cinnamon rolls, specifically the
OG Sticky
(caramel glaze) and
OG Glazed
(cream cheese glaze).
Specialty Beverage Pairings: A dedicated drink menu features cold milk,
Oat Milk
, and specialty flavored milks like
Rainbow Over Bedrock Milk
and
Cinnamon Toast Crunch Milk
, all perfectly designed to accompany their warm cookies, alongside bottled sodas and
Water
.
Convenient Fulfillment: Providing flexible
Service options
including in-store
Takeout
, local
Delivery
, and the ability to handle catering or large orders with an
Onsite services
component.

Features / Highlights

Night Owl Cookies distinguishes itself in the competitive Central Florida dessert market through its unique concept and unwavering focus on quality and convenience.

Late-Night Availability: The defining feature is the late operating hours, which caters directly to college students, shift workers, and anyone with a spontaneous, late-night craving, making them a true "Night Owl" favorite.
Warm & Chewy Consistency: The cookies are frequently served warm, highlighting their signature chewy texture and enhancing the rich flavor profile, a key draw for many loyal customers.
Creative, Gourmet Flavors: Known for pushing the boundaries beyond classic cookies, with unique, decadent options like
Oreo Brownie Cheesecake
,
Dirty Diana
, and the regional favorite,
Ave Maria
.
Excellent Customer Service: Reviews highlight the staff, noting the service provided by team members like Miss K and Chino as "fantastic" and "amazing," contributing positively to the overall visit experience.
Full Dessert Experience: Offering more than just cookies by integrating
Ice Cream
sundaes and
Milkshake
s into the menu, turning a cookie run into a complete dessert occasion.

Contact Information

To place an order for delivery or to plan a visit to the Winter Park location, here is the necessary contact information:

Address: 119 N Orlando Ave Suite 105, Winter Park, FL 32789, USA

Phone: (321) 972-4021

Mobile Phone: +1 321-972-4021

What is Worth Choosing Night Owl Cookies

For Floridians, choosing Night Owl Cookies is all about embracing the fun, spontaneous side of indulgence without compromising on quality. It is uniquely positioned to fill the void for high-quality, freshly baked desserts that are accessible late at night, making it an essential local resource. Unlike many conventional bakeries that close early, Night Owl is there when the craving hits, often offering

Delivery

straight to your door.

The decision to choose Night Owl is fundamentally a choice for a premium, exciting product. Their cookies are consistently praised for being warm, moist, and having a perfect balance of texture, which is a significant step up from mass-produced sweets. The constantly rotating, highly creative menu, which includes everything from the Nutella-stuffed

Dirty Diana

to the tropical

Ave Maria

, ensures there is always something new and intriguing to try. Even with a critical review noting some cookies were "just OK," the same review still praised the "friendly" service, demonstrating a commitment to customer experience.

Finally, the convenience is unmatched. The combination of an easily accessible location on N Orlando Ave with

Wheelchair accessible

facilities, combined with the multiple quick service options like

In-store pickup

and full delivery, simplifies the process of getting delicious food. When Central Florida residents are looking for more than just a cookie—they’re looking for a warm, late-night, gourmet treat—Night Owl Cookies is the dedicated and reliable choice.

Night Owl Cookies Menu

Baked Goods
CINNAMON ROLLS $0.00

Cookies
SINGLE $4.49
12-PACK $44.50
4-PACK $16.25
6-PACK $23.50

Media
Media Box $50.99
This box is designed for media purposes only. Not intended for general sale.

Cookies
Cookies & Cream $4.65
Signature dough mixed with milk chocolate chips and Oreo cookie bits, coated in Oreo powder, and finished with a vanilla creme drizzle.
Oreo Brownie Cheesecake $4.65
Signature dough mixed with chocolate chip and Oreo cookie crumbs. Topped with a cheesecake frosting, Oreo powder, and finished with fudgy brownie bits.
Chocolate S'mores $4.65
Signature chocolate dough mixed with milk chocolate chips. Topped with crisp graham cracker crumbs and toasted marshmallows.
White Chocolate Dubai $5.75
Signature dough, white chocolate chips, crunchy pistachio filling, white chocolate ganache, roasted pistachios, roasted phyllo dough
Ave Maria $4.65
Signature cookie dough infused with guava and mixed with white chocolate chips. Coated with maria cookie crumbles, drizzled guava marmalade, and a cream cheese frosting. Topped with a Maria Cookie. It’ll have you saying “Ave Maria!”
Rainbow Over Bedrock $4.65
Signature dough stuffed with white chocolate chips and topped with crunchy Fruity Pebbles cereal.
Chocolate Chip $4.65
The cookie that started it all. A moist cookie with warm chocolate chip morsels baked into every bite.
Dubai Chocolate $5.75
Signature chocolate dough mixed with milk chocolate, stuffed with a crunchy pistachio filling. Topped with a rich chocolate shell, then finished with crushed pistachios and roasted kadayif.
Dirty Diana $4.65
Signature chocolate dough topped with Nutella. Finished with a dash of powdered sugar and a drizzle of Nutella.
Red Velvet $4.65
Signature red velvet dough mixed with white chocolate chips. Topped with homemade cheesecake filling. Finished with graham cracker dust. *SERVED AT ROOM TEMPERATURE*
Brookie $4.65
Homemade brownie batter mixed with our signature chocolate chip cookie dough.
Birthday Cake $4.65
Signature dough mixed with white chocolate chips and milk chocolate chips. Topped with rainbow sprinkles and finished with a drizzle of frosting.
Frosted Sugar Daddy $4.65
Signature sugar dough opped with creamy vanilla frosting and finished with rainbow sprinkles!

Baked Goods
OG Sticky $5.15
Soft, fluffy dough swirled with cinnamon sugar filling and coated in a sticky caramel glaze.
OG Glazed $5.45
A soft, fluffy cinnamon roll swirled with warm cinnamon sugar and topped with a rich cream cheese glaze

Limited Time Offers
White Chocolate Dubai $5.75
Signature dough, white chocolate chips, crunchy pistachio filling, white chocolate ganache, roasted pistachios, roasted phyllo dough
Dubai Chocolate $5.75
Signature chocolate dough mixed with milk chocolate, stuffed with a crunchy pistachio filling. Topped with a rich chocolate shell, then finished with crushed pistachios and roasted kadayif.

Drinks
Coke 20 Oz Bottle $3.25
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
Rainbow Over Bedrock Milk $3.50
Coke Zero 20 Oz Bottle $3.25
The same great taste but with zero calories.
Water $1.75
Sprite 20 Oz Bottle $3.25
The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.
Oat Milk $3.50
Cinnamon Toast Crunch Milk $3.50
Milk $2.99

Ice Cream
Milkshake $8.50
Double Scoop $0.00
Cookie Sundae $8.50

Drinks
Cinnamon Toast Crunch Milk $3.50
Coke Zero $2.99
The same great taste but with zero calories.
Rainbow Over Bedrock Milk $3.50
Oat Milk $3.50
Milk $2.99
Coke $2.99
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
Water $1.75
Red Bull $4.99
Red bull energy drink 8.4 oz
Sprite $2.99
The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.

Night Owl Cookies Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
Onsite services

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Dining options
Dessert

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments

Night Owl Cookies Photos

Night Owl Cookies Location

Night Owl Cookies

Florida Orange County Winter Park North Orlando Avenue

119 N Orlando Ave Suite 105, Winter Park, FL 32789, USA

Night Owl Cookies Reviews

An average rating of ★4.6 from 136 user reviews.

choicefrostingchocolate chipenergyguava cookiedubai chocolatesharemenusprinklesred velvet

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

The cookies at this place were absolutely fantastic! It was so hard to not order every cookie on the shelves. The service was amazing, Miss K and Chino were also fantastic. Totally recommend this place. Try the Dubai chocolate if still in season.
June 20 · Bamba Ndiaye
Saw this placd and wanted to try it since we love cookies. The name and store are super cute. So is the concept, the result is just OK. The cookies weren't my favorite tried a few and none of them were good. Unfortunately it was a miss. But the service was friendly.
August 26 · jonsay241
Amazing customer service. Alexis and Miss K went above and beyond taking care of me and being so patient explaining each and one of the flavor that they had. The place was very clean. All the cookies that I got were so good and flavorful. I highly recommend this place. I can't wait to come back for new flavors.
May 25 · liz C
Stopped by Night Owl Cookies in Winter Park a couple of weekends ago, right at opening (11am), and the shop was clean, welcoming, and smelled amazing. I came specifically for the much-talked-about Dubai Chocolate cookie, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint!The pistachio filling was rich and delicious, the chocolate cookie itself was soft and indulgent, and the delicate chocolate shell, topped with crushed pistachios and roasted kadayif, was the perfect crunchy contrast. It was so good, I didn’t even share, it didn’t make it home, and I have zero regrets! (Fair warning: the crunchy toppings make it a little messy, but 100% worth it.)I also picked up a few classics for the family: Chocolate Chip, Cookies & Cream, Dirty Diana, and S’mores. All were great, but the standout was definitely the Chocolate Chip, a classic done perfectly.Located in the Trader Joe’s plaza, this spot is surrounded by great little shops, and it’s the perfect sweet ending to any visit. Whether you’re going for the hype or just want a good cookie, Night Owl Cookies delivers. Highly recommend!
July 17 · Teresa
Found this place on google. Downloaded the app and put my order in. It was ready quickly! These cookies were toooo GOOD! Their moist texture was perfect and fully satisfied our craving for something sweet.
August 21 · Alysha