Simply Cinnamon Bakery

For over a decade, Simply Cinnamon Bakery has stood as a cherished local landmark in Pewaukee, WI, serving residents across Waukesha County with an irresistible combination of warmth, flavor, and tradition. Located conveniently on Oakton Avenue, this bakery goes well beyond the typical sweet shop, establishing itself as a vital part of local family celebrations and weekend rituals. It is, quite simply, a must-visit 'Bakery' that truly lives up to its inviting name.

From the moment local customers step inside, they are greeted by a "warm, inviting aroma" that promises a genuine treat. While the selection of pastries and breads is "truly impressive," Simply Cinnamon has earned a legendary status for two distinct and equally compelling offerings: its namesake cinnamon rolls and its incredibly popular, often sold-out, Sunday ham.

The cinnamon rolls are the heart of the business, a "delectable" centerpiece around which the bakery’s reputation is built. Paired with a freshly brewed cup of coffee, they represent the perfect indulgence for a weekend morning or a mid-week lift. However, the unexpected star is the Sunday ham (and their honey-glazed hams for catering), which is described as "nothing short of spectacular," "perfectly seasoned and cooked to tender perfection," and the kind of meal that makes you want to "savor every single bite." This savory specialty is so sought after that local users are explicitly warned to "get there early" as it frequently sells out before noon.

Simply Cinnamon Bakery has become a cornerstone of family traditions, with customers relying on their quality not just for holiday treats but also for elevating weekly Sunday dinners and special gatherings. The fact that the bakery has been the "family's go-to destination for all our holiday treats and more" for ten years speaks volumes about its consistent quality and commitment to the Pewaukee community. This is a local gem where the staff is not just friendly, but passionate about baking, ensuring every visit is a delightful culinary experience.

Simply Cinnamon Bakery is positioned in a central and accessible location within the village of Pewaukee, making it an easy destination for both quick daily visits and planned weekend trips from across Waukesha County.

The physical address is: 115 Oakton Ave, Pewaukee, WI 53072, USA.

The bakery’s location on Oakton Avenue is strategically placed for neighborhood access. The business has taken clear steps to accommodate customers with ease and convenience:

• Wheelchair accessible parking lot: Ensuring accessibility for all patrons.
• Parking availability: The location likely offers straightforward parking options, which contributes to the "Quick visit" appeal.

The operation is geared towards an efficient yet pleasant experience, providing a "Quick visit" option for busy locals, while the "cozy seating and rustic decor" also invites those who wish to "enjoy a leisurely meal" with their coffee and fresh-baked treats.

Simply Cinnamon Bakery provides a focused array of services centered on its bakery expertise and convenience for the local Waukesha County consumer.

• In-Store Baking and Retail: The core service is the daily preparation and sale of a variety of freshly baked goods, including their signature cinnamon rolls, pastries, and breads.
• Breakfast and Brunch: A key dining option is the service of breakfast, which includes their famous Sunday ham and other baked goods, perfect for a weekend splurge.
• Takeout: All items, from a single cinnamon roll to a large catering order, are available for takeout, catering to the need for a quick treat or family meal component.
• Specialty Savory Items: A unique offering is their renowned Sunday ham and other specialty hams for hosting and catering, providing a delicious savory counterpoint to the sweets.
• Coffee Service: The availability of coffee ensures a complete breakfast or snack experience, perfect for pairing with their various sweet and savory items.
• Catering/Holiday Treats: Providing seasonal and holiday-specific items (e.g., Christmas cookies) and large-format hams for family and festive gatherings, establishing the bakery as a crucial part of local traditions.
• Modern Payments: Accepts Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for fast, efficient, and easy checkout.

The longevity and reputation of Simply Cinnamon Bakery are built on specific, highly-praised features that make it stand out in the competitive Wisconsin bakery landscape.

• The Famous Sunday Ham: The "spectacular" and savory "Sunday ham" is a signature, high-demand feature that frequently sells out, drawing customers specifically for its exquisite, tender quality.
• Decade of Tradition: Having been a family's "go-to destination for all our holiday treats" for ten years demonstrates a proven, long-term commitment to quality and community trust in Pewaukee.
• Irresistible Aroma and Atmosphere: The bakery is noted for its "warm, inviting aroma" and "charming" atmosphere with "cozy seating and rustic decor," making the physical visit a pleasant experience.
• Superior Quality and Variety: Customers consistently praise the "delectable cinnamon rolls" and "stunning holiday cookies," noting that "each bite is a testament to their commitment to quality and flavor."
• Friendly, Passionate Staff: The staff is highlighted as "incredibly friendly" and welcoming, with a genuine "passion for baking" that enhances the overall customer experience.

For local Wisconsin patrons looking to inquire about the availability of the Sunday ham, to place a ham or holiday catering order, or to confirm current hours, the following contact information is provided:

Address: 115 Oakton Ave, Pewaukee, WI 53072, USA

Phone: (262) 691-4022 (or +1 262-691-4022 for mobile users)

Current public information suggests the bakery is open Wednesday through Sunday (Mondays and Tuesdays are closed), with operating hours typically running from 8:00 AM until noon or 1:00 PM. Pro Tip for Locals: Due to the popularity of the Sunday ham, calling ahead or arriving right at opening is highly recommended.

Simply Cinnamon Bakery is absolutely worth choosing for the Wisconsin resident who values an established tradition, exceptional quality, and the ability to find both incredible sweet and spectacular savory treats in one place.

You should choose Simply Cinnamon Bakery because:

• You Want the Famous Sunday Ham: This legendary savory dish is a must-try. Its reputation alone justifies an early weekend visit—a true Pewaukee culinary experience.
• You Seek a Cherished Local Tradition: Choosing this bakery means supporting a business that has been a reliable, high-quality centerpiece for local family gatherings and holidays for over a decade.
• The Quality is Consistent and Exceptional: From the "irresistible aroma" to the perfect taste of every bite, the business consistently delivers high standards in both its daily pastries and its seasonal offerings.
• It is the Ideal Destination for Weekend Breakfast: Offering both delicious baked goods and quality coffee, alongside dining options like breakfast, it is the perfect spot for a leisurely or quick weekend indulgence in Waukesha County.

Do yourself a favor and experience the deliciousness for yourself at Simply Cinnamon Bakery in Pewaukee—just remember the advice from the locals: get there early for the ham!

Simply Cinnamon Bakery

115 Oakton Ave, Pewaukee, WI 53072, USA