Romy's Bakery in Reynoldsburg, OH: Artisanal Cakes and Custom Dessert Creations

Romy's Bakery Introduce

Introduction / Overview: Your Artisanal Sweet Spot in Central Ohio

For residents across Reynoldsburg and the greater Columbus area of Ohio, finding a bakery that truly combines stunning artistry with incredible flavor can turn a simple celebration into an unforgettable event.

Romy's Bakery

has established itself as that destination. This is not a mass-production facility; it is a delightful local artisan specializing in high-quality, handcrafted baked goods, with a particular focus on custom cakes for all of life's special occasions—from baptism celebrations to milestone birthdays and engagements.

What truly sets

Romy's Bakery

apart in the Ohio dessert landscape is its commitment to both visual excellence and taste. Customer reviews consistently highlight not just the beauty of the cakes—describing them as

absolutely beautiful—elegant, detailed, and perfectly themed

—but also their

incredible

taste. This combination means that when you choose Romy’s, you are choosing a centerpiece that delights every guest. The bakers take pride in using high-grade ingredients and creating signature elements like

Italian Buttercream

and homemade pastry fillings, ensuring every bite is made

with care and love

. While the core offering is specialized cakes, the entire operation is dedicated to quality that stands out in the Central Ohio bakery scene.

Location and Accessibility for the Ohio Community

Romy's Bakery

is conveniently located at 8666 Kingsley Dr, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, USA. Its position within the local community makes it an accessible spot for both Reynoldsburg residents and those traveling from neighboring Central Ohio suburbs for specialized orders.

In terms of access, the bakery prioritizes a convenient experience for all patrons. Notably, the location is equipped with a

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

, making the journey from the car to the shop straightforward and comfortable for customers with mobility needs. While the primary focus of a visit is often to pick up a pre-ordered item, the set-up is optimized for a

Quick visit

, ensuring that busy Ohioans can get their custom sweets and get back to their day efficiently.

Specialized Services and Offerings

Romy's Bakery

, functioning as a specialty

Bakery

, centers its services around providing bespoke and high-quality baked items, ensuring an exceptional experience for every client’s unique need.

Custom Celebratory Cakes: The flagship service, offering tailor-made cakes for every event, including weddings, engagements, birthdays, baby showers, and baptisms. Customers can request specific themes, designs, and personal messages.
Specialty Flavors: Known for a diverse range of popular and innovative cake flavors, such as marble, carrot, and fresh strawberry, often paired with their famous Italian Buttercream and a variety of delicious fillings.
Bespoke Sweet Treats: Beyond large cakes, the bakery often provides other complementary baked goods for events, which can include items like cupcakes, cookies, and cake pops, ideal for a full dessert spread.
Beverage Offerings: To complement their delicious sweets, the bakery provides
Coffee
, a perfect pairing for sampling during a consultation or for a quick morning treat.
Service Convenience: Orders can be picked up via
Takeout
, which is designed for a fast and hassle-free retrieval of custom-made products.
Dietary Options: The bakery is known to accommodate various preferences, with information suggesting options like vegan, carrot, and coffee-flavored cakes, allowing for customization to suit different dietary needs and preferences.

Features and Customer Highlights

The features of

Romy's Bakery

reflect its status as a highly customer-focused and artisanal local business, catering to a clientele that values quality and personal attention in the Ohio market.

Exceptional Flavor and Quality: The bakery is renowned for its commitment to high-grade, natural ingredients, leading to consistently
delicious
and
incredible
cakes that earn rave reviews. The rich buttercream frosting and creative fillings are noted highlights.
Artistic Customization: Every cake is crafted with an artistic touch, ensuring that designs are
beautiful
and meticulously tailored to the customer’s preferences and occasion, creating a memorable visual impact.
Dedicated Service: The entire experience, from ordering to pickup, is supported by a commitment to
excellent customer service
, ensuring that the needs for such meaningful occasions are met with care.
Efficient Payment Methods: The checkout process is streamlined and modern, accepting major electronic payments including
Credit cards
and
Debit cards
.
Speed and Simplicity: The
Takeout
and operational style is perfectly suited for a
Quick visit
, respecting the busy schedules of local Ohio customers who need fast access to high-quality goods.
Proven Event Success: Multiple customer reviews confirm the bakery’s ability to successfully deliver stunning and delicious cakes for major life events, such as a baptism and a mother's birthday.

Contact Information for Your Custom Order

To place a custom order, inquire about flavor options, or discuss your next celebration centerpiece with the dedicated team at

Romy's Bakery

, please use the following contact details:

Address: 8666 Kingsley Dr, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, USA

Phone: (614) 806-0992

Mobile Phone: +1 614-806-0992

What is Worth Choosing at Romy's Bakery

For any resident of Central Ohio planning a significant life event—a wedding, a baptism, a special birthday, or a holiday gathering—

Romy's Bakery

is worth choosing because it specializes in the one thing that truly makes a celebration stand out: an exceptional cake.

This bakery is distinctly chosen for its quality over sheer volume. Unlike larger chain operations, Romy’s is where you go when you want a beautiful cake that is also guaranteed to taste incredible, reflecting

care and love

in its making. The use of specialty components, such as their signature

Italian Buttercream

and creative flavor combinations like

Marble, Carrots, and Fresh Strawberry

, elevates their products beyond the standard bakery fare. Customers who choose

Romy's Bakery

value the artistic touch, the deep commitment to fresh, high-quality ingredients, and the assurance that their centerpiece dessert will be a memorable hit, earning compliments from all guests. The simple

Takeout

and

Quick visit

options ensure the final step of pickup is easy, leaving you to simply enjoy the delicious and beautiful result of their craftsmanship. When the occasion demands a cake that makes the entire event

even more memorable

, Romy's Bakery is the premier artisanal choice in Reynoldsburg, OH.

Romy's Bakery Details

Service options
Takeout
Delivery

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards

Romy's Bakery Photos

Romy's Bakery Location

Romy's Bakery

Ohio Licking County Reynoldsburg Kingsley Drive

8666 Kingsley Dr, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, USA

Romy's Bakery Reviews

An average rating of ★5 from 64 user reviews.

designcelebrationveganbuttercreamcoffee cakedesertsvanilla flavorcoffee frostingbaptismvanilla cake

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

I just had to share how thrilled we were with the baptism cake this amazing baker made for my daughter’s special day. Not only was the cake absolutely beautiful—elegant, detailed, and perfectly themed—it tasted incredible too! You can really tell it was made with care and love. Everyone at the celebration couldn’t stop talking about it. Thank you for making such a meaningful occasion even more memorable. Highly recommend!
June 04 · cinthia pasillas
Romy Bakery really came through for my mom's birthday. A beautiful cake, but even more delicious. The 3 flavors were a hit. Marble, carrots and fresh strawberry. The carrots was my favorite. Will definitely be using them again in near future.
April 13 · Miss Ida
Great service and beautiful cake! Ordered this for my grad party and she did such an amazing job. It was exactly what I wanted and tasted so good. Everyone really enjoyed it, so I will definitely be ordering again!
May 20 · Ruhama A
I recently ordered a graduation cake for my brother’s special day, and I cannot express enough how delighted we were with the entire experience. From the moment I placed the order, the communication and professionalism demonstrated were impeccable.The cake it self was a masterpiece—beautifully made, and it tasted AMAZING. It was a hit with all the guests at the party.I highly recommend Romy’s Bakery to anyone looking for a top-notch bakery experience.Thank you so much for making my brother’s graduation day extra special with your delicious creation. 🫶🏽
June 04 · Yordanos Kuwaney
I ordered the vanilla flavor cake it was delicious just the way I wanted it. Not too moist not too dry. It was with in the perfect range of moisture.Loved to order again and again.
May 24 · Aleka Adera