Plaza Pastry Shop Introduce
For residents of New Jersey, especially those in the charming town of Nutley, there’s an inherent value in having a trusted local bakery. It’s the place you turn to for that perfect birthday cake, a delightful pastry to accompany your morning coffee, or even fresh bread for dinner. In Nutley, one such establishment that aims to be a cornerstone of the community's sweet tooth is Plaza Pastry Shop. This family-owned bakery has positioned itself as a convenient destination for a diverse range of baked goods, aiming to satisfy the cravings of local patrons.
Plaza Pastry Shop strives to be more than just a place to buy desserts; it endeavors to be a part of life's celebrations and daily rituals. From individual treats like a peanut butter cup to custom cakes for significant events, the shop is dedicated to crafting items that bring joy. While every business strives for perfection and consistent quality, Plaza Pastry Shop is a local fixture in Nutley's vibrant food scene, continually working to serve its neighbors with baked goods that evoke a sense of warmth and tradition.
---Plaza Pastry Shop is conveniently located at 39 Franklin Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110, USA. Franklin Avenue is a well-known street in Nutley, making the bakery easily identifiable and accessible for both residents and visitors to the area. Its central placement within a bustling part of the town ensures that it's a practical stop for those on their daily commute, running errands, or simply taking a stroll through the neighborhood.
The accessibility of Plaza Pastry Shop is a significant advantage for local customers. Whether you're driving, walking, or utilizing local transportation, getting to the shop is generally straightforward. For those arriving by car, on-street parking is typically available in the vicinity, though as with any popular local spot, it's always wise to allow a little extra time during peak hours. This convenient location enhances its appeal as a reliable destination for a quick treat, an order pickup, or a leisurely selection of baked goods, cementing its role within the Nutley community.
---Plaza Pastry Shop offers a diverse array of baked goods and services, aiming to cater to various preferences and occasions. As a family-owned bakery, their focus is on providing a selection that appeals to the local community. Their offerings generally include:
Pastries and Desserts: This is a core offering, with a daily selection of pastries that can include a variety of sweet treats. Examples from customer experiences mention items like peanut butter cups and Portuguese custard, indicating a mix of traditional and perhaps unique options. Other typical pastry offerings might include eclairs, cannolis, tarts, and various cookies.
Cakes for All Occasions: Plaza Pastry Shop specializes in making cakes to order for various celebrations. Whether it's a birthday, anniversary, or another special event, customers can likely place custom orders to suit their specific needs and design preferences. Their website mentions "Cakes. Unapologetically Decadent."
Breads and Rolls: Beyond sweets, the bakery offers a daily selection of fresh breads and rolls. Customers are encouraged to call to find out what is available, suggesting a rotating or varied assortment of freshly baked bread products, possibly including stuffed breads.
Cookies: A popular choice for many, a range of cookies is typically available, from classic chocolate chip to other assorted varieties suitable for individual enjoyment or sharing.
Donuts: As part of their daily pastry selection, donuts are also mentioned, providing another option for a quick sweet treat.
Specialty Items: Depending on the day or season, there may be other specialty desserts or baked goods available, providing variety for returning customers.
Plaza Pastry Shop aims to provide a distinct experience for its customers in Nutley through several key features and highlights. While customer experiences can vary, these are aspects that contribute to its local identity:
Family-Owned Operation: Being a family-owned business fosters a sense of community and personal service. This can lead to a more tailored approach to customer relations and a commitment to maintaining a neighborhood feel.
Diverse Pastry Selection: The bakery offers a variety of pastries, including items like Portuguese custard and peanut butter cups, suggesting a range that can cater to different tastes. This diversity is a key attraction for customers looking for something beyond standard offerings.
Custom Cake Orders: The ability to make cakes to order for all occasions is a significant highlight, allowing customers to personalize their celebrations with unique confectionery creations. This service is crucial for birthdays, anniversaries, and other special events.
Daily Fresh Baked Goods: A fundamental aspect of any good bakery is the commitment to freshness. Plaza Pastry Shop aims to provide daily fresh selections of breads, rolls, and pastries, which is essential for quality and customer satisfaction.
Classic Offerings: Alongside potentially unique items, the presence of universally loved treats like chocolate chip cookies ensures there are familiar and comforting options for everyone.
Local Convenience: Located on Franklin Avenue, the shop's accessibility makes it a practical and regular stop for residents, whether for a planned purchase or a spontaneous treat.
To get in touch with Plaza Pastry Shop for inquiries, to place an order, or to learn more about their daily selections, please use the following contact details:
Address: 39 Franklin Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110, USA
Phone: (973) 661-0011
Their website also notes that they are open every day from 7am to 6pm, though holiday hours may vary. They appreciate business and encourage customers to call to place orders as they do not currently offer delivery.
---For the residents of Nutley, New Jersey, Plaza Pastry Shop stands as a suitable and convenient local bakery for several compelling reasons. Its prime location on Franklin Avenue is a significant advantage, providing easy access for anyone in the area, whether they are commuting, running errands, or simply enjoying a walk through the neighborhood. This accessibility ensures that a delicious pastry, fresh bread, or a custom cake is never far out of reach, making it a practical choice for both daily needs and special occasions.
The shop’s commitment to offering a wide variety of baked goods is another key factor in its appeal to locals. From a diverse selection of pastries, including unique finds like Portuguese custard, to classic cookies and the ability to create custom cakes for any event, Plaza Pastry Shop aims to cater to a broad range of tastes and requirements. This versatility means that locals can rely on it for anything from a spontaneous sweet craving to a planned celebratory dessert, providing a one-stop solution for their baking needs.
Furthermore, as a family-owned establishment, Plaza Pastry Shop contributes to the local economy and fosters a sense of community. Supporting such a business helps maintain the unique charm and character of Nutley. While individual experiences may vary, the bakery’s dedication to providing a convenient location and a varied menu of baked goods makes it a valued part of the local landscape. For those in Nutley seeking a reliable, local spot for fresh pastries, breads, and custom cakes, Plaza Pastry Shop aims to be a go-to destination, offering a taste of tradition and sweetness to the community.
Plaza Pastry Shop Vibe
Antojitos
- Nachos US$6.99
- Gorditas US$3.99
Salads
- Taco US$6.99
- Chicken US$9.00
Tostadas
- Camaron US$4.99
- Rancheras (Veggie) US$3.99
Tacos
- Chile Verde US$3.25
- Barbacoa US$3.25
Torta
- Chile Verde US$5.19
- Queso Fresco US$5.19
Plaza Pastry Shop Details
Service options
- Takeaway
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Offerings
- Coffee
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Plaza Pastry Shop Photos










Plaza Pastry Shop Location
Plaza Pastry Shop Reviews
stalecookiespricesrollssalesitalian breadpecanpersonalitypaper bagflies
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1First time here , we ordered peanut butter cup it was so delicious !!! We had Portuguese custard my bf approved and he’s half Portuguese . A big chocolate chip cookie I enjoyed it , my boyfriend said it was too hard. everything was delicious , def would come back
July 28 · E RedHow can this place have any positive reviews? Spent 50$ on pastries for everything to be STALE. When I say stale, I mean days old, rock solid, inedible. Everything went right in the trash. Save yourself $$ and go somewhere else.
March 16 · KristinToday was my second time stopping here for pastries and bread. The first time was pretty lackluster with stale pastries and an "off" taste to the pastries that had a cream filling. The filling had a strong citrus taste and a sour aftertaste. I thought maybe they were having an off day and decided to try again today. I got the apple crumb cake which was thrown into a paper bag to start. When I got home it completely fell apart into a pile of mush when I took it out. I decided to taste it anyway and wish I hadn't. The dough was completely raw which was probably why it fell apart. My fiance got his favorite treat: tarallis. They were rock hard and tasted like the plastic container they were kept in. When I say rock hard, I'm talking being surprised he didn't chip a tooth. The Italian bread is decent, but very salty. I like saltiness, so it didn't bother me too much, but when I know bread shouldn't have a strong taste of salt. Lesson learned. We will not be returning again.
November 18 · Elizabeth PlavnickyI don't normally write reviews, but between the lack of customer service, and the awful quality of the pastries we bought, I had to. The woman that took our order was unfriendly at best, threw all of our pastries on top of each other in a paper bag, and couldn't wait for us to leave. The crumb cake was doughy and tasted like chemicals. I hate to sound like a Karen, but my recommendation is to steer clear of this establishment unless you're looking to waste your money and be disappointed by the first bite.
August 08 · Emilie BrulatoThe only reason I am giving 1 star is because the sales girl was nice and the bread there is always good. I purchased a cake and cheese danish ring yesterday. The cake was stale, good thing the icing was ok because that’s all my company got to eat. The cheese ring was sour. When I went in this morning to bring it back and ask for a refund for the cheese ring, the counter person was very nice but when the owner came out, he was dismissive and told me cheese doesn’t get sour! After he allowed her to refund me, he walked away and laughed and said to another customer, first time in 35 years that’s happened. I know for a fact a lot of people have brought things back there so there was no reason for that rude and inaccurate statement. I have been going to this bakery since they opened, but will never step foot in there again.
May 04 · Rosie Barbosa
More Bakery Near Me
Glaze Donuts - Nutley4.0 (144 reviews)187 Franklin Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110, USA
Sunrise Hot Bagels4.0 (482 reviews)650 Joralemon St, Belleville, NJ 07109, USA
Nutley Bagel Boy4.0 (338 reviews)244A Franklin Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110, USA
Flavor For Favors LLC5.0 (17 reviews)222 Fairway Ave, Belleville, NJ 07109, USA
Da Vinci Bakery4.0 (344 reviews)100 Centre St, Nutley, NJ 07110, USA
Bagel Plus & Cafe4.0 (176 reviews)154 Washington Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110, USA
Rombiolo Bakery Cafe4.0 (560 reviews)119 Broughton Ave, Bloomfield, NJ 07003, USA
Myra's Bakery3.0 (49 reviews)71 1/2 Belleville Ave, Bloomfield, NJ 07003, USA
Aromi Di Napoli LLC4.0 (286 reviews)246 Washington Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110, USA
Rudy's Pastry Shop4.0 (53 reviews)23 Willet St, Bloomfield, NJ 07003, USA
Gencarelli's Bakery4.0 (1458 reviews)446 Broad St, Bloomfield, NJ 07003, USA
Bloomfield Best Bagels4.0 (625 reviews)404 Broad St, Bloomfield, NJ 07003, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Kafra's Bakery4.0 (147 reviews)
Ashlee's Cookie Fusions5.0 (28 reviews)
Bagel Biz4.0 (498 reviews)
La Chiquita Bakery & Store4.0 (836 reviews)
Panadería Los Gallos4.0 (166 reviews)
Auntie Anne's3.0 (38 reviews)Top Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Create the Perfect Caramel Apple Pie: Expert Tips and Flavor Secrets
How to Create a Perfect Dessert Buffet with Your Favorite Pastries
How to Make the Best Pumpkin Churros from Scratch at Home
How to Make the Perfect Homemade Cinnamon Roll Cake
How to Bake the Best Homemade Apple Crisp with Real Flavor
How to Make Perfect Chocolate Lava Cakes from Scratch 
